Sami Dib NBI, STARPLAN Unveiling the diversity of the MW stellar clusters + Sacha Hony (ITA/Heidelberg) Stefan Schmeja (ARI/ Heidelberg) Dimitrios Gouliermis.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
John Bally Center for Astrophysics and Space Astronomy Department of Astrophysical and Planetary Sciences University of Colorado, Boulder Star Formation.
Advertisements

The Origin of Brown Dwarfs Kevin L. Luhman Penn State.
Proto-Brown Dwarf Disks as Products of Protostellar Disk Encounters Sijing Shen, James Wadsley (McMaster) The Western Disk Workshop May 19, 2006.
Improving mass and age estimates of unresolved stellar clusters Margaret Hanson & Bogdan Popescu Department of Physics.
An upper limit to the masses of stars Donald F. Figer STScI Collaborators: Sungsoo Kim (KHU) Paco Najarro (CSIC) Rolf Kudritzki (UH) Mark Morris (UCLA)
How do stars get their masses? and A short look ahead Phil Myers CfA Dense Core LXV Newport, RI October 23, 2009.
Dissolving globular clusters: the fate of M 12 Work in collaboration with F. Paresce (INAF) and L. Pulone (Obs. Rome)
 Star clusters may often be modelled as simple stellar populations → useful tools to constrain the star formation history of their host galaxies (refs).
Star formation simulations -> N=10000……. Cathie Clarke, I.O.A. cf special issue Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc., ed. De Grijs,Ch.3,arXiv:
Magnetars origin and progenitors with enhanced rotation S.B. Popov, M.E. Prokhorov (Sternberg Astronomical Institute) (astro-ph/ )
Galactic and Extragalactic star formation M.Walmsley (Arcetri Observatory)
Star & Planet Formation Alyssa A. Goodman Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
Bayesian Analysis of X-ray Luminosity Functions A. Ptak (JHU) Abstract Often only a relatively small number of sources of a given class are detected in.
Understanding LMXBs in Elliptical Galaxies Vicky Kalogera.
Constraining the IMF in Extreme Environments: Direct Detection of Young Low Mass Stars in Unresolved Starbursts Julia Greissl, Michael Meyer University.
A Multiphase, Sticky Particle, Star Formation Recipe for Cosmology
A Multiphase, Sticky Particle, Star Formation Recipe for Cosmology Craig Booth Tom Theuns & Takashi Okamoto.
Two stories from the life of binaries: getting bigger and making magnetars Sergei Popov, Mikhail Prokhorov (SAI MSU) This week SAI celebrates its 175 anniversary.
The Complex Star Formation History of NGC 1569 L. Angeretti 1, M. Tosi 2, L. Greggio 3, E. Sabbi 1, A. Aloisi 4, C. Leitherer 4 The object The observations.
X-ray Binaries in Nearby Galaxies Vicky Kalogera Northwestern University Super Star Clusters Starburst galaxies Ultra-Luminous X-Ray Sources Elliptical.
Theoretical Studies of X-Ray Binaries in Clusters Vicky Kalogera MODEST-6 ExtraGalactic only…
Star2map Shannon Guiles Cornell University July 16, 2004.
Adam L. Kraus February 1, 2007 Multiple Star Formation at the Bottom of the IMF.
Star formation from (local) molecular clouds to spiral arms Lee Hartmann University of Michigan.
An analytic explanation of the stellar initial mass function from the theory of spatial networks Andrei Klishin* (MIT Physics) & Igor Chilingarian (SAO)
Star and Planet Formation Sommer term 2007 Henrik Beuther & Sebastian Wolf 16.4 Introduction (H.B. & S.W.) 23.4 Physical processes, heating and cooling.
Courtesy Jason Harris, Steward Observatory Two Tails of a Distribution : The Initial Mass Functions of Extreme Star Formation Michael R. Meyer Steward.
The Low-End MF of the Arches Cluster Sungsoo S. Kim Kyung Hee Univ., Korea with Jihye Shin Don Figer.
The “EPRI” Bayesian M max Approach for Stable Continental Regions (SCR) (Johnston et al. 1994) Robert Youngs AMEC Geomatrix USGS Workshop on Maximum Magnitude.
Deciphering the CIB 12 Oct 2012 Banyuls MODELING COUNTS AND CIBA WITH MAIN SEQUENCE AND STARBURST GALAXIES Matthieu Béthermin CEA Saclay In collaboration.
Practical Statistics for Particle Physicists Lecture 3 Harrison B. Prosper Florida State University European School of High-Energy Physics Anjou, France.
