Inelastic Scattering: Neutrons vs X-rays Stephen Shapiro Condensed Matter Physics/Materials Science February 7,2008
Topics and Outline Discussing collective modes of crystalline solids PHONONS: Not liquids, polymers, soft matter, magnetism Comparing neutrons and x-rays Instrumentation Phonon Dispersion Curves Phase transitions Phonon Linewidths Future Experiments
Neutrons X-rays Massive Slow Magnetic moment Interacts with nucleus E (meV) = 2.07 k 2 k=2 / e.g. =1Å k=6.28Å -1 E = 81.7 meV Mass less Very fast No magnetic moment Interacts with electrons E (keV) = 1.97 k E = 12.4 keV
Inelastic NeutronsX-rays +’s-’s Low energyRad. Source Bulk penetrationWeak source Mag. MomentWeak Interaction Isotope sub.Need lge. sample Put int. on abs. basis Resolution well known Versatility of Inst. Many instruments +’s-’s Very intense Interact with e - Small beam size Little penetration Large k i Need high res. Weak mag. Int. Few instruments
Similarities Measure the same thing: Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem Energy Conservation: Momentum Conservation:
Inelastic Instrument The same principle: Triple axis (also,neutron time-of-flight, neutron spin echo) Developed by B. Brockhouse in 50’s: 1994 Nobel Prize Source Monochromator 2M2M 2S2S 2A2A Sample Analyzer k i, E i k f, E f
Inelastic Instruments Consider phonons: meV 1 meV = 8.07 cm -1 = 0.24 THz Neutrons: E i ~10 meV E/E i ~ X-rays: Ei~10 keV E/E i ~ How to achieve?? M,A ~ 45 M,A ~ 90
ID16 - ESRF BT7 - NIST NeutronX-Ray
Number of Inelastic Instruments with meV resolutions Neutrons US - NIST5 - HFIR 4 - SNS 6 - LANSCE 1 EUROPE - ILL16 - FRMII5 - LLB7 - PSI 4 - ISIS9 ASIA - ……. X-rays US - APS2 Europe - ESRF2 ASIA - SPRING-81
Experiments Phonon dispersion curve anomalies Phase transitions Phonon linewidths
Electron Phonon Coupling B. M. Powell, P. Martel, A.D.B. Woods, Phys. Rev 171, 727 (1968 ) Nb: Sample size: 5 cm 3
- FCC Pu-Ga J. Wong et al., Phys Rev. B72, (2005) ESRF ID28 Sample Size: Large Grain [30 x 60] x10 m 3
Structural Phase Transitions SrTiO 3 Au x Zn 1-x Martensite Transition 65K x=.5 x=??
High T c Superconductors IXS: Fukuda et al. PR B 71, , (2005) INS: Reznik et al., Nature,440, 1170 (2006)
Line-width Measurements Superconductors: Nb Shapiro, Shirane, Axe, PR B 12, 4899 (1975)
Neutron Spin Echo Habicht et al. PRB 69, (2004)
Linewidth Measurements: Neutron Spin Echo TRISP FRMII, Munich Aynajian, Keller, Boeri, Shapiro, Habicht, Keimerr Science, to be published (2008)
Phonons in Thermoelectrics Power generating devices Figure of merit Reduce Reduce phonon lifetime Measure by linewidths in single crystals AgPb m SbTe 2+m AgSbTe 2 - PbTe m LAST - m m=18 spectrum
Needs of < 1.0 meV Resolution in Phonon Measurements Phonon Anomalies in dispersion curves Phonon - ‘x’ interactions Small q measurements Discriminate from Bragg peak Eliminate tails Phase Transitions Soft modes Phonon Linewidths Superconductors Thermoelectrics Lattice dynamics of thin films
My Summary Neutrons historically has been the method of choice in measuring phonon behavior throughout Brillouin Zone X-rays should replace neutrons Intensity Beam size Never for magnetic excitations Need more IXS instruments