1. Brief Climate Discussion William F. Ryan Department of Meteorology The Pennsylvania State University

2. Summary of Remarks Global temperatures are rising. – Arguments to contrary have no scientific basis. – The rate of rise may be unprecedented. This rise cannot be attributed to “natural” causes. – Little change in solar output in last 30 years – We are in a static, slightly cooling portion of the earth-solar cycle. Climate models can accurately reproduce the historic global temperature record. – But only if man-made emissions are included. Current climate impacts are, as predicted, most noticeable in the the Arctic. – Loss of Arctic ice and strongest rate of warming. “Breaking” Science: – Changes in land-based Greenland ice. – Increasing variability in Northern Hemisphere weather patterns. – Variations in strength of Gulf Stream – impacts sea level along East Coast.

3. Global Surface Temperatures are Rising Four major recent independent temperature studies.

4. Global Surface Temperature by Year (dashed) and 5-year Running Average (red line) There is considerable year-to-year variability in global surface temperature. Warmer than average years are associated with: El Nino, short term changes in solar output. Cooler than average years are associated with: La Nina, increased volcanic activity and changes in solar output. (See, this Short Film for a clever explanation)Short Film

5. “No Recent Warming” Talking Point is a Fallacy: Selective truncation (“cherry picking”) of a time series of data can show any 10-year period has a cooling trend Every year since 2000 has been warmer than the mean temperature of the 1990’s. Twelve of the warmest thirteen years have occurred Since 2000. Another interesting short film: 16 Year Film16 Year Film

6. “Natural” Climate Cycles are Driven by Variations in the Orientation of the Sun and Earth

7. Solar Input has Changed Little in Past 30 Years

8. The Consensus of Climate Models Can Approximate Past Temperature

9. Models “Work” Only if Anthropogenic Greenhouse Gas Emissions are Included Observed global temperature anomaly (black line), consensus of climate models (red) and range (pink shading), consensus of climate models with only natural emissions (blue and blue shading.

10. Association of Temperature and CO 2

11. Recent Research Several extensions of the time series of temperature into deep past. – Wider set of ice core data. Recent ocean temperature data. Longer term CO 2 concentrations Impact of melting Arctic on Northern Hemisphere weather patterns.

12. Current Temperature Anomaly Likely Largest in Last 10,000 Years Marcott, et al., 2013: Science

13. CO 2 Levels are Highest in 400,000 Years

14. Oceans are Warming Through a Deep Layer

15. Continuing Rise in Sea Level

16. Sea Level Rise Amplified Along East Coast

17. Global Trend in Sea Level Rise Due to Temperature and Salinity Changes Milne, et al., 2009: Nature

18. Arctic Melting: Positive Feedback Cycle Melting sea ice leads to less reflection of sunlight, warmer temperatures, more melting sea ice and warming of the ocean.

19. The Arctic Ice “Death Spiral”

20. Effect on Northern Hemisphere Weather: The Arctic Oscillation (AO) Warmer (less ice volume) Arctic means weaker polar vortex so that cold air can “leak” southward.

21. Reduced Strength of Polar Vortex: Likely to Lead to More Erratic Weather? Example from May 3, 2013 Amplified Surges of Arctic air Unusual early May snow storm In the southern Plains.

22. Recent Work on Northern Hemisphere Weather

23. Areas of Concern for East Coast of US Sea Level Rise: – Rate of Loss of Greenland Land-Based Ice Melt? Significant Impact on Sea Level Rise. – Weakening of Atlantic Meridional Overturning CurrentsAtlantic Meridional Overturning Currents Gulf Stream is one branch. Atlantic Coast from HAT to Cape Cod may see locally higher sea level rise. Warmer Ocean – Extension of hurricane season? – Impact on ENSO?