The White Dwarf Age of NGC 2477 Elizabeth Jeffery Space Telescope Science Institute Collaborators: Ted von Hippel, Steven DeGennaro, David van Dyk, Nathan.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Comparing RAVE with theoretical models of the Milky Way Sanjib Sharma Joss Bland Hawthorn University of Sydney.
Advertisements

Chronicling the Histories of Galaxies at Distances of 1 to 20 Mpc: Simulated Performance of 20-m, 30-m, 50-m, and 100-m Telescopes Knut Olsen, Brent Ellerbroek,
18 July Monte Carlo Markov Chain Parameter Estimation in Semi-Analytic Models Bruno Henriques Peter Thomas Sussex Survey Science Centre.
Open Clusters: At The Interface of Stellar Evolution and Stellar Dynamics Robert D. Mathieu University of Wisconsin - Madison.
X-ray Astrostatistics Bayesian Methods in Data Analysis Aneta Siemiginowska Vinay Kashyap and CHASC Jeremy Drake, Nov.2005.
Chemical Cartography with SDSS/APOGEE Michael Hayden (NMSU), Jo Bovy (IAS), Steve Majewski (UVa), Jennifer Johnson (OSU), Gail Zasowski (JHU), Leo Girardi.
Variable Stars of Globular Clusters in the Large Magellanic Cloud Evan McClellan (FSU) Horace Smith (advisor) (MSU) Charles Kuehn (MSU) August 6 th, 2008.
The Physics of Crystallization in a Dense Coulomb Plasma from Globular Cluster White Dwarf Stars Don Winget Department of Astronomy and McDonald Observatory.
Constraints and Measurements of the Equation of State from the White Dwarf Stars Don Winget Department of Astronomy and McDonald Observatory University.
1 Low luminosity observations: a test for the Galactic models Degl’Innocenti S. 1, Cignoni M. 1, Castellani V. 2, Petroni S. 1, Prada Moroni P.G. 1 1 Physics.
Formation of Globular Clusters in  CDM Cosmology Oleg Gnedin (University of Michigan)
Improving mass and age estimates of unresolved stellar clusters Margaret Hanson & Bogdan Popescu Department of Physics.
Deep Multi-Color Imaging in 47 Tuc: Some Early Results 2MASS ALL SKY IMAGE Disk Bulge Magellanic Clouds 47 Tuc Halo H. Richer (UBC)
Markov-Chain Monte Carlo
The Distance Scale Ladder A Nested Chain of Cumulative Uncertainty.
Bayesian statistics – MCMC techniques
Probing the evolution of stellar systems Andreas Zezas Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
Constraining Astronomical Populations with Truncated Data Sets Brandon C. Kelly (CfA, Hubble Fellow, 6/11/2015Brandon C. Kelly,
Variable Stars:Pulsation, Evolution and applications to cosmology Shashi M. Kanbur SUNY Oswego June 2007.
Making a Color-Magnitude Diagram for Globular Cluster Omega Centauri Jay Anderson, STScI 1.
 a & Broadband photometry of open clusters Martin Netopil Institute of Astronomy, University of Vienna - Austria AIPW Dubrovnik.
GIANT TO DWARF RATIO OF RED-SEQUENCE GALAXY CLUSTERS Abhishesh N Adhikari Mentor-Jim Annis Fermilab IPM / SDSS August 8, 2007.
A New Technique to Measure ΔY/ΔZ A. A. R. Valcarce (UFRN) Main collaborators: J. R. de Medeiros (UFRN)M. Catelan (PUC) XXXVII SAB meeting Águas de Lindóia,
Globular Clusters: HST Breathes New Life into Old Fossils STScI Public Lecture Series Jay Anderson August 3, 2010.
The Effect of Crowding on the GSMT Stellar Populations Science Case Knut Olsen, Bob Blum (NOAO), François Rigaut (Gemini) GSMT SWG Presentation Hilo 2002.
The Metal-Poor Halo of the Andromeda Spiral Galaxy Jason Kalirai (University of California at Santa Cruz) Hubble Fellows Symposium, Baltimore MD April.
Galactic Helium-to-Metals enrichment ratio from the analysis of local main sequence stars observed by HIPPARCOS 52° Congresso SAIt – Teramo 2008 * Università.
Globular Clusters: HST Breathes New Life into Old Fossils Hubble Science Briefing Jay Anderson STScI June 3,
Red Clump Distance Measurements Andrew Lipnicky Astronomy Observational Techniques and Instrumentation May 9, 2013.
Jason Kalirai (STScI) Diamonds in the Rough: The Oldest Stars in the Galaxy Space Telescope Science Institute: Hubble Science BriefingsJune 11 th, 2009.
Top Five Lessons Learned from the Colliding Antennae Galaxies Brad Whitmore December 1, 2011 Hubble Science Briefing Space Telescope Science Institute.
White Dwarf Binaries in Globular Clusters Fred Rasio (Northwestern)
