Exposure to bisphosphonates and risk of non-gastrointestinal cancers: nested case-control studies SAPC 2013, Nottingham Yana Vinogradova, Carol Coupland, Julia Hippisley-Cox
Background Bone loss and bisphosphonates Laboratory linkages with reduced cancer risk Anti-tumor properties, accumulation in different organs Treatment for osteoporosis and cancer risk Reduced risk of breast cancer Chlebowski (2010) Newcomb (2010) Rennert (2010) Vestergaard (2011) No associations for other cancers Cardwell (2011)
QResearch –EMIS –660 GP practices Clinical Practice Research Datalink –Main (EHR)-IT –643 GP practices Patient level data from GP clinical records Anonymised Longitudinal data for 20+ years Validated externally and internally Industry independent
Methods: Study design Nested case control study Study period Jan 1997 – July 2011 Aged 50 – 100 At least 2 years of records Up to 5 controls matched by –Age –Sex –Practice –Calendar year
Methods: Assessment of Exposure excluding 6 months before the index date use: at least 1 script short-term (<12m), long-term users different types of bisphosphonates
Methods: Confounding factors BMI, ethnicity, smoking, alcohol Osteoporosis Morbidities (rheumatoid arthritis, diabetes, benign breast disease, GI disorders, hypertension) Family history of cancers Other medications (NSAIDs, corticosteroids, acid-lowering drugs, vitamin D, HRT)
Methods: Statistical analysis Multiple imputations Conditional logistic regression Combined analysis –Odds ratios + 95% CI –1% significance level
QRESEARCH Cases: exposed total Breast ,489 Prostate 46026,554 Lung ,961 Bladder 274 7,464 Melanoma 241 4,998 Ovary 204 3,427 Pancreas 178 3,593 Uterus 99 2,248 Cervix % users CPRD Cases: exposed total Breast ,444 Prostate 37623,176 Lung ,059 Bladder 280 7,084 Melanoma 178 4,621 Ovary 170 3,088 Pancreas 196 3,485 Uterus 96 2,149 Cervix % users
Any use of bisphosphonates and risk of cancer QResearch CPRD
Any use of bisphosphonates and risk of cancer, combined analysis P-trend=0.2 P-trend=0.005 P-trend=0.02 P=0.004 P=0.003
Prostate cancer: long-term use of bisphosphonates
Prostate cancer: types of bisphosphonates QResearch CPRD P=0.004 Ptrend=0.009
Summary of findings Use of bisphosphonates is not associated with increased risk of any of the most common cancers Decreased risk of breast, prostate and pancreatic cancers had no duration relationship in either database Decreased risk of prostate cancer associated with alendronate use only in QResearch
Residual confounding as no information –on stage of cancer –on any cancer-related tests –on bone density test Information on prescriptions only Missing data Large sample size and representative population Data electronically collected – unlikely misclassification bias Data collected before diagnosis – no recall bias All cases used – no selection bias Data in the last 6 months before the diagnosis was excluded as might be misleading Based on the most recent data Limitations and Strengths
Thank you Questions?