Trends in mobile telephony & data services Highlights of the INFORMATION ECONOMY REPORT ICTs, Enterprises and Poverty Alleviation ITU-R Regional Workshop on ‘IMT for the Next Decade’ Bangkok, 21 March 2011 Scarlett Fondeur Gil Economic Affairs Officer ICT Analysis Section UNCTAD

Technology should be better leveraged in meeting the MDGs New technology-based solutions that did not exist when the Goals were endorsed can and should be leveraged to allow for rapid scaling up. The most important of these technologies involve use of mobile telephones, broadband Internet, and other information and communications technologies. ” “ Source: Report of the Secretary-General, 12 February 2010, A/64/665.

Informational dimension of poverty Poor people often lack access to vital information, for example about: –market price information –income-earning opportunities –weather forecasts –what pesticides and fertilizers to use –health –disaster risk reduction Lack of information greater vulnerability

Focus of the IER 2010 Trends in affordable access to different ICTs Direct use of ICTs in enterprises –Different industries –Subsistence-based and growth-oriented enterprises –Value chain stages Direct involvement of the poor in the ICT producing sector –as workers or entrepreneurs –ICT manufacturing –ICT and IT-enabled services –Large/medium vs. small/micro enterprises

Mobile revolution is reaching the LDCs bringing interactive connectivity for the first time Source: ITU World Telecommunication/ICT Indicators database. Penetration of selected ICTs in Least Developed Countries, (per 100 inhabitants)

Some unfinished business remains Half of rural population in LDCs lack access to mobile signal Source: ITU.

The Urban-Rural Divide Selected examples from LDCs

New applications and services emerging Voice-based services –helplines, agro-messages SMS services –Election monitoring (Ghana) –Earthquake relief (Haiti) Mobile money services –E.g. M-PESA, M-Paisa, Wizzit, GCash Mobile micro insurance (Kilimo Salama, Kenya) Rural health applications

More mobiles than bank accounts in LDCs Source: Data from ITU and CGAP. Mobile subscriptions and bank accounts per 100 inhabitants, selected LDCs, 2009

Affordability is key South Asian model attractive to low-income mobile users Source: Idea, MTN, Orascom, Portugal Telecom and Zain operating reports. Average revenue per mobile user, selected LDCs and India, 2009 (U.S. dollars) Attractive features for low- income users: -Long period for inactivity -Per-second charging -Nationwide tariffs -Low denomination recharge -“Friends and family”

Exploit the diversity of ICTs ICTs –Mobile telephony –Fixed telephony –Personal computers –Internet –Broadband –Radio Different features –Costs –Skills requirements –Power needs –Functionality –Access Each technology has its pros and cons to meet different user needs Opportunities for combined solutions

ICTs in enterprises can help the poor Preliminary evidence across sectors and countries Cases cited in report –Dairy farmers in Bhutan –Grain traders in Niger –Fishermen in India and Ghana –Women weavers in Nigeria –M-Paisa in Afghanistan –Micro-enterprises in Mumbai –Handicraft in Viet Nam –And more… Most important effects –Reduced information search and transactions costs –Improved communications within supply chains with benefits for individual enterprises and improvements in overall market efficiency Preference for mobiles –Affordable access –Easy to use –Two-way communication –Serve basic needs

The poor and the ICT producing sector Some find new livelihoods in changing ICT landscape Cases cited in report –Sellers of airtime in Bangladesh, Ghana, Uganda –SIM card sales in the Gambia –Mobile entrepreneurs in Venezuela –ICT micro-enterprises in urban slum in Mumbai –ICT manufacturing in China –Social outsourcing in India –And more… Key findings –Micro-enterprises have large involvement of poor; exposed to risk and volatility –ICT manufacturing concentrated; but significant effects in China –High skill requirements a barrier in case of outsourcing, but second-order effects –“Social outsourcing˝ new development tool? –More attention needed to e- waste problem

Ecosystem for policies to reduce poverty via ICTs and Enterprises Source: UNCTAD and Emdon.

The Policy Challenge How to bring more benefits to the poor from ICTs in enterprises 1.Expand mobile coverage in places with no mobile signal 2.Make services affordable – South Asia a model 3.Focus more on ICT adoption at low levels of economic activity and sophistication, incl. for subsistence enterprises 4.Make interventions more demand-driven – needs of enterprises differ by size, industry, location and skills 5.Make more use of mobiles in policy interventions 6.Partnerships between governments, private sector and civil society 7.Development agencies need to stay abreast of developments 8.Feature ICTs in poverty reduction strategies and UN Development Assistance Frameworks (UNDAFs)

IER 2011 ICTs and Private Sector Development How can smart use of ICTs support enterprise creation and growth? Key areas: –Access to government services (business dev. services) –Access to markets –Skills development –Access to finance (mobile money services) –Reduced risk (mobile micro-insurance) –Entrepreneurship in ICT sector –Greater use of ICTs What can we learn from ITC’s experience?

Thank you! The Information Economy Report 2010 can be downloaded free of charge at