1. Performance-Based Communication and Surveillance (PBCS)
Closing remarks
Presented to: ICAO Asia-Pacific RCP/RSP Workshop (Bangkok, Thailand)
By: Tom Kraft
Date: May 2013

2. APAC RCP/RSP Workshop Program
Time
(min)
Session 1 – Understanding RCP/RSP & PBCS
Discussion Leader 20
Introductory Remarks
Fredric Lecat
Tom Kraft 45
ICAO SARPS – Guidance
Paul Radford
Global Operational Data Link Document (GOLD) 15
Derivation of RCP/RSP specifications 35
Introduction to Performance Based Communication and Surveillance (PBCS) 30
Qualification of service provision: ANSP and CSP
ARINC/SITA
Qualification of aircraft equipment for certification
Jerome Condis
Operational authorization to use data link
Post-Implementation Monitoring Guidance
Performance monitoring in the Fukuoka FIR
Koji Nakaitani
Interpreting the results 10
GOLD Performance Analysis Tool

3. Safety realization What is missing? ATM RCP RNP RSP S N C
Benefits come from ATM (e.g. reducing separation minima)
PBN (e.g. RNP) by itself does NOT give you ATM
PBCS implementation plays important role in ATM
Recognized problem
Endorsed GOLD
Endorsed Regional PBCS implementation plan
Conduct PBCS workshops
Implement PBCS in the Region 1
What is missing? 2 3 4 5
APAC Regions 1 2 4 1 2 3 4 5
NAT Region
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015

4. RCP/RSP Workshop Aim – Day 1
Promote PBCS implementation
What is PBCS and what are RCP and RSP specifications?
What amendments are being proposed for Annexes 6 and 11, Doc 4444, Doc 8168, and Doc 9869 to include PBCS provisions?
What guidance material is provided by GOLD?

5. RCP/RSP Workshop Aim – Day 1
Promote PBCS implementation
How do RCP/RSP specifications relate to C and S requirements for application of separation minima?
Why and how does PBCS effectively apply RCP/RSP specifications to ensure safe application of ATM through prescriptive requirements, initial qualification and continued operational safety
How does post-implementation monitoring, analysis and corrective action improve performance?

6. APAC RCP/RSP Workshop Program
Time
(min)
Session 2 – Planning for PBCS implemenation in the APAC Region
Discussion Leader 30
State of the data link implementation in the South Pacific
Toby Farmer 15
An overview of NAT PBCS Implementation Plan
Tom Kraft 45
General Discussion on APAC PBCS Planning and Implementation
Frederic Lecat,
Tom Kraft and Paul Radford
Wrap-up/ Summary of outcomes
Li Peng and Frederic Lecat

7. RCP/RSP Workshop Aim – Day 2
Promote a timely APANPIRG conclusion to endorse an APAC Regional PBCS Implementation Plan
Develop draft plan
To complement APAC Regional PBN Implementation Plan
Compatible with the global air navigation planning and performance-based concepts to ensure effective and harmonized PBCS implementation
ATM
RCP
RNP
RSP S N C

8. NAT PBCS implementation planning tasks
Completed
On track
TASK ID
TASK DESCRIPTOR
COMPLETE BY
LEAD
GENERAL PROJECT DEVELOPMENT & MANAGEMENT 1
Plan
NAT IMG/38 and NAT SPG/47
NAT CNSG 2
Target dates
NAT IMG 3
RCP/RSP specifications
NAT SPG/47
NAT SARSIG 4
NAT PBCS Workshop(s)
ICAO/ States
DOCUMENTATION 5
Operational concepts
NAT IMG/42and NAT SPG/49
NAT ATMG in coordination with CNSG 6
GOLD amendments
NAT IMG/42 and NAT SPG/49
GOLD ad-hoc group 7
Contingency procedures
NAT ATMG/ CNSG 8
Restoration of service 9
Flight plan requirements
a) NAT IMG/42 and NAT SPG/49 (as part of the NAT SUPPs PfA) and GOLD
b) amend Doc target date - NAT SPG/50
ICAO (Global) 10
PfA for NAT Regional Supplementary Procedures (NAT SUPPS)
NAT CNSG NAT ATMG 11
AIPs and other State documents supporting NAT SUPPS
Consistent with Task 10
States 14
GOLD proposal for RCP/RSP compliance determination
CNSG 15
GOLD proposal for guidelines on operator eligibility
OPS/AIR
IMPLEMENTATION ACTIVITIES 12
ATC automation changes
Before the start of operational trials of RLongSM or RLatSM.
NAT ANSPs 13
Confirm actual CPDLC and ADS C performance
Prior to operational implementation
ANSPs, DLMA, CNSG, SARSIG
AIRWORTHINESS AND OPERATIONAL ELIGIBILITY 16
State regulations and guidance material
End of 2014, Prior to operational implementation of RLatSM or RLongSM
SOG, States, ANSPs, Users
POST IMPLEMENTATION TASKS 17
Post-implementation monitoring
ANSPs, DLMA, CNSG

