1. 1 RAC Basics Julian Dyke Independent Consultant Web Version - February 2008 juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke

2. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 2 Agenda  Real Application Clusters  The Theory  The Reality

3. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 3 RAC The Theory

4. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 4 RAC Redundancy  Single Point of Failure  If component fails, system will be inaccessible  Redundancy  Duplicate components  If component fails another can be used  Active-Active or Active-Passive  Examples include  Power Supplies  RAID  Bonded Networks  IO Multipathing  Oracle RAC

5. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 5 RAC 4-node cluster Public Network Shared Storage Node 1 Instance 1 Node 2 Instance 2 Node 3 Instance 3 Node 4 Instance 4 Private Network (Interconnect) Storage Network

6. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 6 RAC Cache Coherency  RAC must ensure changes made by any instance  Are not overwritten by another instance  Maintain ACID properties  Current Blocks  Blocks can be updated by any instance  Only current version of a block can be updated  Only one current version of a block can exist across all instances  Consistent Read Blocks  Can have theoretically unlimited number of consistent versions of a block  in each instance  across all instances

7. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 7 RAC Cluster Manager  All clusters must have cluster management software  Manages node membership and evictions  Oracle Clusterware  Mandatory for RAC in Oracle 10.1 and above  Known as Cluster Ready Services (CRS) 10.1 only  Can be combined with vendor clusterware  IBM HA/CMP  HP ServiceGuard  Sun Cluster  Must be running before ASM/RDBMS instances can be started on a node  Can be used with non-RAC databases and applications  Oracle 10.2 and above

8. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 8 RAC Interconnect  Used for inter-node communication by:  Oracle Clusterware  ASM Instances  RDBMS Instances  Optimally high bandwidth / low latency  Typically 1GB Ethernet  Uses TCP / UDP protocols  NIC interfaces often bonded for availability  Other physical networks supported e.g. Infiniband

9. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 9 RAC Shared Storage  Required for:  Oracle Clusterware Files  Oracle Cluster Registry (OCR)  Voting Disk  Database Files  Control Files  Database  Online Redo Logs  Server Parameter File  Strongly recommended for  Archived redo logs  Backup copies

10. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 10 RAC Shared Storage  Can use:  Storage Area Network (SAN) e.g.:  EMC Clariion / Symmetrix  HP MSA / EVA / XP series  Hitachi  Fujitsu  Network Attached Storage (NAS) e.g.:  Network Appliance  Pillar Data System  Sun StorageTek  EMC Celerra  JBOD (with ASM)

11. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 11 RAC Shared Storage  Fibre Channel  SCSI protocol - block based  Normally 2Gb or 4Gb  Requires one or more Host Bus Adapters (HBA) per node  Requires fabric switches  iSCSI  SCSI protocol - block based  Packets sent over dedicated IP network  Can use standard network components  Processing often offloaded to NIC firmware  NFS  File-based  Uses standard network components

12. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 12 RAC Shared Storage  Cluster-aware File Systems:  Automatic Storage Management  Cluster File Systems  Oracle Cluster File System (OCFS/OCFS2)  Red Hat GFS  IBM GPFS  Sun Storedge QFS  Veritas CFS  Network File System  On supported Network Attached Storage only

13. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 13 RAC Automatic Storage Management (ASM)  Introduced in Oracle 10.1  Additional functionality in 10.2 and 11.1  Generic code (all supported platforms)  Available for both single-instance and RAC databases  Provides shared storage for RAC  Can optionally provide mirroring:  Normal Redundancy (mirrored)  High Redundancy (triple mirroring)  Useful with JBOD or extended clusters  Mandatory for Oracle 10g Standard Edition RAC  Presents storage as disk groups containing  Physical disks  Logical files  Requires additional ASM instance on each node

14. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 14 RAC Licensing  Standard Edition  RAC option free  Maximum two nodes  Maximum four CPUs  Must use Oracle Clusterware  Must use Automatic Storage Management (ASM)  No extended clusters  Enterprise Edition  RAC option 50% extra (per EE license)  No limit on number of nodes  No limit on number of CPUs  Can use any shared storage (ASM, CFS or NFS)  Can use Enterprise Manager Packs (Diagnostics, Tuning..)

15. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 15 Node 1Node 2 RAC Process Architecture Clusterware OPROCDOCSSDCRSDEVMD +ASM1 PMONSMONLGWRDBWnARCH LMONLCK0LMD0LMSnDIAG PROD1 PMONSMONLGWRDBWnARCH LMONLCK0LMD0LMSnDIAG Clusterware OPROCDOCSSDCRSDEVMD +ASM2 PMONSMONLGWRDBWnARCH LMONLCK0LMD0LMSnDIAG PROD2 PMONSMONLGWRDBWnARCH LMONLCK0LMD0LMSnDIAG

16. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 16 RAC Reasons For Deployment  Availability  Node failure  Instance failure  Scalability  Distribute workload across multiple instances  Scale out  Manageability  Economies of scale  Administration / Monitoring / Backups / Standby  Reduction in total cost of ownership  Database consolidation  Commodity hardware

17. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 17 RAC Availability  Ensure continued availability of database in event of node or instance failure  Automatic failover  No human intervention required  In the event of node or instance failure:  All sessions connected to failed node are terminated  Sessions connected to remaining nodes are  temporarily suspended while resources are re-mastered  resume after brown-out period  New sessions will be connected to remaining nodes only  Ensuring availability requires spare capacity during normal operations  Either additional node  Or reduction in service level

18. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 18 RAC Availability Public Network Shared Stoage Node 1 Instance 1 Node 2 Instance 2 Node 3 Instance 3 Node 4 Instance 4 Private Network (Interconnect) Storage Network

19. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 19 RAC Scalability  Workload can be distributed across multiple nodes  Workload can be balanced across all nodes using connection management  Client-side using Oracle Net  Server-side using listener processes  Workload can be directed to specific nodes using services  Level of scalability dependent on application Resources Throughput

20. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 20 RAC Scalability  Factors that can degrade scalability  Excessive parsing  Consistent reads  SELECT FOR UPDATE / user defined locking  DDL  Object-oriented code  Features that can improve scalability  Services  Automatic Segment Space Management  Partitioning  Sequences  Reverse indexes

21. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 21 RAC Manageability  Advantages  Consolidation  Economies of scale  Administration  Monitoring  Backup and recovery  Standby database  Disadvantages  Increased Planned downtime  Complexity  Dependencies  Skills

22. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 22 RAC Total Cost of Ownership  Benefits  Lower hardware costs - commodity hardware  Lower support costs  Management economies of scale  Costs  Redundant hardware  Servers, Storage, NIC, HBA, Switches, Fabric  Oracle licenses  Experienced staff  Application modifications

23. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 23 RAC Applications  Most applications should run on RAC without modification  Performance is not guaranteed  Applications that perform well in single-instance have best chance of scaling in RAC  Applications performing badly in single-instance will perform worse in RAC  Some features do not port easily to RAC e.g.:  DBMS_ALERT, DBMS_PIPE, External files  Applications that can be logically partitioned tend to scale best  Minimize use of interconnect  Maximize use of buffer caches  Implementation more likely to succeed if you have direct or indirect access to source code

24. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 24 RAC Database Services  Allow sessions with similar workload characteristics to be logically grouped and managed  Services can be assigned to  set of preferred instances - used if available  set of available instances - used if preferred instances not available  failover to available instances is automatic  failback to preferred instances is manual  Services can be configured to maximize instance affinity  Limited statistics reported at service level  Can also be reported at service / module / action level  Trace can be enabled at service level  Can also be enabled at service / module / action level

25. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 25 RAC Database Services Listener1 PROD1 Listener2 PROD2 PROD1PROD2 SERVICE1PREFERREDAVAILABLE SERVICE1 Listener1 PROD1 Listener2 PROD2 SERVICE1 AfterBefore

26. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 26 RAC Extended Clusters  Currently the Holy Grail of high availability  RAC nodes located at physically separate sites  Implicit disaster recovery  Requires Enterprise Edition licences + RAC option  In the event of a site failure, database is still available  Storage is duplicated at each site  Can use ASM or vendor-supplied storage technology  Active / Active configuration  Users can access database via either site  Configuration and performance tuning are complex  Cache fusion traffic between sites

27. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 27 RAC Extended Clusters Storage Network Public Network Database Storage Network Site2Site1 Private Network Quorum Site3 Instance 1 Node 1 Instance 2 Node 2 Database

28. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 28 RAC Disaster Recovery  Data Guard and RAC are fully compatible  Can configure any permutation e.g. PrimaryStandby Single-instanceSingle instance RACSingle instance RAC Single instanceRAC  All instances can participate in redo log shipping  Only one instance can perform managed recovery  Standby database might be a potential bottleneck

29. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 29 RAC Alternatives  Single Instance Databases  No RAC overhead  Simpler to install / configure / manage  Single point of failure  Oracle Products  Oracle Streams  Oracle Clusterware  Proprietary Clustering Solutions  HP ServiceGuard  IBM HA/CMP  Sun Cluster

30. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 30 RAC The Reality

31. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 31 RAC The Reality  Many sites running RAC  Mostly Oracle 10.2  A few still running Oracle 10.1  Still some Oracle 9.2  Most RAC users develop their own applications or use bespoke applications developed by a third-party  Probably around 20 extended clusters in production across Europe  Many Oracle 10.2 sites run ASM  Very few run OCFS or raw devices  Very few use third-party cluster file systems  Most sites using SAN - fewer using NAS  In UK most users currently deploy on Linux x86-64  Solaris very popular in other regions

32. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 32 RAC The Reality  Few Oracle 10g users run vendor clusterware  Most RAC deployments for availability  Decreased unplanned downtime  Increased planned downtime  Increasing number of deployments for scalability  Workload balancing  Services  Manageability benefits very doubtful  Economies of Scale versus Additional complexity  TCO reductions possible in some circumstances  Replace large SMP boxes  Replace legacy active-passive clusters

33. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 33 RAC The Reality  Most users run 2-node clusters  Some have 3-node or 4-node clusters  A handful run five nodes or more  Most users only have one database per cluster  Few grids  Oracle Clusterware scales well  Number of nodes does not impact performance  Oracle RAC databases might scale well  Dependent on application  Additional nodes may improve or degrade performance

34. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 34 RAC The Reality  ASM currently the most popular RAC storage technology  Deployed in numerous Oracle 10.2 RAC production systems  No operating system utilities  ASMCMD in Oracle 10.2 and above  Generally disliked by storage administrators  Too much control to DBAs  Acceptable performance  ASM instance provides metadata  RDBMS instances read and write blocks directly from files

35. juliandyke.com © 2008 Julian Dyke 35 Thank you for your interest  References  http://www.juliandyke.com/References/References.html  Questions  info@juliandyke.com