1. Owned and operated as a joint venture by a consortium of Canadian universities via a contribution through the National Research Council Canada Propriété d’un consortium d’universités canadiennes, géré en co-entreprise à partir d’une contribution administrée par le Conseil national de recherches Canada Canada’s national laboratory for particle and nuclear physics Laboratoire national canadien pour la recherche en physique nucléaire et en physique des particules Accelerating Science for Canada Un accélérateur de la démarche scientifique canadienne InterAction Peer Review of TRIUMF 2½ Years Later: Reprise, Respond, Reflect InterActions Collaboration Meeting | July 15, 2011 T.I. Meyer | Head, Strategic Planning & Communications | TRIUMF

2. Recap 15 July 2011 2

3. At written request of TRIUMF director, InterAction Collaboration formed its first Peer Review Committee Conducted detailed review of TRIUMF’s communications activities on February 2-4, 2009 Scope included media, publications, web & social media, community, education & outreach, conferences, internal communications, and management & resources Final written report made publicly available Remember… 15 July 2011 3

4. 4 Elizabeth Clements, Fermilab

5. 15 July 2011 5

6. 6

7. 7

8. 8

9. 9

10. 10

11. Strong comms office –Good progress –Interesting combination of planning & comms –Potential for (a lot) more Planning & budget needs clarity –Focus, resources, plans Lab needs simple/clear vision (even tagline!) Pulling everything together into one spot (figuratively & literally) will be important milestone Recap – in my own words 15 July 2011 11

12. Responses (Yes, we listened!) 15 July 2011 12

13. Five-Year Plan 2010-2015: Building a Vision for the Future was TRIUMF’s formal proposal to Government of Canada for core operating funds –The manuscript itself was recognized with the top prize from the Editors’ Association of Canada (Tom Fairley Award, given June 2009) Report & process widely regarded as defining moment for laboratory –Worry a bit about how to surpass this next time! In Budget 2010, Finance Minister announced five years of core funding for TRIUMF –Federal budget documents used two paragraphs of text from the TRIUMF Five-Year Plan report Response: Five-Year Plan 2010-2015 15 July 2011 13

14. Worked closely with laboratory director to design & implement strategy for maximizing opportunity of Five-Year Plan –Made $60M request of BC provincial government that hinged upon $300M request of Canadian government –Worked with external economists to conduct “economic impact” analysis of joint investment in TRIUMF Result was that governments got into conversation about value of TRIUMF and how to coordinate the opportunity –Federal government supported $222M for five years, largest science commitment in federal budget during recession –Provincial government made single largest contribution to science and to TRIUMF of $30M Critical to develop intimate connections with politicals, senior civil servants, and “people who do the work” Response: Five-Year Plan 15 July 2011 14

15. Communications challenge –Flat-flat core operating funds –Reduction-in-force by ~10% –Taking on more work with ARIEL project Used specific tactics to engage community, university owners, and key government stakeholders –Bottom-line message was to seize opportunity even if funding not fully complete Response: Five-Year Plan 15 July 2011 15

16. Response: Patience turns Loss into Win 16 The 2010-2015 funding consists of: Treasury Board$222.3 M WED 1.0 M E-LINAC funding BCKDF – Building 10.9 M BCKDF – e-LINAC match 19.7 M CFI – e-LINAC 17.8 M NRCan Medical Isotopes 2.0 M Commercial Revenue ~$1M/year 5.0 M TRIUMF NSERC ~7.0 M Total Funding $285.7 M Other CFI Projects: 20.0 M Total $306 M 15 July 2011

17. Vancouver is still seen as far away from Ottawa…and sometimes even Canada Continue to seek ways to position the laboratory as key resource for Canada in global science –CERN DG Rolf Heuer planned Canada trip for honorary degree and public lecture –TRIUMF secured a panel discussion at annual “Canadian Assoc of Physicists” meeting about CERN assoc. membership –TRIUMF arranged for key ministerial mtgs in Ottawa –TRIUMF arranged for media interviews of Heuer in Ottawa (national capital) and Victoria (BC provincial capital) Response: Planning + Comms 15 July 2011 17

18. Cover story in Nature Physics on ALPHA – Lead author was TRIUMF scientist – Magazine chose story title based on lede of Canadian press release Response: Comms + Planning 15 July 2011 18

