Recent Experiences with the CD Procedure in the UK Jonathan Davey, Partner, Addleshaw Goddard 25 April 2008.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

EU Remedies Directives Update Florence Gregg figpc ltd, M:

Advertisements

Designing a Competitive Dialogue Procedure Jonathan Davey, Partner, Addleshaw Goddard 25 April 2008.

Tendering Yuck!.

EU Procurement – competitive dialogue and case-law Norman Ballantyne Yousof Khan.

Session 8 Implementing PPPs

Using the Competitive Dialogue David Nash Divisional Director, Projects Division Shepherd+ Wedderburn.

Dialogue vs Negotiations: is there any difference? Jonathan Davey, Partner, Head of Commercial Group, Addleshaw Goddard 25 April 2008.

Appendix 6: OJEU Process Chart: Summary Restricted Competitive Dialogue Negotiated with OJEU advert Negotiated Without OJEU advert Submit OJEU Award Notice.

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU PROCUREMENT PROCEDURES FOR THE AWARD OF CONCESSION/PPP CONTRACTS.

Jump to first page Dr. Henry Deng Assistant Professor MIS Department UNLV IS 488 Information Technology Project Management.

GPP in the new PP directives Peter Nohrstedt. Structure of the presentation New PP support organisation in Sweden GPP in the EU PP directives – what is.

MANAGEMENT OF OPERATIONS MAINTAINING QUALITY. LEARNING INTENTIONS/SUCCESS CRITERIA LEARNING INTENTIONS: I understand the different ways that organisations.

MANAGING ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE IN A WORLD OF CONSTANT CHANGE, THE SPOILS GO TO THE NIMBLE.

1 PMIG PUBLIC SECTOR PROCUREMENT BEST PRACTICES & LESSONS LEARNED Kevin James Barrie Kroukamp.

Session No. 3 ICAO Safety Management Standards ICAO SMS Framework

INNOVATIVE PROCUREMENT The Next Steps Anthony Cachia Director (Operations) Department of Contracts.

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Martin Oder, LL.M. The Emerging Role of the Competitive Dialogue.

The Lean Sourcing Process

Creating a service Idea. Creating a service Networking / consultation Identify the need Find funding Create a project plan Business Plan.

Competitive dialogue – a French perspective François Lichère Professor of public law University of Aix-Marseille.

Allied health student training Pre-placement training requirements Welcome to the video-conference. This video-conference will be recorded. Your participation.

Public Contracts Regulations 2015 (became law on 26th February 2015)

27 October 2011 Competitive dialogue in UK PFI PPP Forum Perspective Andrew Briggs, Partner.

Manage Project Procurement Unit Guide Diploma of Project Management Qualification Code BSB51507 Unit Code BSBPMG509A.

Managing Change and Future Challenges in Sport Organizations

1 The Care Act and Social Care Markets June 2014.

Irene Khan – Secretary General Building effective and responsive INGOs, the strategic role of HR: The IS Job Value Review 8 February 2008.

SMS Implementation Lessons Learned CTA COSCAP-NA Kim Trethewey.

Finding a PPP Partner Essential EU Law Considerations Bernard Wilson Maribor, 18 January 2005 Bernard Wilson Maribor, 18 January 2005.

Outsourcing Best Practices SIM – Philadelphia April 1, 2003 Presented by: Michael Speaker President, MSC Services, Inc.

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Ensuring Good Quality PPP Projects Martin Darcy United Kingdom.

Preparing for 2014 and beyond - Implementing Personal Health Budgets Trudy Reynolds Delivery programme, personal health budgets.

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Introducing a New Concessions System – Latvian Experience.

Negotiations in Public Procurement Past, present and (near) future ICEL Dublin February 2013 Pedro Telles.

Lessons Learnt from e-Business Projects Are they any different? Dave Corlett (PMP) & Jane Farley (PMP)

Current Challenges and Future Developments in HTA in the UK Frances Macdonald, 23 rd September 2008 (A personal, Industry View)

National Curriculum Board – ISQ Curriculum Forum Robert Randall, General Manager Brisbane, 25 May 2009.

Gwerth Cymru Value Wales Supplier Selection Nick Sullivan Gwerth Cymru/Value Wales 2 Gorffenaf/July.

Implementation of the Public Procurement Directives in the UK Peter Bennett Office of Government Commerce Vilnius 9 December 2004.

July 14, Rural Electric Cooperatives Procurement/Contracting Guidance Roger Jones Region VIII Disaster Assistance Division.

The Directive on Defence and Security Contracts: Introduction Jonathan Davey, Partner 8 June 2011.

Efficiency East Midlands employment and skills workshop Rhianna John Solicitor, Projects and Construction department Trowers & Hamlins LLP 23 April 2010.

