The McKenzie Method An Overview Mechanical Diagnosis & Therapy of the Spine: A Dynamic System of Examination, Diagnosis, Intervention and Prevention By: Amrish Patel, MD, PT
Who am I to talk about McKenzie Therapy Went to PT school Practice McKenzie based therapies for 4 years Went to Medical School to become a MSK doctor Became a Physiatrist who specializes in Sports and Interventional Spine Still use MDT type evaluation for spine patients to find directional preference
NO FINANCIAL DISCLOSURES
Overview EpidemiologyHistory McKenzie Method –Misconceptions –Truths BenefitsClassificationsTreatments The END
Epidemiology 50-80% population experience back pain Peak prevalence years of age and tapers after that C-spine -Women tend to be affected more men L-spine – Men tend to more affected than women First episodes of symptoms start in the 20’s w/ reoccurrence rates between 39-71% Majority (80-90%) of low back disorders occur at the L4/5 and/or L5/S1-
Who is Robin McKenzie?
History MDT Robin McKenzie Physiotherapist from New Zealand Physiotherapist from New Zealand Dr. Cyriax Dr. Cyriax strong influence on McKenzie's initial training strong influence on McKenzie's initial training considered the framework for MDT considered the framework for MDT Clinical experience Clinical experience Mr. Smith 1956 – 2 weeks of radicular sx then serendipitous surprise Exploration of End Of Range - some improved, while others worsened
History - cont Over next 20 years developed approach Began teaching approach 1977 Rancho Los Amigos McKenzie Institute formed in branches around the world
What McKenzie learned from his accidental discovery is that most back and neck pain has a directional preference. Most spinal pain can diminish with backward bending positions/movements and a small percentage will diminish with more twisting or tilting movements. Currently there are approximately >30,000 MDT therapist in US.
Common Misconceptions
McKenzie therapy=extension exercises to centralize symptoms only Centralization: The process by which the pain radiating from the spine is sequentially abolished,distally to proximately, in response to specific therapeutic positions or movements. This ultimately includes reduction and abolition of spinal pain.
Centralization of lower extremity pain
McKenzie Method More than exercises, MDT is a system of evaluation and creating a treatment paradigm –From history: is problem mechanical, medical, biopsychosocial or a combination –Develop Differential Diagnosis –Classify/Stratify: if mechanical is it dysfunction, derangement, postural or other (not all and only about radiculopathy!) –PE helps confirm or refute DDX
McKenzie Classification Three Syndromes PosturalDysfunctionDerangement
MDT cont’d During assessment: –All planes of motion are used in the assessment and to help guide treatment –Direction of treatment is based on patient’s symptomatic and mechanical response to repeated or sustained movements –Movements are done in progression from mid range to end range, not all just at end of range
MDT Classification Postural: Prolonged end range stress on normal structure (e.g,sitting posture) Prolonged end range stress on normal structure (e.g,sitting posture)Dysfunction End range stress or over stretching of shortened structure. (scarring, fibrosis, nerve root, adherence). End range stress or over stretching of shortened structure. (scarring, fibrosis, nerve root, adherence).Derangement Anatomical disruption and displacement within motion segments (I.V.D) (this is the syndrome where centralization is more likely to occur). Anatomical disruption and displacement within motion segments (I.V.D) (this is the syndrome where centralization is more likely to occur).
MDT cont’d “ “MDT is not reliant on a patho-anatomical diagnosis but is based around a sound research proven classification system” and this helps to guide clinical management MDT does use mobilization techniques (not hands off therapy), but “MDT’s focus is primarily on education and self-directed treatments in order to reduce dependency on the clinician and to empower the patient to control their symptoms.”
Classification All three mechanical syndromes, postural, dysfunctional and derangement occur in the cervical as well as thoracic and lumbar regions of the spine. 2 categories of Derangements: -reducible (able to centralize and maintain the centralization). -reducible (able to centralize and maintain the centralization). -irreducible (at least 3-5 sessions of treatment before can lable it) -irreducible (at least 3-5 sessions of treatment before can lable it)
Derangements Severity indicators: - central and symmetrical symptoms. - central and symmetrical symptoms. - unilateral and asymmetrical symptoms to the knee. - unilateral and asymmetrical symptoms to the knee. -unilateral and asymmetrical symptoms to bellow the knee. -unilateral and asymmetrical symptoms to bellow the knee.
Derangements Directional preference or principle of management ExtensionFlexionLateralCombination
McKenzie Exercises Figure 3. Lying Prone Figure 4. Progress to elbows Figure 5. Full press up Figure 1. Seated Figure 2. Standing
More McKenzie Exercises Figure 6. Lying Supine Figure 10. Flex to Floor Figure 7. Knees bent Figure 8. Knees to Chest Figure 9. Flex with hands behind seat
Examples of lateral directional preferences
MDT benefits MDT provides a system of assessment, diagnosis and subgrouping or classifying to help guide treatment. Provides ability for patient prognosis based on response to treatment in a few sessions Emphasis on self treatment provides the patient independence in long term management of their back pain Can help them prevent severe reoccurrences by being independent
McKenzie System Truths/Summary Based on good history taking Based on good observations Is logical if you understand it’s basic concepts and concepts of tissue healing Based on repeated motions, but not all extension Based on end range loading of tissue, but goes through all ranges of motion Based on appropriate/ progressive loading of tissue, to help symptoms and mechanical changes Is a movement based system – is a mechanical based system Is involved in treating movement based problems –Sprained ankles ; painful shoulders ; knee pain and dysfunctions ; can be used for acute or chronic problems –Used world wide