A Photometric Study of Unstudied Open Clusters Berkeley 49 & 84 in the SDSS Jinhyuk Ryu and Myung Gyoon Lee Department of Physics & Astronomy, Seoul National.
Sang-Yoon Lee. Achievements “BVR Photometry of Supergiant Stars in Holmberg II”, Journal of Astronomy and Space Sciences, Vol. 23, no. 1, p. 1-10, 03/2006.
Comprehensive Stellar Population Models and the Disentanglement of Age and Metallicity Effects Guy Worthey 1994, ApJS, 95, 107.
Data Reduction with NIRI Knut Olsen and Andrew Stephens Gemini Data Workshop Tucson, AZ July 21, 2010 Knut Olsen and Andrew Stephens Gemini Data Workshop.
Revised GALEX Ultraviolet Catalog of Globular Clusters in M31 Kyungsook Lee (1), Soo-Chang Rey (1), Sangmo Tony Sohn (2), and GALEX Science Team (1) Department.
New and Odds on Globular Cluster Stellar Populations: an Observational Point of View (The Snapshot Database) G.Piotto, I. King, S. Djorgovski and G. Bono,
The IMF of the Orion Nebula Cluster Across the H-burning Limit Nicola Da Rio HST Orion Treasury Science Meeting STScI, Baltimore, September 12 th 13 th.
The Large-Scale Disk Structure of the LMC As Measured by the OUTER LIMITS SURVEY Olszewski, Saha, Smith, Olsen, Harris, Rest, Knezek, Brondel, Seitzer,
25 Years of Globular Clusters with HST
Ay 123 Lecture I - Physical Properties 10  as = 10% 10  as/yr = ESA Gaia mission: a revolution in 3-D mapping of our Galaxy.
The Giant Branches – Leiden 14/05/09 The Initial-Final Mass Relation Aldo Serenelli – MPA Salaris, Serenelli, Weiss & Miller Bertolami (2009)
MCMC reconstruction of the 2 HE cascade events Dmitry Chirkin, UW Madison.
June 16 th, 2011 Very Wide Field Surveys - STScI Panchromatic Studies of Galactic Stellar Populations Jason Kalirai (STScI) Outline - The role that Galactic.
CHARA Collaboration Year-Five Science Review Dynamite Diameters Tabetha Boyajian GSU/CHARA Presented by Hal McAlister.
Lecture 18 Stellar populations. Stellar clusters Open clusters: contain stars loose structure Globular clusters: million stars centrally.
HR diagram of 20,853 stars with distances and colors measured by Hipparcos (borrowed from Catherine Turon’s web site). Brighter Redder.
H-R diagrams for star clusters. H-R Diagram Relation between luminosity L, temperature T and radius R: L = 4  R 2  T 4.
Globular Clusters. A globular cluster is an almost spherical conglomeration of 100,000 to 1,000,000 stars of different masses that have practically.
The Photometric Properties of NGC 6134 and Hogg 19 SDSS u’g’r’i’z’ Open Cluster Survey: Credit: Credit: SMARTS consortium.
Metallicity and age of selected nearby G-K Giants L. Pasquini (ESO) M. Doellinger (ESO-LMU) J. Setiawan (MPIA) A. Hatzes (TLS), A. Weiss (MPA), O. von.
June 5, 2006 AAS/Calgary Stellar Populations: Old Stars in the Nearest E Galaxy From Field Stars to Globular Clusters.
Dynamite Diameters Observations of main sequence stars with long baseline optical/infrared interferometry Tabetha Boyajian (Georgia State University /
Miguel CerviñoESAC 23 March 2007 How to use the SEDs produced by synthesis models? Miguel Cerviño (IAA-CSIC/SVO) Valentina Luridiana (IAA-CSIC/SVO)
Age and distance for the unstudied open cluster Teutsch 7 In Sung Jang and Myung Gyoon Lee Department of Physics & Astronomy, Seoul National University.
BATC Multi-color Photometry of Open Cluster M48 Zhenyu Wu 8.11, 2005, Weifang.
HOLMBERG IX: THE NEAREST YOUNG GALAXY E. Sabbi, J.S. Gallagher, L.J. Smith, D.F. de Mello, & M. Mountain Deep images taken with the Wide Field Channel.
White Dwarfs and the Age of the Galaxy Kurtis A. Williams & Prof. James Liebert.
Galaxy formation and evolution with a GSMT: The z=0 fossil record 17 March, 2003.
Before it was seen, it was heard. Brainstorming. Star Clusters Chang, Seo-Won.
Pete Kuzma PhD student, Research School of Astronomy and Astrophysics
Modern cosmology 1: The Hubble Constant
Sang-Yoon Lee.
Dong-Hwan Cho1, 2, Hyun-Il Sung2, Sang-Gak Lee3, and Tae Seog Yoon1
Modern cosmology 1: The Hubble Constant
GPI Astrometric Calibration
Multidimensional Integration Part I
Yalchin Efendiev Texas A&M University
Presentation transcript:

The White Dwarf Age of NGC 2477 Elizabeth Jeffery Space Telescope Science Institute Collaborators: Ted von Hippel, Steven DeGennaro, David van Dyk, Nathan Steinn, W.H. Jefferys, D.E. Winget, Kurtis Williams White Dwarf European Workshop Tübingen, Germany August 17, 2010 A Bayesian Approach to Measuring Cluster Ages

Talk Outline Stellar Ages : Main Sequence and White Dwarf Ages  Calibration using open clusters Clusters for study Hubble Space Telescope data  WD ages New Bayesian technique  analysis of clusters

Ages of Stellar Populations The Question of When Fundamental property in astronomy Two main ways: Main Sequence Isochrones vs. the White Dwarf Luminosity Function Winget, et al vs. Alcaino et al. 1998

Comparing Ages in Open Star Clusters Why do both? Calibrate MSTO and WD ages Why not use white dwarfs in halo globular clusters? More difficult to observe (3 to date) Gradually increase calibration; thoroughly understand physics WDs provide independent check of MS models, and vice versa increase understanding of both MS models have uncertainties up to 20% between models. WD models have uncertainties up to 5% – 20%

Observing Cluster White Dwarfs Cluster white dwarfs are FAINT, requiring large or space-based telescopes (Hubble) This is expensive This is time consuming … but it’s possible! …

Relationship between a WD’s luminosity and cooling time (i.e., age) Location of the terminus of the cluster WD sequence is determined by the age Open Clusters Ages White Dwarf Techniques Simulated Cluster, 3 Gyr 0.5 Mo 0.8 Mo MvMv

Current Agreement von Hippel 2005 NGC 3960NGC 2660NGC 2360 NGC 188* * see Poster 72 by Williams, Jeffery, & For

Talk Outline Stellar Ages : Main Sequence and White Dwarf Ages  Calibration using open clusters Clusters for study Hubble Space Telescope data  WD ages New Bayesian technique  analysis of clusters

Data – The Observations HST, ACS and WFPC2: Deep observations of the white dwarfs CTIO 1m/Y4kCam CCD : Observations of cluster turn off, giants, and upper main sequence

Data – The Observations Field of View Comparison – NGC 2477 (WFPC2)

Data – Deep Color-Magnitude Diagrams NGC 2477NGC 2360NGC 2660 NGC 3960NGC 188 Things to Note: (1)Data go deep (2)Cluster Main Sequence (3)Many field stars / background galaxies

