STATE OF POLICING IN MUMBAI (April 2008 to March 2012) December 2012 Supported by FORD FOUNDATION 1

Occurrences of Crime in Mumbai City Specific Crime % Increase to % Increase to % Increase to Murder % % Rape %1805%20715% Molestation %48326%55214% Riot %3850%365-5% House Breaking (Day/Night) %338611% % Chain Snatching %213425% % Thefts %6495-3%6271-3% Accident/Fatal Accidents %258324%286711% Vehicles Stolen %4339-2%483311% Rape, Molestation, Accidents and Vehicle Stolen are growing consistently 2

How secure do people feel in Mumbai Overall 25% of those surveyed feel unsafe Percentage of Respondents who feel unsafe in Mumbai Area of Mumbai How secure do the people feel in Mumbai How secure do the people feel about women, children and senior citizens are in one's locality How secure do the people feel while travelling from one place to another within the city North Mumbai 26%28%31% North West Mumbai 24%37%32% North East Mumbai 20%28% North Central Mumbai 29%40%41% South Central Mumbai 29%31%33% South Mumbai 23%34% 3

Cases Investigated for the year 2011 (includes cases from 12 Police Zones and the Port Zone) Pending Investigation from 2010 Cases Reported in 2011 Classified final as Statement B/C Final reports sent (Statement A) Cases sent-up in 2011(Charge sheet) Pending Investigation as of Dec’11 CLASS - II SERIOUS OFFENCES (Case including Murder, Rape, Grievous Hurt, Kidnapping, Abduction etc.) ,7623%10%87%49% Total (includes cases registered under IPC and cognisable offences under local & special acts) ,4254%31%65%55% 4

Statement A mentioned in the earlier side as ‘Final Reports Sent’ means cases in which charge sheet was not filled but investigation completed. In colloquial police vocabulary Statement A is also known as ‘Case True but not Detected’. E.g. a murder case in which the body is recovered but no clue is available after investigation. Statement B/C means cases declared false or mistake of fact or law. E.g. in the recent case of the two girls in Palghar who were arrested for their remarks on Facebook, the police intend to file Statement C and close the case. 5

Trial Cases for the year – 2011 (includes 12 Police Zones and Port Zone) Pending Trial from 2010 Cases sent-up in 2011CompoundedWithdrawnAcquittedConvicted Pending Trial as of Dec’11 CLASS - II SERIOUS OFFENCES (Case including Murder, Rape, Grievous Hurt, Kidnapping, Abduction etc.) ,87490%10%93% Total (includes cases registered under IPC and cognisable offences under local & special acts) ,61,52883%17%92% 6

Designation wise number of Police Personnel sanctioned and working (as of July 2012) Sr. No. DesignationSanctionedWorking Actual Difference b/w sanctioned and working Difference b/w sanctioned and working in % 1Commissioner of Police (C.P.)1100 2Joint Commissioner of Police (Jt. C.P.) Additional Commissioner of Police (Addl. C.P.) Deputy Commissioner of Police (D.C.P.) % 5 Assistant Commissioner of Police (A.C.P.) % 6Police Inspector (P.I.) % 7Assistant Police Inspector (A.P.I.) % 8Police Sub - Inspector (P.S.I.) % 9Assistant Police Sub-Inspector (A.S.I) % 10Head Constable (H.C.) % 11Police Naik (P.N.) % 12Police Constable (P.C.) % Total Police Force % 7

Police Personnel details based on Department (as on 31st July 2012) Department Police Personnel Sanctione d Police Personnel Working (July’12) Difference between Sanctioned and Working (July ’12) % difference between Sanctioned and Working (July ’12) Difference between Sanctioned and Working (Nov’11) % difference between Sanctioned and Working (Nov’11) Special Branch (I - CID) % % Special Branch (II - Passport) % % Crime Branch % % Protection and Security %-55-4% Armed Police % % Anti-Terrorist Squad %2515% Wireless Section %-93-21% Traffic % % Control Room % % Total % % Control Room is short by 145 officers (again a gap of 53%). The shortage in the Traffic Police has come down from 49% in 2011 to 8% in 2012 – this is a welcome step as this can have significant impact on the increasing number of accidents in the city. 8

Property recovered and stolen in the year 2011 Offences No. of cases in which property was stolen No. of Cases in which Property was recovered % of cases in which Property was recovered to cases in which Property was stolen Amount of Property Stolen (in Lakh) Amount of Property recovered (in Lakh) % of value of property recovered to value of property stolen Theft15,7455,33834%26,6086,05623% Dacoity302687% % Robbery % % Criminal Breach of Trust %23,8481,2815% Criminal Breach of Trust by public servant or by a banker, merchant or agent 4250%5300 Possession of stolen property XXII %10 100% Criminal Miss- appropriation %21, % TOTAL17,7036,30936%72,9528,11511% ‘Criminal Breach of Trust’ and ‘Criminal Miss- appropriation’ includes 62% of the total value of the property stolen and has the least recovery rate i.e. 5% and 1% respectively. 9

Questions asked by MLAs on Crime issues area-wise Sr. No. Area of Mumbai No. of Police Stations MLAs Total questions asked in Crime Total occurrence of crime from April 2011 to March North Mumbai13 Gopal Shetty, Vinod Ghosalkar, Pravin Darekar, Ramesh Thakur, Yogesh Sagar, Aslam Shaikh North West Mumbai 14 Ravindra Waikar, Rajhans Singh, Subhash Desai, Baldev Khosa, Ashok Jadhav, North East Mumbai 11 Sardar Tara Singh, Mangesh Sangle,Shishir Shinde, RamchandraKadam, Prakash Maheta, Abu Azmi North Central Mumbai 13 Krishnakumar Hegde, Milind Kamble, Prakash Sawant, Baba Sidikki, Kripashankar Singh South Central Mumbai 15 Nawab Malik, Chandrakant Handore, Jagannath Shetty, Kalidas Kolambkar, Nitin Sardesai South Mumbai26 Bala Nandgaonkar, Madhukar Chavan, Mangal Prabhat Lodha, Amin Patel, Annie Shekhar Note: 1) Questions Asked by MLAs only during the following sessions have been included: Monsoon 2011, Winter 2011 and Budget ) Sachin Ahir, Varsha Gaikwad, Arif Naseem Khan and Suresh Shetty are ministers hence there are no questions asked by them 10

What needs to be done Separate Investigation from Law and Order. Strengthen and where necessary create infrastructure for continuous training, forensic labs, crime mapping and crime forecasting. Upgrade the archaic police acts to suit the needs of today. Immediately take steps to fill up gaps in the sanctioned and available strengths of the police force. 11

THANK YOU !!! 12