1. Academic Cooperation and Competitiveness. University Ranking Methodologies 17 th - 20 th September, 2009, Cluj-Napoca Competitiveness at Babe-Bolyai University. BBU’s positions in rankings Prof. dr. Andrei Mărcu - vice-rector for quality assurance and competitiveness Gelu Gherghin – Centre for Quality Management

2. INTERNATIONAL AND NATIONAL EVALUATIONS 2000 - The OSCE High Commissioner on National Minorities 2001 - European University Association 2002 - the Salzburg Seminar. May 2009 – the Romanian evaluation and accreditation agency ARACIS. The result of this evaluation was “high degree of confidence’’.

3. BBU’S EFFORTS ON COMPETITIVENESS - DECISIONS 2006 - the “BBU 500” program has been launched: until 2012 BBU will become one of the world class universities (according to the Shanghai criteria) 2008 - The BBU500 program - Proposals for action February 2008 - Criteria for the competitiveness of faculties and of the university. These are inspired by the methodologies of several international rankings. April 2008 - Decision on the responsibilities for meeting the competitiveness criteria.

4. Promotion of the programs - PUBLICATIONS 2006 - Bulletin of the Research Department 2007 - Quality Assurance at BBU 2007 - BBU Research Policy 2008 - Bulletin of the Competitiveness and Quality Department 2009 - Competitiveness and Quality Guide at Babe-Bolyai University Contents: - Research results - Internal decisions and national regulations - presentations of national and international rankings - scientific databases, news

5. RELEVANT RANKINGS FOR BBU National Rankings Ad Astra Association - Romanian Universities Ranking CNFIS / CNCSIS International Rankings Academic Ranking of World Universities (Shanghai) THE - QS World University Rankings (Times) CHE University Ranking Performance Ranking of Scientific Papers (Taiwan) Webometrics Ranking of World's Universities European Student Barometer

6. Ad Astra Association - Romanian Universities Ranking Ad Astra – a non-profit organization founded in 2002 by Romanian researchers. Between 2005 – 2007 Ad Astra publicized the Romanian Universities Ranking – based on the number of articles published in ISI Web of Science indexed journals in the previous year. One general ranking - the total number of articles reported to the number of teachers in the institution. Rankings on 32 scientific domains and sub-domains - done by adding the impact factor of journals.

7. Ad Astra Association - Romanian Universities Ranking (BBU’s position) YearPositionNo. of articles / 100 persons % from maximum No. of articles Staff 20052 17,3396%2251298 20063 21,3283%2691262 20072 24,0175%3031262

8. CNFIS / CNCSIS - Financing State Universities The National Council for Financing Higher Education (CNFIS) and The National University Research Council (CNCSIS) have advisory role for the Ministry of Education. Romanian higher education funding is based on the number of students and a qualitative (quality indicators) component. Quality criteria were introduced in 2002, and have developed both in terms of complexity and weight. In 2008 these reached 30% of total funding base. CNFIS & CNCSIS do not publish an annual league-table, but they gather the data, and the conclusions can be drawn.

9. CNFIS / CNCSIS - Criteria and Indicators 13 indicators in 4 groups, each groups having 2 sub- indicators I. Quality of the teaching staff (8.5% of total funding base) II. Research impact (8% of total funding base) III. Infrastructure (3.5% of total funding base) IV. University management (10% of total funding base) IC 6 – The level of performance in scientific research - has the greatest weight among indicators – 7%

10. CNFIS / CNCSIS ranking - BBU’s rank CNFIS & CNCSIS published in 2008 the The analysis of the of the IC 6 quality indicators’ evolution, regarding “the performance of scientific research in universities” and its influence in the distribution of budgetary allocations to funding base – an IC 6 review for 2003-2007 period. There were set up five value groups, plus two additional groups for art and architecture universities. Babe-Bolyai University has always been in the first value groups, obtaining the maximum of 50 points for maintaining its position five years in this group

11. Academic Ranking of World Universities ARWU is a hierarchy with 500 positions, annually published by Shanghai Jiao Tong University since 2003. The concept of “World Class University” has been defined and developed. ARWU, ARWU-FIELD (Broad Subject Field), ARWU-SUBJECT (Subj Field) CriteriaIndicatorCodeWeight Quality of EducationAlumni of an institution winning Nobel Prizes and Fields MedalsAlumni10% Quality of Faculty Staff of an institution winning Nobel Prizes and Fields MedalsAward20% Highly cited researchers in 21 broad subject categoriesHiCi20% Research Output Articles published in Nature and ScienceN&S20% Articles Indexed in Science Citation Index-Expanded and Social Science Citation Index SCI 20% Size of InstitutionAcademic performance with respect to the size of an institutionPCP10% http://www.arwu.org

12. ARWU - BBU’s rank There is no Romanian university in the top 500 of ARWU According to unpublished information, Babe-Bolyai University is placed somewhere between 700 and 800. Babe-Bolyai University launched in March 2006 the “BBU 500” programe: until 2012 BBU will become a world class university. In 2008 several measures were taken to increase competitiveness and bring BBU closer to this goal.

