1. 1 Comments on HW1 reports A short self assesment My observations and general comments Your questions About the Oral presentation Specific comments in the review groups Jan Markendahl November 13, 2015

2. 2 About review of the homework reports Below is a short check list with key aspects to consider when reviewing the HW reports Are the key aspects of the analysis covered? Is there a relevant methodology section? Are the results and analysis clearly described and supported by a convincing argumentation? Is the report OK when it comes to layout, presentation style and language Are there sections with “cut and paste” material from webpages, reports, etc? Are relevant references used? Is there any self-assessment and is it relevant? Each student should reviews 2 other students

3. 3 Good reports.... …are clear and understandable Good coverage of aspects Are convincing.. are balanced When it comes to type of content Description vs analysis When it comes to layout and space Use the 4 pages to describe and explain Empty space, BIG pictures, long ref lists??

4. 4 Good to know What type of country Customers Penetration Postpaid vs prepaid Conditions to run telecom business State involvement BIG operator dominating or not Type of regulation Regulation Different for competition, telecom & broadcast or – all in one? Mobile business Is it standalone Is it integrated with fixed lines, ISP, TV?

5. 5 OBVIOUS THINGS To include title, your name and date To use normal font and column width To send only 4 pages Not to cut and paste from web pages To include conclusion or summary To use balanced number of references TO AVOID General trends not specific for your country Pictures saying the same thing Pictures just to fill the space Actors not really having an impact

6. 6 To avoid … General trends not specific for your country Pictures saying the same thing Pictures just to fill the space Actors not really having an impact General trends not specific for your country Pictures saying the same thing Pictures just to fill the space Actors not really having an impact

7. 7 Oral presentation HW1 Max 5 minutes per student 2 slides summarizing your HW1 1 slides about review comments you got