Intensive Course in Research Writing Barbara Gastel, MD, MPH Texas A&M University Summer 2011

Intensive Course in Research Writing: Session 3 (29 June 2011)

Today Follow-up: workshop on draft abstracts Discussion: titles and authors Discussion: results sections Discussion: tables and figures Workshop: drafts of methods sections

Drafts of Abstracts What types of revisions did your classmates suggest? What other comments or questions do you have about revising your abstract? Does the paper you’ve chosen as a model have an abstract? If so, what is it like? Does looking at give you any ideas for revising your abstract?

A Few Teaching Points (based on initial review of abstracts received) In general, use an unjustified (“ragged”) right margin. (It tends to make text more readable.) Use mainly past tense to report methods and results. If acronyms are used, remember to define them. Beware of misusing semicolons. Use i.e. and e.g. carefully (or, perhaps better, avoid them). Normally, don’t begin a sentence with a numeral.

Title The fewest possible words that adequately indicate the contents of the paper Important in literature searching Shouldn’t include extra words, such as “a study of” or “Observations on” Should be specific enough Generally should not include abbreviations (Running title: short version of title—appears at tops of pages)

Five Ws and an H Who What When Where Why How

Mini-Exercise: Looking at a Title What’s the title of the paper you’re using as a model? Is it a good title? Why or why not? Does looking at this title give you any ideas about what title to give your paper?

Authors Those with important intellectual contributions to the work Often listed largely from greatest contributions to least Head of research group often is listed last In some fields, listed alphabetically Best to list one’s name the same way on every paper

Results The core of the paper Often includes tables, figures, or both Should summarize findings rather than providing data in great detail Should present results but not comment on them (unless the paper has a combined Results and Discussion section)

The Results Section: Some Writing Advice Present the results in past tense—for example: –A total of 417 of the customers replied. –_____ increased, but _____ decreased. –The average temperature was _____. –Three of the dogs died. –This difference was not statistically significant.

Results Sections of Papers with Tables or Figures How much should the information in the text overlap that in the tables and figures? –Not extensive overlap –In general, text should present only the main points from the tables and figures –Perhaps also include a few of the most important data Remember to mention each table or figure. Do so as soon as readers might want to see it.

Mentioning Tables and Figures: Some Writing Advice In citing tables and figures, emphasize the finding, not the table or figure. –Not so good: Table 3 shows that researchers who took the course published twice as many papers per year. –Better: Researchers who took the course published twice as many papers per year (Table 3).

Mini-Exercise: Looking at a Results Section Please look at the Results section of the paper you are using as a model. –How many paragraphs is it? –What verb tense is it written in? –How many tables, if any, does it include? –How many figures, if any, does it include? –What else do you notice about it?

Discussion Questions What’s some advice from the textbook to remember about tables? What other advice do you have regarding tables?

Tables: A Few Suggestions Use tables only if text will not suffice. Design tables to be understandable without the text. If a paper includes a series of tables, use the same format for each. Be sure to follow the instructions to authors.

An Example of Improving a Table

Discussion Questions What’s some advice from the textbook to remember about figures? What other advice do you have regarding figures?

Figures: A Few Suggestions Use figures (graphs, diagrams, maps, photographs, etc) only if they will help convey your information. Avoid including too much information in one figure. Make sure any lettering will be large enough once published. Follow the journal’s instructions.

Sources of Further Information “Almost Everything You Wanted to Know About Making Tables and Figures,” Department of Biology, Bates College, ( urces/writing/HTWtablefigs.html) urces/writing/HTWtablefigs.html Writing and Publishing Scientific Papers, Part 2 (from China Medical Board course), accessible at library?type=all&subject=preparing_tables_and_ figures&lang=allhttp:// library?type=all&subject=preparing_tables_and_ figures&lang=all

Mini-Exercise: Tables and Figures Look at a set of instructions to authors that you obtained. –What, if anything, does it say about tables and figures? Look at any tables and figures in the paper you are using as a model. –What are some things you notice? –What, if anything, did you see that could apply to your paper?

Comments: Methods Sections Looked At What are some things you noticed about the Methods section of the paper you are using as a model? What questions do you have?

Workshop: Drafts of Methods Sections Read your group members’ Methods sections fairly quickly, to get the general meaning. Read each Methods section more carefully, and write comments on it. Discuss each Methods section, noting strengths and then providing suggestions. Give the commented-on Methods sections to the authors.

Discussion: Workshop on Methods What are some comments you received? What are some revisions that you’re thinking of making?

Homework For tomorrow (Thursday): –Read the chapters listed. –Revise the draft of your Methods section. –Bring in some figures, tables, or both from papers reporting research similar to yours. (One copy of each is enough.) Note: Your homework for Friday will include drafting the Results section of your paper. Feel free to start on it.

Wishing you a good afternoon!