Presentation on theme: "A Shippers Perspective on the Ever Changing Railroad Industry"— Presentation transcript:
1 A Shippers Perspective on the Ever Changing Railroad Industry March 14th, Badger Mining Corporation
2 The Beginning of Railroading 18271st Railroad in North AmericaThe Baltimore & Ohio18402,800 miles of track5 of the 6 New England States, Kentucky & Indiana18509,000 miles of trackU.S. World Leader186535,000 miles of track“The Golden Age” of Railroads1916254,000 miles of trackIn 1827 the first railroad in North America is chartered by Baltimore merchants – The Baltimore & OhioBy 1840 we had over 2,800 miles of track operating in 5 of the 6 New England states and the frontier states of Kentucky & IndianaBy 1850 we had over 9,000 miles of track in the U.S., as much as in the rest of the world combined.In 1865 the golden age begins as the rail network grows from 35,000 miles to a peak of 254,000 miles in 1916.
3 Interstate Commerce Act of 1887 Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) FormedSubjected railroads to comprehensive federal economic regulation.Controlled railroad operations for the next 108 years and nearly destroy the industry.Government intervention started in 1887 when Congress passed the Interstate Commerce Act, creating the Interstate Commerce Commission.This made railroads the first U.S. industry to become subject to comprehensive federal economic regulation.The ICC would control wide areas of railroad operations for the next 108 years and nearly destroy the industry.
4 Elkins Act of 1903 Strengthened the Interstate Commerce Act of 1887 Imposed heavy fines on railroads offering rebates and shippers accepting them.The Elkins Act of 1903 strengthened the Interstate Commerce Act of 1887 by imposing heavy fines on railroads offering rebates, and on shippers accepting them.It prohibited unequal treatment of rail shippers,therefore the railroads could not effectively offer their services using their full range of marketing techniques,Nor could they promote special shipper relationships, without risking undue attention by the Commission's Bureau of Enforcement.
5 Surface Transportation Board (STB) Replaced the ICC in 1995Shift in Control from Shippers to the RailroadsThe ICC was replaced by the STB, Surface Transportation Board in 1995.Back then, shippers had more clout with the ICC, but today, the railroads have the clout with the STB.The ICC had expertise concerning the tariff-based rate structure, and shippers had no hesitancy turning to the agency to invoke its power in this area.Railroads, on the other hand, did not have a comparable advantage.
6 The Peak Period of Railroads In 1916, there were over 1,500 railroads operating in the U.S.They operated on about 254,000 miles of railEmployed 1.8 million people.Largest U.S. EmployerThe peak period for railroads was in 1916,there were over 1,500 railroads operating in the U S, and they operated on about 254,000 miles of rail and employed 1.8 million people.At the time, this was the largest employer in the US
7 Shipper Advantages Mandatory Interchange Nonnegotiable Tariff Rates Interchange traffic w/out discriminationContract-like preferences were illegalNonnegotiable Tariff RatesICC EnforcementThe Advantages Shippers enjoyed during this peak period, were that the U.S. railroads had to interchange traffic without discrimination throughout the rail system. This Mandatory interchange, made the multi-carrier U.S. railroad system operate as a true network.Bolstering the shippers’ routing obligations was the assurance that they had remedies available at the ICC if there was any perceived discriminatory treatment. The agency spent an inordinate amount of enforcement effort, tracking down and disciplining carriers appearing to give preferred shippers special unwarranted treatment.Contract-like preferences were illegal per se.This had a profound impact on railroad management, effectively emasculating any real “marketing” initiatives prior to the Staggers Act.Another advantage was Tariff rates. Given the vast number of actual and potential interchanges in the 254,000 mile system, along with the non negotiable tariff rates, shippers had access to numerous route combinations with alternative carriers and carrier combinations for their traffic, and could also rely on the ICC to enforce service obligations by those carriers.
