Everybody Wants to Rule Your Deal – A Practical Guide to International Merger Control Dave Anderson Partner, Berwin Leighton Paisner LLP Brussels 9 October,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 ETRMA experience F. Cinaralp, Secretary General EC Conference on WTO TBT notification procedure Brussels, 29 March 2007.
Advertisements

THE PUBLIC LENDING RIGHT SITUATION IN EUROPE JIM PARKER APRIL 2011.
IRSES Marie Curie Actions. IRSES FP7 in brief Budget:  Budget of € 50 billion - 4,75 billion for PEOPLE over 7 years ( period)  Increase of.
© 2005 Morrison & Foerster LLP All Rights Reserved Data Security and Incident Notification: The Impact of Foreign Law Presented April 26, 2006 to EDUCAUSE.
Merger Working Group BOS 5 - Outreach: International Merger Enforcement Cooperation and Younger/Newer agencies Dave Anderson – European Commission NGA,
International Merger Enforcement Cooperation and younger/newer agencies ICN Annual Conference, MWG BOS 5, April 29, 2015 Hiromitsu Miyakawa, Jones Day.
Kyriakos Fountoukakos, Partner, Herbert Smith Freehills, Brussels Sydney, 28 April 2015 CHALLENGES IN DESIGNING AND IMPLEMENTING CROSS- BORDER REMEDIES:
Procedure under the Merger Regulation. Procedure – legal documents The Merger Regulation Art. 4 – notification of concentration Art. 7 – suspension of.
Climate Change - International Efforts. Direct Observation of Climate Change Source: IPCC 4AR.
Worldwide System for Conformity Testing and Certification of Electrotechnical Equipment and Components (IECEE) The IECEE Pillar: PEER ASSESSMENTS Mr. Pierre.
© Lloyd’s Regional Watch Content Guide CLICK ANY BOX AMERICAS IMEA EUROPE ASIA PACIFIC.
An introduction to the EU and its legislation. Member States currently 15 –Austria- Ireland –Belgium- Luxembourg –Denmark- Netherlands –Finland- Portugal.
Connection of Piracy and Export and import control International preview Experience of Armenia.
THE OECD’S GLOBAL RELATIONS PROGRAMME IN TAXATION
How can trade contribute to growth and jobs? The role of EU trade policy Signe Ratso Director Directorate General of Trade European Commission.
R&D incentives in South Africa: a sense check of policy implementation Presentation by Mohammed Jada to SCOF 27 August 2014.
Special Interest Group Real Estate Business Plan 2014/ Annual Tax Conference Hong Kong Presented by: Henning-G. Wind.
Information Security Management – Management System Requirements, Code of Practice for Controls, and Risk Management supervision Assistant Professor Dr.
1 ICN Merger Workshop March 10 – 11, 2009 Taipei, Taiwan Panel I: Setting Notification Thresholds “Determining Whether a Filing is Required or Advisable”
Safety Driven Performance Conference 2013 The future of managing asset-intensive businesses John Keefe APM/RBMI Technical Manager Asset Integrity Services.
Speaker: Koen Nomden Guidelines on student and scholar selection (Action 2) Deadline:
The role of ERE in Costumer Protection Eduard Elezi Albanian Regulatory Authority ERE Conference “Albanian Energy Sector, Challenges and Regulation” Tirana,
Introduction to project- Clare Madge. Structure of presentation 1.Welcome 2.Background to the project 3.Tour of the site 4.The project process 5.Evaluation.
A Global Approach for Ex-Products – IECEx UNECE WP.6 Geneva June 2006 Proposal for a new activity: “International legal requirements for explosion.
Special meeting on the Operation of SPS Enquiry Points Gretchen H. Stanton Secretary of the SPS Committee 31 October 2003.
VIETNAM TRAINING WORKSHOP ON M&A EVALUATION SKILLS FOR COMPETITION AUTHORITY OFFICIALS Ha Long Bay, Vietnam, 13 & 14 August 2005.
OECD Review of Russian Statistics Peer Review Mission to Russia April 2012 Tim Davis Head, Global Relations, Statistics Directorate.
OECD Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Organisation and Content Overview.
The Portuguese Competition Authority’s Experience with the ICN Recommended Practices and Anti-Cartel Enforcement Manual Abel M. Mateus President Autoridade.
Environmental issues and local development Partnerships and the Green Economy Styria, 11 th October 2010 Gabriela Miranda
Conformity Assessment and Accreditation Mike Peet Chief Executive Officer South African National Accreditation System.
International Regulatory Trends Sector specific independent regulators separate from line ministries Competition authorities have been given an enhanced.
By: Victoria Macedo and Cody Carvahlo. To provide governments with a setting to discuss effective approaches to economic and social issues. Allows similar.
