1. Describe Emmanuel Goldstein’s theory on revolution in relation to class structure. Who are the perpetrators? What is the result?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Economic Dimensions of the Cold War
Advertisements

The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism
Consider: Can anarchism work? Give one reason why it might. The Last Word: Assignment 1 for tomorrow.
Woodrow Wilson believed in peace, democracy and individual rights. Outlined the fourteen elements which Wilson believed were essential to a lasting peace.
THEORIES ON ART &BEAUTY
Political Culture.
The Enlightenment ca (a.k.a. The Age of Reason)
LIBERALISM AND SOCIALISM Ideologies of the state.
Enlightenment Thinkers
Realism and Pacifism.
What are the two central goals of the inner party?
Unit 7: The World Since 1945 Unit Focus: How has the world changed and developed since the end of WW2 until now?
Bellwork  What is a dystopia? If you can, define dystopia in your own words and give any examples you can think of (movies, books, plays, ect).
The Philosophy of Exotischism Ignorance Is No Excuse 1 Most of us have heard the old expression "ignorance is no excuse for breaking the law". If courts.
Mass Surveillance Ethical Arguments towards a Unifying Ideal Robert Heston.
“The Book” within a Book: Emmanuel Goldstein’s view of Oceania.
GOVERNMENT Write words or draw pictures that come to mind about when you hear the word “government.” What is the reason or purpose for having a government?
Context for 1984 – George Orwell George Orwell was born Eric Blair in India in Educated as a scholarship student at prestigious boarding schools.
Hobbes Hobbes believed that the individual should be seperate from the state and the monarchy and should be equal with each other. - Men.
Marxist Theory.
People and Government. Principles of Government  Population, the most obvious essential feature of a state. ◦ State: a political community that occupies.
Totalitarianism A government in which a political party or group maintains complete control and bans all others.
Chapter 8: Inequality. American Individual Success Model American individual success model: The cultural model shared by many Americans whereby success.
The Hunger Games Vs
Chapters 1and 2 Thinking about Politics and the American Creed.
. "dangerous and alienating future societies"  - criticizing current trends in the author’s culture.  - possible deprivation, oppression, or terror.
Ch5 1 ETHC303 Chapter 5- Privacy Instructor: Dr. Hassan Ismail Abdalla Room: E236.
& By. George Orwell- A man of “lower-upper-middle class” He attended some of England`s most prestigious schools, but with his encounters with the upper.
Hobbes and Rousseau 3 September Hobbes’ approach to conflict Where does conflict come from, for Hobbes? –Desire to preserve your life plus –Rationality.
Gender and Inequality How do different versions of feminism explain gender inequality? What are their strengths and weaknesses?
The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism
1984: Chapter 9 The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism by Emmanuel Goldstein.
Chapter PreviewChapter Preview  Winston gets his hands on Goldstein’s manifesto, but he’s worked so much getting ready for Hate Week that he’s exhausted.
Emmanuel Goldstein’s The Theory and Practices of Oligarchical Collectivism – Oligarchical Collectivism: the political principle of centralized social and.
“’Meanwhile I shall send you a copy of the book--” even O’Brien, Winston noticed, seemed to pronounce the words as though they were in italics---”Goldstein’s.
Activator 5/6 Orwell’s main goals in 1984 are to depict the frightening techniques a totalitarian government (in which a single ruling class possesses.
POLITICAL CULTURE. The American View of the Political System / Elements include: / 1) Liberty / 2) Equality / 3) democracy / 4) Civic duty, individual.
Purpose Theories Categories of Government Types of Government
The world & the democracy This is true that the world people have seen many good changes with the democracy at present working for the people but not without.
For Enlightenment (of this kind) all that is needed is freedom. And the freedom in question is the most innocuous form of all – freedom to make public.
Introduction to Philosophy Lecture 7 The argument from evil By David Kelsey.
American Government and Politics Today Chapter 1 The Democratic Republic.
1984 Daily Journal Questions
 Mill believes liberty is needed for full development of human nature.  Having liberty and being able to make your free choice will flourish your capacity.
1984 (Chapter 1) Read the first chapter and answer the following questions. 1. When does the novel begin? 2. Where does the novel begin? 3. Cite the caption.
BNW, 1984, and Our Society Final Project Examples 2015.
Step Forward Step Back 1.Those who would exchange freedom for security deserve neither. 2.To assure our country’s freedom, the government should be able.
Thomas Hobbes Background on Hobbes A product of the Puritan revolution and the English civil war. Royalist. Opposed to parliamentarianism and.
Before the tardy bell rings… DO THIS QUICKLY AS WE HAVE A TON TO DO TODAY!!! HAVE THE 2 FIGURATIVE LANGUAGE WORKSHEETS FROM TUESDAY ON YOUR DESK TURN TO.
Chapter 1 Introduction: The Citizen and Government.
“The Book”. Superstates Eurasia: Russia, N. Europe, Asiatic land mass Oceania: British, U.S., Americas, British Isles, Australia, Southern Part of Africa.
Chapter 1 Ignorance Is Strength Perpetual Class Struggle of Human Societies A hierarchy has always been present High, middle, low High = ruling class,
Freedom v. Security during WWI. Debt Reduction Every year the government spends more money than it raises from tax revenue. It is able to do so by borrowing.
A.k.a. “Goldstein’s book” Book Two, Chapter 9.  The principal enemy of the state  Former member of the Inner Party Convicted of treason Escaped and.
1984 Overview.
Democracy & Totalitarianism
Essential Features of a State
Pressure Groups.
The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism
The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism
EQ: How do we preview the text of what we will be studying?
The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism
1984 George Orwell Menu Introduction Background Discussion Starters.
The Party And Big Brother.
1/1/2019 George Orwell ( ) George Orwell, 1933.
Historical Context of 1984 Why Orwell Wrote It
Summary and key points from chapter 9 Book 2
The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism
POLITICAL PHILOSPHY IN 1984
Role of Government Chapter 1.
Presentation transcript:

1. Describe Emmanuel Goldstein’s theory on revolution in relation to class structure. Who are the perpetrators? What is the result?

