1. DATA VERTICAL Technical Exchange
Classification
DATA VERTICAL Technical Exchange
JAWG
Jerry Makowka,
Briefing to DV WG
March 09, 2011
Classification

2. Data Vertical Working Session Agenda
Background
Conceptual Data Model (CDM)
Generalization Hierarchy
CDM Description

3. Data Vertical Work Plan
Deliverable 1: CDM and associated Data Dictionary  March 2011
Deliverable 2: Data Vertical Description (DVD) --  31 May 2011
Deliverable 3: IC Data Architecture Framework -- 1 Dec 2011
Deliverable 4: Architecture Data Meta-Model  --  1 Dec 2011
Deliverable 5: IC Information Exchange Models --  Post 1 Jan 2012

4. Data Vertical Value
Provides the means to organize and characterize data within the IC
Common lexicon about data that the IC produces, consumes, and manages.
Promotes cross-organizational communication regarding data/information (Understanding)
Aides in the identification of data/information gaps and potentially unnecessary duplication.
Forms a basis to assess a IC program or investment from a data/information perspective
CDM provides common basis for logical and physical data models to promote interoperability between solution architectures through standard information exchanges, potentially eliminating the requirement to develop custom information exchanges.
Provides the means to understand the inter-relationships between data-related capabilities and requirements across IC portfolios.
Supports architecture-informed portfolio analysis and decision-making (data needs, dependencies, constraints, risks, etc)
A necessary component of the IC Core Reference Architecture
Describes a key dimension to the services perspective heretofore used to define what it means for the IC to operate as a federation.

5. TEM Prioritized Review Topics
Dictionary is correct and descriptive
Relationship
Relations between entities correct and descriptive
Cardinality correct
Relations missing
Entity
Names are correct
Supertype/subtype is complete and correctly grouped
JARM level(s) is correct
Definition is clear and correct
Missing entities
Subject Areas correct and clear

6. Presentation Organization
CDM level diagram(s)
Dictionary for that level

7. Terminology Cats and Dogs are Mammals
Cardinality of the entity is shown near the entity
0..1 Zero or one
1 One only
* Zero or more
1..* One or more
Relationship between two entities is bidirectional.
A relationship is bidirectional, but read in the direction of the arrow (Dog chases one or more Cats
Mammal
Dog
<<extends>>
Cat
Cat
Dog
1..*
<<chases>>

8. Data Vertical Conceptual Data Model Level 0 (Baselined)*
<<17-performs / produced by/ consumed by>>
<<1-requires ability to perform>>
<<10-has>>
Condition
{Layer 2-9}
<<2-is performable under>>
Location
{Layer 1-9}
<<19-is at>>
<<18-produced by>>
<<6-constrains>>
<<11-has>>
<<3-is performable under>> 1
Activity
{Layer 8,9}
<<15-measures>>
Measure
{Layer 1-8}
<<16-measures>>
<<12-measures>>
<<14-measures compliance>>
<<7-constrains>>
Initiative
1..*
<<8-defines>>
<<9-constrains>>
Resource
{Layer 1-10}
<<4-produce outcomes>>
<<5-is performed under/ characterized by>>
Capability
{Layer 9}
Guidance
{Layer 10}
<<13-measures>>

9. CDM Level 0 Dictionary Data Vertical DV Definition Activity
Work accomplished by any performer that transforms a resource’s state.
Capability
The ability to achieve an outcome under specified (performance) standards and conditions through a combination of activities and resources to perform a set of activities.
Condition
The state of an environment or situation in which a performer performs. This includes constraints and required any pre and post condition necessary for an activity to occur.
Guidance
An authoritative statement intended to lead or steer the execution of actions. It represents the strategic or tactical direction and policies based on internal and external needs / influences presented through a variety of information artifacts and drive the required capabilities of the organization.
Initiative
Is a temporary endeavor undertaken to create resources or outcomes.
Location
A point or extent in space that may be referred to physically, logically or virtually.
Measure
The magnitude of an attribute for the purpose of assessment.
Resource
Data, Information, Performers, Materiel, or Personnel Types that are produced or consumed.

