What can we learn from hydrodynamic analysis at RHIC? Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics, Columbia Univ. Workshop on Quark-Gluon-Plasma Thermalization August.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Huichao Song The Ohio State University Lawrence Berkeley National Lab Viscous Hydro +URQMD In collaboration with S.Bass, U.Heinz, C.Shen, P.Huovinen &

Advertisements

New Results from Viscous Hydro + URQMD (VISHNU) International School for High Energy Nuclear Collisions, Wuhan, Oct 31- Nov.5, 2011 References: Supported.

Elliptic flow of thermal photons in Au+Au collisions at 200GeV QNP2009 Beijing, Sep , 2009 F.M. Liu Central China Normal University, China T. Hirano.

Supported by DOE 11/22/2011 QGP viscosity at RHIC and LHC energies 1 Huichao Song 宋慧超 Seminar at the Interdisciplinary Center for Theoretical Study, USTC.

Effects of Bulk Viscosity on p T -Spectra and Elliptic Flow Parameter Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo, Japan Collaborator:

Hadronic Rescattering Effects after Hadronization of QGP Fluids Tetsufumi Hirano Institute of Physics, University of Tokyo Workshop “Hadronization” in.

Hadronic dissipative effects on transverse dynamics at RHIC Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics The Univ. of Tokyo QM2008, Feb. 4-10, 2008 TH, U.Heinz, D.Kharzeev,

Collective Flow from QGP Hydro + Hadronic Cascade Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics The Univ. of Tokyo ISMD, Aug. 4-10, 2007 TH, U.Heinz, D.Kharzeev, R.Lacey,

Mass ordering of differential elliptic flow and its violation for  mesons Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics, The Univ. of Tokyo Matsumoto, Feb ,

DNP03, Tucson, Oct 29, Kai Schweda Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory for the STAR collaboration Hadron Yields, Hadrochemistry, and Hadronization.

1 Questions about sQGP Carlos Arguello Columbia University 24 th Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics April 10 th 2008.

Hydrodynamic Approaches to Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions Tetsufumi Hirano RIKEN BNL Research Center.

Statistical Models A. ) Chemical equilibration B

Flow and Femtoscopy from QGP Hydro + Hadronic Cascade Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics The Univ. of Tokyo WPCF, Aug. 1-3, 2007.

System size and beam energy dependence of azimuthal anisotropy from PHENIX Michael Issah Vanderbilt University for the PHENIX Collaboration QM2008, Jaipur,

XXXIII International Symposium on Multiparticle Dynamics, September 7, 2003 Kraków, Poland Manuel Calderón de la Barca Sánchez STAR Collaboration Review.

WWND, San Diego1 Scaling Characteristics of Azimuthal Anisotropy at RHIC Michael Issah SUNY Stony Brook for the PHENIX Collaboration.

Perfect Fluid: flow measurements are described by ideal hydro Problem: all fluids have some viscosity -- can we measure it? I. Radial flow fluctuations:

Perfect Fluid: flow measurements are described by ideal hydro Problem: all fluids have some viscosity -- can we measure it? I. Transverse flow fluctuations:

QGP and Dynamics of Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions Tetsufumi Hirano The University of Tokyo, Komaba Thermal Quantum Field Theories and Their Applications.

Toward understanding of Quark-Gluon Plasma in relativistic heavy ion collisions Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics The University of Tokyo.

S C O T T PRATPRAT MICHIGANMICHIGAN S T T E UNIVRSITYUNIVRSITY T H BTBT PUZZLE PUZZLE Z A N D E X T E N D I N G HYRODYNAMICS HYRODYNAMICS.

Perfect Fluid QGP or CGC? Tetsufumi Hirano Institute of Physics, University of Tokyo References: T.Hirano and M.Gyulassy, Nucl.Phys.A 769(2006)71. T.Hirano,

Hydrodynamical Simulation of Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions Tetsufumi Hirano Strongly Coupled Plasmas: Electromagnetic, Nuclear and Atomic.

Viscous hydrodynamics DPF 2009 Huichao Song The Ohio State University Supported by DOE 07/30/2009 July 27-July 31, Detroit, MI with shear and bulk viscosity.

Masashi Kaneta, LBNL Masashi Kaneta for the STAR collaboration Lawrence Berkeley National Lab. First results from STAR experiment at RHIC - Soft hadron.

Hydrodynamic Approach: Open Issues Tetsufumi Hirano Special thanks to Nu Xu, Miklos Gyulassy and Denes Molnar The Berkeley School, LBNL, CA, May 27, 2005.

