Groundwater Arsenic Concentrations and Cancer Incidence Rates: A Regional Comparison in Oregon Harmony Fleming, MS Anna K Harding, PhD Department of Public.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Sources and effects of bias in investigating links between adverse health outcomes and environmental hazards Frank Dunstan University of Wales College.
Advertisements

Statistical Analysis and Data Interpretation What is significant for the athlete, the statistician and team doctor? important Will Hopkins
Ellen F. Heineman, Ph.D. National Cancer Institute Epidemiology & Genetics Research Program The GIS for the Long Island Breast Cancer Study Project.
CONCEPTS UNDERLYING STUDY DESIGN
Chi-Squared Hypothesis Testing Using One-Way and Two-Way Frequency Tables of Categorical Variables.
Environmental exposures  Cancer risks:  Tobacco smoke  Radon in homes  Arsenic.
BEN ANDERSON PROJECT MANAGER UNIVERSITY OF LOUISVILLE CENTER FOR HAZARDS RESEARCH AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT Using Dasymetric Mapping.
SPATIAL DATA ANALYSIS Tony E. Smith University of Pennsylvania Point Pattern Analysis Spatial Regression Analysis Continuous Pattern Analysis.
Sociology 601 Class 13: October 13, 2009 Measures of association for tables (8.4) –Difference of proportions –Ratios of proportions –the odds ratio Measures.
Chance, bias and confounding
Food Accessibility in Wisconsin: Comparison of Self-Report, Direct Observation, and Mapping Data ResultsKey Findings Results Conclusions Background Results.
Introduction to Risk Factors & Measures of Effect Meg McCarron, CDC.
1 Lauren E. Finn, 2 Seth Sheffler-Collins, MPH, 2 Marcelo Fernandez-Viña, MPH, 2 Claire Newbern, PhD, 1 Dr. Alison Evans, ScD., 1 Drexel University School.
Incorporating neighborhood context into the study of health outcomes Jennifer F. Culhane, MPH, PhD Drexel University College of Medicine Department Of.
12.The Chi-square Test and the Analysis of the Contingency Tables 12.1Contingency Table 12.2A Words of Caution about Chi-Square Test.
Two-Way Tables Two-way tables come about when we are interested in the relationship between two categorical variables. –One of the variables is the row.
Statistics 303 Chapter 9 Two-Way Tables. Relationships Between Two Categorical Variables Relationships between two categorical variables –Depending on.
Statistical Analysis SC504/HS927 Spring Term 2008 Week 17 (25th January 2008): Analysing data.
Study Design and Measures of Disease Frequency Intermediate Epidemiology.
SPATIAL DATA ANALYSIS Tony E. Smith University of Pennsylvania Point Pattern Analysis Continuous Pattern Analysis Spatial Regression Analysis.
Data Analysis Statistics. Levels of Measurement Nominal – Categorical; no implied rankings among the categories. Also includes written observations and.
Environmental Public Health Tracking: Some Records are Vital Suzanne K. Condon, Director Bureau of Environmental Health Massachusetts Department of Public.
Evaluation of Childhood Cancer Incidence in Sandwich, MA: Present Massachusetts Department of Public Health Center for Environmental Health Community.
Spatial Statistics for Cancer Surveillance Martin Kulldorff Harvard Medical School and Harvard Pilgrim Health Care.
Descriptive Epidemiology
Comorbidity in SLE Compared with Rheumatoid Arthritis and Non-inflammatory Disorders Frederick Wolfe 1, Kaleb Michaud 1,2, Tracy Li 3, Robert S. Katz 4.
Medical Statistics (full English class) Ji-Qian Fang School of Public Health Sun Yat-Sen University.
Lecture 3: Measuring the Occurrence of Disease
Multiple Choice Questions for discussion
1 Journal Club Alcohol, Other Drugs, and Health: Current Evidence January–February 2014.
CHP400: Community Health Program - lI Research Methodology. Data analysis Hypothesis testing Statistical Inference test t-test and 22 Test of Significance.
Health Consultation: Evaluation of Cancer Incidence in Census Tracts of Attleboro and Norton, Massachusetts: Suzanne K. Condon Associate Commissioner.
ATSDR’s approach to site assessment and epidemiologic considerations for multisite studies Steve Dearwent, PhD, MPH Chief, Health Investigations Branch.
Association between area- level poverty and HIV diagnoses, and differences by sex, New York City Ellen Wiewel, HIV Epidemiology & Field Services.
1/26/09 1 Community Health Assessment in Small Populations: Tools for Working With “Small Numbers” Region 2 Quarterly Meeting January 26, 2009.
