Augustine’s Philosophy of Mathematics Jim Bradley Nov. 3, 2006.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
© Michael Lacewing Innate ideas Michael Lacewing.
Advertisements

René Descartes "I am thinking therefore I exist." - Discourse on Method.
Immanuel Kant ( ) Theory of Aesthetics
The ontological argument. I had the persuasion that there was absolutely nothing in the world, that there was no sky and no earth, neither minds nor.
Descartes God.
Faith and Revelation Chapter 1
Descartes’ rationalism
Descartes’ rationalism
Descartes’ cosmological argument
Descartes’ trademark argument Michael Lacewing
Kant Philosophy Through the Centuries BRENT SILBY Unlimited (UPT)
The Ontological Argument
The Existence of God and the Problem of Evil
Idealism.
Plato Theory of Forms.
© Michael Lacewing Omnipotence and other puzzles Michael Lacewing co.uk.
Malcolm’s ontological argument Michael Lacewing
Descartes on Certainty (and Doubt)
The Rationalists: Descartes Certainty: Self and God
The Cosmological Argument. Also known as ‘The First Cause Argument’ Unlike the Ontological Argument, it derives the conclusion from a posteriori premise.
The Perfect God Anselm’s clever trick.
René Descartes The father of modern Western philosophy and the epistemological turn Methodological doubt, his dreaming argument and the evil.
Is Religion Reasonable? Faith Seeking Understanding The ontological argument The cosmological argument The teleological argument (from design)
Faith and Reason And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us… -John 1:14 This is a great mystery… -Eph 5:32 The Holy Family with Painted Frame -Rembrandt.
Is Belief in God Reasonable? Faith Seeking Understanding A posteriori arguments (based on experience): The teleological argument (from design) The cosmological.
Metaphysics Philosophy 21 Fall, 2004 G. J. Mattey.
 Derives from Greek words meaning Love of Wisdom.
The True Self and Its Realization Katha and Brihad-Aranyaka Upanishads.
The Critique of Pure Reason (1781, 1787)
Signs and Symbols.
Epistemology Revision
Theories of Perception: Empirical Theory of Perception Berkeley’s Theory of Reality Direct Realism Moderate Thomistic Realism.
Descartes & Rationalism
Philosophy 1050: Introduction to Philosophy Week 10: Descartes and the Subject: The way of Ideas.
Epistemology Section 1 What is knowledge?
Augustine’s Confessions Book Two Chap IV? Reflects on how and why he stole some pears: on how and why he did wrong (evil) for its own sake Do we do this?
René Descartes ( AD) Meditations on First Philosophy (1641) (Text, pp )
Can you learn this? You have 2 minutes. Then you will try and write it down word for word “if you can conceive it to be possible for any mixture or combination.
The Trinity and Incarnation The Twin Mysteries of Faith.
© Michael Lacewing Hume and Kant Michael Lacewing co.uk.
Evidential Challenge: Kierkegaard and Adams
Chapter 4 The God Who Reveals Religion
11/26/2015 Modern Philosophy PHIL320 1 Kant III Charles Manekin.
© Michael Lacewing Kant on conceptual schemes Michael Lacewing osophy.co.uk.
Descates Meditations II A starting point for reconstructing the world.
Class 6 Kant. Immanuel Kant (1724–1804) From Königsberg, Germany.
Anselm’s “1st” ontological argument Something than which nothing greater can be thought of cannot exist only as an idea in the mind because, in addition.
The Ontological Argument for the Existence of God August 15, 2015 George Cronk, J.D., Ph.D. Professor of Philosophy & Religion Bergen Community College.
An analysis of Kant’s argument against the Cartesian skeptic in his ‘Refutation of Idealism” Note: Audio links to youtube are found on my blog at matthewnevius.wordpress.com.
René Descartes Brandon Lee Block D.
Anselm & Aquinas. Anselm of Canterbury ( AD) The Ontological Argument for the Existence of God (Text, pp )
Meditations: 3 & 4.
An Outline of Descartes's Meditations on First Philosophy
The Nature of God Nancy Parsons. Attributes- Nature of God Candidates should be able to demonstrate knowledge and understanding of: 1.God as eternal,
The Cosmological Argument Today’s lesson will be successful if: You have revised the ideas surrounding the cosmological argument and the arguments from.
Ontological Argument (Ontological is from the Greek word for being, named by Kant) Learning Objectives To know the specification content To know the meaning.
Meditation Three Of God: That He Exists.
Intuition and deduction thesis (rationalism)
Human intellect.
Descartes’ trademark argument
Major Periods of Western Philosophy
Michael Lacewing Hume and Kant Michael Lacewing © Michael Lacewing.
Remember these terms? Analytic/ synthetic A priori/ a posteriori
March, 26, 2010 EPISTEMOLOGY.
Anselm & Aquinas December 23, 2005.
Descartes -- Meditations Four
Norman Malcolm on the Ontological Argument
The Big Picture Deductive arguments - origins of the ontological argument Deductive proofs; the concept of ‘a priori’. St Anselm - God as the greatest.
March, 26, 2010 EPISTEMOLOGY.
Meditation Three Of God: That He Exists.
Presentation transcript:

Augustine’s Philosophy of Mathematics Jim Bradley Nov. 3, 2006

Why am I interested in Augustine’s philosophy of mathematics? modernism post-modernism

Neither is satisfactory Modernist approach is a form of idolatry. Post-modern approach can’t account for mathematics’ sense of transcendence. Augustine a (the?) preeminent pre- Enlightenment Christian thinker

Why is Augustine interested in the philosophy of mathematics?

Augustine’s argument for the existence of God Faith seeking understanding a sure starting point - our own existence levels of being - existence, life, understanding we have senses, an inner sense, and reason Is there anything in human nature more exalted than reason? Among all things greater than reason, if such exist, the greatest is God

Inner sense - means by which we perceive our senses - animals have it - is not reason but is an agent of reason Reason (Latin ratio) - (Gilson) “Reason is the movement whereby the mind passes from one of its knowledges to another to associate or disassociate them.” - is how we attain knowledge - grasps itself by itself

“The bodily senses perceive material objects. No bodily sense can perceive itself. The inner sense, however, perceives material objects through the bodily senses and also perceives the bodily senses themselves. And by reason all of these things, as well as reason itself, become known and are part of knowledge.”

Such a thing does exist – Number (Latin numerus)

Human reason Inner sense SightHearingTaste... x y z …

What is the philosophy of mathematics? Four basic themes: 1. Ontology 2. Epistemology 3a. Meaning of truth 3b. How do we account for the certainty of mathematical truth? 4. Effectiveness

My main thesis: Augustine addresses all of these questions in a way that provides a viable starting point for a Christian philosophy of mathematics.

Concept of truth Def’n: A truth is a necessary and therefore immutable proposition. Distinctive characteristics of all truths: necessity immutability eternity common to all minds that contemplate them Some items of rational knowledge are truths.

Examples of truths One ought to live justly. Inferior things should be subjected to superior things. Like should be compared with like. Everyone should be given what is rightly his. The uncorrupted is better than the corrupt, the eternal than the temporal, the invulnerable than the vulnerable. A life that cannot be swayed by any adversity from its fixed and upright resolve is better than one that is easily weakened and overthrown by transitory misfortunes.

Truth Is a kind of light - it’s possessed by all who perceive the same truths at a given moment but it’s not changed by any of them. Cannot come from any individual reason as it is common to every reason. Rules the mind therefore is independent of it - transcends our minds. Cannot be gained from sensible objects. E.g., the idea of unity must precede my perception of it.

In seeing any truth, the mind perceives something above itself and immutable, therefore perceives aspects of God. “Is God greater than truth or is the truth God?”

Mathematical truths are instances of truths and hence are: - necessary - immutable - eternal - and they transcend human minds

Ontology Some widely held positions: Platonism (realism) Nominalism Kant’s anti-realism Constructivism To Augustine, numbers are ideas in the mind of God.

Menzel: Is mathematics created or uncreated? Both sides are problematic: Created: coherence freedom Uncreated: uniqueness sovereignty

Menzel’s answer: created but... Continuous creation So numbers and truths about them are - thoughts that God necessarily thinks - distinct from individual minds, superior to them - complete, immutable

Epistemology Truths of mathematics are present to all who think - neither deduced nor induced but perceived. Not perceived by bodily senses - our understanding of infinity is enough to prove that Are more foundational than bodily senses. Accessible to anyone who uses reason. How do we account for this presence?

Effectiveness “Every material object, however mean, has its number.” Augustine says things have form because they have number - take away their number and they cease to be. Math is effective because the number of things existed in the mind of God at creation and because we are created in the image of God.

Questions this opens up If we ground number in God’s thoughts, do we ground logic there also? Menzel’s continuous creation only solves half the freedom problem. What about more sophisticated mathematical structures such as groups or fields? Do we want to ground these in God’s nature also?

More questions Is all mathematics discovery of God’s thoughts? Is there room for human creativity in this approach? Augustine wants the structure of mathematics to precede creation. He also wants time created “In the beginning…”. He recognizes that “before time” is self-contradictory. Thus he says that mathematics precedes creation in a causative sense but not in a temporal sense. What does causation mean apart from time?

One more Should Calvin merge the mathematics and religion departments?

2 Timothy 2:13: “If we are faithless, he will remain faithful, for he cannot disown himself.”

Aside Faith, Reason and the university: memories and reflections Benedict XVI at the University of Regensburg, September 12, 2006 “Is the conviction that acting unreasonably contradicts God’s nature merely a Greek idea, or is it always and inextricably true?”