10. Data Vertical Conceptual Data Model Subject Areas
Management
Guidance
{Layer 10}
<<constrains>>
Measure
{Layer 1-8}
<<manages>>
Initiative
{Layer 8,9}
<<measures>>
Enabler
<<performs / produced by/ consumed by>>
Location
{Layer 1-9}
<<is at>>
Resource
{Layer 1-10}
Execution
Capability
{Layer 9}
Condition
{Layer 2-9}
Activity
Constrained by>>

11. Data Vertical Conceptual Data Model Level 1 (Draft)
Guidance
Mission
Vision
Strategy
Rule *
1..*
<<9-constrains>>
<<3-constrains>>
<<15-constrains>>
Policy
<<7-Constrans / Driven by>>
<<10-implements>>
Initiative
Portfolio
Program
<< 8-contains>> 1
1..*
Measure
Trustworthiness *
<<12-assures>>
Organizational Measure
Physical Measure
Service Level
Outcomes Measure
<<14-assures>>
<<13-assures>>
<<11-assures>>

12. Data Vertical Conceptual Data Model Level 1 (Draft) (Continued)
Resource
Performer
Information
Materiel *
<< 4-uses>>
<<1-describes>>
<< uses /produces>>
Activity
Interactive Activity
Automatic Activity
Manual Activity
Capability
Thread
Competency
Condition
A Priori Condition
Performance
Post Condition
Location
Logical Location
Physical Location
<<5- fixes>>
Virtual Location
<< 6-fixes>>
<< 2-instantiates>>

13. CDM Level 1 Dictionary

14. CDM Level 1 Dictionary

15. Data Vertical Conceptual Data Model Level 2 (Draft)
Measure
Guidance 1
Trustworthiness
Security
Confidence
Trustworthiness
Security
Confidence
Service Level
Maintainability Measure
Needs Satisfaction Measure
Adaptability Measure
Performance Measure
Physical Measure
Temporal Measure
Spatial Measure
Rule
Standard
Agreement
1..*
<<1-adheres to>>
Constraint
Requirement 1
<<2-formalizes>>
Security Attributes Group
Resource
Performer
PersonRole
Service
Organization
System
Interface
<<5-has>>
<<6-has>>
<<3-interact with >>
<<4-interact with >> *
1..*
Materiel
Supplies Data
Equipment Data
Information
Partially Structured
Unstructured Data
Structured Data
Policy
External Policy
Internal Policy
Guidance

16. Data Vertical Conceptual Data Model Level 2 (Draft) (Continued)
Capability
Competency
Tasking
Data Acceptance & Ingest
Data Access & Delivery
Homeland Security
Community Functional Management
Planning and Budgeting
Human Resources
Collection
Analysis
Special Activities
Law Enforcement
Controls & Oversight, Legislative Relations, Public Affairs, and Regulatory Development Operations
Administrative Management
Supply Chain Management
Processing
Intelligence Production
Defense & National Security
Community Deployed Resource Services
Internal Risk Management & Mitigation
Financial Management
Information and Technology Management
Strategic Mission Operations
Planning
Security Services
Thread
Time Critical Operations Support
Counter Foreign Intel Defense
Foreign Intel Analysis & Provisioning
Foreign Intel Collection & Processing
Human Capital Selection, Development, & Retention
Information & Resource Management & Protection
Business Operations Management

17. CDM Level 2 Dictionary 1of 5

18. CDM Level 2 Dictionary 2 of 5

19. CDM Level 2 Dictionary 3 of 5

20. CDM Level 2 Dictionary 4 of 5

21. CDM Level 2 Dictionary 5 of 5

22. CDM Level 2 Dictionary

23. Data Vertical Conceptual Data Model Level 3 (Draft)
Guidance/Rule
Measure/Trustworthiness
Standard
Functional Standard
Technical Specification
Profile Package
Requirements
Performance Requirement
Technical Requirement
Resource Requirement
Function Requirement
Constraint
Security Attributes Group
Usage Constraint
Environmental Constraint
Support Constraint
Security
Logical Security
Physical Security
Confidence
Content Confidence
Usage Confidence
Environmental Confidence

24. CDM Level 3 Dictionary

25. BONUS SLIDES

26. Complete Generalization Hierarchy (1 of 5)

27. Complete Generalization Hierarchy (2 of 5)

28. Complete Generalization Hierarchy (3 of 5)

29. Complete Generalization Hierarchy (4 of 5)

30. Complete Generalization Hierarchy (5 of 5)