Airport Systems Planning RdN Multi-Airport Systems in Era of Low-Cost Carriers  Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Engineering Systems and of Civil.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Analysis Of The Airline Industry. Introduction Deregulation in the US 1978 UK and Netherlands followed with deregulation in 1984 The economic boom of.
Advertisements

Marketing in the Age of Technology: Ryanair Mike Ward Salford Business School University of Salford, Greater Manchester United Kingdom.
Airport Capacity Problem Southern California Transportation Alternatives LCDR Kirby and LT Burba.
Mukhtar Ahmed Irene Chandra Shalini Seema Shaveen Lata.
Airport Systems Planning & Design / RdN Configuration of Airport Passenger Buildings Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Engineering Systems and Civil.
European Commission Slot allocation at Community airports Infrastructures and Airports Unit Klaas Pel.
The Hub-and-Spoke Routing for Airlines Costs and Competitiveness
Airport Systems Planning & Design / RdN  Effects of Deregulation on Airports Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Engineering Systems and Civil and Environmental.
Hub and Spoke vs. Point to Point Evan Demick February 28, 2013.
1 © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited. The Airline Industry.
Airport Systems Planning & Design / RdN  Forecasting Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Engineering Systems and Civil and Environmental Engineering.
AIRLINE CHALLENGES CURRENT STRATEGIES AIRLINE CHALLENGES CURRENT STRATEGIES A personal perspective by Pierre J. Jeanniot Opening session.
January 2015 GLOBAL COMPETITIVENESS FORUM At the Crossroads How Saudi Arabia can Leverage its Unique Position and Become a Leader in Global Transport Dr.
LMI Airline Responses to NAS Capacity Constraints Peter Kostiuk Logistics Management Institute National Airspace System Resource.
FOUNDATIONS OF HUMAN ACTIVITY (CHAPTER 3). INTRODUCTION
Airport Systems Planning & Design / RdN AIRPORT PASSENGER BUILDINGS: EFFICIENCY THRU SHARED USE  Dr. Richard de Neufville  Professor of Engineering Systems.
Public transport British Airways.
Developments in the Airline Industry L.O: to know the main changes in the airline industry, and how this has impacted upon travel and tourism. ALL must.
Airport Systems Planning RdN Multi-Airport Systems in Era of Low-Cost Carriers  Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Systems Engineering and of Civil.
The emergence and growth of no frills, low-cost carriers have radically altered the nature of competition within the industry Those major LCCs have exploited.
State of the Air Transport in 2013
Air Transportation A Management Perspective
Impact and Model of Low-Cost Carriers
1.231 Term Project Multiple Airports in Campania Italy Shiro Yamanaka CTL MST ’04.
Textbook Reviews By Aj.Weerawit Lertthaitrakul Logistics & Supply chain management Business Administration Air Transportation A Management Perspective.
Airport Systems Planning & Design / RdN  Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Systems Engineering and Civil and Environmental Engineering Massachusetts.
Airport Systems Planning & Design / RdN  Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Engineering Systems and Civil and Environmental Engineering Massachusetts.
Continental Airlines: The Competitive Arena
Small Community Service Prospects Faye Malarkey Regional Airline Association Federal Aviation Administration 30th Annual Aviation Forecast Conference March.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology Dr. Philippe A. Bonnefoy Postdoctoral Associate Department of Aeronautics & Astronautics
The Role of Business Aviation in the European Economy Philip Thomas Oxford Economics 13 March 2013.
Brittni Pladson Kyle Bachand Stacy Li Yang Liu. Introduction – Brittni History – Yang SWOT Analysis – Kyle Competition – Stacy Industry Analysis – Brittni.
Presentation to Universita’Roma3 Low Cost-Modello differenziato di Business 13 th of December
1 Airport as an economic and spatial regional driver Airport of the Future; March 30, 2006 Meiltje de Groot; sr advisor Airport Development.
Aircraft The Market Michelin participates in all segments of the aviation industry.
Transport in Europe The search for mobility. Importance of transport in Europe 1 million transport-related enterprises Over 7million jobs Value-added.
European Low Fares Airlines Association European Low Fares Airline Association Low fares airlines: business model and impact on regional airports John.
Regional Update North America Air Traffic and Airlines ACI World Economic Committee January 24, 2008 Leo Fermin San Francisco International Airport.
Will anything Curb our Increasing Demand for Flying? To see more of our products visit our website at Professor Colin Bamford.
The importance of regional aviation to the UK European Regions Airline Association Simon McNamara.
Thought Questions: Questions to answer. Write these questions on a piece of paper and answer them. 1. What things would cause people to leave a certain.
Airport Systems Planning & Design / RdN Cultural Differences Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Systems Engineering and Civil and Environmental Engineering.
AIR TRAVEL Unit 5. Review of unit reading material from textbook: Travel Career Development 8 th ed. Authors: Gagnon,P. & Houser, S.
AST 205 Chapter 1 Notes. Home Previous Next Help FBO What does FBO stand for? Fixed Based Operator How did that term originate? Originated from the early.
TEAM 1 – Airbus AXX Future of Air Transportation and Possible Air Response.
Global networking strategies: Strategic alliance
Airport Systems Planning RdN Multi-Airport Systems in Era of Low-Cost Carriers  Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Engineering Systems and of Civil.
June 26, 2009 REGIONAL AIRPORT SYSTEM PLAN ANALYSIS Study Update Prepared for: Regional Airport Planning Committee Prepared for: Regional Airport Planning.
Airport Systems Planning & Design / RdN Airport and Airline Access Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Systems Engineering and Civil and Environmental.
Hazırlayan World Statistics Day Workshop Panel-1: New Understandings and Approaches in Airline and Tourism Business Airline Business - Market Outlook Source:
Airport Systems Planning & Design / RdN Design of Components of Airport Passenger Buildings Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Engineering Systems and.
Airline Flight Industry Nicole Kinney, Kelly Dwyer and Blaine Taylor.
Components of AP Pax Bldgs Slide 1 of 27 / RdN © Design of Components of Airport Passenger Buildings Richard de Neufville Professor of Engineering Systems.
Risk Factors in Airport Financing in Challenging Times or If You Build It and They Don’t Come, Who Will Pay? 30 th Annual FAA Aviation Forecast Conference.
30 th Annual FAA Aviation Forecast Conference AIRPORT FORECASTING IN UNCERTAIN TIMES Presented By: Christina Cassotis Vice President, SH&E, Inc. Presented.
Ribbons in the Sky The Airline Transportation Industry
The Global Military Aircraft Engines Market
Valuation Ratios in the Airline Industry Hari Stirbet Tammy Cheung Shelly Khindri Parmjit Marway.
Biography for William Swan Chief Economist, Seabury-Airline Planning Group. AGIFORS Senior Fellow. ATRG Senior Fellow. Retired Chief Economist for Boeing.
CIS Today and in the future Simon McNamara European Regions Airline Association.
2015: In Rarefied Air According to US Bureau of Transportation statistics, the 25 US scheduled service passenger airlines, which are the basis of the.
Dr. Richard de Neufville
Ryanair-The Low fares Airline
Dr. Richard de Neufville
Dr. Richard de Neufville
Dr. Richard de Neufville
Design of Components of Airport Passenger Buildings
Annual Traffic Growth Places SFO as the #7 U.S. Busiest Airport.
Presentation transcript:

