ISTEP Update Transmission Planning Summit August 11, 2009 Crown Plaza Hotel New Orleans, LA.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Cleco Transmission Planning Summit 2013
Advertisements

October 16, 2009 RPG Meeting ERCOT RPG Project Review Update Jeff Billo.
1 Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (Louisiana) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
Company LOGO Cleco Planning Process. Models Cleco uses SPP’s annual series of models to determine the NERC reliability violations. Cleco uses SPP or VST.
Cleco Transmission Planning Summit 2012
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (North) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
Entergy Arkansas, Inc. Proposed Transmission Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
Cleco Transmission Planning Summit 2011 Coughlin Transmission Operations Center April 15, :00 – 11:00am.
Congestion Management in a Market Environment 2 nd CIGRE / IEEE PES International Symposium San Antonio, Texas October 5, 2005 Kenneth W. Laughlin.
Tucson Area Reliability Mike Flores Control Area Operations Tucson Electric Power May 2000.
KURTEN SWITCH PROJECT (BRYAN/ COLLEGE STATION AREA UPGRADES) Technical Advisory Committee December 1, 2005 Transmission Services.
System Voltage Planning Brian Moss PD / Transmission Planning Transmission Planning Overview October 30, 2007.
January 5, 2012 TAC Cross Valley 345 kV Project Jeff Billo Manager, Mid-Term Planning.
ICT 2011 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy Transmission Summit August 11, 2010 Sheraton New Orleans, Louisiana.
1 Entergy Louisiana, LLC (South) & Entergy New Orleans, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans,
1 Voltage Stability and Reactive Power Planning Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004 Entergy Transmission Planning Summit.
Xcel Energy Smaller Scale Transmission Projects Northern MAPP Subregional Planning Group April 3, 2007 Srinivas Vemuri, Jason Standing, and Daniel Kline.
RTP Update RPG Meeting July 21, RTP update  Reliability analysis for the contingencies where load shed is not allowed is complete.
1 Local Area Planning Update to TRANSAC – September 18, 2014.
Jan 13, 2012 RPG Meeting El Campo – Vanderbilt 69 kV Project – Status report Ehsan Ur Rehman Planning Engineer ERCOT.
SPP.org 1. 2 Aggregate Transmission Service Study (ATSS)
Joel Koepke, P.E. ERCOT Operations Support Engineer ERCOT Experiences During Summer 2011.
George Bartlett Director, Transmission Operations Economic Transmission Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
1 Entergy Mississippi, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
ICT Strategic Transmission Plan (ISTEP) Review and Status Update Entergy Transmission Summit July 29, 2008 Astor Crown Plaza New Orleans, Louisiana Douglas.
1 Entergy Texas, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 29, 2008.
Lyndonville Electric Department Feasibility Analysis Review December 2,
1 Entergy Arkansas, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
1 Generator Interconnection Status Update Tom Lanigan Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
1 Entergy Transmission Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
ISTEP Phase II Final Report Summary LTTIWG Meeting – January 27, 2009 Douglas Bowman, PE Lead Engineer, ICT Planning
Base Plan Development Overview 2007 Transmission Summit July 31, 2007 New Orleans, Louisiana.
October 16, 2009 RPG Meeting ERCOT 2009 Five-Year Transmission Plan Update Jeff Billo.
1 Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (Louisiana) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
SPP.org 1. ICT Construction Plan Evaluation and Reliability Assessment Part 1 Entergy Transmission Summit July 29, 2008 Astor Crown Plaza New Orleans,
Proposed North – South Congestion Mitigation Plan Luminant Energy July 2008.
1 Stability Issues in Entergy System Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
1 Entergy Gulf States Louisiana, L.L.C. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects.
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (South) & Entergy New Orleans, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans,
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (South) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
© ABB Group August 23,2010 | Slide 1 MBPC Study – 1 st Load Pocket Preliminary Results for Discussion only Entergy Regional State Committee (ERSC) Southwest.
SPP.org 1. ESRPP 2009 Regional Studies Initial Results ESRPP Stakeholder Meeting August 12, 2009 Astor Crown Plaza New Orleans, Louisiana.
1 Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (Louisiana) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 31, 2007.
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (North) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
Big Stone II – Delivery Study Phase 6 and Supplemental #2 For Northern MAPP SPG Meeting 4/3/07 Elk River Richard Dahl Missouri River Energy Services.
SPP.org 1. Status Update for Reliability and Economic Assessments Stakeholder Meeting September 16, 2008 Austin, TX.
February 13, 2009 RPG Meeting ERCOT System Development Update Jeff Billo.
OCTOBER 2, 2013 Maine 2013 Outage Coordination Redacted Copy.
Current Operational Challenges Computing the West – North Limits Potential IROLs Local Voltage & Thermal issue (OOME) High Voltage Outages.
© 2000 PACIFICORP | PAGE 1 –Main Transmission Sources  kV Transformers. Terminal, Mid Valley, 90 th South and Oquirrh –Generation: Gadsby (~350.
ESI Alternate Economic Study Process E-RSC Meeting October 21, 2010.
Reliability Redispatch Pilot Presentation for NIPPC June 13, 2007 Term of Pilot 6/26/07 through 9/30/07.
1 Entergy Mississippi, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
ERCOT Transmission Planning Process Overview and Recommendations November 6, 2002.
1 Entergy Arkansas, Inc. Proposed Transmission Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 29, 2008.
SPP.org 1. ICT Construction Plan Evaluation and Reliability Assessment Part 2 Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit July 29, 2008 Astor Crown Plaza.
Douglas Bowman, PE, PMP Project Manager Entergy Corporation New Projects and Processes Ensure Power Transfer for Northeast Arkansas Customers.
SPP.org 1. Regional and Inter-Regional Planning Update Entergy Transmission Summit July 29, 2008 Astor Crown Plaza New Orleans, Louisiana.
1 Entergy Arkansas, Inc. Proposed Transmission Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 31, 2007.
PJM© Market Efficiency RTEP Proposal Window PJM TEAC 1/9/2014 – Market Efficiency Presentation.
2006 Preliminary Reliability Study Results Bryan Guy September 7, 2006.
Presentation For PSAST May 14, Outline Most Limiting N-1-X Events Voltage Limitations For Loss of Three Terminal Monroe- Echo Lake 500kV and Chief.
2008 Annual Five Year Plan Update 4 For RPG-CREZ Meeting 12/14/2007 Department of Regional Planning Harry Liu.
Local Area Planning Update – TRANSAC Base Case Status Base case study models representing the base scenarios will be completed as follows for.
ERCOT – LP&L Study Status Update For Regional Planning Group Ben Richardson March 22, 2016.
Removal of Fraser RAS from RAS Databse
Removal of Fraser RAS from RAS Databse
Two-Tier Firm Curtailment Overview
Strategic Plan and Economic Upgrade Process
Presentation transcript:

ISTEP Update Transmission Planning Summit August 11, 2009 Crown Plaza Hotel New Orleans, LA

ISTEP 2009 Projects

4 1.South Central Arkansas/Northeast Louisiana constraint – to address North to South flows 2.Central Arkansas constraint – to address South to North flows 3.Lake Charles 230 kV Loop (relieve 138 kV Flowgate NELLC_NELLCB) 4.Baton Rouge/South MS constraint – to address Central to South flows 5.Jackson Area Today’s presentation focuses on preliminary results for projects 1 and 2 ISTEP 2009

ISTEP Projects 1 & 2 – ISSUES

6 Project 1 & 2 Issues 2008 Monitored Flowgate Curtailments FGDescriptionNon-Firm MWhFirm MWh 1Sheridan – Mabelvale 500 kV FTLO White Bluff – Keo 500 kV (SHRMAB_KEO) 18,7294,324 2Sheridan – El Dorado 500 kV FTLO Etta – McNeil 500 kV (SHRELD_HSPET) 73,01025,199 3White Bluff – Sheridan 500 kV FTLO Mabelvale – Sheridan 500kV (WHBSHE_MABEL) 32,0840 4Mabelvale – Sheridan 500 kV FTLO White Bluff – Sheridan 500kV (MABSH_WBSH) 14,0960 5White Bluff – Keo 500 kV FTLO Sheridan – Mabelvale 500 FTLO (WBKEO_SHMAB) 4430