8 Government Intervention Federal Government seized control of railroads during World War I1920s returned to private ownershipRundown conditionBy 1940s Unregulated CompetitorsAutomobiles, buses, trucks, planes, pipelines, etc.The federal government seized control of the railroads for the duration of World War I.By the time they were returned to private ownership in 1920, they were in seriously run down condition and in need of substantial maintenance & improvement.By the 1940’s, automobiles, large buses, trucks, planes, and pipelines, supported by government subsidies, and less burdened by regulation than railroads, have become full fledged competitors to railroads.
9 Bankruptcy in the Future After World War II, railroad invest billionsNew locomotives, freight equipment, passenger trains, etc.Rail market share continues to declineDeferred Maintenance in the BillionsOperate at Reduced SpeedsStanding DerailmentAfter WWII railroads invest billions of dollars in new locomotives, freight equipment, and passenger trains. In spite of the modernization, the decline in the rail market share that began before the war, continued to slide.By 1976, more than 47,000 rail miles had to be operated at reduced speed because of dangerous conditions.The amount of deferred maintenance was in the billions of dollars and the term "standing derailment" (in which stationary railcars simply fell off poorly maintained track) entered the railroad vocabulary.
10 Lead to Congressional Involvement! BankruptcyNortheastern RailroadsMidwestern RailroadsLead to Congressional Involvement!In 1976 the Penn Central and its various connecting Northeastern railroads, (the Pennsylvania Railroad, the New York Central, and the New York, New Haven, Hartford Railroad) filed for bankruptcy with the threat of further Midwestern railroad bankruptcies from (the Rock Island and the Milwaukee Road).Congress could no longer ignore the rail industry or depend upon the ICC to sort it out under unchanged regulatory statutes.
11 Consolidation from 1980 Avoid Bankruptcy or simply increase profits WP & MP merge into UP1985 – Milw Rds & Soo Line = CP– Seaboard System, B&O, C & O =CSXT1988 – DRGW & SP1988 – MKT = UP1995 – CNW = UP1995 – ATSF = BN1996 – SP = UP
12 Deregulation was chose. Staggers Rail Act of 1980NationalizationORDeregulationDeregulation was chose.So along came the Staggers Act of 1980.The status quo was untenable, so Congress essentially had two options: nationalization, at a continuing cost of untold billions of dollars,orderegulation and reliance on the free market.Congress chose deregulation and passed the Staggers Rail Act of 1980
13 Post Staggers Rail Act 1980 1980s Over 40 Class I Railroads Today Only 7 Class I RailroadsOf which 4 control over 95% of the U.S. railroad business.When Congress passed the Staggers Act in 1980 there were over 40 Class I railroads competing for business.Today, after over 50 mergers and consolidations, there are only 7 Class I railroads in North Americaand four of them control over 95 percent of the U.S. railroad business.
14 Staggers Act Worked For Class 1’s From the brink of bankruptcy in 1980The free market place conditions allowed by Staggers produced th quarter profits:BNSF $519 millionCanadian National $499 millionCanadian Pacific $145 millionCSXT $347 millionKansas City Southern $88 millionNorfolk Southern $385 millionUnion Pacific $485 millionThe bottom line!, the Staggers Act Worked! for the railroads.From the brink of bankruptcy in 1980, to this years second quarter profits of$519 million for the BNSF$499 million for the CN$145 million for the CP$347 million for the CSX$88.2 million for the KCS$385 million for the NS$485 million for the UP
15 Consequences Shippers captive to a single railroad. Lack of CompetitionThis consolidation has led to whole states, regions, and entire industries becoming captive to a single railroad.This level of concentration and the lack of competition it has brought were never envisioned in the 1980 Act.
16 Railroad Classification Today 2006Class 1 Railroads >$277M ORClass 11 Railroads > $20.5 M ORClass 111 Railroads < $20.5 ORThere are approximately 150,000 miles (240,000 km) of railroad track in the United States, nearly all standard gauge. The following is a partial list of United States railroads which currently operate there. For former railroads, see List of defunct United States railroads.
