Keeping Service User Involvement in Research Honest Dr Hugh McLaughlin University of Salford

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

C4EO Support for Regional Developments Gill Taylor Regional Associate 1.

Advertisements

Every Child Matters: Change for Children Building a world-class workforce for children and young people David N Jones Children’s Services Improvement.

Leeds Metropolitan University

Collaborative Enquiry in Networked Learning Communities Jane McGregor, Darren Homes, Julie Temperley BERA School Improvement Symposium 2004.

Manchester Children and Young People’s CYP IAPT Learning Collaborative

Clinical Psychologist Counselling Psychologist

Evaluating new OH initiatives - lessons from WHC Claire Tyers Institute for Employment Studies.

SEXUALITY EDUCATION Young people say they want parents to do it Parents say they want schools to do it SO WHO DOES IT ???

Civic Action: The Role of School Boards to Advance Youth Engagement and the Civic Mission of Schools Bill Hughes, PhD, Superintendent of Schools, Greendale.

WHAT IS COLLABORATIVE RESEARCH WITH ‘SERVICE USERS’ AND OTHER ‘USER GROUPS’? Dr Jo Frankham Senior Research Fellow Centre for Education, Research and Evaluation.

You’re Welcome: raising the profile of young people and adolescent medicine Anna Gregorowski – Consultant Nurse Nigel Mills – Clinical Nurse Specialist.

Public engagement and lifelong learning: old wine in a new bottle, or a blended malt? Paul Manners Director, National Co-ordinating Centre for Public Engagement.

1 What People Really Think About Foster Care Association of Children’s Welfare Agencies Conference 4 August 2010 Knowledge and Perceptions of the Australian.

Cisco Confidential © 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. 1 Cisco WebEx University Services & Portfolio: Leading Virtual Classroom Instruction.

Introduction to Team Building Presented by Margo Elliott Momentum Performance Solutions 6 September 2001.

Tuning Occupational Therapy Structures in Europe Sandra M. Rowan Stephanie Saenger.

Merging academic and practice based learning for enhanced student employability. Transferability of a TLQIS funded project implemented at the School of.

The Rights-Respecting School Award An Introduction

CREATING OPPORTUNITIES – JOB CREATION WITH THE THIRD SECTOR LEARNING FROM COMMUNITY JOBS SCOTLAND Alex McTier 18 th September 2013.

Motivational Theories What it takes to be an effective teacher in the year 2010 and beyond.... As with learning, different theories of motivation offer.

Education and Labor Market Outcomes of Young Adults Dr. Paul Harrington Center for Labor Market Studies Northeastern University Boston, Massachusetts.

Thinking Skills 1 of 23. Why teach thinking skills? Is it really that important? Creative and critical thinking abilities are not inborn as was once believed.

Portfolio training: Case study dr. Nijolė Burkšaitienė Mykolas Romeris University.

Social work doctorates in the UK Jonathan Scourfield Cardiff School of Social Sciences, UK.

O n l y f r o m S y n e r g i s t i c s Establishing Knowledge Communities with KM Portals.

S oTL Project Wisconsin Teaching Scholars Program, Dr. David M. Jones Department of English/Women’s Studies Affiliate EDI/Honors Fellow, University.

RESPONSIBILITY, CHALLENGE AND SUPPORT IN TEACHER EDUCATORS´ LIFELONG PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT Main policy conclusions of an EC peer learning activity Marco.

User-Designer HCI Research Model for Online Communities Groupz-ware Niki Lambropoulos Interaction Design Consultant Intelligenesis Consultancy nikilambropoulos.org.

Developing critical and reflective graduates through a research-based learning project Dr. Agnieszka Rydzik and Year 3 BA International Tourism Management.

St Andrew’s Junior College

1 Dr. Ralph R. Young Director of Software Engineering PRC, Inc. (703) DOORS USER GROUP CONFERENCE Reston, VA September 17,

Peer Leadership 101: Standing on the Shoulders of Ordinary People Created by: Brian Poser, Associate Director Edited by: Mahshad Kolahdouzan, Joshua Plener,

The Social Care Commitment. White paper initiative ‘caring for our future’ Improving care, and the public’s confidence in care Developed by employers,

1 Keeping Service User Involvement in Research Honest Professor Hugh McLaughlin 10 th July 2012.

Dr Anna Tarrant School of Sociology and Social A strategy for exploring men’s care responsibilities in low-income.