19. TRIUMF Style Guide developed (V1.5) –Stationery, templates; rolling out sub-brands –Influencing new signage being erected on site –Conference room refurbs consulted comms team for branding/décor advice) No real enforcement beyond peer pressure Tagline –“Accelerating Science for Canada” Response: Branding 15 July 2011 19

20. Original artwork now generated by comms team Response: Branding (Samples) 15 July 2011 20

21. Response: Budget & Resources 15 July 2011 21 Admittedly, end of formal GR/lobbying effort for five-year funding allows for simplified budgeting New CFO is key asset, though, in honest planning and…adjusting perceived costs

22. Head is formal member of Senior Management team –Report directly to lab director –Typically involved in Division-Head-only meetings Job includes public affairs, government relations, and some “choosing what the lab will actually do” Response: Staffing (1) 15 July 2011 22

23. Shuffled some staff –Eliminated FTE “Conference Coordinator” position –Redeployed publications people to “event management” and “scientific pubs” –Sticking with two undergrad students/term as much as possible –Summary: 3 + 1.5 + 2 students = 6.5 FTEs for comms, outreach, graphics, govmt rlxns, strategy, publications Response: Staffing (2) 15 July 2011 23 Students are engines for success –Meghan Magee earned Co- Op Student of the Year both at UBC and state-wide –Sometimes need to choose graphics vs writing skills

24. Scattered activities…now centralized –Newsletter, annual financial report, annual business- development report all developed by comms office –Challenge is resources (esp. time) Human Resources’ internal bulletin still separate but better coordinated now –They also join staff meeting every two weeks –Some persistent arm wrestling for control of web (sections), internal comms, and vision/values for recruiting Response: Pulling It All Together 15 July 2011 24

25. Group is now co-located in upstairs office suite in Main Office Building –Publications, web, outreach, and students –Adjacent to ES&H officer, Engineering Division Head –Well-travelled, easy to find space –Becoming a regular stomping ground Huge boost for morale and WELL worth it Debated whether TM should move as well –From adjacent to director’s suite to one floor away –Trade-offs Response: Geography 15 July 2011 25

26. 15 July 2011 26 Response: Clear Vision (1) TRIUMF is Canada's national laboratory for particle and nuclear physics. It is owned and operated as a joint venture by a consortium of Canadian universities via a contribution through the National Research Council Canada with building capital funds provided by the Government of British Columbia. Its mission is: To make discoveries that address the most compelling questions in particle physics, nuclear physics, nuclear medicine, and materials science; To act as Canada's steward for the advancement of particle accelerators and detection technologies; and To transfer knowledge, train highly skilled personnel, and commercialize research for the economic, social, environmental, and health benefit of all Canadians.

27. Response: Clear Vision (2) 15 July 2011 27 TRIUMF will: Lead in Science: The world sees TRIUMF as Canada’s leader in probing the structure and origins of matter and in advancing isotopes for science and medicine. Leverage University Research: The Canadian university research community views TRIUMF as a way to strengthen and expand their research programs. Connect Canada to the World: International subatomic physics laboratories look to TRIUMF when partnering with Canada and its research community. Create Social and Economic Growth: The global scientific community sees TRIUMF as a bridge between academia and the private sector and as a model for commercialization & social impact.

28. TRIUMF is committed to a set of core values that characterize its culture and govern its relationship with the external world. Excellence and Progress. A commitment to excellence and merit with an emphasis on achieving TRIUMF’s mission and vision. Innovation and Creativity. Approaching assignments, tasks, and problems in new and efficacious ways; creating novel ideas and techniques. Integrity and Transparency. Being responsible and accountable for our actions and their consequences; respecting people, their ideas and diversity; working safely and sustainably with openness, honesty, generosity, and equity. Partnership and Service. Working with other individuals, groups, and institutions for mutual benefit, the good of society and each other. Response: Clear Vision (3) 15 July 2011 28

29. TRIUMF is owned & operated by a consortium of 17 universities Founded 42 years ago in Vancouver Members University of Alberta University of BC Carleton University University of Guelph University of Manitoba Université de Montréal Queen’s University Simon Fraser University University of Toronto University of Victoria York University TRIUMF: Accelerating Science for Canada 15 July 2011 29 Associate Members University of Calgary McMaster University University of Northern BC University of Regina Saint Mary’s University University of Winnipeg Research focus: Advancing isotopes for science & medicine Probing the structure & origins of matter