Perfect Fluid: flow measurements are described by ideal hydro Problem: all fluids have some viscosity -- can we measure it? I. Radial flow fluctuations:

QGP hydro + hadronic cascade model: Status report Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics The Univ. of Tokyo RCNP, Oct , 2007 TH, U.Heinz, D.Kharzeev,

Open data table of hydrodynamic simulations for jet quenching calculations Tetsufumi Hirano Institute of Physics, University of Tokyo Original work: TH,

Lecture 12: Hydrodynamics in heavy ion collisions. Elliptic flow Last lecture we learned:  Particle spectral shapes in thermal model ( static medium)

Workshop for Particle Correlations and Femtoscopy 2011

What can we learn from hydrodynamic analysis of elliptic flow? Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics, Columbia Univ. T.H. and M.Gyulassy, nucl-th/ T.H.,

Dynamical Modeling of Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions Tetsufumi Hirano Workshop at RCNP, Nov 4, 2004 Work in partly collaboration with Y.Nara (Frankfurt),

Relativistic Ideal and Viscous Hydrodynamics Tetsufumi Hirano Department of Physics The University of Tokyo The University of Tokyo Intensive Lecture YITP,

Dynamical Modeling of Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions

Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo Collaborator: Tetsufumi Hirano V iscous Hydrodynamic Expansion of the Quark- Gluon Plasma.

Perfect Fluidity of QGP at RHIC? Tetsufumi Hirano Institute of Physics University of Tokyo Komaba, Tokyo , Japan 平野哲文东京大学 References: T.Hirano.

1 Jeffery T. Mitchell – Quark Matter /17/12 The RHIC Beam Energy Scan Program: Results from the PHENIX Experiment Jeffery T. Mitchell Brookhaven.

LP. Csernai, NWE'2001, Bergen1 Part II Relativistic Hydrodynamics For Modeling Ultra-Relativistic Heavy Ion Reactions.

Phantom Jets: the  puzzle and v 2 without hydrodynamics Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Early Time Dynamics in Heavy Ion Collisions Montreal, July.

Perfect Fluid QGP or CGC? Tetsufumi Hirano* Institute of Physics, University of Tokyo References: T.Hirano and M.Gyulassy, Nucl.Phys.A 769(2006)71. T.Hirano,

Steffen A. BassModeling of RHIC Collisions #1 Steffen A. Bass Duke University Relativistic Fluid Dynamics Hybrid Macro+Micro Transport flavor dependent.

Masashi Kaneta, First joint Meeting of the Nuclear Physics Divisions of APS and JPS 1 / Masashi Kaneta LBNL

Peter Kolb, CIPANP03, May 22, 2003what we learn from hydro1 What did we learn, and what will we learn from Hydro CIPANP 2003 New York City, May 22, 2003.

11/18/2003Tetsufumi Hirano (RBRC)1 Rapidity Dependence of Elliptic Flow from Hydrodynamics Tetsufumi Hirano RIKEN BNL Research Center (Collaboration with.

A Blast-wave Model with Two Freeze-outs Kang Seog Lee (Chonnam Nat’l Univ.)  Chemical and thermal analysis, done in a single model HIM

Perfect Fluid QGP or CGC? Tetsufumi Hirano Institute of Physics, University of Tokyo References: T.Hirano and M.Gyulassy, Nucl.Phys.A 769(2006)71. T.Hirano,

Scaling of Elliptic Flow for a fluid at Finite Shear Viscosity V. Greco M. Colonna M. Di Toro G. Ferini From the Coulomb Barrier to the Quark-Gluon Plasma,

RHIC-II EoS working groupEoS Physics Program #1 1. What physics topics are to be addressed? 2. What observables are sensitive to this physics? 3. Where.

Elliptic flow and shear viscosity in a parton cascade approach G. Ferini INFN-LNS, Catania P. Castorina, M. Colonna, M. Di Toro, V. Greco.

HBT puzzle: from an ideal hydrodynamic point of view Tetsufumi Hirano RHIC/AGS user’s meeting, BNL, NY, June 21, 2005.

Perfect Fluid QGP or CGC? Tetsufumi Hirano Institute of Physics, University of Tokyo References: T.Hirano and M.Gyulassy, Nucl.Phys.A 769(2006)71. T.Hirano,

Hydrodynamic Modeling of Heavy Ion Collisions Tetsufumi Hirano 平野哲文 Department of Physics The University of Tokyo The University of Tokyo ATHIC2008 Tsukuba.

Heavy-Ion Physics - Hydrodynamic Approach Introduction Hydrodynamic aspect Observables explained Recombination model Summary 전남대 이강석 HIM

Dynamical Modeling of Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions Tetsufumi Hirano hirano_at_phys.s.u-tokyo.ac.jp Collaborators:

Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook, ISMD, Kromĕříž, Roy A. Lacey What do we learn from Correlation measurements at RHIC.