The French presidency of the European Union Conclusions of the EUPF conference And the [future] LLG resolution The role of guidance actors : competences.

Involving Young Service Users as Co-Researchers in Evaluating Service Provision: Perils, Potential and Potential Issues Dr Hugh McLaughlin University.

Involving Young Service Users as Co-Researchers in Evaluating Service Provision: Perils, Potential and Limitations Dr Hugh McLaughlin University of Salford.

Service User Involvement in Research: Panacea or Pretence Dr Hugh McLaughlin University of Salford

 An ideal topic will:  be theoretically and personally interesting  be of value to your client  offer developmental opportunities  help advance your.

Open Peer Review & Collaboration - by Heather Morrison

Call | Visit Sport Future Prize Challenge Fund summary.

Lucy-Jane Attrill Communications Manager, artswork.org.uk Suzanne Lee Artistic Director, all allchangearts.org.

Human Resources Office of 1 Summary of Results College of Design Dean’s Reports.

Lisboa, 29th September 2005 Éric Sutter, ADBS Certification & Bureau van Dijk Eurocertification in I & D What is it ? How to implement it ? Organisme certificateur.

A Comprehensive Framework for Evaluating Learning Effectiveness in the Workplace Presented by Dr Cyril Kirwan.

Standard for providers’ responsibility for the authenticity and academic integrity of student work submitted for assessment Dr Reg Allen CEO Tasmanian.

OUR FOCUS FOR 2011 TO 2012 The CfWI produces quality intelligence to inform better workforce planning, that improves people’s lives.

Welcome to the Feedback Provider Briefing Behaviours 360 feedback Amanda Brown.

KTE Part B PPI Impact Momoko Sato NIHR DEC London.

Angela Kleanthous University of Cyprus May 20th, 2017

we help to improve social care standards

Introducing… the concept.

Operated by Public Health England

INTERNET LITERACY and E-SAFETY.

The Rights Respecting Schools Introduction Thorn Primary May 2016

The Impact of the Livelihoods Training Project: Findings from the Evaluation Dr Mark Wilding Reader in Social & Public Policy Associate, SHUSU University.

COMMUNICATOR Applies effective reading skills to acquire knowledge and broaden perspectives Employs active listening strategies to advance understanding.

Introduction to Lesson 2 Your personal profile – part 1

Community Pharmacists – How you can make every Opportunity Count

Kirsti Ala-Mutka & Yves Punie

Paula Jones ULF Senior Project Lead

Wellbeing Challenge Days

Unit 4 - A06 – Review Grade Criteria To get a c

Recognising professional expertise

Digital skills for employability and social inclusion

Promoting Research Collaboration with Service Users

National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization’s Palliative Care Resource Series Understanding the Importance of the Interdisciplinary Team in Pediatric.

Take Charge – early findings

Presentation transcript:

Keeping Service User Involvement in Research Honest Dr Hugh McLaughlin University of Salford

Levels of Involvement Tokenism Consultation Collaboration Service User Controlled Profile required

Claimed benefits for research Common language Identify questions overlooked, prioritizing User-friendliness of tools Range and quality of data enhanced YP raise issues with other young people they would not raise with an adult Self-esteem, confidence and employability Energy Presentation of results

Before the Research Begins Whose idea was it? Recruitment –same old suspects? Informing-for-consent Training Safeguarding Morally active researcher Over promising Reward and recognition

Issues During the Research Support needs of service users Confidentiality Researcher discomfort Identity- Service user co-researcher or co- researcher who is also a service user

Knowledge Claims Favours qualitative ‘No research about us without us’ Standpoint position Service user peers Same or different criteria of validity Experience plus research tools

Conclusions Inadequate attention Outcomes not just process Less rhetoric more critical analysis Neither underclaim nor overclaim Keep service user involvement in research honest

Final thoughts If we accept that differing types of Knowledge and expertise contribute to a full understanding, then no one has privilged ‘insider’ knowledge, but everyone has differing knowledge from which everybody can learn. Herein lies the nub of the issue. Nolan et al. 2007:190