Binary Pulsar Coalescence Rates and Detection Rates for Gravitational Wave Detectors Chunglee Kim, Vassiliki Kalogera (Northwestern U.), and Duncan R.
Introduction The formation and destruction of star cluster populations in galaxy mergers Slide 1 of 22 Star clusters in galaxy mergers – 7 April 2011 Diederik.
Theoretical Predictions about the Cold- Warm Gas Size around Cluster Galaxies using MgII systems Iván Lacerna VII Reunión Anual, SOCHIAS 2009 January 14.
Comprehensive Stellar Population Models and the Disentanglement of Age and Metallicity Effects Guy Worthey 1994, ApJS, 95, 107.
Fifty Years of IMF Theory and Observations John Scalo University of Texas at Austin.
Star Clusters in the Galactic Center Sgr A* at 30 Workshop Green Bank W.Va March 25, 26, 2004 Donald F. Figer STScI.
New and Odds on Globular Cluster Stellar Populations: an Observational Point of View (The Snapshot Database) G.Piotto, I. King, S. Djorgovski and G. Bono,
Expected Coalescence Rate of NS/NS Binaries for Ground Based Interferometers Tania Regimbau OCA/ARTEMIS on the behalf of J.A. de Freitas Pacheco, T. Regimbau,
Is the Initial Mass Function universal? Morten Andersen, M. R. Meyer, J. Greissl, B. D. Oppenheimer, M. Kenworthy, D. McCarthy Steward Observatory, University.
Xiaohu Yang (SJTU/SHAO) With: H. Wang, H.J. Mo, Y.P. Jing, F.C van den Bosch, W.P. Lin, D. Tweed… , KIAS Exploring the Local Universe with re-
HBT 28-Jun-2005 Henry Throop Department of Space Studies Southwest Research Institute (SwRI) Boulder, Colorado John Bally University of Colorado Portugal,
Field O Stars: A Mode of Sparse Star Formation Joel Lamb Sally Oey University of Michigan.
Philamentary Structure and Velocity Gradients in the Orion A Cloud
By Soren S. Larsen (arXiv: ) Reporter: Sun Wei.
Elinor Medezinski Johns Hopkins University Galaxy Galaxy Lensing in CLASH clusters.
Rotation Among High Mass Stars: A Link to the Star Formation Process? S. Wolff and S. Strom National Optical Astronomy Observatory.
Sally Oey University of Michigan Cathie Clarke IoA, Cambridge HDF Smith et al. / MCELS Massive Stars: Feedback Effects in the Local Universe.
Stellar Population Mass Estimates Roelof de Jong (STScI AIP) Eric Bell (MPIA Univ. of Michigan)
Oct. 30, 2002Source Simulation & Data Analysis1 Gravitational-Wave Observations of Galactic Populations of Compact Binaries M. Benacquista Montana State.
The Initial Mass Function in Clusters Bruce G. Elmegreen IBM T.J. Watson Research Center Yorktown Hts., NY May 9, 2006 Salpeter ‘55.
Binary Compact Object Inspiral: Rate Expectations Vicky Kalogera with Chunglee Kim Richard O’Shaughnessy Tassos Fragkos Physics & Astronomy Dept.
On the importance of the few most massive stars: the ionizing cluster of NGC 588 L. Jamet 1, E. Pérez 2, M. Cerviño 2, G. Stasinska 1, R.M. González Delgado.
1 Dynamical Interactions and Brown Dwarfs Michael F. Sterzik, ESO Richard H. Durisen, Indiana University Hierarchical fragmentation and „two-step“ dynamical.
Star Formation: From Cores to Disks
Mass Profiles of Galaxy Clusters Drew Newman Newman et al. 2009, “The Distribution of Dark Matter Over Three Decades in Radius in the Lensing Cluster Abell.
Prestellar core formation simulations in turbulent molecular clouds with large scale anisotropy Nicolas Petitclerc, James Wadsley and Alison Sills McMaster.
Towards Realistic Modeling of Massive Star Clusters Oleg Gnedin (University of Michigan) graduate student Hui Li.
Michael R. Meyer Institute for Astronomy, ETH-Zurich
Genevieve J. Graves University of California, Santa Cruz
8th Gravitational Wave Data Analysis Workshop
An upper limit to the masses of stars
The primordial binary population in Sco OB2
IMF inferred based on field stars (red) and based on a variety of clusters (blue, green, and black) (Kroupa 2002)
8th Gravitational Wave Data Analysis Workshop
Probing the IMF Star Formation in Massive Clusters.
Center for Gravitational Wave Physics Penn State University
Star-planet coalescence
The Power-Law Tail in the Initial Mass Function (IMF) of Stars
CS639: Data Management for Data Science
Presentation transcript:

Sami Dib NBI, STARPLAN Unveiling the diversity of the MW stellar clusters + Sacha Hony (ITA/Heidelberg) Stefan Schmeja (ARI/ Heidelberg) Dimitrios Gouliermis (ITA/Heidelberg) Åke Nordlund (NBI, STARPLAN)

The multi- exponent power law: Kroupa 2002 The lognormal distribution+power law: Chabrier 2003, 2005 The TPL IMF: de Marchi & Parecse 2002; Parravano et al The Galactic field IMF Maschberger (2013): L 3 function (low mass + high mass power laws) Basu et al. (2015): MLP (modified lognormal+ power law)

Luhman & Rieke 1999; Luhman 2000, ++ rho-Ophiucus Taurus The IMF of young clusters

comparing the slope at the intermediate-to-high mass end Massey et al. 1995a,b Massey 2003 The IMF of Open Stellar Clusters Sharma et al. 2008

Figer 1999; Stolte et al. 2005, Kim et al Espinoza et al. 2010, Habibi et al The IMF of Starburst clusters: Arches, NGC 3603: shallower than Salpeter Stolte et al. 2006

Characterizing The IMF of stellar clusters with Bayesian statistics Avoids:  The effects of the bin size  Making subjective choices about break points Allows for:  Including the effects of individual uncertainties on masses  Effects of completness  Use of prior information

Test on synthetic data Likelihood: TPL Flat prior functions on the parameters (in linear space) MCMC

Application to young clusters: TPL Likelihood Dib 2014

Application to young Galactic Stellar Clusters Case of “Chabrier”-like likelihood function Dib 2014 No overlap in the parameters at the 1σ confidence limit

Effect of completeness & mass uncertainties: ONC Dib 2014

The statistics of massive stars in young clusters The MWSC (Kharchenko et al. 2012,13, Schmeja et al. 2014, Schmeja, Dib et al. 2015) Based on 2MASS + PPXML data; 3145 clusters within < 2 kpc; complete to ~ 1.8 kpc from the Sun Extract statictics from the MWSC catalogue that can be contrasted with large sample of synthetic clusters  extract order zero statistics i.e, scalars  order 1: distributions of specific quantities  Order 2: relations between 2 quantities

Some statistics (among others)  The fraction of “lonely” O stars of masses and no massive B stars (between 10 and 15 Msol)

Construct a statistical sample of clusters Model chart Define how much mass is present in clusters that contains stars with M > M O,lim Define cluster mass function (slope, mininum & maximum cluster Masses) And distribute over this distribution For each cluster of mass  Define the distributions of the IMF parameters From which they are draw for each cluster. Sample the masses of stars: i.e., the IMF with the chosen set of parameter for each cluster  assign an age to each cluster For each O system of mass in each cluster:  Define a binarity probability  For binary system, define a mass ratio  Correct for stellar evolution Correct for CLMF completeness Measure the fractions & other statistics

Sampling the IMF parameters Which distributions of the IMF parameters allow us to match the statistics from the MWSC ?

How does the sample look like ? ICLMF, CLMF, CLMF-lonOSystem IMFs

Comparing the statistical sample to the MWSC Sampling the IMF parameters no M max -M cl relation. IMF sampled between 0.02 and 150 Msol Reproducing the observations is only compatible with the IMF parameters having

Dependence onthe sampling parameters Effect of the CLMF exponent. Best match for Effect of the choice of M cl,min Best match for M cl,min =50 Msol

with a M *,max -M cl relation (Weidner& Kroupa 2013)

Summary (1)The IMF of Galactic clusters is not universal !..given the data (2) Better not describe the IMF by a set of 3 (or more) parameters, but by distribution functions of the parameters that may vary from galaxy to galaxy (3) The cluster mass function has a slope of -2 (4) Minimum mass cutoff of ~50 M sol in young cluster masses required (or a turnover) (5) M max -M cl relation incompatible with the matching of statisticals models and the MWSC data Implications/suggestions: In local simulations: aim should be to recover distributions of IMF parameters rather than single values In global simulations: implement distributions of the IMF rather than single values

Variations of CMF and IMF Effect of accretion on cores

Dib et al Data points: Orion A+B cloud Johnstone & Bally 2006

Dib et al In low-mass clusters: no tail at high stellar masses

Application to the Orion Cloud and the ONC Dib et al. (2010)

Dib et al Variations with the cores properties: making a Taurus cluster Effect of varying the lifetimes of the cores+stopping effect of feedback

 =0.4  =1.8 Slope= -3/(4-  )-1=-2.33 calculate instanteneous cross section of collision between contracting objects of Masses M i and M j and integrate over the mass spectrum. Initial conditions from turbulent fragmentation (Padoan & Nordlund 2002) Variation of the IMF Effects of core coalescence Dib et al. 2007

Core coalescence: application to Starburst Clusters Dib et al time