Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Prefatory comments  I am not an expert. I hold degrees in political science and communication, not theoretical physics.  The only morally permissible.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "Prefatory comments  I am not an expert. I hold degrees in political science and communication, not theoretical physics.  The only morally permissible."— Presentation transcript:

1

2 Prefatory comments  I am not an expert. I hold degrees in political science and communication, not theoretical physics.  The only morally permissible space jokes are Star Wars related.

3 The Resolution  Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its exploration and/or development of space beyond the Earth’s mesosphere.

4 Mesosphere  Who are the ad wizards who came up with that one?  What it is: the zone of the Earth’s atmosphere between the stratosphere and the thermosphere.  What it is not (at least not now): a subterranean section of the Earth’s mantle.

5 Mesosphere, cont’d.

6 So, what is out there?  Planets  Stars  Nebulae  Galaxies  Orbitals and NEOs  Dark matter and black holes  Solar System

7 The Solar System  Terrestrial planets  Jovian planets  Trans-Neptunian region  Asteroid belt  Oort cloud

8 American Space Policy  Cold War origins (Mercury, Gemini, Apollo)  Space Shuttle  Space Dominance (Reagan/Bush)  End of crewed space flight (Obama)

9 America’s Space Infrastructure  NASA  DOD  NOAA/OSC

10 International Space Context  Russia  China  European Union  Japan  India  ISS  OST

11 Space policy at a Cross-Roads  Cost, cost, cost  Physics  Human space flight  Private Sector  Leadership or Dominance

12 Global space issues  Debris  Appropriation  Finite resources  Equitable development  Environmental factors

13 Affirmatives 7 Major categories:  Colonization  Resources  Military  Space access technology  Propulsion Technology  Space science  Pseudo-topical mechanisms

14 Extra-solar colonization.  Inter-generational flight.  Von Neumann probes  Life-seeding.

15 Inner-solar Colonization  Mars:  A) Robotic  B) Manned  C) One-way/Two-way  Moon  Titan

16 Resources  Asteroid/NEO mining  Lunar mining  Lunar solar power  Space Based Solar Power

17 Military affirmatives  Space weaponization  SBI/BMD  ASATs  SBL  KEWs

18 Space Technology  Constellation  Reusable launch vehicle  Rail-guns  Space elevator

19 Propulsion technology  Solar sails  Nuclear detonations  Ion engines  Anti-matter

20 Remote exploration  Asteroid mapping/defense  Deep space/origins research  ISS (expand or new)  Remote sensing  Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI)

21 Pseudo-topical Mechanisms  Property rights recognition.  Consortiums  New international regimes

22 Impact/advantage controversies  The Lifeboat  Hegemony/Leadership  Economy  Energy/Environment  Space weapons  Space debris  Whacky stuff  Contamination/Viruses  International law  International relations

23 Aff Cases: Development  Colonization Cases  Extra-solar colonization  Generational star ships  Panspermia  Von Neumann probes  Solar colonization  Lunar colonization  Martian colonization  Orbital colonization

24 Aff Cases: Dev’t [cont’d]  Resource Extraction Cases  Asteroid mining (NEAs)  Lunar mining (He3)  Lunar solar power  Space solar power (PowerSats)

25 Aff Cases: Dev’t [cont’d]  Military Cases  Doctrine  Forces (Space Forces)  Weapons systems/types  Missile Defense/SBI  Space-Based Lasers (SBL)  STEW/Rods from God

26 Aff Cases: Dev’t [cont’d]  Space Access Cases  Constellation  Railgun  Reusable launch vehicle  Small booster rockets  Space elevator  Space junk removal  Transorbital railroad

27 Aff Cases: Exploration [cont’d]  Propulsion development  Anti-matter  Nuclear/Project Orion  Solar sails

28 Aff Cases: Exploration  Asteroid mapping/defense  Deep space/origins research  ISS (expand or new)  NEA mission (robotic, crewed)  Remote sensing  Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI)

29 Aff Cases: Cooperation  Joint missions with…  China  India  South Korea

30 Aff Cases: Other (policy)  Export controls/ITAR  Private space—promote/remove barriers  Space Tourism

31 Aff Cases: Other (weird)  Astral projection  Inner space/transcendental meditation  U.S. off the Planet (Churchill)  Worm holes/time travel

32 Disadvantage Areas  Budget DAs  Fiscal discipline  Tradeoffs  Politics DAs  Elections  Presidential agenda

33 Disad Areas [cont’d]  Space-y DAs  Diseases  Launch accidents  Overcrowding (GSO)  Ozone  Space junk  Space regime credibility/Space law  Space weaponization

34 Counterplan Areas  Domestic Agents  NASA  New agency  Department of Defense  Executive  Congress  Multilateral Cooperation  Private Actor/Prizes

35 Counterplan Areas [cont’d]  International Agents (net benefits can be written as disads)  China  EU  Japan  Russia  Emerging space powers—Brazil, India, South Korea  Bilateral Cooperation—same list  Advantage CPs

36 Kritik Ground  The usual suspects [See: France, philosophy; Germany, philosophy]  Capitalism  Objectivism  Anthropocentrism  Escapism  Technologism (Heidegger et al.)  Space Colonialism  Space Security  Transhumanism  Virilio/Speed


Download ppt "Prefatory comments  I am not an expert. I hold degrees in political science and communication, not theoretical physics.  The only morally permissible."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google