1. 06/10/2015 End-to-End Quality of service in ITU-T Where we are, Perspectives Jean-Yves Monfort France Telecom, R&D Division ITU-T SG 12 Chairman 1GSC-9, Seoul SOURCE:ITU-T TITLE:End to end Quality of Service; Where we are, Perspectives AGENDA ITEM:GTSC; 5.2 CONTACT:Jean-Yves Monfort (ITU-T SG 12 Chairman) France Telecom, R&D Division 22307 Lannion France Jeanyves.monfort@francetelecom.com GSC9/GTSC_020Rev1

2. GSC-9, Seoul206/10/2015 Messages on QoS and Interoperability from the CTO's meeting organized by TSB Director (décember 2003) http://www.itu.int/ITU-T/tsb-director/cto/index.html - ITU-T should ensure global interoperability. (Similar conclusions were raised in several other workshops (e.g. e- health, TDR,…). - Mechanisms to provide end-to-end QoS are required, including - MPLS based QoS - Session based QoS - QoS Classes or High quality classes. - Interoperability for all major services required on a global scale and interoperability for the required core middleware functionalities - Simplicity and ease of use for the end users, QoS determined by user choice of service, and high quality for voice (e.g. wideband)

3. GSC-9, Seoul306/10/2015 Challenges for QoS Statements/Conclusions of ITU-T Workshop on QoS – Oct 2003 http://www.itu.int/ITU-T/worksem/qos/index.html "Need for interworking standards to achieve end to end QoS" "Need for a common understanding and implementation of QoS classes" "Generic requirements for IP QoS and traffic signalling being developed in ITU-T SG 11(and on-going activities in Q.EE/11) – TRQ.IPQOS.SIG.CS1( Y.1541/Y.1221 specifications are being applied, Dynamic QoS apportionment will be supported ) and related work is under way in IETF/NSIS, but work is still needed to enable implementation of QoS control-based networks." "Need to define the specific signalling system(s) to be used to implement assured QoS in IP-based networks, because several candidate systems exist and have strong proponents. The alternatives are a broad consensus, or many gateways to be needed. Need for collaborations/cooperations."

4. GSC-9, Seoul406/10/2015 Challenges for QoS Statements/Conclusions of ITU-T Workshop on QoS – Oct 2003 "More work needed to understand the relationship between Service Level Specification, monitoring and application monitoring" " Ultimately the issue for accelerating deployment of QoS that fully supports the user experience is capital, which these days is only made available when persuasive business cases have been made " A general remark, but well adapted to QoS To ensure IP QoS interoperability it is needed to : - ensure a high level leading role - have experts from each relevant (standardisation) bodies working together, to understand each other aims, working methods, process and to work with coherent schedules - ensure that the areas of work in progress are in line with the guidelines in the relevant bodies - have the relevant support of the experts of a company, working in the different bodies.

5. GSC-9, Seoul506/10/2015 On –going work on QoS architecture -JRG-NGN, and Question D/13 are developping several Recommendations (see also annex 1) Recommendation Y.1291 (Y.qosar) "An architectural framework for support of Quality of Service (QoS) in Packet networks This Recommendation, approved in early may, could be used as a basis that could be used as a common basis. Draft Rec. Y.e2eqos "A QoS Architecture for IP/MPLS Networks" Draft Recommendation Y. 123.qos "A QoS Architecture for Ethernet-Based IP Access Network" It is a basis to specifiy a layered reference model and methods for support of QoS in Ethernet-based IP access network and associated protocol requirements. Other activities planned in particular in Q. D/13 (Requirements and framework for QoS for NGN) : QoS mechanisms end to end, Study of QoS enablers and QoS architectures that integrate QoS enablers, What new Recommendations to support QoS in packet access network?, …

6. GSC-9, Seoul606/10/2015 Other important topics related to QoS (on –going activities) - Quality assesment methodologies for multimedia services On-going work under a JRG Multimedia assessment (for opinion models, psychoacoustic models and models associated to INMD). Note that for voice, INMD Recommendations (P.561/P.562) have been recently updated for Class D equipments (to take into account the new network interfaces using packet mode transmission). -The need consider also the user point of view : it means that the technical parameters need to be correlated to user perception/expectations (follow-up actions based on G.1000, G.1010, E.QoSparam,…), for all kinds of services. Recommendations under development : G.MMPerf, G.Webperf

7. GSC-9, Seoul706/10/2015 Other important topics related to QoS (on –going activities) - Handbook on QoS will be available soon (prepared by WP2/2) - On-going work on network performance: - Ethernet (Y.ethperf) - Hybrid networks (Y.hybperf) Note that other relevant recommendations have been approved recently : - Y.1561: Performance and availability parameters for MPLS networks (may 2004) - Y.1560: TCP performance parameters and objectives (september 2003) -QoS Interoperability : A new question Q.K/12. - Transmission performance (including NGN) Q.J/12

8. GSC-9, Seoul806/10/2015 Perspectives/actions for NGN QoS -Classes of services - Need to harmonize ITU-T QoS classes and 3 GPP TS 23.107 to permit a mapping. Better convergence needed. A good approach of these issues and possible solutions being documented by MM Wohlert and Seitz (see COM13- D53cor1). - On-going work to "concatenate" QoS values in multinetwork conditions. - QoS Control (Some terminals are able to control QoS, some are not) -Different QoS mechanisms corresponding to different technologies (xDSL-Type" and "3GPP-Type" - A basis available in packet cable environment (to be considered more largely?). - QoS architecture (see annex 1 on on-going work onQoS archtecture in JRG NGN) - Qos control signalling based on already defined protocols (e.g. RSVP, COPS, NSIS,…)

9. GSC-9, Seoul906/10/2015 Annex 1 Complements : Recommendations under development in JRG-NGN

10. GSC-9, Seoul1006/10/2015 Works on NGN QoS Architecture in ITU-T (see also GSC9-GTSC-009) JRG NGN work on Recommendation Rec Y.1291 (May 2004) "An architectural framework for support of Quality of Service (QoS) in Packet networks This Recommendation could be used as a basis for the different standard bodies. It defines a set of generic mechanisms for controlling the network service response to a service request, and the three logical planes (Control, Management, Data)

11. GSC-9, Seoul1106/10/2015 On-going Work on NGN QoS Architecture in ITU-T in ITU-T JRG NGN work on Recommendations Draft Rec. Y.e2eqos "A QoS Architecture for IP/MPLS Networks" - Support flexibility billing and business Model - Interface and signalling between service control layer and transport resource control layer - Cover the inter-domain QoS control cas between different operators - Cover the connectionless services - Support mobility.

12. GSC-9, Seoul1206/10/2015 On –going work on QoS Architecture in ITU-T JRG NGN work on Recommendations Y. 123.qos A QoS Architecture for Ethernet-Based IP Access Network It is a basis to specifiy a layered reference model and methods for support of QoS in Ethernet-based IP access network and associated protocol requirements.