Complementarity of weak lensing with other probes Lindsay King, Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge University UK.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Astronomical Solutions to Galactic Dark Matter Will Sutherland Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge.
Advertisements

Where will supersymmetric dark matter first be seen? Liang Gao National observatories of China, CAS.
Observational Cosmology - a laboratory for fundamental physics MPI-K, Heidelberg Marek Kowalski.
Christian Wagner - September Potsdam Nonlinear Power Spectrum Emulator Christian Wagner in collaboration with Katrin Heitmann, Salman Habib,
Probing DM Halo Shapes Using Satellite Galaxy Kinematics Jeremy Bailin (Swinburne) Chris Power, Brad Gibson (Swinburne), Peder Norberg (ETH), Dennis Zaritsky.
Dark Halos of Fossil Groups and Clusters Observations and Simulations Ali Dariush, Trevor Ponman Graham Smith University of Birmingham, UK Frazer Pearce.
Observational Cosmology - a unique laboratory for fundamental physics Marek Kowalski Physikalisches Institut Universität Bonn.
PRESENTATION TOPIC  DARK MATTER &DARK ENERGY.  We know about only normal matter which is only 5% of the composition of universe and the rest is  DARK.
Å rhus, 4 September 2007 Julien Lesgourgues (LAPTH, Annecy, France)
The National Science Foundation The Dark Energy Survey J. Frieman, M. Becker, J. Carlstrom, M. Gladders, W. Hu, R. Kessler, B. Koester, A. Kravtsov, for.
Strong Lensing in RCS-2 Clusters Matt Bayliss University of Chicago Department of Astronomy & Astrophysics Great Lakes Cosmology Workshop 8 – June 2, 2007.
July 7, 2008SLAC Annual Program ReviewPage 1 Future Dark Energy Surveys R. Wechsler Assistant Professor KIPAC.
Complementary Probes ofDark Energy Complementary Probes of Dark Energy Eric Linder Berkeley Lab.
On the Distribution of Dark Matter in Clusters of Galaxies David J Sand Chandra Fellows Symposium 2005.
Galaxy-Galaxy lensing
Relating Mass and Light in the COSMOS Field J.E. Taylor, R.J. Massey ( California Institute of Technology), J. Rhodes ( Jet Propulsion Laboratory) & the.
Lens Galaxy Environments Neal Dalal (IAS), Casey R. Watson (Ohio State) astro-ph/ Who cares? 2.What to do 3.Results 4.Problems! 5.The future.
THE STRUCTURE OF COLD DARK MATTER HALOS J. Navarro, C. Frenk, S. White 2097 citations to NFW paper to date.
Neutrinos in Cosmology Alessandro Melchiorri Universita’ di Roma, “La Sapienza” INFN, Roma-1 NOW-2004, 16th September, 2004.
Galaxy-Galaxy Lensing What did we learn? What can we learn? Henk Hoekstra.
Impact of intrinsic alignments on cosmic shear Shearing by elliptical galaxy halos –SB + Filipe Abdalla astro-ph/ Intrinsic alignments and photozs.
The Science Case for the Dark Energy Survey James Annis For the DES Collaboration.
Eric V. Linder (arXiv: v1). Contents I. Introduction II. Measuring time delay distances III. Optimizing Spectroscopic followup IV. Influence.
Modern State of Cosmology V.N. Lukash Astro Space Centre of Lebedev Physics Institute Cherenkov Conference-2004.
What can we learn from galaxy clustering? David Weinberg, Ohio State University Berlind & Weinberg 2002, ApJ, 575, 587 Zheng, Tinker, Weinberg, & Berlind.
Cosmic Structures: Challenges for Astro-Statistics Ofer Lahav Department of Physics and Astronomy University College London * Data compression – e.g. P(k)
Constraints on Dark Energy from CMB Eiichiro Komatsu University of Texas at Austin Dark Energy February 27, 2006.
Constraining the Dark Side of the Universe J AIYUL Y OO D EPARTMENT OF A STRONOMY, T HE O HIO S TATE U NIVERSITY Berkeley Cosmology Group, U. C. Berkeley,
Constraining Dark Energy with Cluster Strong Lensing Priyamvada Natarajan Yale University Collaborators: Eric Jullo (JPL), Jean-Paul Kneib (OAMP), Anson.
Cosmological studies with Weak Lensing Peak statistics Zuhui Fan Dept. of Astronomy, Peking University.
Center for Cosmology and Astro-Particle Physics Great Lakes Cosmology Workshop VIII, June, 1-3, 2007 Probing Dark Energy with Cluster-Galaxy Weak Lensing.
The KAT/SKA project and Related Research Catherine Cress (UKZN/KAT/UWC)
Clustering in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Bob Nichol (ICG, Portsmouth) Many SDSS Colleagues.