The first chapter, Ignorance is Strength, begins with the observation that throughout history, all societies have been divided into a caste system.

The three groups or classes: The High, who are the rulers; the Middle, who yearn to take over the position of the High, and the Low, who are typically so suppressed that in their drudgery they have no goals beyond day-to-day survival (if they are at all able to formulate any "political" agenda, it is to establish a society where all people are equal).

Time and time again down the ages, the Middle have overthrown the High by enlisting the Low on their side, pretending to the Low that after the revolution a just society will emerge. However, once the Middle have taken over, they simply become the new High and thrust the Low back into servitude, and as a new Middle group eventually splits off, the pattern repeats. The Middle only speak of justice and human brotherhood as long as they are seeking power; once they are in power, they simply become the new oppressors of the Low.

2. Why was this revolution different? What changed? Why?

In the first half of the twentieth century, there was an alarming development: Even before they were in control, the current Middle group did not pretend to others or to themselves that they were seeking freedom and justice for everyone — or anyone. "In each variant of Socialism that appeared from about 1900 onwards the aim of establishing liberty and equality was more and more openly abandoned. The new movements which appeared in the middle years of the century...had the conscious aim of perpetuating unfreedom and inequality."

This is accomplished through a consistent campaign of control This is accomplished through a consistent campaign of control. Language is manipulated to restrict free speech and thought. The elements of fear and mistrust are instilled in the citizens through restrictions of privacy, propaganda, and the concepts of doublethink and groupthink. Technological advancements allow for the impression of total surveillance. Permanent war keeps the citizens employed and united against a scapegoat – as well as providing an enduring poverty, which further prevents the time and impetus for free thought.

3. How did technological developments make an absolute Totalitarian system possible?

In the twentieth century, technological developments had for the first time made an absolutely totalitarian society possible. Electronic gadgets like two-way television ("telescreens") allowed the authorities to keep citizens under constant surveillance and in the equally constant sound of official propaganda. "The possibility of enforcing not only complete obedience to the will of the State, but complete uniformity of opinion on all subjects, now existed for the first time."

4. What is the sole concern (goal) of the Party? How does the Party accomplish this?

The sole concern of the Party was to maintain its own power — not to distribute wealth to all citizens. The Party deliberately creates poverty so that the masses must struggle to stay alive: thus they will not have the leisure to start thinking for themselves.

5. Why doesn’t Oceania (or the other Superstates) fear being overthrown from without, despite the continuous warring?

All three states are too evenly matched for any of them to successfully invade the other. The proletarian masses of Oceania itself will not rise up against the Party, for they are denied any standards of comparison and are thus not even aware that they are suppressed. The sole potential threats against the rule of the Party are therefore "the splitting-off of a new group of able, under-employed, power-hungry people, and the growth of liberalism and skepticism in their own ranks".

6. Explain the meaning of the slogan, “War is Peace 6. Explain the meaning of the slogan, “War is Peace.” By what logical argument can this be claimed as a truth?

The never-ending war between the superstates is seemingly pointless — "it is a warfare of limited aims between combatants who are unable to destroy one another, have no material cause for fighting and are not divided by any genuine ideological difference". All three superstates are based on very much the same totalitarian ideology as Big Brother's Oceania.

However, the Party and its counterparts in the rival superstates have excellent reasons to keep the war going. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, the use of machines in production raised "the living standards of the average human being greatly." It was "clear to all thinking people that the need for human drudgery, and therefore to a great extent for human inequality, had disappeared...hunger, overwork, dirt, illiteracy and disease could be eliminated within a few generations."

However, since the Party wants to maintain a hierarchical society with itself on top, this real possibility of eliminating poverty and inequality is a deadly threat rather than something to be desired: "If leisure and security were enjoyed by all alike, the great mass of human beings who are normally stupefied by poverty would learn to think for themselves" — eventually sweeping away the oligarchy ruling them. "In the long run, a hierarchical society was only possible on a basis of poverty and ignorance."

Since large-scale machine production could not be eliminated once invented, the Party must see to it that the products are destroyed before they can make "the masses too comfortable, and hence, in the long run, too intelligent." A permanent state of war takes care of this problem: resources are deliberately wasted on warfare, and the war effort "is always so planned as to eat up any surplus that might exist after meeting the bare needs of the population...

Research into new weapons continues — but using doublethink, Inner Party administrators are also in some sense aware that the war must never be allowed to end.  

The war is actually "waged by each ruling group against its own subjects, and the object of the war is not to make or prevent conquests of territory, but to keep the structure of society intact".

As far as the lack of any genuine outside threat is concerned, the superstates might just as well agree to live in permanent peace; then they would still be "freed for ever from the sobering influence of external danger" (the kind of danger that might force the rulers to behave somewhat responsibly). This, according to the author, "is the inner meaning of the Party slogan: War is Peace."