Stephen Fine, Ph.D. Director, The Hollows Camp, Ontario, Canada Chair, Education & Research, Ontario Camping Association INTRODUCTION Narrative is the.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Marc Gold & Associates© 4101 Gautier-Vancleave Rd. Ste. 102 Gautier, MS (228) Discovery and Customization The Touchstone of Customization:
Advertisements

Anonymous Services, Hard to Reach Participants, and Issues around Outcome Evaluation Centre for Community Based Research United Way of Peel Region Roundtable.
Barriers to Health Service Utilization by Immigrant Families Raising a Child with a Disability Unmet Needs and the Role of Discrimination.
Open All Areas Partners: difficult to find them (internal and external) and to get them to commit, different goals, coordination of the cooperation, different.
External Team Observation Summary.  Staff has aligned results analysis with the needs of students to set goals ◦ There is a focus on building skills.
Assessment of Service-Learning: Principles and Techniques Barbara A. Holland, Ph.D. Senior Scholar, Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis Director,
Neighbor to Neighbor Lessons learned from a community- based HIV testing partnership: The HIV Minority Community Health Partnership Presented at American.
Ann Gillard, Clifton E. Watts, Peter A. Witt Texas A&M University INTRODUCTION Campers arrive at camp with a range of motivations to attend, from amotivation.
Designing an Effective Evaluation Strategy
Evidence for effective learning and teaching: ways and means Professor Marilyn Hammick July 2009.
Narrowing the achievement gap through curriculum development – probe 6 Natalia Buckler (CUREE) & Michael Jopling (University of Wolverhampton)
Community-Based Participatory Research
Understanding Boards Building Connections: Community Leadership Program.
The word pragmatism is derived from the Greek “pragma” Greek word pragma meaning action, from which the words ‘practice’ and ‘practical’ come.
AMERICAN INSTITUTES FOR RESEARCH Evaluating the Gates Foundation National School District and Networks Grant Program Foundation Theory of Change The American.
Learning through Service: The Contribution of Service- Learning to First Year Pre-Service Teachers Miranda Lin, Ph.D., Alan Bates, Ph.D., & Ashley Olson.
Formulating the research design
Group Mentoring Program Mentor & Mentee Preparation for Mentoring Helping People Succeed.
Helping Leadership Teams and Professional Learning Communities Create the Trust and Structures Needed to Address the Racial Achievement Gap.
Molly Chamberlin, Ph.D. Indiana Youth Institute
Roger Woodruff University of the Western Cape Supervisor: Dr. M. Young An Exploratory Study Of Essential Life Skills For Adolescent Elite Athletes In South.
Refugee Resettlement Program Mario J. Calla Executive Director.
Inclusion Parent Meeting Welcome!
Reaffirmation of Accreditation: Institutional Effectiveness Southern Association of Colleges and Schools February 2008 Stephen F. Austin State University.
Catherine Wehlburg, Ph.D. Assistant Provost for Institutional Effectiveness Texas Christian University TAMU Assessment Conference 2011.
Chapter 19: Mixed Methods Research
In a Conversation Circle.  Introductions What CCSYR is all about Getting to know you  Learning Objectives What is Conversation Circle? Expectations.
+ Using Mixed Methods Research Designs for Research in Teaching and Learning Dr. Elizabeth G. Creamer, Virginia Tech Dr. Beth Mac Donald, Utah State University.
1 Bratislava, 12 Feb Roma Employment – Challenges and Barriers What do we know about Roma Employment in Central and Eastern Europe? Europe and CIS.
From Evidence to Action: Addressing Challenges to Knowledge Translation in RHAs The Need to Know Team Meeting May 30, 2005.
A Qualitative Analysis of Student Alumni Reflective Adult Perceptions of the Impact of a Just Community School ( ) Jacqueline Horan, M.A. 1, Ann.
Measuring the Value of Your Volunteer Efforts Nikki Russell Volunteer Initiatives Manager United Way of King County.
Growing Innovations in Rural Sites of Learning: Learning Together Elluminate meeting #2 – December, 2011.
The Evaluation Plan.
Building an Information Community: IT and Research Working Together Responsive Evaluation in the Community College: An Alternative Approach to Evaluating.
Making the most of it: Assessing impact with small data sets Susanna Dilliplane, PhD Deputy Director Aspen Planning and Evaluation Program ANDE Annual.
Evidence from 26 U.S. Jewish Population Studies on Adult Jewish Engagement.
Week 8: Research Methods: Qualitative Research 1.
Research Design & the Research Proposal Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches Dr. Mary Alberici PY550 Research Methods and Statistics.
The challenge and promise of community based participatory research 1.
Connecting University and County Resources to Answer: What difference are we making? How can we continuously improve?
All together now! The impact of the ‘Music for Health’ pilot project on the emotional health and well- being of vulnerable children in Bath and North East.
Involve Lifelong Learning niace.org.uk.
Developing and Writing Winning Individual, Corporate and Foundation Proposals Robin Heller, Director, Corporate and Foundation Philanthropy, BBBSA Robert.
What We've Learned: How Service Prepares Individuals for Employment and Post-Secondary Education Sheila Fesko Dana Carpenter.
April Anderson-Vizcaya California State University Long Beach May 2012.
Public Health Advocacy in Low Income Settings: Views and Experiences on Effective Strategies and Evaluation of Health Advocates in Malawi IFGH Conference:
Engineering Education International Diversity in Graduate Engineering Education: Development of a Multi Institutional Survey Erin Crede Maura Borrego Department.