7 Project 1 & 2 Issues 2008 Monitored Flowgates - Locations

8 Replicate the flowgate issues that have occurred in 2008 and determine solutions to mitigate them Issue not apparent in long-term models Determine system operation during a known TLR event Model the system as shown during the event using a day-ahead operational model Should replicate the flowgate overload issues Determine system changes to eliminate flowgate issues Projects 1 & 2 Method of Preliminary Study

Project 1 South Central AR / Northeast LA Constraint

10 North – South generation bias observed Affected Flowgates Sheridan – Eldorado FTLO Etta – McNeil (Flowgate 2) WhiteBluff-Sheridan FTLO Mabelvale-Sheridan (Flowgate 3) Mabelvale-Sheridan FTLO White Bluff-Sheridan (Flowgate 4) Flowgate issues occur during daily off-peak periods of the peak loading season Project 1: Southcentral AR / Northeast LA Constraint Background

11 Used July 6, 2008 Operational day-ahead model TLR curtailment called July 6, 2am WhiteBluff-Sheridan FTLO Mabelvale-Sheridan (Flowgate 3) Actual Generation / Load / Transactions used in the model simulation Project 1: South Central AR / Northeast LA Constraint Modeling and Assumptions

12 South Central AR / Northeast LA Constraint Base Flows Base flows for 500kV are North to South

13 South Central AR / Northeast LA Constraint SHRMAB_KEO (Flowgate 1)

14 Southcentral AR / Northeast LA Constraint SHRELD_HSPET (Flowgate 2)

15 South Central AR / Northeast LA Constraint WHBSHE_MABEL (FG3), WBKEO_SHMAB (FG5)

16 South Central AR / Northeast LA Constraint MABSH_WBSH (Flowgate 4)

17 Southcentral AR / Northeast LA Constraint Upgrades in the Change Case Terminal Limiting Equipment Upgrades: Sheridan-Eldorado 500kV from 1732 to 2546 MVA (FG2) White Bluff – Sheridan 500 kV from 1732 to 2546 MVA (FG3) Mabelvale – Sheridan500 kV from 1732 to 2546 MVA (FG4)

18 South Central AR / Northeast LA Constraint Change Case Base Flows

19 South Central AR / Northeast LA Constraint Change Case SHRMAB_KEO (Flowgate 1)

20 Southcentral AR / Northeast LA Constraint Change Case SHRELD_HSPET (Flowgate 2)

21 South Central AR / Northeast LA Constraint Change Case WHBSHE_MABEL (FG3), WBKEO_SHMAB (FG5)

22 South Central AR / Northeast LA Constraint Change Case MABSH_WBSH (Flowgate 4)

Project 2 Central Arkansas Constraint

24 Generation Outlet Issue South to North Flows Observed Affected Flowgates Sheridan – Mabelvale FTLO White Bluff – Keo (FG1) Flowgate issue occurs during daily on-peak periods of off-peak load season Project 2. Central AR Constraint Background 4

25 Used Dec 21, 2008 Operational day-ahead model TLR curtailment called Dec 21, 6pm Sheridan – Mabelvale FTLO White Bluff – Keo (Flowgate 1) Actual Generation / Load / Transactions used in the model simulation Project 2. Central AR Constraint Modeling and Assumptions

26 Central AR Constraint Base Flows Base flows for 500kV are South to North

27 Central AR Constraint SHRMAB_WBKEO (Flowgate 1)

28 Central AR Constraint SHRELD_HSPET (Flowgate 2)

29 Central AR Constraint WHBSHE_MABEL (FG3), WBKEO_SHMAB (FG5)

30 Central AR Constraint MABSH_WBSH (Flowgate 4)

31 Central AR Constraint Upgrades in the Change Case Terminal Limiting Equipment Upgrades: Mabelvale – Sheridan 500 kV from 1732 to 2546 MVA (FG1)