30. “TRIUMF’s newly launched Web site represents a great step forward in the laboratory’s electronic communications. The continuing incorporation of new content and of Web 2.0 tools could further strengthen this key communication tool.” Contracted with David Harris for “Social Media Training & Planning Workshop” in Feb 2011 –Met with potential contributors and engaged key senior staff to address concerns –Identified niche opportunity for TRIUMF related to “personality” of particle-physics lab –Completely hooked lab director Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, Flickr, Quantum Diaries –Still residual concerns about “usage” policies Comment & Response: Web & Social Media 15 July 2011 30

31. Response: Web & Social Media 15 July 2011 31

32. “The committee recognized both the risk and the opportunity created by the changing demographics of TRIUMF’s immediate neighbourhood combined with real and perceived environmental hazards at the laboratory. The committee recommended that TRIUMF implement a professionally-led community task force to advise laboratory management on public participation in planning and decision-making at TRIUMF.” Comment: Community Relations 15 July 2011 32

33. TRIUMF celebrated 40 th anniversary 2009 with Community Open House –Team of 110 people –1,300 people visited in four hours Included commemorative ceremony for planting of “Newton’s Apple Trees” –Brought together “alumni” community and VIPs Response: Community Relations 15 July 2011 33

34. Frequent co-programming with local civic group, University Neighbourhood Association –Tours of TRIUMF –Science lectures –“Science in the Movies” –Annual community picnic At TRUMF 40 th Anniversary, Exec Dir said…. Response: Community Relations 15 July 2011 34

35. Physics in Action high-school educational video –Pushed through to next milestone, then stopped work –Started discussions with partners for new funding, new direction, and new approaches Still lack focused Education & Outreach plan –Starting to connect with regional resources/agencies Public tours improved as result of community open-house efforts, but stalled again Response: Education & Outreach 15 July 2011 35

36. “The committee commended TRIUMF management’s commitment to transparency and internal communication and encouraged the development of improved internal communication media, as well as the integration of communication into line management responsibility.” Comment: Internal Comms 15 July 2011 36

37. Borrowing from STFC… –Each division now has monthly all-staff meeting –People JUST starting to ask questions –Director gives site-wide all-hands meeting every qtr –Director meets new employees each month –Every 2-3 weeks, 10 employees selected for “Breakfast with Director” Still no efficient/effective channel to reach all staff –Paper memos have been useful, but debate about whether “everyone has e-mail” continues Morale has been oscillating –Director sometimes seen as irrational instead of ambitious –Transition to pay parking was rough…misunderstood Response: Internal Comms 15 July 2011 37

38. 15 July 2011 38

39. 15 July 2011 39

40. Reflect 15 July 2011 40

41. 15 July 2011 41 Courtesy The Onion & P. Schaffer

42. Invaluable to get team+lab+leadership on same page Peer Review gave really good guidance –And especially focus! What to focus on first… –Even shared with government stakeholders Strengthened core capabilities so we can deal with everything that changes in more responsible fashion Some new risks have emerged –Animal research / rights … openness/transparency –Politically-driven changing tax environment Grateful… 15 July 2011 42

43. Some hopes are still dreams –Moving forward with neighbourhood task force has been tough –Stalled by lack of time, money, initiative –Just this year, started group project management planning, but at expense of updating comms strategy –Tours steady, but further growth & professional updating stalled –Science program not well promoted on website –Have not made modern TRIUMF brochure for VIPs –Future of NSL In some ways, peer review outlined vision, but still need muscle! Still Challenges 15 July 2011 43

44. Peer review was brilliant –Will seek a follow-up review in Year 3 or Year 5 Realistic, cost-neutral advice would be helpful –As in, contingency plans when resources not available –Don’t want to strengthen constraints but sometimes need advice about how to cope with them –Maybe put these terms into charge letter? How do we broaden recognition & reputation? Going forward 15 July 2011 44

45. Owned and operated as a joint venture by a consortium of Canadian universities via a contribution through the National Research Council Canada Propriété d’un consortium d’universités canadiennes, géré en co-entreprise à partir d’une contribution administrée par le Conseil national de recherches Canada Canada’s national laboratory for particle and nuclear physics Laboratoire national canadien pour la recherche en physique nucléaire et en physique des particules Accelerating Science for Canada Un accélérateur de la démarche scientifique canadienne Merci Thank You Questions? TRIUMF: Alberta | British Columbia | Calgary | Carleton | Guelph | Manitoba | McMaster | Montréal | Northern British Columbia | Queen’s | Regina | Saint Mary’s | Simon Fraser | Toronto | Victoria | Winnipeg | York