1. Cultural Relevance and Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI)
A study by:
Jaqueline Leonard
James Earl Davis
Jennifer L. Sidler
Journal of Research on Technology in Education
Presented by Christine Ray

2. Focus of study Research Questions:
What effect will the CAI have on task engagement in African American Elementary School students?
How will this program effect students’ ability to solve math and science problems?
What effects will environment and prior teaching have on student outcomes?

3. Overview of CAI Software
Engaged students in a Computer Simulation of Riding the Freedom Train, an Underground Railroad themed CAI.
Math and Science content embedded into program.
The Program employed a “Learning for Use” model and was “Problem solving Based.”
Encouraged higher order thinking skills.
Goal directed.
Scaffolding and hints provided.
Introduced as supplement to teacher instruction.

4. Study Participants Students in (3) fourth-grade classrooms.
Two Schools-Pennsylvania & Illinois.
Ethnic background (both schools) >98% African American.
No significant differences in SES, gender, or achievement-test scores.

5. Rationale Culturally Relevant Instruction African American Students
Achievement Gap.
NAEP 46% of AA 4th gr. and 61% 8th gr. are below basic level of math achievement.
Low income students
have difficulty w/
processing math
language when
presented out of context.
Technology Gap
Culturally Relevant Instruction
Improves motivation.
“Anchors context to content.”
Validates the way that students count, measure, classify, & infer meaning and links it to culture.
Consistent with NCTM goals and standards.

6. Method-Data Collection
Pre Test- pencil/paper.
Post Test- scores from CAI program.
Teacher interview
Sample student interviews (random).
Observation-video taped (1 classroom)

7. Riding the Freedom Train Story Line: Narration with digital images
Fictional Character: Sam, a slave on a MD plantation.
Sam decides to leave plantation and travel north on the Underground Railroad to freedom in PA.
Students must help Sam on his journey by answering a series of math and science problems.

8. Examples of Embedded Questions
“The Big Dipper is made of stars, and stars are made out of ________?”
a. Rocks
b. Gases
c. Glitter
d. Clouds
“Sam wants to take 20 fruit on his journey and eats 2 fruit per day. How many fruit did Sam eat if it Takes him 8 days to get to Philadelphia?” ____
No choices provided.

9. Results
Engagement: Interview and observations indicated a high level of engagement & enjoyment.
Pre-test vs. post test accuracy
Science-56% increase
Math-43% increase
Environmental Factors: Computer lab vs. classroom work station made no significant difference.

10. Other benefits:
Students gained better understanding of the concept of the Underground Railroad.
CAI promoted independent inquiry about Underground Railroad.
No significant difference between group performances despite marked differences in overall unit instruction.

11. Considerations
Study could not be generalized and no control group was used.
Unanswered Questions:
Would students do as well with same activities (i.e. narration with embedded problems) without computer software?
Would there have been a difference in student performance if pre tests and post tests had identical formats and methods?