1. The Joy of Debate “A friend of mine once described himself as “hungry for rational opposition.” The words seemed to me to hit off very happily the state of a man who has published doctrines which he knows to be controversial, and yet finds no one to voice the general disagreement he is looking for.... In such matters to find an opponent is almost to find a friend.” C. S. Lewis

2. Basics of Debate Process Resolution: a declarative statement that focuses the subject of dispute Affirmative Team: Team that argues for the resolution and for significant change Negative Team: Team that argues against the resolution

3. Format of Our Debates First Affirmative Constructive First Negative Constructive Negative Rebuttal Affirmative Rebuttal Affirmative Cross Examination Negative Cross Examination Negative Close Affirmative Close

4. Constructives Define key terms in the resolution or that are part of your case Lay out key arguments that support your position These may are may not directly “clash” with the opponents case Round ONE is just the Constructives followed by discussion

5. Rebuttals Direct challenges to the opponents case and repair of your own case in response to challenges by opponents Speak to the audience, not opponent Critical to think and speak in outline terms! Be sure to tie challenges to the decision- making process. Round TWO is revised constructives plus rebuttals followed by discussion

6. Cross Examination Direct questioning of opponents Plan questions ahead of time Think of some in “real time” Use to “set up” closing remarks

7. Close Efficient summary of the debate Emphasis on why you won the debate Tie to stock issues or other key issues in the decision-making process.

8. What Will Be Debatable? Definitions Criteria Values Evidence Reasoning Process Stock issues Ill Blame Cure Cost

9. Quiz Prep Talk with 2-3 other folks about readings Each group can ask one question before quiz Quizzes will be taken individually

10. Quiz You have 12 minutes to complete the quiz Keep your quiz but let me know when you are done I can do this!

11. Group Time Individual Assignments Group agenda for next time you meet as a group

12. Exit Slip Before you go, put down on piece of paper without your name (unless you want to) How course is going What questions you have about debate What you want me to cover soon