The origin of E+A galaxies

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Star formation histories and environment Bianca M. Poggianti INAF – Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova WE ARE ALL AFTER THE BIG PICTURE: 1)To what extent,
Advertisements

MAHALO-Subaru collaboration
Subaru UM 2009/01/15 1 Extended ionized gas regions around the Coma cluster galaxies Michitoshi YOSHIDA Okayama Astrophysical Observatory, NAOJ with Masafumi.
The Environments of E+A galaxies in the local universe (further clues from the 2dFGRS) Environments of Galaxies Meeting: Chania, Crete, Aug 2004 Warrick.
207th AAS Meeting Washington D.C., 8-13 January The Spitzer SWIRE Legacy Program Spitzer Wide-Area Infrared Extragalactic Survey Mari Polletta (UCSD)
An Evolutionary Connection between AGNs and GALEX UV-excess Early-type Galaxies Hyun-Jin Bae*, Kiyun Yun, Yumi Choi, and Suk-Jin Yoon Department of Astronomy.
JWST Science 4-chart version follows. End of the dark ages: first light and reionization What are the first galaxies? When did reionization occur? –Once.
ASKAP Continuum Surveys of Local Galaxies Michael Brown ARC Future Fellow Monash University.
RESULTS AND ANALYSIS Mass determination Kauffmann et al. determined masses using SDSS spectra (Hdelta & D4000) Comparison with our determination: Relative.
Multivariate Properties of Galaxies at Low Redshift.
Star formation at high redshift (2 < z < 7) Methods for deriving star formation rates UV continuum = ionizing photons (dust obscuration?) Ly  = ionizing.
THE MODERATELY LARGE SCALE STRUCTURE OF QUASARS
SFR and COSMOS Bahram Mobasher + the COSMOS Team.
The Evolution of Galaxy Morphologies in Clusters “ New Views of the Universe” KICP, U. Chicago, December 2005 Marc Postman & collaborators: Marc Postman.
Hubble Space Telescope Images of Post-Starburst Quasars Michael S. Brotherton, S. Cales, R. Ganguly, Z. Shang (University of Wyoming) G. Canalizo (University.
Discovery of Galaxy Clusters Around Redshift 1 Deborah Haarsma, Calvin GLCW, June 1, 2007.
Spectroscopic Indicators of Galaxy Evolution: Early-type Galaxies in Cl at z~0.4 Sean Moran Ge/Ay 132.
Dusty star formation at high redshift Chris Willott, HIA/NRC 1. Introductory cosmology 2. Obscured galaxy formation: the view with current facilities,
Venice – March 2006 Discovery of an Extremely Massive and Evolved Galaxy at z ~ 6.5 B. Mobasher (STScI)
Galaxy properties in different environments: Observations Michael Balogh University of Waterloo, Canada (Look for 3 new job postings on AAS soon)
Jerusalem 2004 Hans-Walter Rix - MPIA The Evolution of the High-z Galaxy Populations.
Molecular absorption in Cen A on VLBI scales Huib Jan van Langevelde, JIVE Ylva Pihlström, NRAO Tony Beasley, CARMA.
 Galaxies with extremely violent energy release in their nuclei  Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN)  Up to many thousand times more luminous than the entire.
Astrophysics from Space Lecture 8: Dusty starburst galaxies Prof. Dr. M. Baes (UGent) Prof. Dr. C. Waelkens (KUL) Academic year
Star Clusters and their stars Open clusters and globular clusters General characteristics of globular clusters Globular cluster stars in the H-R diagram.
The Evolution of Quasars and Massive Black Holes “Quasar Hosts and the Black Hole-Spheroid Connection”: Dunlop 2004 “The Evolution of Quasars”: Osmer 2004.
Richard Mushotzky (NASA/GSFC) and Amalia K. Hicks (University of Colorado) An enduring enigma in X-ray astronomy is the "missing mass" in cooling flow.
Galaxies (And a bit about distances). This image shows galaxy M 100 in which the Hubble Space Telescope detected Cepheid variables.
Understanding formation of galaxies from their environments Yipeng Jing Shanghai Astronomical Observatory.
The Evolution of Galaxy Morphologies in Clusters “ Distant Clusters of Galaxies” Ringberg, October 2005 Marc Postman with lots of help from: Marc Postman.
Galactic Astronomy 銀河物理学特論 I Lecture 1-5: Dependence of Galaxy Properties on Environment Seminar: Park et al. 2007, ApJ, 658, 898 Lecture: 2011/11/07.
