Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Workshop for Debate Teachers

Published byAnnabella Perry Modified over 5 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Workshop for Debate Teachers"— Presentation transcript:

1 Workshop for Debate Teachers
GUET—CDEN Workshop for Debate Teachers December 11 – 13, 2015 Identifying Fallacies of Argument

2 Johnson & Blair’s Model of Argument Cogency
RSA Triangle: Criteria a good argument must meet. Relevance Acceptability Sufficiency

3 Johnson & Blair’s Model applied to the Structure of Argument
Logically Adequate (More or Less) Acceptable ??? Relevant ??? Sufficient ??? Link Evidence Claim

4 Three Basic Fallacies:
#1: Problematic Premise Unacceptable Evidence Unsuccessful Claim

5 Three Basic Fallacies:
#2: Irrelevant Reaon No link between claim and evidence Evidence Unsuccessful Claim

6 Three Basic Fallacies:
#3: Hasty Conclusion Evidence 1 Insufficient link between claim and evidence Evidence 1 Unsuccessful Claim Evidence 1

Download ppt "Workshop for Debate Teachers"

Similar presentations

The Basics of Logical Argument Two Kinds of Argument The Deductive argument: true premises guarantee a true conclusion. e.g. All men are mortal. Socrates.

The Basics of Logical Argument Two Kinds of Argument The Deductive argument: true premises guarantee a true conclusion. e.g. All men are mortal. Socrates.
The aim of this tutorial is to help you learn to identify the types of fallacious reasoning discussed in Chapter 6. Chapter 6 discusses fallacies of insufficient.

The aim of this tutorial is to help you learn to identify the types of fallacious reasoning discussed in Chapter 6. Chapter 6 discusses fallacies of insufficient.
Unit 1A Recognizing Fallacies. LOGIC Logic is the study of the methods and principles of reasoning.

Unit 1A Recognizing Fallacies. LOGIC Logic is the study of the methods and principles of reasoning.
Understanding Logical Fallacies

Understanding Logical Fallacies
Three Basic Fallacies All the fallacies we deal with are forms of three basic fallacies: - Irrelevant Reason - Hasty Conclusion - Problematic Premise.

Three Basic Fallacies All the fallacies we deal with are forms of three basic fallacies: - Irrelevant Reason - Hasty Conclusion - Problematic Premise.
Refutation China Debate Education Network:. Definition of Refutation Refutation involves one debater directly responding to an argument of an opposing.

Refutation China Debate Education Network:. Definition of Refutation Refutation involves one debater directly responding to an argument of an opposing.
Chapter 6 Lecture Notes Working on Relevance. Chapter 6 Understanding Relevance: The second condition for cogency for an argument is the (R) condition.

Chapter 6 Lecture Notes Working on Relevance. Chapter 6 Understanding Relevance: The second condition for cogency for an argument is the (R) condition.
LogicandEvidence Scientific argument. Logic Reasoning –Deductive –Inductive.

LogicandEvidence Scientific argument. Logic Reasoning –Deductive –Inductive.
Chris Girouard, Mississippi House of Representatives Refutation 2010 Advocacy Institute International Debate Education Association and Willamette University.

Chris Girouard, Mississippi House of Representatives Refutation 2010 Advocacy Institute International Debate Education Association and Willamette University.
ALEC 604: Writing for Professional Publication Week 4: APA, Grammar, & Punctuation.

ALEC 604: Writing for Professional Publication Week 4: APA, Grammar, & Punctuation.
Building Logical Arguments. Critical Thinking Skills Understand and use principles of scientific investigation Apply rules of formal and informal logic.

Building Logical Arguments. Critical Thinking Skills Understand and use principles of scientific investigation Apply rules of formal and informal logic.
Media Literacy Week 13.  According to Webster’s Dictionary, a fallacy is an error in reasoning or a flawed argument.  It’s an argument that does not.

Media Literacy Week 13.  According to Webster’s Dictionary, a fallacy is an error in reasoning or a flawed argument.  It’s an argument that does not.
What Are Essays? The Application of Reason. Define Rhetoric “Rhetoric is the art of persuasion. Its goal is to change people’s opinions and influence.

What Are Essays? The Application of Reason. Define Rhetoric “Rhetoric is the art of persuasion. Its goal is to change people’s opinions and influence.
Today’s Quote Use soft words and hard arguments English Proverb.

Today’s Quote Use soft words and hard arguments English Proverb.
Grading Criteria for Assigment 1 Structure – –sense of time, present and past –conflict with two distinct sides –description of cause of conflict –shared.

Grading Criteria for Assigment 1 Structure – –sense of time, present and past –conflict with two distinct sides –description of cause of conflict –shared.
Visual Argumentation.

Visual Argumentation.
Copyright  2010 Pearson Education Canada / J A McLachlan 5 - 1 Chapter Five Principles of Discussion and Debate.

Copyright  2010 Pearson Education Canada / J A McLachlan Chapter Five Principles of Discussion and Debate.
Recognizing Fallacies.  Logic ◦ The study of the methods and principles of reasoning  Premises ◦ Facts or assumptions  Fallacy ◦ A deceptive argument-

Recognizing Fallacies.  Logic ◦ The study of the methods and principles of reasoning  Premises ◦ Facts or assumptions  Fallacy ◦ A deceptive argument-
Important Things to Know About Processing an Argumentative Essay There are three steps that every AP student should do every time he or she reads an argumentative.

Important Things to Know About Processing an Argumentative Essay There are three steps that every AP student should do every time he or she reads an argumentative.
Debate Basics: The Logical Argument. Argument An argument is a set of claims presented in a logical form. An argument attempts to persuade an audience.

Debate Basics: The Logical Argument. Argument An argument is a set of claims presented in a logical form. An argument attempts to persuade an audience.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google