Airport Systems Planning RdN Multi-Airport Systems in Era of Low-Cost Carriers  Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Engineering Systems and of Civil and Environmental Engineering Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Airport Systems Planning RdN Theme “Low cost” airlines are developing a “parallel network” of travel “network choice” (rather than “airport choice”) may determine traffic in multi-airport systems Competition between “low cost” and “legacy” airlines leading to struggle between “low cost” and “legacy” hubs  Boston/Logan vs. Boston/Providence, etc., etc.

Airport Systems Planning RdN What is a Multi-Airport System? the significant airports serving transport in a metropolitan region, without regard to ownership or political control  Ex: Boston, Providence, Manchester  Ex: Copenhagen (Denmark), Malmo (Sweden) Discussion  This is reality for travelers  Contrasts with focus on ownership (as used by ACI – Airports Council International, and others)

Airport Systems Planning RdN Discussion of Tables 1 – 4 derived from de Neufville database Table 1: Except for very crowded situations, secondary airports are a small fraction of total at airport with most passengers.  This reflects concentration factor … Table 2: Catalog of Major Secondary Airports Table 3: MAS ranked by Estimated Number of Originating Passengers, eliminating transfers  This focuses on a Major Driver of MAS Table 4: Potential MAS, mostly driven by Low-Cost airlines.  New ones constantly emerging…