Hydrodynamic Analysis of Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions at RHIC and LHC Tetsufumi Hirano The Univ. of Tokyo & LBNL Collaborators: Pasi Huovinen and.

Spectra and Flow from a Full 3D Hydro+Cascade Model Tetsufumi Hirano Institute of Physics, University of Tokyo References: T.Hirano and M.Gyulassy, Nucl.Phys.A.

Bulk properties at RHIC Olga Barannikova (Purdue University) Motivation Freeze-out properties at RHIC STAR perspective STAR  PHENIX, PHOBOS Time-span.

3-D Hydro: present and future Tetsufumi Hirano Columbia University Second RHIC II Science BNL, Probes of EOS.

Collective motion at 5.5 TeV (from RHIC to the LHC) Raimond Snellings.

Hadron Spectra and Yields Experimental Overview Julia Velkovska INT/RHIC Winter Workshop, Dec 13-15, 2002.

What do the scaling characteristics of elliptic flow reveal about the properties of the matter at RHIC ? Michael Issah Stony Brook University for the PHENIX.

Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo Collaborator: Tetsufumi Hirano V iscous Hydrodynamic Evolution with Non-Boost Invariant Flow.

Duke University 野中千穂 Hadron production in heavy ion collision: Fragmentation and recombination in Collaboration with R. J. Fries (Duke), B. Muller (Duke),

Chiho Nonaka QM2009 Nagoya University Chiho NONAKA March 31, Matter 2009, Knoxville, TN In collaboration with Asakawa, Bass, and Mueller.

Hydro + Cascade Model at RHIC

Outline First of all, there’s too much data!! BRAHMS PHOBOS PHENIX

QGP in small colliding systems?

Presentation transcript:

What can we learn from hydrodynamic analysis at RHIC? Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics, Columbia Univ. Workshop on Quark-Gluon-Plasma Thermalization August 10-12, TU Wien, Vienna, Austria T.H. and M.Gyulassy, nucl-th/ T.H., Y.Nara et al., in preparation.

Outline 1.Perfect fluidity of sQGP core and highly dissipative hadronic corona 2.CGC + full 3D hydro + cascade 3.Hydrodynamic analysis suggests even a signal of DECONFINEMENT?! DECONFINEMENT?!

Basis of the Announcement Integrated elliptic flow NA49(’03) PHENIX white paper Differential elliptic flow Common initial time in hydro ~ fm/c A big surprise! Our claims: 1. Ideal hydrodynamics accidentally reproduces these data! 2. Nevertheless, “perfect fluidity of the sQGP” statement still holds. WHY!!!???

Classification of Hydro Models TcTc QGP phase Hadron phase  P artial C hemical E quilibrium EOS Model PCE: Hirano, Teaney; Kolb… Model HC: Teaney, Shuryak, Bass, Dumitru, Nonaka… T ch T th H adronic C ascade C hemical E quilibrium EOS T th Model CE: Kolb, Huovinen Heinz, Hirano… Perfect Fluid of QGP T ~1 fm/c ~3 fm/c ~10-15 fm/c ideal hydrodynamics

PHENIX white paper, NPA757,184(2005) Are hydro results consistent? If not, what does it mean? elliptic flow p T spectra p  P artial CE C hem. E q. H adronic C ascade

Differential Elliptic Flow Develops in the Hadron Phase? T.H. and K.Tsuda (’02) Kolb and Heinz(’04) Is v 2 (p T ) really sensitive to the late dynamics? MeV 100MeV transverse momentum (GeV/c)

Mean p T is the Key Slope of v 2 (p T ) ~ v 2 / Response to decreasing T th (or increasing  ) v2v2 PCE CE v 2 / <pT><pT>    Generic feature!

Accidental Reproduction of v 2 (p T ) pTpT v 2 (p T ) v2v2 pTpT v 2 (p T ) v2v2 pTpT v 2 (p T ) v2v2 Chemical Eq. Chemical F.O. At hadronization CE: increase CFO: decrease freezeout

1.Why mean p T behaves so differently? 2. Why CE result ~ HC result? P artial CE C hem. E q. H adronic C ascade PHENIX white paper, NPA757,184(2005)

Intuitive Picture Chemical Freezeout Chemical Freezeout Chemical Equilibrium Chemical Equilibrium Mean E T decreases due to pdV work For a more rigorous discussion, see T.H. and M.Gyulassy, nucl-th/ MASS energy KINETIC energy E T per particle increases in chemical equilibrium.  This effect delays cooling of the system like a viscous fluid.  Chemical equilibrium imitates viscosity at the cost of particle yield!!!

