1. A Study on Evaluating the Quality of Group Study（２）
9/14/2018
A Study on Evaluating the Quality of Group Study（２）
TETSURO FURUKAWA
Kanazawa Institute of Technology、 Japan
25ｔｈ July 2005
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

2. Objectives One of the Course（Engineering Design 1,2) Objectives
9/14/2018
Objectives
One of the Course（Engineering Design 1,2) Objectives
To Bring Up Student’s Teamwork Ability, So As To Be an Active Engineer
Objective of this Study
To Find Evaluation Index Which Shows Student’s Teamwork Ability
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

3. Other abilities and skills
9/14/2018
Team Record Evaluation System (Relation Between Teamwork Ability and Team Record )
Teamwork
ability
Other abilities　and　skills
Individual ability
Group work
Output
peer- evaluation
team- record
self-evaluation
130 Items
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

4. Evaluation Items At Peer-Evaluation
9/14/2018
Evaluation Items At Peer-Evaluation
For Freshman
Evaluate Contribution Synthetically　
For Sophomore 1　
　If he expressed his opinions actively in the team?　 2
　If he listen to others’ opinion well. 3
　If he showed the leadership and led the team. 4
　Was he responsible and carried out his sharing
work. 5
　Did he carried out advanced work technically.
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

5. Relation between Standard Deviation of Peer-Evaluation and Team Record
9/14/2018
Relation between Standard Deviation of Peer-Evaluation and Team Record R 2 = 52 56 60 64 68 5 10 15 20 25 30
Standard-Deviation of Peer-Evaluation
Team-Record
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

6. 9/14/2018
Relation between Standard Deviation of Peer-Evaluation and Team Record-2
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

7. 9/14/2018
Relation between Standard Deviation of Peer-Evaluation and Team Record-3
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

8. Results of Correlation Analysis on Peer-Evaluation and Team-Record
9/14/2018
Results of Correlation Analysis on Peer-Evaluation and Team-Record
Team-record take maximum at the point of standard deviation of peer-evaluation
This correlation factor was not so strong on the whole
In a few class, such a tendency does not shown
However, standard deviation of peer-evaluation might be helpful when we evaluate teamwork quality.
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

9. Self-Evaluation System
9/14/2018
Self-Evaluation System
Home Page
ID Number
Pass word
Week Number
Evaluate their abilities by 5 grads about 23 or 26 questionnaires (include 3 items about teamwork)
Individual corresponding page
Each
Student
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

10. An Example of Self- evaluation Results
9/14/2018
An Example of Self- evaluation Results
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

11. Examination about 9th and Improved Point of Self-Evaluation
9/14/2018
Examination about 9th and Improved Point of Self-Evaluation
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

12. Relation between the Improved Point of Self-Evaluation and Team record
9/14/2018
Relation between the Improved Point of Self-Evaluation and Team record
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

13. 9/14/2018
Results of Correlation Analysis Between Self-Evaluation and Team-Record
self-evaluation result correlate with the team record
Correlation between improvement of self-evaluation and team-record is stronger than the one evaluated at the end of a term (9th week)
In a parts of classes, that correlation is weak.
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

14. 9/14/2018
SUMMARY
In the class for improving the student’s teamwork ability, we examined to find some index which shows teamwork ability itself and we got the following conclusions
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

15. 9/14/2018
SUMMARY -2-
Standard deviation of peer-evaluation in a team correlate with team record and team the record take maximum when the standard deviation is in a half.
Improved value of self-evaluation correlate with team record stronger than the value evaluated at the end of the term correlate with.
Those correlation are not so strong on the whole
It isn’t sufficient to assess the teamwork ability only with these coefficients of correlation, however these might be helpful for evaluation of team work quality.
FURUKAWA
ICEE2005，Gliwice
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice

16. Thank you for your attention
9/14/2018
Thank you for your attention
THE END
FURUKAWA ICEE2005,Gliwice