Black Sea Regional Transmission Planning Project - renewables integration - By Predrag Mikša EKC - Electricity Coordinating Center Simferopol, June 2011

Black Sea Transmission Project TASK#3 – Renewables data collection Renewables Generation expansion plans Wind Small hydro Other Estimated connection to grid Market approach (feed in tariff and price,…) Rules of engagement Each country to prepare country report, Model integrator to prepare regional overview and regional report

Black Sea Transmission Project ARMENIA Renewables development plan Small hydro Biomass? Solar? Geothermal? Wind Few sentences with basic data (estimated posible capacities, present level of usage, development plans etc...) Maps with RES locations, wind measurements etc...

Black Sea Transmission Project ARMENIA Connection of renewables to transmission grid Description of present network Connection strategy? Network development plan Development that does not depend on RES Development required by RES Connection procedure? (rough description or algorithm) Studies and analyses (done so far, conclusions etc...)

Black Sea Transmission Project ARMENIA Renewables tariffs Stipulation system? Present level of RES tariffs Future plans? Analyses results and renewables balancing and control System reserves (analyses results so far) Power plants that are used Operational difficulties? results and conclusions based on calculations done by EKC

Black Sea Transmission Project ARMENIA Remarks and comments Critical overview by TSO on realization of plans and how realistic they really are. Also, expected problems that can occur because large renewables penetration in transmission networks (points of network that need strengthening) based on your experience and expertise. References list of documents (official ones), studies etc that are used for this survey, no mater if they are public or not.

Black Sea Transmission Project BULGARIA Renewables development plan Small hydro Biomass Solar Geothermal Wind Few sentences with basic data (estimated posible capacities, present level of usage, development plans etc...) Maps with RES locations, wind measurements etc...

Black Sea Transmission Project BULGARIA Connection of renewables to transmission grid Description of present network Connection strategy? Network development plan Development that does not depend on RES Development required by RES Connection procedure? (rough description or algorithm) Studies and analyses (done so far, conclusions etc...)

Black Sea Transmission Project BULGARIA Renewables tariffs Stipulation system? Present level of RES tariffs Future plans? Analyses results and renewables balancing and control System reserves (analyses results so far) Power plants that are used Operational difficulties? results and conclusions based on calculations done by EKC

Black Sea Transmission Project BULGARIA Remarks and comments Critical overview by TSO on realization of plans and how realistic they really are. Also, expected problems that can occur because large renewables penetration in transmission networks (points of network that need strengthening) based on your experience and expertise. References list of documents (official ones), studies etc that are used for this survey, no mater if they are public or not.

Black Sea Transmission Project GEORGIA Renewables development plan Small hydro Biomass Solar Geothermal Wind Few sentences with basic data (estimated posible capacities, present level of usage, development plans etc...) Maps with RES locations, wind measurements etc...

Black Sea Transmission Project GEORGIA Connection of renewables to transmission grid Description of present network Connection strategy? Network development plan Development that does not depend on RES Development required by RES Connection procedure? (rough description or algorithm) Studies and analyses (done so far, conclusions etc...)

Black Sea Transmission Project GEORGIA Renewables tariffs Stipulation system? Present level of RES tariffs Future plans? Analyses results and renewables balancing and control System reserves (analyses results so far) Power plants that are used Operational difficulties? results and conclusions based on calculations done by EKC

Black Sea Transmission Project GEORGIA Remarks and comments Critical overview by TSO on realization of plans and how realistic they really are. Also, expected problems that can occur because large renewables penetration in transmission networks (points of network that need strengthening) based on your experience and expertise. References list of documents (official ones), studies etc that are used for this survey, no mater if they are public or not.

Black Sea Transmission Project MOLDOVA Renewables development plan Small hydro Biomass Solar Geothermal Wind Few sentences with basic data (estimated posible capacities, present level of usage, development plans etc...) Maps with RES locations, wind measurements etc...

Black Sea Transmission Project MOLDOVA Connection of renewables to transmission grid Description of present network Connection strategy? Network development plan Development that does not depend on RES Development required by RES Connection procedure? (rough description or algorithm) Studies and analyses (done so far, conclusions etc...)

Black Sea Transmission Project MOLDOVA Renewables tariffs Stipulation system? Present level of RES tariffs Future plans? Analyses results and renewables balancing and control System reserves (analyses results so far) Power plants that are used Operational difficulties? results and conclusions based on calculations done by EKC

Black Sea Transmission Project MOLDOVA Remarks and comments Critical overview by TSO on realization of plans and how realistic they really are. Also, expected problems that can occur because large renewables penetration in transmission networks (points of network that need strengthening) based on your experience and expertise. References list of documents (official ones), studies etc that are used for this survey, no mater if they are public or not.

