1. RHIC Experimental Status & Future Outlook Huan Zhong Huang Department of Physics and Astronomy University of California, Los Angeles June 28-29 @ Shanghai Eastern Forum

2. Topics 1)Deconfined Partonic Matter 2)What Can Heavy Ion Physics Experimentalists Teach About Lattice QCD? 3) Is There a Phase Transition? 4) Chiral Symmetry Restoration? 5) RHIC as an Exotic Particle Factory

3. Constituent Quark Scaling STAR PHENIX Baryon Meson Constituent (n) Quark Scaling -- Meson n=2 and Baryon n=3 grouping Saturation of v 2 at Intermediate p T

4. Partonic v 2 and Surface Emission PRL 92 (2004) 052302; PRL 91 (2003) 182301 At hadron formation time there is a collective v 2 among constituent quarks Recombination/coalescence provides a hadronization scheme (not necessarily related to partonic matter, works for d+Au) Possible geometrical nature of v 2 saturation – surface emission

5. Hadronization of Bulk Partonic Matter 1) At the moment of hadronization in nucleus-nucleus collisions at RHIC the dominant degrees of freedom is related to number of constituent quarks. 2) These ‘constituent quarks’ exhibit an angular anisotropy resulting from collective interactions. 3) Hadrons seem to be formed from coalescence or recombination of the ‘constituent quarks’, and the hadron properties are determined by the sum of ‘constituent quarks’.

6. Conditions at T c Empirically, Partonic matter evolves such that at the hadronization, the dominant degrees of freedom are in ‘constituent quarks’/quasi-hadrons. The formation mechanism could be coalescence or recombination of these quarks. Gluon degrees of freedom are not manifested at hadronization, though at initial stage of the heavy ion collision, gluons must dominate.

7. Lattice QCD LQCD, Spectral functions of hadrons (J/psi and light hadrons) survive near T C or somewhat above T C. Strong correlations persist up to high temperature above T C ! LQCD e.g. S. Datta et al, hep-lat/0412037 J/  and  C may survive up to 2.25 T C ! Our data indicate that at T=T C even light hadrons are in quasi-hadron state (strongly interacting constituent quark state) !

8. Phase Transition ? The Initial State from the Collision must be dominated by gluons (Temperature?)  Parton Evolutions (?)  At the Hadronization Stage the dominate degrees of freedom are constituent quarks (or quasi-hadrons) (Empirical + LQCD) What is the parton evolution dynamics?? Empirically the dense matter with collective motions of constituent quark degrees of freedom must be preceded with a deconfined partonic matter, BUT we do not have any experimental indication that this is a phase transition !

9. Chiral Symmetry How Chiral Symmetry has manifested in nucleus-nucleus collisions? We must measure vector mesons in both hadronic and leptonic decay channels! electron PID  TOF upgrade HFT – reduce conversion BK K-pi PID  TOF upgrade  and  ’  EMC + high statistics Baryonic resonances (  )....)

10. RHIC Physics in + Years 1)Heavy Quark Production -- Yield and pT distribution (Energy Loss) -- Parton Collectivity 2) Thermal Photon Radiation 3) QCD Photons (gamma-jet and QGP Brem.) 4) Chiral Symmetry and low mass di-leptons 5) Exotic Particle Searches

11. RHIC – Exotic Particle Factory Clustering and Surface Emission Volcanic mediate p T – Spatter (clumps) Enhancement of Clusters at intermediate p T ! Search for Multi-quark (>3) Cluster State at RHIC !

12. dAu results M (GeV/c 2 ) pK + and pK - from 18.4 M d+Au at 200 GeV Background – Combinatorial and Correlated Pairs

13. dAu results Understand the Background! PeaK?!