32 Central AR Constraint Change Case Base Flows

33 Central AR Constraint Change Case SHRMAB_WBKEO (Flowgate 1)

34 Central Ar Constraint Change Case SHRELD_HSPET(Flowgate 2)

35 Central AR Constraint Change Case WHBSHE_MABEL (FG3), WBKEO_SHMAB (FG5)

36 Central Ar Constraint Change Case MABSH_WBSH (Flowgate 4)

Results Summary

38 Results Summary: ISTEP solution FGDescriptionISTEP Project no. MVA Added New MVA Rating 1Sheridan – Mabelvale 500 kV FTLO White Bluff – Keo 500 kV (SHRMAB_KEO) Sheridan – El Dorado 500 kV FTLO Etta – McNeil 500 kV (SHRELD_HSPET) White Bluff – Sheridan 500 kV FTLO Mabelvale – Sheridan 500kV (WHBSHE_MABEL) Mabelvale – Sheridan 500 kV FTLO White Bluff – Sheridan 500kV (MABSH_WBSH) White Bluff – Keo 500 kV FTLO Sheridan – Mabelvale 500 FTLO (WBKEO_SHMAB) NoneN/A

39 Preliminary Cost Estimate Limiting Element Listing Project 1: Southcentral AR / Northeast LA Constraint DescriptionLine Rating 1st Limiting ElementICT Cost Estimate* Sheridan – El Dorado 500 FTLO Hot Springs – Etta 500 SHRELD_HSPET(FG2) 1732MVA (2000A) Sheridan CT ratio ~2000A El Dorado switch & line trap all ~2000A Replace CT $225,000 Replace Switch & Line Trap $700,000 ($925,000) (+433MVA) 2nd Limiting Element ICT Cost Estimate* Sheridan 4 switches ~2500A Sheridan line trap ~2500A Replace 4 Switches and Line Trap ($1,300,000) (+381MVA) DescriptionLine Rating 1st Limiting ElementICT Cost Estimate* White Bluff – Sheridan 500 FTLO Sheridan – Mabelvale 500 WHBSHE_MABEL (FG3) 1732MVA (2000A) Sheridan ~2000AUpgrade CT $225,000 (+433MVA) 2nd Limiting Element ICT Cost Estimate* 5 White Bluff ~2500A Replace 5 Switches $1,000,000 (+381MVA) DescriptionLine Rating 1st Limiting ElementICT Cost Estimate* Mabelvale – Sheridan 500 FTLO White Bluff – Sheridan 500 MABSHE_WBSH (FG4) 1732MVA (2000A) Mabevale 4 Switches & Line Trap--2000A Replace 4 Switches and Line Trap $500,000 ($1,300,000) (+433MVA) 2nd Limiting Element ICT Cost Estimate* Sheridan Line trap ~2500A Sheridan 4 Switches ~2500A Replace 4 Switches and Line Trap ($1,300,000) (+381MVA) * costs for upgrades to substation bus, and/or breaker relaying, and/or line relaying are not included in the above estimates. If required, additional costs will apply.

40 Preliminary Cost Estimate Limiting Element Listing Project 2: Central Arkansas Constraint DescriptionLine Rating1st Limiting ElementICT Cost Estimate* Sheridan – Mabelvale 500 FTLO White Bluff – Keo 500 SHRMAB_KEO (FG1) 1732MVA (2000A)Mabelvale 5 Switches & Line Trap—2000A Replace 5 Switches & Line Trap $1,500,000 (+433MVA) 2nd Limiting ElementICT Cost Estimate* Sheridan 4 Switches & Line Trap ~2500A Replace 4 Switches & Line Trap $1,300,000 (+381MVA) * costs for upgrades to substation bus, and/or breaker relaying, and/or line relaying are not included in the above estimates. If required, additional costs will apply.

Next Steps

42 Further Analysis for Projects 1 and 2 Begin Work on Projects 3, 4, and 5 Status Report at October LTTIWG Meeting Next Steps

Douglas Bowman, PE, PMP Lead Engineer, ICT Planning Questions?