Department of Correctional Services NEW GENERATION CORRECTIONAL CENTRES BRIEFIENG SYNOPSIS DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES.

The use of Competitive Dialogue for major projects in the UK PhD findings 19 October 2011 Susie Smith, Bevan Brittan LLP Richard Craven, University of.

Negotiation Skills Mike Phillips Training Quality Manager

community based support services and personal care

Healthy Young Minds Matter: The Procurement Process John Fuller Assistant Director - Procurement NHS Gloucestershire September 2009.

MGT 461 Lecture #27 Project Execution and Control Ghazala Amin.

Common failures in PPP process management Maarten Groothuis.

Childhood Neglect: Improving Outcomes for Children Presentation P29 Childhood Neglect: Improving Outcomes for Children Presentation Understanding integrated.

MN5131 HRM in International Mergers and Acquisitions.

Change Management. Definition Change management is a structured approach to transitioning individuals, teams, and organizations from a current state.

DECC Framework Contract for Innovation Delivery Support – presentation to potential contractors Thursday 20 October.

Contract Models & Effective Tendering Practices National Commissioning & Contracting Training Conference Martin Quinn Cat Consultancy.

Contract Models & Effective Tendering Practices National Commissioning & Contracting Training Conference 2 nd /3 rd July 2013 Rakesh Mistry Commissioning.

The new EU directives on public procurement and concessions Māris Pūķis, Dr.oec., Dr.phys., Senior adviser Latvian Association of Local and Regional Governments.

EU Funding Support Joe Galloway, Research Support Manager European Team, Research Support Office Friday 1st April 2016.

The Challenge of Deciding What Procurement Method to Use

NHS Commercial Solutions Voluntary Sector Briefing All About Procurement With DGS CCG Andy Glenister – Head of Procurement 20 November 2014.

Options for Future Delivery of Learning Services Brin Martin and Richard Barker 23 rd October

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Ensuring Good Quality PPP Projects Martin Darcy Regional Workshop.

12.2 Conduct Procurements The process of obtaining seller responses, selecting a seller and awarding the contract The team applies selection criteria.

National Commissioning & Contracting

Decision Support System Development

Competitive dialogue – a French perspective

9/16/2018 The ACT Government’s commitment to Performance and Accountability – the role of Evaluation Presentation to the Canberra Evaluation Forum Thursday,

Outcome Harvesting nitty- gritty Promise and Pitfalls of Participatory Design Atlanta, 10:45–11:30 29 October, 2016.

The Lean Sourcing Process

Enablers and Blockers: Public Procurement

Competitive Dialogue/Competitive Procedure with Negotiation

Presentation transcript:

Recent Experiences with the CD Procedure in the UK Jonathan Davey, Partner, Addleshaw Goddard 25 April 2008

Structure of this session History in UK Aims of CD Shape of UK legislation Early UK experiences Current position Some suggestions

History PPP in UK since 1990’s  Manchester Metrolink Project Historically no CD Procedure  Competitive Negotiated Procedure used  “Prior overall pricing” ground  Challenge to use of Negotiated Procedure  Pimlico Schools  Norwich Airport

Aims of CD Provide a flexible procedure suitable for complex PFI/PPP projects whilst minimising risk of distortion Outcome is a compromise  Considerable negotiation required to deliver complex projects  Fear that negotiation aids national or other preferences A practitioner’s view (and separate handout)

Shape of UK legislation Subordinate legislation Four sets of regulations replaced by just two with effect from 31 January 2006:  Public Contracts Regulations 2006  Utilities Contracts Regulations 2006 Remedies Directive

Early UK experiences Significant number of OJEU advertisements placed referring to CD even before UK implementation Large number of existing projects continue using Negotiated Procedure Personal experience – 2 urban regeneration CD adverts prior to UK implementing Regulations

Current position Almost universal replacement of Negotiated Procedure by CD CD in name but not in substance? Frequent pitfalls:  Lazy use of NP documentation/procedures  Failure to define needs and requirements  (still) failure to get Evaluation Criteria and Weightings right (and see Lianakis case)  Poor control of/use of dialogue phase  Uncertainty around closing dialogue  Insufficient development of terms prior to ITT, leading to need for post-PB negotiation going beyond “clarifying and confirming commitments”

Some Suggestions Early work (planning, modelling, team structuring) pays later! CD is a process of communication, not a set of documents Share experiences; use resources; promote best practice Bidder skill; challenge culture (in UK now; in CZ tomorrow?) Be flexible; ensure your documents allow it Maintain momentum but try to resist external deadline pressure

Any questions?

Recent Experiences with the CD Procedure in the UK Jonathan Davey, Partner, Addleshaw Goddard 25 April 2008