9. APAC PBCS implementation planning
Did the workshop provide the APAC Region with an understanding of PBCS and RCP/RSP specifications?
Is there a convincing argument for PBCS implementation in the APAC?
What should be considered in planning for APAC PBCS implementation?
What tasks should be identified, who is lead and involved in competing the task and what is the schedule?

10. APAC PBCS Implementation Plan
TASK ID
TASK DESCRIPTOR
COMPLETE BY
LEAD
GENERAL PROJECT DEVELOPMENT & MANAGEMENT 1
Plan 2
Target dates 3
Applicability of RCP/RSP specifications 4
PBCS Workshop(s)
DOCUMENTATION 5
Operational concepts 6
GOLD amendments 7
Contingency procedures 8
Restoration of service 9
Flight plan requirements 10
PfA for NAT Regional Supplementary Procedures (NAT SUPPS) 11
AIPs and other State documents supporting NAT SUPPS 14
GOLD proposal for RCP/RSP compliance determination 15
GOLD proposal for guidelines on operator eligibility
IMPLEMENTATION ACTIVITIES 12
ATC automation changes 13
Confirm actual CPDLC and ADS C performance
AIRWORTHINESS AND OPERATIONAL ELIGIBILITY 16
State regulations and guidance material
POST IMPLEMENTATION TASKS 17
Post-implementation monitoring

11. Are more PBCS workshops needed?
When and where?

14. NAT PBCS implementation schedule (1 of 2)
GOLD Jun 2010
Proposed PANS/ATM & Draft GOLD Amendment
Proposed PANS/ATM & GOLD Amendment 6
Global
6, 9
6, 9
Plan Draft Jun 2008
Endorsed RCP/RSP Plan
Proposed GOLD Amendment
NAT Doc 006/007
Draft PfA NAT Doc 7030
GOLD Amendment
PfA NAT Doc 7030 1
NAT Groups
1, 2, 3
5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 14, 15 10
6, 10
Plan update
Target dates
Performance specifications
GOLD, NAT Doc 006/007
ADS-C conformance monitoring
Procedures for reroutes, non-normal operations
Flight plan indicators for specifications
Operator/aircraft approval guidance update
Technical/monitoring update
Guidance on operational approval
Draft PfA NAT Doc RLongSM, RLatSM
NAT SPG/49
Adopt GOLD Amendment
Process PfA
DLMA Jun 2009
GOLD performance monitoring
RCP/RSP Workshops
State AIPs & other docs 12
NAT States/ANSPs/DLMA 12 4 12
11, 16
4, 13, 17
New York – < 2010 Gander – 1Q/2011
Shanwick – 4Q/2010 Santa Maria – 2Q/2011
Reykjavik –3Q/2011
Shannon –1Q/2013
Bodo – TBD
RLongSM Trial
NAT SPG/47
NAT SPG/48
12th ANC
Data Link Mandate
NAT SPG/49
OPLINKP
OPLINKP D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M
2011
2012
2013

15. NAT PBCS implementation schedule (2 of 2)
GOLD amendment Jun 2013
PANS/ATM amendment Nov 2014
6, 9
Global 9
GOLD NAT adoption
PfA NAT Doc 7030
6, 10
NAT Groups
Program management
Coordination
GOLD performance monitoring
State AIP and other documents
Operational readiness
4, 11, 13, 16, 17
NAT States/ANSPs/DLMA 17
11, 13, 16
Performance-based
Concept
RLongSM
RLatSM
NAT SPG/50
NAT SPG/51
NAT SPG/52 D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M
2014
2015
2016