1. September 2013 www.navarra.es The renovation of the street lighting systems in Navarre XIII European Symposium for the Protection of the Night Sky

2. 1. Legal framework 2. Effects of lighting systems 3. Actions by the Administration of Navarre Índice

3. Royal Decree 1890/2008, of November 14th, approving the Regulations of energy efficiency in public ligthing systems and its complementary technical instructions EA-01 a EA-07. Royal Decree 842/2002, of August 2nd, approving the Regulations for low voltage electric systems. 1. Legal framework Navarre Law 10/2005, of November 9th, regulating lighting systems por night environment protection. Navarre Decree 199/2007, of September 17th, approving regulations in accordance to Navarre Law 10/2005.

4. Public lighting = lighting of public areas and ways with the objective of providing adequate visibility for normal activities. Cizur Mayor. A-12 high speed way Pamplona-Estella-Logroño. www.celfosc.org 1. Legal framework

5. 2. Effects of lighting systems EFFECTS OF LIGHTING SYSTEMS EFFECTS ON THE ECONOMY EFFECTOS ON THE ENVIRONMENT

6. 2. Effects of lighting on the environment  Light pollution  CO2 emissions

7. Energy consumption in Administration and public services in Navarre 1991-2011 (TOE) 2. Effects of lighting on the economy ADMIN. AND PUBLIC SERVICES COAL PETROL PRODUCTS NATURAL GAS ELECTRICITY BIOMASS SOLAR THERMAL

8. Energy expense in Navarra in 2009, 2010 y 2011 (thousands of euros) 2. Effects of lighting on the economy

9. (save energy)

10. 2. Effects of lighting on the economy

11. Promenade close to the train station. Before the crisis, both rows of lights were on. As a result of the crisis, only one row is used. Promenade close to the Pamplona road ring. Before the crisis, all lights were on. As a result of the crisis, only one out of two are used.

12.  Regional Ministry of Local Administration:  Objective: Promote and develop actions in Municipalities by means of triennial plans.  Subsidized actions: not only public lighting but also other public services related to water, waste management, etc.  Criteria: state of the current lighting system and economic return of the action. 3. Actions by the Administration of Navarre

13.  Regional Ministry of Environment:  Objective: Promote and develop actions in Municipalities members of the Network of local sustainable Municipalities  Subsidized actions: public lighting, RES installation, Municipal buildings refurbishment, rural paths...  Criteria : Type of action, budget, documentations submitted and other criteria. 3. Actions by the Administration of Navarre

14.  Regional Ministry of Industry:  Objective: Promote renovation of public lighting systems by the Municipalities with energy efficiency criteria.  Subsidized actions  Energy audits of existing lighting systems  Renovation of existing lighting systems with energy efficiency criteria  Criteria:  There has been an evolution from 2006 to 2012 3. Actions by the Administration of Navarre

15.  Regional Ministry of Industry: Criteria:  2006-2008: No previous energy audit needed. No specific technology required.  2009: No previous energy audit needed. Renovation by changing to LED required.  2010: No previous energy audit needed. Renovation by changing to LED required or lighting flux regulation systems required.  Staff from the Regional Ministry of Industry meets “Cel fosc” and starts a collaboration period with this association and some independent consultants in lighting systems. All of them work for free, just looking for a better job.  2011: Previous energy audit compulsory. Renovation must follow energy audit recommendations. In addition, the existing installation must be 20 year-old, renovated installation must have “A” energy efficiency label and minimum light pollution. 3. Actions by the Administration of Navarre

16.  Regional Ministry of Industry: Other actions:  2012: Study of LED installations in Navarre.  Special action for very small municipalities (less than 200 inhabitants)  The Regional Ministry pays an independent lighting audit for 173 small municipalities in order they can later take measures to improve an save energy.  2012: Handbook on efficient management of public lighting systems. 3. Actions by the Administration of Navarre

17. Public subsidy (euros) Investment (euros) Savings (MWh/año)Number of subsidies 200688.953,00340.738,01400,009 (2 auditorias y 7 inv.) 200789.311,40140.317,49453,00 13 (6 auditorias y 7 inv.) 2008402.374,331.727.489,945.304,00 31 (3 auditorias y 28 inv.) 2009368.865,261.281.240,87601,00 18 (5 auditorias y 13 inv.) 2010448.823,611.433.726,711.137,00 42 (9 auditorias y 33 inversiones) 2011510.625,13983.270,781.003,00 42 (32 auditorias y 14 inv. EELL> 200; 173 auditorias (180.000€) en EELL< 200) Summary of subsidies given by the Regional Ministry of Industry 3. Actions by the Administration of Navarre

18. Thank you for your attention www.navarra.es