Traditional vs. Alternative Assessment Assessment is the process of finding out how well students have mastered the curriculum.

Traditional Assessment Tests, quizzes, essays Became very popular in schools in the 80s when grades were based almost entirely on results of completing multiple choice items on classroom tests that were similar to standadrized tests. Research shows in some cases that there is very little relationship between such test grades, and any measure of students’s ability to apply knowledge.

Traditional Assessment These types of tests (multiple choice, similar to standardized tests) are very low on Bloom's taxonomy (recall). They emphasize memory over more complex skills with a focus on grdes and ranking.

Traditional (continued) Based on psychometric theories of the 1950s Individuals have/develop specific and general abilities that can be measured by written tests and will predict / correlate in practice.

Traditional (continued) The formats of these items tend to be very similar (ie> multiple choice) The conditions under which the tests are given are also standardized (ie: amount of time, no talking).

Traditional (cont) Produce results that are comparable between groups, (class to class) but it also tends to make testing highly artificial when compared to what scientists or anyone actually does in real life.

Alternative assessment Uses activities that reveal what students can do, emphasizing their strengths instead of their weaknesses. Alt. Assessment instruments are designed and structured differently and are graded and scored differently Since they are performance based, sometimes called “performance” assessment.

Alternative Assessment Can be difficult to use when it comes to comparing a large group of students Works well in learner centred classrooms since they are based on the idea that students can evaluate their own learning and learn from the evaluation process.

Alternative cont... Built around topics or issues of interest to the students Replicate real world communication contexts and situations Involve multi-stage tasks and real problems that require creative use of language rather than simple repetition. Require learners to produce a quality product or performance.

Alternative Evaluation criteria and standards are known to the student Involve interaction between the assessor (instructor/peers/self) and the person being assessed.

Alternative Allow for self-regulation, self-evaluation and self-correction. Methods include checklists, portfolios, journals.....

Alternative disadvantages Difficult to assign a score to a single student performance Portfolios can be time consuming to evaluate for a teacher with a full course load Comprehensive set of scoring guidelines must be developed in order to accurately judge completeness and quality

Disadvantages Lack of use in traditional educational institutions (universities) Most instructors have no training to develop these types of assessments difficult to develop and grade

In summary.... Difficult to dismiss traditional assessment entirely Ideally a combination of both Start slowly to implement alternative assessment strategies