17 Classifications Rarely Used Regional Railroads350 miles $40 MLocal RailroadsNon-regional feeder railroadsSwitching & Terminal RailroadsBRC 28 MILESTomahawk RailroadEscanaba Lake ErieWGN Wis Great Northern Feeder line by HaywardThe Belt Railway of Chicago (AAR reporting marks BRC), headquartered in Chicago, is the largest intermediate switching terminal railroad in the United States. It is co-owned by six Class I railroads — BNSF Railway, Canadian National Railway, Canadian Pacific Railway, CSX Transportation, Norfolk Southern Railway, and Union Pacific Railroad — each of which uses the switching and interchange facilities of the BRC. As Chicago is the largest central hub of the railroad industry, rail cars seldom travel cross-country without passing through Chicago. Owner lines and other railroads bring their trains to the Belt Railway to be separated, classified, and re-blocked into new trains for departure. The BRC also provides rail terminal services to approximately 100 local manufacturing industries. The company employs about 520 people,
18 Why short lines are needed In ,000 miles of track 1,500 + railroads2006 – 500, regional & local rail roads (short line) railroads feeding the 7 class 1s150,000 miles of track
19 The Role of The WSOR & Feeder R R WSOR is one of 34 Regional Railroads700 miles of branch & mainline track21 counties in WisconsinMade up of defunct WI & C, M R, C&NW runs over UP & CP trackConnects with 6 Class 1’s BNSF, CN, CP,UP,CSXT,NSThe Wisconsin and Southern Railroad (AAR reporting marks WSOR) is a Class III shortline railroad operating in the southern portion of Wisconsin and the northeast corner of Illinois.WSOR runs over 700 miles of branch and mainline tracks which are jointly owned by the state of Wisconsin and the 21 counties that the railroad serves. The WSOR holds a 50 year operating agreement with the state of Wisconsin to operate on these tracks. Using existing rights of way, some of the bridges along the line date back as early as Much of the railroad's operating territory is formed from the defunct Wisconsin and Calumet Railroad, on tracks originally constructed by the Milwaukee Road and Chicago and North Western railroads.Within Wisconsin, WSOR connects with four western Class I railroads: BNSF Railway, Canadian National Railway, Canadian Pacific Railway and Union Pacific Railroad. With direct access to Chicago, WSOR connects with eastern Class I railroads CSX and Norfolk Southern Railroad. WSOR has access to harbor facilities in Prairie du Chien, and WSOR transload facilities are located in Milwaukee, Janesville, Madison, and Oshkosh. 22 grain elevators have located rail load-out facilities on the Wisconsin & Southern system
20 Operational costs6 of the 7 class 1 railroads intend to spend over 1 in 2007 on Maintenance of Way, Infrastructure, & HorsepowerWithout State & County help the WSOR’s could not compete or stay in business.
21 Operation Comparison TRACK ONLY Class 1 New Track 2m per mile Class 1 2m onlymiTRACK ONLYClass 1 New Track 2m per mileRehab track $250, per mileWSOR $10, PER MILE
22 Private vs. Railroad Owned Equipment North AmericaRail FleetClass I RailroadPrivateShort Line19971.4 Million37%58%5%20041.6 Million25%69%6%Data Source: AAR Umler File, Ownership MarkAs for the change in equipment ownership.In 1997, the North American rail fleet consisted of just over 1.4 Million railcars37% (518,000) were owned by the class 1 railroads; 58% were furnished by private owners, and 5% to the Short line Railroads.In 2004, the North American rail fleet consisted just under 1.6 Million railcarsWith only 25% (400,000) being owned by class 1 railroads, they reduced there exposure by 20% in 7 years. (518K to 400K)Leaving private car owners 69% of the fleet, and the last 6% filled in by short lines.