Constraining cluster abundances using weak lensing Håkon Dahle Institute of Theoretical Astrophysics, University of Oslo.
MASS AND ENTROPY PROFILES OF X-RAY BRIGHT RELAXED GROUPS FABIO GASTALDELLO UC IRVINE & BOLOGNA D. BUOTE P. HUMPHREY L. ZAPPACOSTA J. BULLOCK W. MATHEWS.
Exotic Physics in the Dark Ages Katie Mack Institute of Astronomy / Kavli Institute for Cosmology, University of Cambridge.
Testing the Shear Ratio Test: (More) Cosmology from Lensing in the COSMOS Field James Taylor University of Waterloo (Waterloo, Ontario, Canada) DUEL Edinburgh,
The masses and shapes of dark matter halos from galaxy- galaxy lensing in the CFHTLS Henk Hoekstra Mike Hudson Ludo van Waerbeke Yannick Mellier Laura.
The Structure Formation Cookbook 1. Initial Conditions: A Theory for the Origin of Density Perturbations in the Early Universe Primordial Inflation: initial.
Cosmology with Gravitaional Lensing
Observational constraints and cosmological parameters Antony Lewis Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge
Michael Doran Institute for Theoretical Physics Universität Heidelberg Time Evolution of Dark Energy (if any …)
Ignacy Sawicki Université de Genève Understanding Dark Energy.
Racah Institute of physics, Hebrew University (Jerusalem, Israel)
中国科学院高能物理研究所 INSTITUTE OF HIGH ENERGY PHYSICS Constraints on the cross-section of dark matter annihilation from Fermi observation of M31 Zhengwei Li Payload.
Cosmic shear and intrinsic alignments Rachel Mandelbaum April 2, 2007 Collaborators: Christopher Hirata (IAS), Mustapha Ishak (UT Dallas), Uros Seljak.
April 3, 2005 The lens redshift distribution – Constraints on galaxy mass evolution Eran Ofek, Hans-Walter Rix, Dan Maoz (2003)
Strong Lensing Surveys and Statistics Dan Maoz. zqzq Survey strategies: Search among source population for lensed cases or Search behind potential lenses.
THE CONNECTION OF NEUTRINO PHYSICS WITH COSMOLOGY AND ASTROPHYSICS STEEN HANNESTAD CERN, 1 OCTOBER 2009 e    
Gravitational lensing: surveys and studies with new instruments.
Probing Cosmology with Weak Lensing Effects Zuhui Fan Dept. of Astronomy, Peking University.
Elinor Medezinski Johns Hopkins University Galaxy Galaxy Lensing in CLASH clusters.
Investigating dark matter halos of galaxies from the COMBO-17 survey Martina Kleinheinrich (Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie, Heidelberg) & Hans-Walter.
Probing Dark Energy with Cosmological Observations Fan, Zuhui ( 范祖辉 ) Dept. of Astronomy Peking University.
Probing dark matter halos at redshifts z=[1,3] with lensing magnification L. Van Waerbeke With H. Hildebrandt (Leiden) J. Ford (UBC) M. Milkeraitis (UBC)
Chapter 25 Galaxies and Dark Matter. 25.1Dark Matter in the Universe 25.2Galaxy Collisions 25.3Galaxy Formation and Evolution 25.4Black Holes in Galaxies.
Mass Profiles of Galaxy Clusters Drew Newman Newman et al. 2009, “The Distribution of Dark Matter Over Three Decades in Radius in the Lensing Cluster Abell.
Dark Energy: The Observational Challenge David Weinberg Ohio State University Based in part on Kujat, Linn, Scherrer, & Weinberg 2002, ApJ, 572, 1.
Cheng Zhao Supervisor: Charling Tao
The Nature of Dark Energy David Weinberg Ohio State University Based in part on Kujat, Linn, Scherrer, & Weinberg 2002, ApJ, 572, 1.
The Dark Side of the Universe L. Van Waerbeke APSNW may 15 th 2009.
Cosmological constraints on neutrino mass Francesco De Bernardis University of Rome “Sapienza” Incontro Nazionale Iniziative di Fisica Astroparticellare.
Constraining Dark Energy with Double Source Plane Strong Lenses Thomas Collett With: Matt Auger, Vasily Belokurov, Phil Marshall and Alex Hall ArXiv:
Bayesian analysis of joint strong gravitational lensing and dynamic galactic mass in SLACS: evidence of line-of-sight contamination Antonio C. C. Guimarães.
Thomas Collett Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge
Thomas Collett Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge
Thomas Collett Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge
Cosmological Constraints from the Double-
Neutrino Masses in Cosmology
Intrinsic Alignment of Galaxies and Weak Lensing Cluster Surveys Zuhui Fan Dept. of Astronomy, Peking University.
Presentation transcript:

Complementarity of weak lensing with other probes Lindsay King, Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge University UK

From Tegmark

Tereno et al future space cosmic shear WMAP-1 + CBI Cosmic shear constraints can be almost orthogonal to CMB shear survey specs Provides lever for parameter constraint on small scales

Lewis 2005 Planck operational ~ end 2008 Ignoring CMB lensing biases parameter estimates Parameter estimation from Planck data

Gratton, Lewis & Efstathiou ‘07Lesgourgues et al. ‘06 Neutrino mass: Ly-alpha forest, CMB lensing, Planck constraints Neutrino masses affect cosmic history & structure formation. A main effect is suppression of power on small scales, roughly proportional to neutrino contribution to matter content.

Testing the CDM paradigm on galaxy cluster scales Cluster mass function and density profiles are a sensitive test of cosmology. Weak lensing probes scales dominated by dark matter; but relies on having sufficient background galaxies. A number of massive high redshift (z~1.4) x-ray clusters have been reported (e.g. Mullis et al. 2005) - possibly indicative of early dark energy (Bartelmann et al. 2006) CMB lensing by clusters as a complementary tool?

Futuristic constraints on clusters from lensing of CMB and weak lensing of galaxies Lewis & King 2006 space-based, galaxy lensing CMB (polarisation) lensing 500 gal/arcmin sq. photo-z estimates  2 x 0.1  K / 0.5 arcmin pixel on Stokes parameters Less futuristic constraints imply CMB lensing better for clusters beyond z~0.8

The inner regions of clusters: home to strongly lensed giant arcs Li et al. (2006) discuss how giant arc statistics seem to be in conflict with WMAP3; o.depth ~6 below  CDM0 (  8 =0.9  m =0.3). Even  CDM0 must be pushed to be consistent with observations! Future surveys will detect thousands of clusters creating giant arcs! Better statistics. Campaigns to obtain photometric/spectroscopic redshifts for lensed objects (to which this analysis is sensitive) will increase the power of arcs as a cosmological tool.

triaxiality Corless & King ‘07 not isolated Lokas et al ‘06 ellipticity in potential Meneghetti et al. (spectroscopy) (lensing) King & Corless ‘07 cM r

Probing dark matter and baryons on small scales Galaxy-galaxy weak lensing probes ensembles of galaxies on scales where dark matter dominates. The relationship between baryons and dark matter, as a function of mass and environment, is essential to understanding both galaxy and cluster formation. Future surveys will contain ~10^5 strongly lensed galaxies, and ~10^3 strongly lensed quasars! Observational requirements covered by weak lensing requirements.

Strong lensing (+/- stellar kinematics) gives galaxy density profiles very close to isothermal inside  E Koopmans et al 2006 Log density slopes for early-type field lenses (SLACS/LSD) Average density profile from time delays of 10 lenses Dobke & King 2006

On larger scales profiles also consistent with isothermal From galaxy-galaxy lensing (e.g. Wilson et al. ‘01, Sheldon et al. ‘04, Mandelbaum et al. ‘06) Weak lensing around SLACS strong lenses (Gavazzi et al. 2007) Gavazzi et al Total density profile close to isothermal over wide range of scales. Outer halos of strong lenses similar to typical field galaxies.

But for galaxies in denser environments: evidence for deviations from isothermal (e.g. Kochanek et al. ‘06, Dobke et al. ‘07, Read et al. ‘07) Simulations show slope changes in strong lensing regions Dobke, King & Fellhauer 2007 Tidal truncation of DM halos seen in very dense environments (e.g. Natarayan et al.‘02, Limousin et al.‘07 Halkola et al.‘07)

On cluster scales probed by weak lensing, halos consistent with NFW.... Isolated galaxies consistent with isothermal.... What about intermediate scales? We’ve started to carry out a search for large separation lenses in SDSS. One of the first discoveries is a 10’’ almost compete Einstein ring; lens is a very massive LRG. Belokurov et al Future large surveys will allow us to detect many lenses, and hence study the interplay between baryons and dark matter as a function of mass and environment.

Testing models of the early universe String loops predicted in different amounts by different brane inflation models Long strings collide & reconnect to form loops Of order 10^5 loops compared with ~40 long strings per horizon volume! Allen & Shellard

Strong lenses - Schwarzschild lens well outside loop. CLASS/JVAS lens surveys demonstrated advantages of targeting compact, flat spectrum, radio sources. Large number of these radio sources in future radio surveys increase detection probability of loop lenses e.g. ~10^8 expected in future half-sky SKA survey. Window on the physics of the early universe? How can we directly detect loops?

CLASS LOFAR SKA (~2020) ~10^8 CRSs Mack, Wesley & King 2007 Looks very promising...

The future of weak lensing from space holds great promise. Along with other tools, tighter constraints on our cosmological model will be obtained. Massive objects can be probed on a wide range of scales, testing the CDM paradigm and helping us better understand structure formation. Future CMB experiments offer a means to study the highest redshift clusters via their lensing signatures. Models of brane inflation will be tested by the presence - or absence - of string loop strong lensing events in future radio surveys such as SKA.