1 RUSSIAN SCIENCE UNDER THE MICROSCOPE Philip Purnell Moscow, October 2013

THOMSON REUTERS - DATA PROVIDER 2

RESEARCH OUTPUTS 3

CONFIDENTIAL4

5

RUSSIAN RESEARCH COLLABORATIONS CONFIDENTIAL6

IMPACT OF INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATION CONFIDENTIAL7

COLLABORATION NETWORKS CONFIDENTIAL8

EVALUATING INSTITUTIONS

OUTPUT AND IMPACT BY INSTITUTION CONFIDENTIAL10

ADDRESS UNIFICATION

WIDER LOOK AT INDICATORS Profiles Project Institution submitted data Bibliometric data Academic reputation survey

WIDER LOOK AT INDICATORS

UNIVERSITY RANKINGS 14

EVALUATING INDIVIDUALS

ARTICLE LEVEL INDICATORS 16 Source: Thomson Reuters InCites This paper has received 45/16.74 = 2.69 times the expected citations for this subject category This paper has received 45/21.48 = 2.09 times the expected citations for this journal Integrative & Complementary Medicine articles from 2005 have been cited times Articles published in this journal from 2005 have been cited times

IDENTIFY THE BEST RESEARCHERS IN THEIR FIELD 17 Computer Science Medicine Source: InCites™

EVALUATE INDIVIDUAL RESEARCHERS 18 Web of Science Documents by Publication Year Citations by Year

RESEARCHER ID 19

RESEARCHER ID 20

LIMITATIONS

22 SPECIAL CASE: ARTS & HUMANITIES

23 SPECIAL CASE: ARTS & HUMANITIES

SPECIAL CASE: NEGATIVE CITATIONS 24

SPECIAL CASE: SELF-CITATIONS Journal self-citation REV BRAS FARMACOGN: First Journal Impact Factor in 2009=3.462 Journals whose rank in category is significantly distorted by self-citation are removed from JCR for 2 years, then re- evaluated

SPECIAL CASE: MULTI-AUTHORED PAPERS 26