Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
1
Options for TGaa Proposal Selection Procedures
November 2007 4/4/2019May 2008 doc.: IEEE /2752r1 Options for TGaa Proposal Selection Procedures Date: Authors: Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al Peter Ecclesine, Cisco Systems
2
November 2007 4/4/2019May 2008 doc.: IEEE /2752r1 Abstract This contribution tries to initiate discussions on the procedures that the IEEE aa Task Group will follow for selecting the proposals. Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al Peter Ecclesine, Cisco Systems
3
Etiquette It is nice if the consensus can be achieved on a proposal through discussions without a vote However, in reality, this may not always be true. It is important that All members respect all opinions during the discussion of the proposals and are open minded to work with others to enhance proposals via harmonization and merger according to the best technical solutions. The selection procedures Several options Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al
4
Option 1 Similar to the ones used by TGs, TGn, etc.
1st round proposal presentations and voting Yes Similar to the ones used by TGs, TGn, etc. Out Bottom 25%? No 2st round proposal presentations and voting No Out Support Votes >= 50%? Yes 3st round proposal presentations (normally 2 or 3 merged full proposals left) No Out Most supported proposal? Yes Final two or three most popular proposals come back, compete and merge One winning proposal No Confirmation vote on the final proposal as baseline draft (>=75%)? Yes Baseline specification requires 75% or greater approval Baseline document Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al
5
Option 2 Similar to the ones used by 802.16
Define a baseline ToC according to PAR scope and requirements documents Present the partial proposal + proposed text No Out Support Votes >= 75%? Yes Incorporate into the baseline Baseline specification requires 75% or greater approval Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al
6
Straw Poll 1 Would you prefer that TGaa adopts a selection procedure similar to Option 1 that is described in document IEEE /1341r0? Yes: No: Abstain: Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al
7
Straw Poll 2 Would you prefer that TGaa adopts a selection procedure similar to Option 2 that is described in document IEEE /1341r0? Yes: No: Abstain: Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al
8
Thank You! Questions? Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al
Similar presentations
![1 Introduction to IEEE Standardization Hang Liu. 2 IEEE Standard Association [1] Standards Activities Board 802.3 CSMA/CD Ethernet 802.5 Token Passing.](/16/4918495/big_thumb.jpg "1 Introduction to IEEE Standardization Hang Liu. 2 IEEE Standard Association [1] Standards Activities Board 802.3 CSMA/CD Ethernet 802.5 Token Passing.>")