Data – Deep Color-Magnitude Diagrams CMD Features: (1)Cluster Main Sequence NGC CMD Features: (1)Cluster Main Sequence (2)Background population (3)Background galaxies (4)White Dwarfs CMD Features: (1)Cluster Main Sequence (2)Background population (3)Background galaxies (4)White Dwarfs CMD Features: (1)Cluster Main Sequence (2)Background population (3)Background galaxies (4)White Dwarfs

Data – Deep Color-Magnitude Diagrams NGC 2477

Fitting White Dwarf Isochrones NGC Gyr 1.5 Gyr 1.0 Gyr

Talk Outline Stellar Ages : Main Sequence and White Dwarf Ages  Calibration using open clusters Clusters for study Hubble Space Telescope data  WD ages New Bayesian technique  analysis of clusters

New Machinery Using Bayesian Statistics Bayesian Statistics – Bayes Theorem: Posterior α Likelihood * Prior Use Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) technique to numerically sample posterior probability distributions Simultaneously fit age, distance, reddening, and metallicity by modeling photometry. Run with different models: DSED, Y 2, Girardi von Hippel, T., et al. 2006, ApJ, 645, 1436 Jeffery, E. et al. 2007, ApJ, 658, 391 DeGennaro S. et al. 2009, ApJ, 696, 12

Data – Deep Color-Magnitude Diagrams NGC 2477

Applying MCMC NGC 2477 Posterior Distributions DSED (Dotter et al. 2008) Y 2 (Yi et al. 2001) Girardi et al. (2000)

Applying MCMC NGC 2477 DSED (Dotter et al. 2008) Y2 (Yi et al. 2001) Girardi et al. (2000) WD Age (Gyr) : ± ± Weighted Average (“Answer”) Error among models (“external”) Error within models (“internal”) MSTO Age = 1.0 Gyr (Kassis et al. 1997)

Applying MCMC NGC 2477 DSED (Dotter et al. 2008) Y2 (Yi et al. 2001) Girardi et al. (2000) WD Age (Gyr) : ± ± 0.087

Further Power of the Technique Comparing complete distributions NGC 2360 MS Fit WD Fit

A Calibration of the Ages Where we are now

Concluding Remarks Open clusters provide ideal environment for calibration of MS ages and WD ages, testing theory against theory Analysis of six clusters New Bayesian Algorithm High precision fits allows us to pin down problems in the models Compare distributions – not just single numbers Incorporate different combinations of model ingredients, pushing the models to their limits Good agreement found for clusters included here

Improving Error Bars NGC 2420 von Hippel & Gilmore /- 0.2 Gyr

Applying MCMC NGC 2420

Applying MCMC The Example of NGC 2420

1.83 +/ Gyr

Applying MCMC The Example of NGC 2420 – MSTO

What does the best fit demonstrate? DSED vs. Y 2 isochrones Age (Gyr)1.53 +/ / [Fe/H] / / Which is right?  Compare age with the White Dwarfs White dwarf age is / Gyr. Age (Gyr)1.53 +/ / [Fe/H] / / Discrepancy in age is likely caused by inadequate incorporation of metallicity in the models.

Ages from the Bright Cluster WDs Rationale of the Idea

A Test Case for the Bright White Dwarf Idea The Hyades White Dwarfs DeGennaro S. von Hippel, T., Jefferys, W.H., Stein, N., van Dyk, D., & Jeffery, E., 2008, in prep

Data – Color-Magnitude Diagrams NGC 2360NGC 2477NGC 2660 NGC 3960NGC 2420 NGC 188

Data – Deep Color-Magnitude Diagrams Things to Note: (1)Data go deep (2)Cluster Main Sequence (3)Many field stars / background galaxies NGC 2477

Data – Deep Color-Magnitude Diagrams Things to Note: (1)Data go deep (2)Cluster Main Sequence (3)Many field stars / background galaxies NGC 2660

Data – Deep Color-Magnitude Diagrams Things to Note: (1)Data go deep (2)Cluster Main Sequence (3)Many field stars / background galaxies NGC 188

Fitting White Dwarf Isochrones NGC 2477NGC 2360NGC 2660 NGC 3960 NGC 188