Black Sea Transmission Project ROMANIA Renewables development plan Small hydro Biomass Solar Geothermal Wind Few sentences with basic data (estimated posible capacities, present level of usage, development plans etc...) Maps with RES locations, wind measurements etc...

Black Sea Transmission Project ROMANIA Connection of renewables to transmission grid Description of present network Connection strategy? Network development plan Development that does not depend on RES Development required by RES Connection procedure? (rough description or algorithm) Studies and analyses (done so far, conclusions etc...)

Black Sea Transmission Project ROMANIA Renewables tariffs Stipulation system? Present level of RES tariffs Future plans? Analyses results and renewables balancing and control System reserves (analyses results so far) Power plants that are used Operational difficulties? results and conclusions based on calculations done by EKC

Black Sea Transmission Project ROMANIA Remarks and comments Critical overview by TSO on realization of plans and how realistic they really are. Also, expected problems that can occur because large renewables penetration in transmission networks (points of network that need strengthening) based on your experience and expertise. References list of documents (official ones), studies etc that are used for this survey, no mater if they are public or not.

Black Sea Transmission Project RUSSIA Renewables development plan Small hydro Biomass Solar Geothermal Tidal Wind Few sentences with basic data (estimated posible capacities, present level of usage, development plans etc...) Maps with RES locations, wind measurements etc...

Black Sea Transmission Project RUSSIA Connection of renewables to transmission grid Description of present network Connection strategy? Network development plan Development that does not depend on RES Development required by RES Connection procedure? (rough description or algorithm) Studies and analyses (done so far, conclusions etc...)

Black Sea Transmission Project RUSSIA Renewables tariffs Stipulation system? Present level of RES tariffs Future plans? Analyses results and renewables balancing and control System reserves (analyses results so far) Power plants that are used Operational difficulties? results and conclusions based on calculations done by EKC

Black Sea Transmission Project RUSSIA Remarks and comments Critical overview by TSO on realization of plans and how realistic they really are. Also, expected problems that can occur because large renewables penetration in transmission networks (points of network that need strengthening) based on your experience and expertise. References list of documents (official ones), studies etc that are used for this survey, no mater if they are public or not.

Black Sea Transmission Project TURKEY Renewables development plan Small hydro Biomass Solar Geothermal Wind Few sentences with basic data (estimated posible capacities, present level of usage, development plans etc...) Maps with RES locations, wind measurements etc...

Black Sea Transmission Project TURKEY Connection of renewables to transmission grid Description of present network Connection strategy? Network development plan Development that does not depend on RES Development required by RES Connection procedure? (rough description or algorithm) Studies and analyses (done so far, conclusions etc...)

Black Sea Transmission Project TURKEY Renewables tariffs Stipulation system? Present level of RES tariffs Future plans? Analyses results and renewables balancing and control System reserves (analyses results so far) Power plants that are used Operational difficulties? results and conclusions based on calculations done by EKC

Black Sea Transmission Project TURKEY Remarks and comments Critical overview by TSO on realization of plans and how realistic they really are. Also, expected problems that can occur because large renewables penetration in transmission networks (points of network that need strengthening) based on your experience and expertise. References list of documents (official ones), studies etc that are used for this survey, no mater if they are public or not.

Black Sea Transmission Project UKRAINE Renewables development plan Small hydro Biomass Solar Geothermal Wind Few sentences with basic data (estimated posible capacities, present level of usage, development plans etc...) Maps with RES locations, wind measurements etc...

Black Sea Transmission Project UKRAINE Connection of renewables to transmission grid Description of present network Connection strategy? Network development plan Development that does not depend on RES Development required by RES Connection procedure? (rough description or algorithm) Studies and analyses (done so far, conclusions etc...)

Black Sea Transmission Project UKRAINE Renewables tariffs Stipulation system? Present level of RES tariffs Future plans? Analyses results and renewables balancing and control System reserves (analyses results so far) Power plants that are used Operational difficulties? results and conclusions based on calculations done by EKC

Black Sea Transmission Project UKRAINE Remarks and comments Critical overview by TSO on realization of plans and how realistic they really are. Also, expected problems that can occur because large renewables penetration in transmission networks (points of network that need strengthening) based on your experience and expertise. References list of documents (official ones), studies etc that are used for this survey, no mater if they are public or not.

Black Sea Transmission Project Thank You!