13. THE-QS World University Rankings Since 2004, THE Supplement and Quacquarelli Symonds annually publish The Times Higher Education - QS World University Rankings Top 100 (500+) universities, subject rankings, regional rankings, rankings by indicator IndicatorDescriptionWeight Academic Peer ReviewComposite score drawn from peer review survey (which is divided into five subject areas) 40% Employer ReviewScore based on responses to employer survey.10% Faculty Student RatioScore based on student faculty ratio20% Citations per FacultyScore based on research performance factored against the size of the research body 20% International FacultyScore based on proportion of international faculty5% International StudentsScore based on proportion of international students5% http://www.topuniversities.com

14. THE-QS World University Rankings (BBU’s rank) Since 2008 BBU has a profile on www.topuniversities.com (www.topuniversities.com/schools/data/school_profile/default/ babesbolyaiuniversity) BBU was invited to send data for 2009 edition of The Times Higher Education - QS World University Rankings Besides UBB, from Romania, only the University of Bucharest is registered on www.topuniversities.com, being successively ranked 472-th (2006), 513-th (2007) and 501-th (2008) in the world ranking.

15. CHE University Ranking (Presentation) The Center for Higher Education Development (CHE) is a private non-profit organization, founded on 1994 at the initiative of the German Rectors Conference and the Bertelsmann Foundation. The first ranking was published in 1998, focused on economics and chemistry. From 2005, CHE publishes the rankings in co-operation with Die Zeit. The CHE Ranking system has indicators, but is not a league-table. The CHE University Ranking tries to comply with the Berlin Principles. It is based on 3 methodological principles (Federkeil, 2006) - No ranking of whole universities Ranking of single subjects/subject areas - No overall score from weighted indicators Multidimensional ranking - No individual ranks in league tables Rank groups: top, intermediate, bottom

16. CHE University Ranking (BBU’s rank) In 2008 BBU was invited to participate to the 2009 edition of the CHE University Ranking, with study programmes offered in German and English. BBU has sent data for programmes on Mathematics, Computer Science, Physics, Chemistry, Biology, Geography, both bachelor and master levels. The participation of the BBU’s students was poor; very little information about BBU was published. Depending on subject fields, BBU was ranked in the top, intermediate, or bottom group in terms of Doctorates per professor, For all the subject fields, BBU was ranked in the bottom group, in terms of Publications per academic, and Citations per publication.

17. Performance Ranking of Scientific Papers The Higher Education Evaluation and Accreditation Council of Taiwan (HEEACT) is a national structure created in 2006. The “2007 Performance Ranking of Scientific Papers for World Universities“ - a 500 position top. In 2008, a new ranking with 300 positions on six subject fields was added. Criteria2008 Overall Performance Indicators Weight Research productivity Number of articles of the last 11 years (1997-2007)10% 20% Number of articles of the current year (2007)10% Research impact Number of citations of the last 11 years (1997-2007)10% 30% Number of citations of the last 2 years (2006-2007)10% Average number of citations of the last 11 years (1997-2007)10% Research excellence H-index of the last 2 years (2006-2007)20% 50% Number of Highly Cited Papers (1997-2007)15% Number of articles of the current year in high-impact journals (2007)15% http://ranking.heeact.edu.tw

18. Performance Ranking of Scientific Papers for World Universities (BBU’s rank) In the two editions of PRSPWU published so far, no Romanian university appears. The situation is the same for the classifications of research areas. According to unpublished information, BBU was ranked 643- th in 2008. We expect that the "BBU 500" program adopted in 2006, and the measures for competitiveness taken in 2008 will facilitate BBU’s access in PRSPWU in the near future.

19. Webometrics Ranking of World's Universities This is an initiative of the Cybermetrics Lab, a group belonging to the Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientificas, the largest public research body in Spain. Webometrics is based on assessment of the web-sites. The ranking is published twice a year, in January and July IndicatorDefinitionWeight Size (S)Number of pages recovered from four engines: Google, Yahoo, Live Search and Exalead. 20% Visibility (V)The total number of unique external links received (inlinks).50% Rich Files (R)Adobe Acrobat (.pdf), Adobe PostScript (.ps), Microsoft Word (.doc) and Microsoft Powerpoint (.ppt). 15% Scholar (Sc)Google Scholar provides the number of papers and citations for each academic domain. 15% http://www.webometrics.info

20. Webometrics Ranking of World's Universities (BBU’s rank) EditionWorld rank National rank Size (S)*Visibility (V)* Rich Files (R)* Scholar (Sc)* July 20071425 3 13232230686781 January 20081237 3 11012059710654 July 20081158 3 11191820652744 January 20091197 1 10821883662769 July 20091034414301872676852 * Lower score is better ranked in the top

21. European Student Barometer 2009 European Student Barometer is a student satisfaction survey conducted annually among European students, which offers them the possibility to express an opinion about their career and education. BBU participated for the first time in 2009 edition of the ESB, with 1101 students responding. The students of BBU appreciated the following aspects: Academic reputation (88,1%), Good location (86.9%), Reputation among employers (79.8%), IT facilities (75.5%), International orientation (70.9%) and Teaching quality (70.2%).