Airport Systems Planning RdN Planning Issue Many ‘mistakes’ in planning multi- airport systems  Washington/Dulles – planned as major DC airport, but had only ~ 3 MAP for 20 years  London/Stansted – similar story – only developed with Ryanair hub around 2002  Osaka/Kansai – Osaka/Itami did not close  Montreal/Mirabel – huge airfield, now “closed” to passenger traffic  Et cetera…

Airport Systems Planning RdN Why mistakes happened Failure to appreciate traffic concentration at primary airports … Because planners/forecasters using wrong mental model

Airport Systems Planning RdN What drives traffic allocation in Multi-Airport System? Airline competition has been primary S-shaped market share/frequency share Drives airlines to  Match flights => Allocate flights to major markets  Concentrate Traffic at primary airports Frequency Share Market Share

Airport Systems Planning RdN Right model: “Concentration” not “Catchment Areas” Concentration is standard urban phenomenon  e.g.: financial, jewelry, etc. districts Driven by what suppliers offer Customers choose which location (airport) depending on where they find what they need -- not just most convenient facility

Airport Systems Planning RdN “Concentration” persists -- until high level of local traffic When local originating traffic high… More flights add little at major airports Airlines place flights at second airports There appears to be a ‘threshold”… Currently ~ 16 million originations/year Note: higher as “average” aircraft carries more passengers, larger aircraft or higher load factor

Airport Systems Planning RdN New Reality: No-frill airlines setting up “parallel network” Low-cost carriers “parallel” majors Major fare distinctions Ticket distribution separate  Internet direct to users, ‘no’ travel agents Parallel service between cities  Providence/Baltimore not Boston/Washington ‘No’ interlining of bags, tickets ‘Not’ in Reservation systems

Airport Systems Planning RdN Metropolitan areas with significant multi-airport systems de Neufville data base for 2007

Airport Systems Planning RdN Metropolitan areas with significant multi-airport systems de Neufville data base for 2007

Airport Systems Planning RdN Major exceptions to rule: technical or political Until recently, major exceptions to concentration rule were: Technical -- runways too short  Belfast, Belo Horizonte, Buenos Aires, Rio de Janeiro, Taipei Political -- or military...  Berlin, Dusseldorf/Bonn, Glasgow, Moscow

Airport Systems Planning RdN New Reality: No-frills choose different airports Southwest, Westjet (Canada), Ryanair and Easyjet (UK) require:  Cheap properties, no Taj Mahals (compare San Francisco/International and Oakland; London/Gatwick and Luton)  Low congestion and delays  Flexible work force They find this at aggressive, ‘hungry’ airports -- not in major facilities

Airport Systems Planning RdN New Reality: US/Canada Network of Low-Cost Carrier Airports

Airport Systems Planning RdN New Reality: Europe Network of Low-Cost Carrier Airports

Airport Systems Planning RdN Multi-Airport Systems in Brazil Source: Infraero; de Neufville database 2007

Airport Systems Planning RdN Importance of Parallel Network of close-in Brazilian airports

Airport Systems Planning RdN Implications for modelling future of second airports A new driver for second airports...  Low-cost carriers often ‘not’ competing at big airports  Frequency competition does not drive growth pattern of secondary airports Competition between networks may be primary… … followed by catchment area model of airport choice

Airport Systems Planning RdN Implications for future of second airports No-frills airlines are becoming ‘major’  Southwest 2nd largest airline in world (pax)  Market Cap ~ 10 billion $ > any other pax airline  Ryanair Market Cap greater than British Airways Majors are shrinking (UAL, USAir, etc.) Implies that Primary airports will lose significant traffic to second airports This is already happening!!!

Airport Systems Planning RdN Southwest entry in Boston market grew second airports Source: Louis Berger, New England Regional Aviation System Plan materials

Airport Systems Planning RdN Market Share of Boston/Logan is in decline Source: Louis Berger New England Regional Aviation System Plan The 2004 Share is about 57% (SH&E, ’05)

Airport Systems Planning RdN Summary A new, parallel air transport network is emerging to compete with majors This low-cost carrier network may become a major feature of industry It implies growth and importance of low-cost second airports throughout North America, Europe -- and perhaps elsewhere

Airport Systems Planning RdN Supplemental Comment Meanwhile, a similar development is taking place in air cargo Fedex and UPS are developing their own networks of cargo airports Fedex: Memphis, Toronto/Hamilton, San Francisco/ Oakland, etc. UPS: Louisville, Los Angeles/Ontario. Chicago/Rockford, etc.