Chem. Eq. Imitates Viscosity! Model PCE Model CE Contour(T=const.) T(  ) at origin T.H. and K.Tsuda(’02) (T th ) 

Summary of Hydro Results Models for Hadron Phase v2(pT,m)v2(pT,m) p T spectra Yield or ratio Viscous effect Caveat Chemical Equilibrium Y es Y es *NoNo NoNo * P (Pbar) yields << exp. data Partial Chemical Equilibrium NoNo Y es *Y es NoNo *Only low p T for pions Hadronic Cascade Y es Y es * *Kinetic approach Boundary (QGP  hadron) “No-Go theorem” Ruled out! WINNER for hydro race at RHIC !  Hybrid model (Ideal QGP fluid + dissipative hadron gas) by Teaney, Lauret, and Shuryak

The End of 50-Year-Old Ideal, Chem. Eq. Hadronic Fluid After the famous Landau’s paper (1953), ideal and chemical equilibrium hadronic hydrodynamics has been exploited for a long time. However, the model may not be used when chemical freezeout happens earlier than thermal freezeout since it accidentally reproduces p T spectra and v 2 (p T ) at the cost of particle yields in a way that it imitates viscosity.

A Long Long Time Ago… …we obtain the value R (Reynolds number)=1~10… Thus we may infer that the assumption of the perfect fluid is not so good as supposed by Landau. Digression

Summary 1 Critical data harvested at RHIC 1.Particle ratio (Particle yield) 2.p T spectra 3.v 2 AND v 2 (p T ) Nearly perfect fluidity of the sQGP core AND Highly dissipative hadronic corona Hydrodynamic analyses

Results from CGC + full 3D hydro + hadronic cascade Part 2

Toward a Unified Model in H.I.C. Proper time Transverse momentum CGC (a la KLN) Color Quantum Fluid (Q S 2 <k T 2 <Q S 4 /  2 ) (x-evolution eq.) Shattering CGC (k T factorization) Hydrodynamics (full 3D hydro) Parton energy loss (a la Gyulassy-Levai-Vitev) Hadroniccascade(JAM) Low p T High p T Recombination Collinear factorized Parton distribution (CTEQ) LOpQCD(PYTHIA) Nuclear wave function Parton distribution Parton production (dissipative process?) QGP Hadron gas Fragmentation (MV model on 2D lattice) (classical Yang-Mills on 2D lattice) Jet quenching Intermediate p T important in forward region? Not covered in this talk T.H. and Y.Nara, PRC66(’02)041901, 68(’03)064902, 69(’04)034908, PRL91(’03)082301, NPA743(’04)305

CGC + Full 3D Hydro + Cascade 0 z t Color Glass Condensate sQGP core (Full 3D Hydro) Hadronic Corona (Cascade, JAM) c.f. Recent similar approach by Nonaka and Bass (DNP04,QM05)

v 2 (  ) from CGC + Full 3D Hydro + Hadronic Cascade PHOBOS data: “Triangle shape” prop. to dN/d  T th =100MeV: “Trapezoidal shape” Typical hydro result T th =169MeV: Triangle shape! Just after hadronization CGC+hydro+cascade: Good agreement! Perfect fluid sQGP core + dissipative hadronic corona picture works in forward region!

CGC+Hydro+Cascade in Cu+Cu Collisions The effect of rescattering is seen especially near midrapidity.

Predictions for LHC from CGC+Hydro+Cascade No jet components Need to estimate systematic error from Cooper-Frye formula Monotonic increase is consistent with previous work by Teaney et al.

Early Thermalization in Peripheral Collisions at RHIC? CGC + hydro + cascade agreement only up to 15~20% centrality (impact parameter ~5fm) Centrality dependence of thermalization time?  Common  0 =0.6fm/c Semi-central to peripheral collisions:  Not interpreted only by hadronic dissipation  Important to understand pre-thermalization stage  Imcomplete thermalization? (Talk by Borghini)

Does the hydrodynamic agreement with experimental data suggest even DECONFINEMENT?! DECONFINEMENT?! hydro+cascade Part 3

Viscosity and Entropy 1+1D Bjorken flow (Ideal) (Viscous) Reynolds number  : shear viscosity (MeV/fm 2 ) s : entropy density (1/fm 3 ) where  /s is a good dimensionless measure to see viscous effects. R>>1  Perfect fluid Iso, Mori, Namiki (1959)

What Have We Learned? T.H. and M.Gyulassy (’05) ! Absolute value of viscosityIts ratio to entropy density What makes this sudden behavior?  : shear viscosity, s : entropy density

Summary The sQGP core + the dissipative hadronic corona picture can be established through careful comparison of current hydro results with high precision RHIC data. This picture is confirmed in forward rapidity region by using a “cutting edge” hybrid model (CGC + full 3D hydro + hadronic cascade). This picture is manifestation of the sudden change of entropy density at T c, namely deconfinement!