“What is an Author?” By Michel Foucault.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Subject-Matter of Ethics
Advertisements

How to Succeed at Life (and Do Well on the AP English Language and Composition Multiple Choice) Adapted from: English Language and Composition, 3rd Edition.
Conceptualization Making clear what we are talking about.
Chapter 32: Critical Approaches Important in the Study of Literature
Postmodern Theories on Author Some Preliminary Ideas & Overview.
1 CHAPTER 4 RELATIONAL ALGEBRA AND CALCULUS. 2 Introduction - We discuss here two mathematical formalisms which can be used as the basis for stating and.
Why study grammar? Knowledge of grammar facilitates language learning
The nature of Sign and sign/symbol distinction
New Historicism Exploring the value of history in literature A sociological and anthropological approach to criticism.
Bell's Theory of Art Bell’s requirements for constructing a Theory of Art The ability to think clearly. The possession of an artistic sensibility. (the.
English 472 A Review. Overview  Histories  Theories  Questions and Quandaries.
Structuralism Semiotic. Definition Semiotic / semiology => The study of sign and sign-using behavior a domain of investigation that explores the nature.
What is a subject? “Inhumanities” 201 Day 17. Itinerary today Evaluate Michel Foucault’s “What is an Author?” Evaluate the role of subjectivity in contemporary.
Knowledge and Experience
Assessing the Credibility of Sources 5 Aspects. 1. Source of Publication Books (University & Scholarly Presses vs. Popular Presses) Books (University.
Post-Structuralism & Postmodern Texts (3) 1. Post-Structuralism Defined & Marxism vs. Post-Structuralism 2. Fiction and Reality: Examples 1: context into.
Speech and Phenomena Philosophy 157 G. J. Mattey ©2002.
Literature and History (3): Michel Foucault: His Views on History & New Historicism.
Preface. Reading in a Special Way Reading the Bible as literature boils down to a certain way of reading—reading in the context of the categories and.
overview of the “Introduction” from Film Analysis,
Main Branches of Linguistics
Philosophical Concerns in Critical Psychology Critical Psychology is rooted in different social critiques to industrial capitalism (Marx, 1844) and the.
LOGIC AND CRITICAL THINKING Jonathan Dolhenty, Ph.D. Logic and Critical Thinking. Available at
Module A: Comparative Study of Texts and Context The comparative study of texts in relation to historical or cultural contexts.
By Lillianie T. Millan ENGG 630 Prof. Evelyn Lugo
“Analysing Gender in Media Texts” or, “Welcome to Media Studies...” By, Gill.
Through the Literary Looking Glass: Critical Theory in Practice 1301.
Copyright © 2002 Thomson Learning, Inc. Chapter 5: Language: Barrier and Bridge PowerPoint Presentation to accompany Looking Out, Looking In, Tenth Edition.
Elements of Fiction.
Methods of Development
Linguistics Introduction.
Qualitative Data Analysis: An introduction Carol Grbich Chapter 13: Structuralism and post structuralism.
Chapter 1 Introduction to Statistics. Statistical Methods Were developed to serve a purpose Were developed to serve a purpose The purpose for each statistical.
© 2005 Brenda RogersIEP Game Patent Pending #9014.
Reviewing how to analyze rhetorically for all genres.
We do not search for the meanings of things in the things themselves. Rather, we find meaning in the way we can relate things together, either through.
1. Focus Unit 5: The phenomena Language, Language as a (tangible, physical) symbolic system for communication Language as a window to the mind (internal.
Sei Shnagon Blogger Sei Sh ō nagon Blogger. What is an Author? Locating the author as an individual  Author as outside and preceding the text  The source.
Making sense of it all analysing and interpreting data.
MODULE 1 In classical mechanics we define a STATE as “The specification of the position and velocity of all the particles present, at some time, and the.
GUÍA 1. Main ideas writers (indeed, all human beings) function within a language or textual system (there is nothing outside of the text); texts must.
Language, Ideology and Power Lecture 1: Language, Discourse and CDA (Critical Discourse Analysis)
Frames of Analysis of Heritage Tourism Critical Discourse Analysis.
Visual Understanding. Purpose of Visual Understanding Understand what you see and communicate that to an audience. Understand the rhetorical purposes.
New Historicism Exploring the value of history in literature
Moulay Ismail University Faculty Of Letters And Humanities English Department Master program Communication in contexts Approaches To Criticism Prof.
Module C REPRESENTATION AND TEXT
What representation is not… Media instantaneously planting images and thoughts in our heads.
Definition Context Themes Literature: - Representants Representants - Text Text In reaction of…
1 Literary Criticism Exploring literature beneath the surface.
CIV Class 2 january 23, 2015 Two approaches to analyzing cultural history Michel Foucault TS Kuhn Analyzing art.
What is Postmodernism? A complicated term A set of ideas emerged as an area of academic study since the mid-1980s It is hard to define it is a concept.
Structuralism By John Lye General principles 1.Meaning occurs through difference 2.Relations among signs are of two sorts, contiguity and substitutability.
What is rhetoric? What you need to know for AP Language.
Stuart Hall Who Needs ‘Identity’?.
SAETA Refresher Course 2016 Ideas for Creating Texts for Stage 1 Alex Cape.
Western Civilization to c CIV Professor Ed Lamoureux Day 2 January 22, 2016 Two approaches to analyzing cultural history Remember: I put these.
Post-structuralism Literature in English ~ ASL. Structuralism VS Post-structuralism  Post-structuralism is a response to structuralism structuralism.
Translatability. Noam Chomsky ("hómski“) In Chomsky's view, every phrase, before being formulated, is conceived as a deep structure in our mind. A phrase.
Literary Theory Reader-Response Criticism. Subjective vs. Objective When we refer to something as “subjective” we mean that it pertains to the individual.
Classification of Research
Introduction to critical theory: Organizations, power, and rhetoric, pt. 1 Why Critical Theory? Eventually, we are going to examine and analyze communication.
POSTMODERNISM-PSYCHOANALYSIS
Post- Structuralist.
Semiotics Structuralism.
“Welcome to Media Studies”
Literature in English ASL
POSTSTRUCTURALISM AND POSTMODERNISM
What is Postmodernism? A complicated term
Presentation transcript:

“What is an Author?” By Michel Foucault

The Criticisms of the previous book The Order of Things The inadequate descriptions of Buffon, Marx and their works The “monstrous families”—the associations of seemingly irrelevant authors as if they belong to the same discursive family

Foucault’s responses “I want to locate the rules that formed a certain number of concepts and theoretical relationships in their works” (1622) “…asking why we are concerned with the idea of authors at all, rather than seeing “discourse” as the groupings of texts and ideas.” (Klages)

The purposes & preliminary thinking of “author” “[to] set aside a sociohistorical analysis of the author as an individual and the numerous questions that deserve attention in this context” (1623) Samuel Beckett’s question “What matter who’s speaking?”

The concerns of writing (1)—writing & discourse “[T]he writing of our day has freed itself from the necessity of ‘expression’; it only refers to itself, yet it is not restricted to the confines of interiority. On the contrary, we recognize it in its exterior deployment” (1623)

The concerns of writing (2)—writing & language Writing as an interplay of signs, the play among signifiers “Thus the essential basis of this writing is not the exalted emotions related to the act of composition or the insertion of a subject into language. Rather, it is primarily concerned with creating an opening where the writing subject endlessly disappear” (1623)

The concerns of writing “ecriture” (3)—writing & death The concept of writing as a protection against death, achieving “immortality” ex. the Greek epic, The Arabian Nights “Where a work had the duty of creating immortality, it now attains the right to kill, to become the murderer of its author” (1624)

The concerns of writing (3)—writing & death “So why does Foucault say the author is ‘dead’? It’s his way of saying that author is decentered, shown to be only a part of the structure, a subject position, and not the center…By declaring the death of the author, Foucault is ‘deconstructing’ the idea that the author is the origin of something original, and replacing it with the idea that the ‘author’ is the product or function of writing, of the text.” (Klages)

Author's disappearance & work/ “ecriture” How can an author’s works be defined? What should be included in his work? The notion of “ecriture” “rather, it stands for a remarkably profound contempt to elaborate the conditions of any text, both the conditions of its spatial dispersion and its temporal deployment.” (1625) “in emphasizing the play of signification over any fixed or stable meaning, doesn’t really get rid of the idea of authorship completely, but rather makes authors ‘transcendental’ rather than historical real” (Klages)