14. dAu results The invariant mass distribution is fitted to a Gaussian plus a linear function. A 3.5-5.0 sigma signal is seen Measured mass is about 1.53 GeV/c 2. Full width is about 15 MeV

15. The Puzzle Continues 1)If pK + peak at 1530 MeV/c 2 is a real pentaquark, then I = 1 likely, there must be a  +. But the recent JLab null result on  + casts serious doubt on the observation of  +. 2)The STAR observed yield is so small such that many experiments would not have the sensitivity to see it. 3)Within the STAR data we have not seen any significant peak signal in p+p (8M) data and Au+Au at 200 GeV (~10M). What do these null observations mean? Production dynamics or data set bias unknown to us? What is so special about d+Au 200 GeV (18.4 M events) and Au+Au 62.4 GeV (5.1 M events)?

16. Other Exotic Particles Gluon Balls Exotic mesons (uds)(ud)  (uds)s Pentaquarks Dibaryons H (uuddss) [  (ssssss)

17. STAR – Exciting Physics Program A full TOF and Heavy Flavor Tracker upgrade will greatly enhance STAR’s capability !! RHIC – Exotic Particle Factory Heavy Flavor Tracker Using Active Pixel Sensor two layers of thin silicon detector 1.5 cm and 4 cm radius Charmed Exotics?! Full Barrel TOF Using MRPC

18. eRHIC Inevitable ?! But When? RHIC II – Machine Upgrade -- Tandem -- Electron Cooling Electron – LINAC 10 GeV Natural Physics Direction from RHIC/JLAB 20 Years ?

19. RHIC Beyond +5 Years Hadrons with internal structure beyond existing QCD qqq and q-qbar framework !! pp pA AA pp pA AA Exotic RHIC – Dedicated QCD Machine&Beyond (spin) (CGC,EMC) (Deconfinement Phase Transition)

20. The End

21. Identified Particles No Clear Idea on what to measure for phase transition signatures ! Particle Flavor Fluctuations Strangeness Baryon numbers Baryon Formation Mechanism? Hadronization time scale? STAR Full TOF Upgrade will open a new window. Is it sufficient to see a clear picture? ??

22. Deconfined Matter at RHIC Coalescence/Recombination Mechanism IS not key argument for deconfinement ! It works in d+Au and perhaps p+p as well ! Deconfined – Constituent quark degree of freedom Matter – Collective interaction  partonic v 2 strange/charm dynamics in the deconfined medium

23. Is There a  ++ Pentaquark State?  Require the opening angle of the two daughters to be greater than 30 degree, and change the proton p&pt cut to be within 0.3 and 1.5 GeV  A clear peak is seen with a 5-6.4 sigma significance d+Au

24. Is  Isospin One ? If both  + and  ++ exist as the lowest pentaquark state – Isospin >= 1 Chiral Soliton Model Di-quark model Quark cluster model ??? If  state has isospin I = 1, there will be  0  n + K S Critical confirmation for I = 1 !!

25. RHIC’s Uniqueness Multi-Strange Exotic Particles: M  1890-180*Y] MeV RHIC: Large Strangeness Production Strangeness  s ~ 1 baryon and anti-baryon ~ symmetric NA49 Pentaquark ?  - -   - +  -

26. What Are Required High Detection Efficiency for Weak Decays -- Intermediate Tracking R~10 cm up -- Continuous Tracking a plus Large Acceptance -- Ks, Lambda, Xi, Omega -- Multi-particle Correlations Neutral Detectors -- Neutron (anti-neutron!) --  0 PID – TOF and trigger capability Micro-Vertex– for Charmed Exotic Particles High Rate Capability and DAQ Rate

27. New Experiment Affordable Neutron Detector Tracking of V0 near primary vertex Excellent Particle Identification (TOF) Upgradeable with Heavy Flavor Tracker

28. STAR versus New Experiment STAR: Existing detector Large Acceptance Reasonable Data Rate V0 Capability not ideal -- lack of continuous tracking at intermediate R No Neutron detection PID – TOF will do Limited high rate (distortion) Large Inertial in STAR