Marine & Energy Practice Risk and Insurance Seminar Houston 20 September 2004 John Lapsley Chairman Marine & Energy.
International Comparison Program (ICP) Overview of 2003 Round Workshop Goals and Objectives Fred Vogel, Global Manager.
FIDIC MDB Conference Brussels June 2012 © European Bank for Reconstruction and Development 2010 | EBRD Procurement considerations when financing.
Human Factors in Approved Maintenance Organizations: An International Survey Dr. William B. Johnson Chief Scientific & Technical Advisor for Human Factors.
INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS AND COMPETITION LAW. Index 1. Why are competition / antitrust issues important? 2. Merger control 3. Distribution systems 4.
Baker & Hostetler LLP EU Antitrust Enforcement of US Entities: The Aftermath of GE-Honeywell Part II US. Merger Clearance by Gregory J. Casas 1000 Louisiana.
1 MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS IN TURKEY: COMPETITION LAW ASPECTS Ece Gürsoy One Fleet PlaceLevent Cad. Alt Zeren Sokak London EC4M 7WSNo 7/ Levent.
Institute for Austrian and International Tax Law MAP/Arbitration as a means of addressing transfer pricing disputes Dr. Raffaele Petruzzi,
Recent Trends and Developments in Competition Law - Private Enforcement Panel Dave Anderson Berwin Leighton Paisner LLP, Brussels Czech Office for the.
© Enterprise Europe Network South West 2009 The Eurostars Programme Kenny Legg R&D Funding for the Environmental Sector – 29 June 2010 European Commission.
Implementing the new Directives 12 March 2002 Policy Focus Group.
Why is there a need for a European Association for Language Testing and Assessment? Charles Alderson, Lancaster University, Coordinator of ENLTA.
23 January 2016 Gustavo C ARUSO Head, Regulatory Activities Section Division of Nuclear Installations Safety Department of Nuclear Safety and Security.
Who we are 2© 2015 INC Research, LLC Therapeutically specialized teams The complete range of Phase I to IV clinical development services Helping you develop.
2016 Global Manufacturing Competitiveness Index. 2Deloitte and US Council on Competitiveness I 2016 Global Manufacturing Competitiveness IndexCopyright.
Quality Care Standards Mrs. Bente Frokjaer Secretary Community Pharmacy Section of FIP and Mr. Robert L. Grant Pharmacy Guild of New South Wales Australia.
Ana Cristina Hirata Barros Research / Operations Analyst Europe and Central Asia Region THE WORLD BANK Public Availability of Financial Statements by Non-listed.
Investigations: Strategies and Recommendations (Hints and Tips) Leah Lane, CFE Director, Global Investigations, Texas Instruments, Inc.
0 Copyright © 2008 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. Dong Hee Kim, Audit Manager IFRS Conversion For seminar.
Best Practices for Competition Law Enforcement: March 18, 2016 Russell W. Damtoft Associate Director Office of International Affairs United States Federal.
Protect Association Meeting FCA s166 Skilled Person Reviews 4 March 2016 Mark Davies Associate Director Financial Services Group T: E:
Trade Agreements. Free Trade Vs. Protectionism Free Trade: when government put in place policies that allow producers from overseas nations to freely.
Key Points for a Privacy Programme for Multinationals Steve Coope.
Centre for Tax Policy and Administration Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Promoting a Pro-Growth Tax Environment for Global Business.
REPUBLIC OF ALBANIA PUBLIC PROCUREMENT AGENCY Eighth Regional Public Procurement Forum May, 22-25, 2012 Tirana
Introduction to the OECD. 4 key questions Who are we? What do we do? How do we do it? What happens next?
IEC System of Conformity Assessment Schemes for Electrotechnical Equipment and Components.
IEC System of Conformity Assessment Schemes for Electrotechnical Equipment and Components.
IEC System of Conformity Assessment Schemes for Electrotechnical Equipment and Components.
Introduction DSV is a global supplier of transport and logistics services. DSV has offices in more than 70 countries all over the world and an international.
Presented By: Manish Gidwani 10 Kapil Israni 16
Strategic Management and Strategic Competitiveness
Strategic Management and Strategic Competitiveness
International Accounting - The Issues
Citi Virtual Card Accounts – Continued Global Expansion
A Global Approach for Ex-Products
Financial Reporting Policy
Presentation transcript:

Everybody Wants to Rule Your Deal – A Practical Guide to International Merger Control Dave Anderson Partner, Berwin Leighton Paisner LLP Brussels 9 October, 2007

Initial questions… Is everybody trying to rule my deal? Why is everybody trying to rule my deal? Who is trying to rule my deal? –Jurisdiction What do we have to tell them? –Notification How do I deal with all of these bodies trying to rule my deal? –Process and timing

Agenda for today Merger regimes worldwide – common features Around the world tour of major regimes – EMEA, Asia-Pacific, Americas Handling international merger control –Where: jurisdictional information needed/filing decisions –What: notification requirements –How & when: process and timing Q & A Reception

Merger control regimes – common features Jurisdiction – thresholds & exceptions Notification – contacts & forms (Brussels effect) Buyer usually files/responsible for filing Fees Suspension of closing/implementation Investigations –Phase I/phase II and duration –clear/block/change deals unwind, divestments, other commitments –Powers - failure to file on time, failure to reply to information requests, complete without clearance Appeals

Around the world in minutes –Jurisdictional thresholds –Procedure EMEA, Asia-Pacific, Americas The ICN –Guidelines and Recommended Practices –Training officials The good, the ok and the ugly

EMEA (1) EC Merger Regulation – European Commission EU Member States

EMEA (2) Switzerland Israel Russia South Africa Turkey Ukraine

Asia-Pacific Japan Korea Australia and New Zealand Welcome to the club –China – New Anti-monopoly law – comes into force 1 August, 2008 –India – New Competition Act due to come into force by mid-2008 – including mandatory merger notification –Singapore – voluntary; market share tests

The Americas USA Canada Mexico Brazil

More good, less ugly – the ICN effect ICN Guidelines and Recommended Practices on mergers – major multilateral milestone Reform successes – e.g., Belgium, Brazil, Czech, Estonia, Finland, Greece, US, Korea Overall RP implementation –2004 – less than 10% of ICN members had made changes –2006 – 50% of ICN members with merger control regimes had made changes; seven planning changes –Major jurisdictions are leading by example – US, EC, Brazil Peer pressure Training new/young agencies/officials

Your deal – practical guide Where: filing decisions What: notification requirements How & when: process and timing Substantive assessment –market power –public interest

Where - jurisdiction Deal-type/concentration analysis –Mergers, acquisitions, disposals –Watch - JVs, minority stakes, assets, outsourcing Thresholds –Turnover – main tool –Market share –Asset value Exceptions and special sectors Buyer v.s. seller

Where - turnover Calculation - general rules –Gross revenue (not profit) –Acquirer - “group” revenue –Target - only that part being sold Geographic allocation –Main rule - location of customer Last financial year –Adjust for post-year end acquisitions/disposals Special cases – financial/insurance sectors Brussels rules used most often Consider maintaining turnover information for merger control purposes

Where - market share It’s a bit early isn’t it? Yes, but… –Approx. 25 jurisdictions still use market share for establishing jurisdiction –Strong lobby from ICN and businesses to remove National market or relevant market? –Portugal v.s. Brazil Aggregation needed? –Spain v.s. UK ICN effect – Greece, Czech, Brazil, Slovenia, Portugal

Where - assessing jurisdiction Assessment boxes –Box 1 - straightforward yes/no (and voluntary/mandatory) –Box 2 - unclear – more information required? –Box 3 - technical requirement – but candidate for not filing? Box 3 – candidates for not filing –“We may have to file where? Are you crazy?” –Possible factors in considering taking a view: limited/no effects: considering levels of local sales, local assets and local overlap local sanctions/powers aggressiveness of agency risk tolerance illegitimate exercise of jurisdiction – international law Appointing coordinating outside counsel to manage jurisdictional assessment and notification process

What – notification information Deal details Parties’ details/turnover/subsidiaries Internal documents assessing deal Substantive information –Relevant markets –Market shares – parties and competitors –“Story telling” – e.g., entry barriers, buyer power Top customer, supplier, competitor contact details Power of attorney/ translations/ signatures/ authenticated copies Pushing back when needed –Some regimes focus on form not substance –The weird and wacky – when to go with it, when not to

How – timing tips Building merger control timing into deal timing –Preparation of filing –Pre-notification contacts/drafts –Suspension of closing and clock stopping –Contract – conditions/drop dead dates Getting the clocks running –How early can we file? –How early do we have to file – filing deadline jurisdictions –Priority timing filing deadline jurisdictions substantive “lead” jurisdictions longest investigation periods –Is there a short-form/simplified procedure?

How – process tips Internal team – BD/marketing/strategy –Notification information –Post-filing requests for information Aim to tell the same basic story everywhere –“Template” filing – deal/parties/substantive story –May be asked for “waivers”: int’l cooperation Previous/next filings –What did we say last time? keep filings to hand –Merger filings as part of exit/growth strategy avoiding hostages to fortune Dealing with the agencies –Their agendas, capabilities, know-how

How – post-filing/clearance tips Information requests –Fast reactions to avoid/minimise clock stopping Will third parties be involved/consulted? What form does the clearance decision take? Published – protect business secrets Advising agencies about other clearances (peer pressure/timing) Post-clearance obligations (Germany, Greece) Fees (pre/post filing)

Summary Is merger control relevant Obtaining turnover/asset information Assessing jurisdictional thresholds Identifying any lead jurisdictions on timing and substance Preparing notifications – coordination Getting the clocks running Keeping them running Clear and close!

Everybody wants to rule your deal – a practical guide to international merger control Dave Anderson Partner, Berwin Leighton Paisner LLP Brussels 9 October, 2007