Problems with a proper name, the author’s name and their functions The name of the author/a proper name: “a signifier that designates a specific and discrete historical individual” (Klages) The Author’s name: “it is situated in the breach, among the discontinuities, which gives rise to new groups of discourse and their singular mode of existence…is to characterize the existence, circulation, and operation of certain discourses within a society.” (1628)

The proper name of an author “The proper name and the name of an author oscillate between description (the ideas, the work related) and designation (the person).” (1626) “The relation between signifier and signified—between proper name and what it either designates or describes—is arbitrary and separable” (Klages) ex. Shakespeare and “the plays of Shakespeare”

4 features of texts which create the author function (1) Objects of appropriation, forms of property “From this idea of locating authorship in someone held responsibility for writing or speech came also the idea of ownership of works, and the idea of copyright rules.” (Klages)

4 features of texts which create the author function (2) The “author function” is not a universal or constant feature of every text The anonymous literary texts vs. scientific texts required names Since the 17th, 18th centuries however: the objective scientific texts vs. the literary works evaluated on the basis of the notion of the author

4 features of texts which create the author function (3) The author function is not formed spontaneously through the simple attribution of a discourse to an individual “Rather, it results from various cultural constructions, in which we choose certain attributes of an individual as ‘authorial’ attributes, and dismiss others.” (Klages)

Standard level of quality How the author is culturally constructed: St. Jerome 4 criteria attributed to a single author Standard level of quality Contradiction or conflicts of ideas—denotes a field of conceptual or theoretical coherence Stylistic uniformity Definite historical figure in which a series of events converge

How the author is culturally constructed: Modern criticism on textual study, a similar approach The author’s biography explains the presence of certain events in the texts The author is the principle of unity The author neutralizes contradictions The author is the particular source of expression manifested equally well in texts, letters, fragments, etc (Klages’ summery)

4 features of texts which create the author function (4) The text always bear signs that refer to the author, or create the “author function” (Klages) ex. The pronoun “I”: narrator and author

4 features of texts which create the author function (5) “The ‘author-function’ is tied to the legal and institutional systems that circumscribe, determine, and articulate the realm of discourses; it does not operate in a uniform manner in all discourses, at all times, an in any given culture; it is not defined by the spontaneous attribution of a text to its creator, but through a series of precise and complex procedures; it does not refer, purely and simply, to an actual individual insofar as it simultaneously gives rise to a variety of egos and to a series of subjective positions that individuals of any class may come to occupy.” (1631)

Transdiscursive position (1) Initiators of discursive practices: Freud, Marx, Radcliffe These authors produced not only their work, but the possibility and rules of formation of other texts “Marx and Freud not only made possible a certain number of analogies that could be adopted by future texts, but they also made possible a certain number of differences.” (1632)

Transdiscursive position (2) The initiation of discursive practices appears similar to the founding of any scientific endeavor “The initiation of a discursive practice, unlike the founding of science, overshadows and is necessarily detached from its later developments and transformations.” (1633)

Discourses “returning to the origin” (1) Different from the scientific “rediscoveries” and “reactivations” Rediscoveries: “the effects of analogy or isomorphism with current forms of knowledge that allow the perception of forgotten or obscured figures.” (1634) Reactivations: “the insertion of discourse into totally new domains of generalization, practice, and transformation.” (1634)

Discourses “returning to the origin” (2) Features of “returning to the origin” “Designates a movement with its proper specificity, which characterizes the initiation of discursive practices.” (1634) “They tend to reinforce the enigmatic link between an author and his works.” (1634) “Form a relationship between "fundamental" and mediate authors, which is not identical to that which links an ordinary text to its immediate author.” (1635)

Conclusions “Partially at the expense of themes and concepts that an author places in his work, the "author-function" could also reveal the manner in which discourse is articulated on the basis of social relationships.” (1635) “The subject (and its substitutes) must be stripped of its creative role and analyzed as a complex and variable function of discourse.” (Hsu) Questions about the relations of subjects to discourses

References Klages, Mary. “Michel Foucault: ‘What is an Author?’ http://www.colorado.edu/English/ENGL2012Klages/foucault.html Hsu, Sophia. “Michel Foucault's ‘What Is an Author?’--An Outline.” http://www.eng.fju.edu.tw/Literary_Criticism/postmodernism/foucault_author.html