Gulf of Maine and the World Ocean REU Efforts to Increase Minority Participation in the Ocean Sciences David M. Fields, Rebecca A.
Donor perspectives on planning and evaluation Janice Astbury The J.W. McConnell Family Foundation.
Connecting Learners to their Career, Community & the Future
Marianne Bird, University of California Cooperative Extension Aarti Subramaniam, 4-H Center for Youth Development INTRODUCTION On the Wild Side is an environmental.
Nursing research Is a systematic inquiry into a subject that uses various approach quantitative and qualitative methods) to answer questions and solve.
Evaluation of the Quebec Community Learning Centres: An English minority language initiative Learning Innovations at WestEd May 21, 2008.
Interviews By Mr Daniel Hansson.
2014 Accreditation Updates Our mission: HIPPY partners with parents to prepare their children for success in school.
Accountability & Effectiveness Innovation Network, Inc. January 22, 2003.
Statewide Evaluation Cohort 7 Overview of Evaluation March 23, 2010 Mikala L. Rahn, Ph.D.
SH EYFS EYFS Early Years Foundation Stage From birth – 5 years.
- CAT 1 - Developing the Organization: By Recognizing the Importance and Relevance of Student Voices in Developing a Positive School Climate.
Pamela D. Ennis. Video recording of this presentation can be found at: dx0&feature=youtu.be.
Bringing the Power of Patient Narrative to Patient Submissions Zal Press, PatientCommando.com Michael Houlahan, Type 1 Diabetes Think Tank Network Going.
Primary Social & Emotional Aspects of Learning Theme 1: New beginnings.
Social networking and career management skills Kane Needham & John Mowbray Careers guidance research workshop 3D Social Networking © Photo by: Potter,
Highland Community School District Instructional Rounds October 15, 2009.
So You Think You’ve Made a Change? Developing Indicators and Selecting Measurement Tools Chad Higgins, Ph.D. Allison Nichols, Ed.D.
Reading Discussion – s519 by Peter Hall – 1/21/09 Ryan, J., McClure, C. R., & Bertot, J. C. (2001). Choosing measures to evaluate networked information.
What is the Foundation Stage?
Partnership for Preparing for Adulthood
Injury epidemiology- Participatory action research and quantitative approaches in small populations Lorann Stallones, PhD Professor and Director, Colorado.
Presentation transcript:

Stephen Fine, Ph.D. Director, The Hollows Camp, Ontario, Canada Chair, Education & Research, Ontario Camping Association INTRODUCTION Narrative is the heart of this study. When we tell a story we are expressing how an experience has touched us or been personally meaningful. Studies into the phenomenon of camp often utilize pre- camp post-camp designs which account for immediate and short-term outcomes. Throughout more rigorous longitudinal designs the outcomes still do not have a generational reach. Over all quantitative designs prevail utilizing a variety of measurement instruments often not compatible with one another making convergence of data and meta-analysis problematic. To determine the long-term effects of camp experiences necessitated a combination of both QUANT and QUAL data with an emphasis on listening to the recollections of former campers and staff. METHODS The research employed both qualitative and quantitative strategies. The approach was sequential and exploratory with three phases of data collection 1) camp director’s participant observation, 2) personal interviews with camp alumni, and 3) a survey for current campers. The process is representative of the pragmatic paradigm and the case study approach and is effectively triangulated through mixed- methods. 17 camp alumni, 113 campers and their parents signed consents. Alumni were interviewed twice. The convergence of these data served to mutually verify the research results. ABSTRACT The value of summer camp is not evident to everyone. Newcomers to Canada and the U.S.A., members of traditional ethnic communities, and parents who never attended camp themselves are all potential market groups. As these market populations grow this lack of appreciation is becoming particularly evident to the summer camp industry. One way to assess the value of an experience is to explore the long-term outcome. This research focuses on the question: Do summer camp experiences have any significant impact on the lives of adults in later life? The narratives of 17 camp alumni express how their camp experiences have been meaningful and advantageous. The data covers a generational span of 30 years. QUAL data from alumni narratives were triangulated with additional QUAL and QUANT data from the camp director and 113 campers respectively. Findings showed that camp developed: intrinsic motivation which transferred to later life situations, successful social networking skills, ethical behaviour, parenting skills, and an acceptance of others regardless of ethnicity or social standing. Camp conditioning and/or sustained social networks often assisted in the resolving of personal difficulties. RESULTS PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS The positive long-term outcomes of the camp experience as expressed in this study: Provides relevant and authenticated testimonials that allows potential access to new markets, including the children of first generation Canadians and Americans, newcomers, and parents who have never attended camp. Are of value for camps and camp organizations that rely on funding from external sources. Increases the visibility and public profile of accredited camps and camp associations. Further attests to the capacity for camps to provide successful youth development programs. Speaks to all levels of government. The Generational Reach of the Camp Experience Alumni Perspectives 2007 ACA Camp Research Symposium, Austin, Texas Experience as a counsellor lead to successful skills as a parent. Camp teaches acceptance of others regardless of ethnicity or social standing. Understandings from camp often assisted in resolving personal challenges: “a foundation for understanding [my] world” and “something to fall back on when the hard times come.” Recurring themes which emerged from the interviews with camp alumni were that: Learning in the camp setting was remembered with great clarity. Camp experiences were considered important and life shaping. Camp developed intrinsic motivation which transferred to later life situations. Camp developed successful social networking skills and ethical behaviour. The Hollows Camp