A study of a ULIRG-to-QSO transition object: possibly another gas-rich/gas-poor merger and a serendipitous line detection Manuel Aravena, Jeff Wagg, Padelis.
The Environmental Effect on the UV Color-Magnitude Relation of Early-type Galaxies Hwihyun Kim Journal Club 10/24/2008 Schawinski et al. 2007, ApJS 173,
Starbursts in clusters of galaxies When starbursts meet clusters of galaxies… La Thuile, March 2005Rencontres de Moriond, “When UV meets IR” Pierre-Alain.
1 The mid-infrared view of red-sequence galaxies Jongwan Ko Yonsei Univ. Observatory/KASI Feb. 28, 2012 The Second AKARI Conference: Legacy of AKARI: A.
The Local Universe A CCAT perspective Christine Wilson McMaster University, Canada 7 January 20131AAS 221 – Long Beach, CA.
Gas stripping and its Effect on the Stellar Populations of Virgo Cluster Galaxies Hugh H. Crowl UMass with Jeff Kenney (Yale)‏ Jacqueline van Gorkom (Columbia),
Naoyuki Tamura (University of Durham) The Universe at Redshifts from 1 to 2 for Early-Type Galaxies ~ Unveiling “Build-up Era” with FMOS ~
A wide field multi-wavelength survey of two clusters at z~0.5 Tommaso Treu (UCSB)
Galaxies with Active Nuclei Chapter 14:. Active Galaxies Galaxies with extremely violent energy release in their nuclei (pl. of nucleus).  “active galactic.
Major dry-merger rate and extremely massive major dry-mergers of BCGs Deng Zugan June 31st Taiwan.
Active Galaxies and Supermassive Black Holes Chapter 17.
Submm galaxies and EROs: Expectations for FMOS in the light of OHS observations Chris Simpson (University of Durham)
The Star Formation- Density Relation …and the Cluster Abell 901/2 in COMBO-17 Christian Wolf (Oxford) Eric Bell, Anna Gallazzi, Klaus Meisenheimer (MPIA.
AGN Demographics Christine Black 3/1/12
Multiwavelength Properties of the SDSS Galaxies in Various Classes Feb 19, 2008 Joon Hyeop Lee 1, Myung Gyoon Lee 1, Changbom Park 2, Yun-Young Choi 2.
Evidence for a Population of Massive Evolved Galaxies at z > 6.5 Bahram Mobasher M.Dickinson NOAO H. Ferguson STScI M. Giavalisco, M. Stiavelli STScI Alvio.
Red-Sequence Galaxies with young stars and dust The cluster A901/902 seen with COMBO-17 Christian Wolf (Oxford) Meghan E. Gray (Nottingham) Klaus Meisenheimer.
Modes of Star Formation along the Hubble Sequence … and beyond Richard de Grijs University of Sheffield, UK Terschelling, 7 July 2005.
Panoramic Imaging and Spectroscopy of Cluster Evolution with Subaru (PISCES) FMOS meeting (Kyoto, 13-14/01/04) PI: Taddy Kodama (NAOJ) Arimoto, Futamase,
AGN / Starbursts in the very dusty systems in Bootes Kate Brand + the Bootes team NOAO Lijiang, August 2005.
KASI Galaxy Evolution Journal Club A Massive Protocluster of Galaxies at a Redshift of z ~ P. L. Capak et al. 2011, Nature, in press (arXive: )
Competitive Science with the WHT for Nearby Unresolved Galaxies Reynier Peletier Kapteyn Astronomical Institute Groningen.
Chapter 25 Galaxies and Dark Matter. 25.1Dark Matter in the Universe 25.2Galaxy Collisions 25.3Galaxy Formation and Evolution 25.4Black Holes in Galaxies.
High Redshift Galaxies/Galaxy Surveys ALMA Community Day April 18, 2011 Neal A. Miller University of Maryland.
9 Gyr of massive galaxy evolution Bell (MPIA), Wolf (Oxford), Papovich (Arizona), McIntosh (UMass), and the COMBO-17, GEMS and MIPS teams Baltimore 27.
Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) is a NASA infrared- wavelength astronomical space telescope launched on December 14, 2009 It’s an Earth-orbiting.
[OII] Lisa Kewley Australian National University.
GRB A: A short GRB associated with recent star-formation?
A Survey of Starburst Galaxies An effort to help understand the starburst phenomenon and its importance to galaxy evolution Megan Sosey & Duilia deMello.
Merging Galaxy Cluster Abell 2255 in Mid-Infrared
Mike Brotherton: HST Images of Post-Starburst Quasars
Hugh H. Crowl UMass with Jeff Kenney (Yale)
The Starburst-AGN Connection Among COSMOS (U)LIRGs
Star Clusters and their stars
The dust attenuation in the galaxy merger Mrk848
Rubén Sánchez-Janssen (IAC) J.Alfonso L. Aguerri Casiana Muñoz-Tuñón
Galaxies With Active Nuclei
Galaxies With Active Nuclei
Presentation transcript:

The origin of E+A galaxies Elliptical’s line features + A star feature. (Metal lines, Ca, Fe, Mg like K stars) Balmer=> recent SB no emission => non ongoing SF POST STAR BURST galaxies Tomo Goto Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency Tomo Goto

January In Japan In Chile

The origin of E+A galaxies Strong Balmer absorption No [OII], no Hα Post-starburst A star + absorption lines E+A galaxies K+A galaxies Elliptical’s line features + A star feature. (Metal lines, Ca, Fe, Mg like K stars) Balmer=> recent SB no emission => non ongoing SF POST STAR BURST galaxies Tomo Goto Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency Tomo Goto

Two puzzles on E+A(post-starburst) What caused star burst? What stopped it? Cluster related. Found to live in cluster region (MORPHS, Dressler & Gunn 83) Dust enshrouded star formation.(Poggianti et al. 1999; Smail et al. 1999) Merger/Interaction (Zabludoff et al 1996)   Still puzzles Very rare(21/11113 in LCRS). Phase is short(1Gyr). Million spectra of SDSS provide good opportunity to address this 20-year-old puzzle. Galaxy evolution in action. Tomo Goto

color Morphological Butcher-Oemler effect in CE (Goto, et al. 2003, PASJ, 55,755) morphology More blue galaxies in higher redshift The Morphological BO Effect Tomo Goto

Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) SDSS will produce Imaging of 10,000 sq.deg r~23.1 In 5 optical bands (ugriz) Spectra of and in 5 years Using 2.5m telescope at APO. Tomo Goto

Tomo Goto

Tomo Goto

Evolution is difficult to observe. Elliptical Galaxy@z=0 Important Transition Stage popIII galaxy@z=10 ? Spiral galaxy@z=0 It is important to observe galaxy evolution in action.=> E+As Tomo Goto

Not much information on past SFH Truncation of SF: galaxy evolution in action Tomo Goto

The largest catalog of 564 E+As out of 650,000 galaxies. How to find E+As Goto, T. et al. 2003,  PASJ, 55, 771 Goto, T. 2005, MNRAS, 357, 937 HδEW>4Å (2.42%) 4 categories. E+A: Hα<1σ, [OII]<1σ, No emission lines. (0.04%) HDS+[OII]: Hα<1σ, [OII]≧1σ (0.09%) HDS+Hα: Hα≧1σ, [OII]<1σ (0.04%) HDS+em: Hα≧1σ, [OII]≧1σ, Significant emission lines. (2.25%) (~2σ) (~2σ) (~2σ) (~4σ) (540/21679) (26/21679 7 with 2MASS) (137/21679 12 with 2MASS) The largest catalog of 564 E+As out of 650,000 galaxies. Tomo Goto

E+A Spectra Tomo Goto

E+A Atlas Images Tomo Goto Images suggests variety of colors, luminosities & morphologies. I will quantify these. Tomo Goto

HDS+em Spectra Tomo Goto

HDS+em Sample Atlas Images Also suggests variety of colors, luminosity, morphology. suggests difference from true E+A. Tomo Goto

HDS+Hα Spectra [OII] has been used as SF indicator. mention High-z study used [OII] [OII] has been used as SF indicator. Could be dust? Metallicity effect?  Possible 52% contamination in high-z work Tomo Goto

HDS+Hα Atlas Images Tomo Goto

HDS+[OII] Spectra Could be self-absorption? HI gas cloud? Tomo Goto Possible cause Ha self absorption. Could be self-absorption? HI gas cloud? Tomo Goto

HDS+[OII] Atlas Images Tomo Goto

Three Scenarios for E+A Cluster Related (ram pressure, tidal interaction with cluster potential, …etc; Dressler et al. 1999; Poggianti et al. 1999) Dusty Starburst (2/15 of E+As have radio SF; Miller et al. 2002; Smail et al. 1997;) Interaction/Merger (tidal features in 5/21 E+As in Zabludoff et al. 1996) Tomo Goto

E+A E+A is K+A “E+A” is sometime called “K+A” because of its disk-like morphology. However,… Previous sample might be contaminated by HDS+Hα Tomo Goto

Environment of E+A Galaxies Goto, T. 2005, MNRAS, 357, 937 Not by cluster, not by large-scale structure Tomo Goto

Three Scenarios for E+A Cluster related (ram pressure, tidal interaction, merging…etc; Dressler et al. 1999; Poggianti et al. 1999) Dusty Starburst (2/15 of E+As have radio SF; Miller et al. 2002; Smail et al. 1997;) Interaction/Merger (tidal features in 5/21 E+As in Zabludoff et al. 1996) Tomo Goto

Optical-Infrared color: r-K E+As are not dustier. (c.f., 5 dusty starbursts in Smail et al. are ~1mag redder.) Tomo Goto

Radio Estimated SFR No evidence that E+As are not dusty starbursts. Goto, T. 2004, A&A, 427, 125 No evidence that E+As are not dusty starbursts. Tomo Goto

Three Scenarios for E+A Cluster related (ram pressure, tidal interaction, merging…etc; Dressler et al. 1999; Poggianti et al. 1999) Dusty Starburst (2/15 of E+As have radio SF; Miller et al. 2002; Smail et al. 1997;) Interaction/Merger (tidal features in 5/21 E+As in Zabludoff et al. 1996) Tomo Goto

Hδ_EW vs Time Tomo Goto

u-g vs HδEW (current SF vs recent SF) Young E+As: closer to burst (130-470 Myrs) Tomo Goto

Young E+A Spectra (HδEW>7Å) Tomo Goto

Atlas Image of Young E+As Tomo Goto

Naccompanying galaxies More accompanying galaxies for young E+As at <100kpc scale. Goto, T. 2005, MNRAS, 357, 937 Tomo Goto

Three Scenarios for E+A Cluster related (ram pressure, tidal interaction, merging…etc; Dressler et al. 1999; Poggianti et al. 1999) Dusty Starburst (2/15 of E+As have radio SF; Miller et al. 2002; Smail et al. 1997;) Interaction/Merger (tidal features in 5/21 E+As in Zabludoff et al. 1996) Tomo Goto

178 Ultra Luminous Infrared Galaxy (ULIRG) 1012Lsun< Lir<1013Lsun Largest Sample of ULIRG before ASTROF Goto, T. 2005, MNRAS, 360, 322 Tomo Goto

Not every meger is E+A. Goto, T. 2005, MNRAS, 360, 322 Tomo Goto

Color gradient of E+As : (Yamauchi & Goto 2005,MNRAS,359,1557) Bluer core in >60% of local E+As Tomo Goto

Correlation between color-gradient and D4000: possible merger time clock. (Yamauchi & Goto 2005,MNRAS,359,1557) Tomo Goto

Spatially resolved spectroscopy (Yagi & Goto 2006,ApJ,642,152, 2006AJ Tomo Goto

Spatially resolved spectroscopy (Yagi & Goto 2006,ApJ,642,152, 2006AJ APO3.5m telescope x0.89kpc/pix x0.39kpc/pix Poststarburst is centered at the core, but spatially extended. -> rather a merger product than a truncated spiral arm. x0.72kpc/pix Tomo Goto

Possible longer/delayed truncation at the center. Time sequence of truncation (Yagi & Goto 2006,ApJ,642,152, 2006AJ....131.2050) Possible longer/delayed truncation at the center. Tomo Goto

color Morphological Butcher-Oemler effect in CE (Goto, et al. 2003, PASJ, 55,755) morphology More blue galaxies in higher redshift The Morphological BO Effect Tomo Goto

Passive Spiral Galaxies in the SDSS (Goto et al. 2003,PASJ,55,757) Spiral but no star formation. What are these? Tomo Goto

Optical-IR color --- not dustier   Close this Window Yamauchi, Chisato & Goto, Tomotsugu Are passive spiral galaxies truly 'passive' and 'spiral'? A near-infrared perspective. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society  352 (3), 815-822. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2004.07966.x Optical-IR color --- not dustier PS do not look like dusty star forming galaxies. Yamauchi & Goto 2004 MNRAS, 352, 815 Tomo Goto

The Environment of Passive Spirals (Goto et al. 2003,PASJ,55,757) Passive spirals may be a smoking gun in cluster galaxy evolution. Tomo Goto

Morphology Radius Relation (Goto et al. 2003, MNRAS, 346, 601,) SFR :Gomez et al. 2003 Tomo Goto

Hdelta-strong AGNs: AGNs outlive starburst in the starburst-AGN connection? (Goto 2006, MNRAS,369,1765 ) Tomo Goto

Hδstrong-AGNs Poststarburst & AGN are spatially correlated, suggesting underlying physical connection. The existence of poststarburst-AGN suggests that AGNs outlive starburst. Hdelta/D4000 can possibly used as a time clock to understand the AGN lifecycle. Tomo Goto

The Origin of E+As E+As are not cluster/LSS origin. E+As are in all environment including the field. E+As are not cluster/LSS origin. Optical-IR color is not redder; radio SFR<10Msun/yr. E+As are not likely to be Dusty Starburst. Excess in Naccompanying galaxies . Merger/interaction is most likely to be responsible for the E+As. Consistent with E morphology. Tomo Goto