Evidence-Based Medicine 3 More Knowledge and Skills for Critical Reading Karen E. Schetzina, MD, MPH.
An Analysis of Childhood Asthma and Environmental Exposures in Utah Michelle Gillette, M.P.H. Office of Epidemiology Utah Department of Health.
There are two main purposes in statistics; (Chapter 1 & 2)  Organization & ummarization of the data [Descriptive Statistics] (Chapter 5)  Answering.
POTH 612A Quantitative Analysis Dr. Nancy Mayo. © Nancy E. Mayo A Framework for Asking Questions Population Exposure (Level 1) Comparison Level 2 OutcomeTimePECOT.
Community Health Needs Assessment Introduction and Overview Berwood Yost Franklin & Marshall College.
Baseline Analysis of Ground Water Quality Around Open Dumpsites in Lagos, Nigeria: Focus on Polynucelar Aromatic Hydrocarbons. Baseline Analysis of Ground.
1 Clinical Investigation and Outcomes Research Research Using Existing Databases Marcia A. Testa, MPH, PhD Department of Biostatistics Harvard School of.
Ecoinformatics, Environmental Research: Current progress, research strategies and needs Ispra, Italy Jan 17 – 20, 2006 Environmental Public Health Indicators:
Various topics Petter Mostad Overview Epidemiology Study types / data types Econometrics Time series data More about sampling –Estimation.
Trend and Levels of Liver Cancer Mortality in the Upper Northeastern of Thailand: A Case Study of Using Google Earth in Public Health Patarapan Odton 1.
Chapter-8 Chi-square test. Ⅰ The mathematical properties of chi-square distribution  Types of chi-square tests  Chi-square test  Chi-square distribution.
Urban-Rural Inequalities in Potentially Preventable Hospital Admissions Carolyn Hunter-Rowe Senior Health Intelligence Analyst Department of Public Health.
CHAPTER INTRODUCTORY CHI-SQUARE TEST Objectives:- Concerning with the methods of analyzing the categorical data In chi-square test, there are 2 methods.
BC Jung A Brief Introduction to Epidemiology - XIII (Critiquing the Research: Statistical Considerations) Betty C. Jung, RN, MPH, CHES.
F UNCTIONAL L IMITATIONS IN C ANCER S URVIVORS A MONG E LDERLY M EDICARE B ENEFICIARIES Prachi P. Chavan, MD, MPH Epidemiology PhD Student Xinhua Yu MD.
Analyzing the Geospatial Imbalance of the Primary Care Physician Labor Supply in the Contiguous United States By Russ Frith University of W. Florida Capstone.
Asthma is the most prevalent chronic illness among children and adolescents, reported in 1 in 10 children. 1 With an estimated 10.5 million missed days.
Organization of statistical research. The role of Biostatisticians Biostatisticians play essential roles in designing studies, analyzing data and.
CHAPTER INTRODUCTORY CHI-SQUARE TEST Objectives:- Concerning with the methods of analyzing the categorical data In chi-square test, there are 3 methods.
BIOSTATISTICS Lecture 2. The role of Biostatisticians Biostatisticians play essential roles in designing studies, analyzing data and creating methods.
1 Bandit Thinkhamrop, PhD.(Statistics) Dept. of Biostatistics & Demography Faculty of Public Health Khon Kaen University Overview and Common Pitfalls in.
Headlines Introduction General concepts
Chapter 3 Descriptive Statistics for Qualitative Data.
Introduction to Biostatistics, Harvard Extension School, Fall, 2005 © Scott Evans, Ph.D.1 Contingency Tables.
Stephen Nkansah-Amankra, PhD, MPH, MA 1, Abdoulaye Diedhiou, MD, PHD, H.L.K. Agbanu, MPhil, Curtis Harrod, MPH, Ashish Dhawan, MD, MSPH 1 University of.
ARSENIC By: Marqita Tebeau. What is Arsenic? Arsenic is an element that occurs naturally in soil, bedrock, groundwater and ocean water. Arsenic is an.
BREAST CANCER BY STAGE OF DISEASE AT DIAGNOSIS, CENTRAL OKLAHOMA Arthur Owora, MPH; Aaron Wendelboe, PhD; David Thompson, PhD; Janis Campbell, PhD The.
Introduction to General Epidemiology (2) By: Dr. Khalid El Tohami.
Closer to home “…older farmers, faced with financial difficulties, hint that the only way out may be to commit suicide so that their families can receive.
Residential Segregation: A Key Connector Between Race and Environmental Health Disparities Jennifer Davis, Sacoby Wilson, Muhammad Salaam, Rahnuma Hassan.
Statistics & Evidence-Based Practice
Groundwater Arsenic Contamination in the United States
ANALYSIS SPATIAL DATA University of Pennsylvania
Research Techniques Made Simple: Interpreting Measures of Association in Clinical Research Michelle Roberts PhD,1,2 Sepideh Ashrafzadeh,1,2 Maryam Asgari.
Effect Modifiers.
Presentation transcript:

Groundwater Arsenic Concentrations and Cancer Incidence Rates: A Regional Comparison in Oregon Harmony Fleming, MS Anna K Harding, PhD Department of Public Health Oregon State University

Background: Chronic exposure to arsenic in drinking water has been linked to both carcinogenic and non- carcinogenic health effects in humans. Health effects associated with inorganic exposure include: – –tumors of the bladder, kidney, liver, and lung; blood vessel damage; – –reproductive and developmental effects; neurological effects; peripheral vascular and cardiovascular disease; diabetes mellitus; and – –dermal effects such spotted melanosis, leucomelanosis and keratosis and basal cell cancer of the skin.

Background: Primary exposure route is ingestion from drinking water due to contamination in groundwater from dissolution of natural mineral deposits, industrial effluent and drainage problems. Current MCL for public water systems is 10 ppb (2006) which was reduced from 50 ppb Considerable proportion (25%) of Pacific NW population relies on private wells for domestic water supply—no enforceable MCL Known “hot spots” for higher arsenic levels in at least two geographic areas in Oregon—Willamette Valley and southeastern Oregon Known “hot spots” for higher arsenic levels in at least two geographic areas in Oregon—Willamette Valley and southeastern Oregon Interest in investigating if the population drawing groundwater from these areas at higher risk of cancer Interest in investigating if the population drawing groundwater from these areas at higher risk of cancer

Study Objectives: Determine if there is a spatial relationship between arsenic concentrations in the Willamette Valley and Southeast Oregon and incidence rates of bladder, liver, lung, and kidney cancers Contribute to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s development of the Environmental Public Health Tracking network by using secondary data to investigate linkages of arsenic in groundwater and associated health effects Serve as an exploratory tool for identifying a public health concern that can be followed up with comprehensive analytical studies of the region

Data sets used for analyses: Oregon State Cancer Registry; bladder, liver, lung & kidney cancer data for the year Oregon Department of Human Services Drinking Water Program; community water system arsenic data U.S. Geological Survey National Water Inventory System; groundwater arsenic data U.S. Census Bureau; population data from 2000 Census

Limitations of Secondary Data: Data sets used to answer research questions had not been collected for the purpose of identifying causal relationships between arsenic concentrations and cancer incidence. Arsenic exposure is inferred by the presence of arsenic in groundwater that is known to supply domestic water supplies. An implied surrogate exposure may not accurately represent the actual exposure of the population. Cancer cases located in rural areas not always geocodable by state cancer registry (e.g. only 58% of cases in Harney County were included) Cancer cases located in rural areas not always geocodable by state cancer registry (e.g. only 58% of cases in Harney County were included)

Methods: Data were analyzed both statistically and spatially using SAS, Excel and ArcGIS. The three independent variables; arsenic concentration, age and sex were grouped into intervals for the analyses: CategoryValues Age (reference group) Sex 1 - male 2 - female (reference group) Census Tract Quintile 1 - quintile 1 (0-0.9 ppb) (reference group) 2 - quintile 2 (1-10 ppb) 3 - quintile 3 ( ppb) 4 - quintile 4 ( ppb) 5 - quintile 5 (≥50.1ppb)

Statistical Methods: A spatial representation of the data was created with ArcGIS by linking the arsenic concentration and census tract attributes of the study area. Use Chi-square to compare the observed cancer cases (for each cancer type) to the expected cancer case count for the five census tract groups for both genders. Poisson regression was used to attempt to determine if significant differences of observed cancer occurrence exist within the three categories; age, gender and census tract quintile groups. Spatial Display:

Maps of Aggregate Arsenic Concentration Data

The Maps show that: Arsenic in groundwater is widely distributed throughout the regions. Arsenic concentration levels vary greatly between census tracts located in close proximity Aggregated values of arsenic are the mean of all arsenic samples within a census tract from both the USGS data and DWP community water system data. Aggregated concentration values in some cases were considerably lower than the highest sample value. Obvious limitation to accurately estimating arsenic concentrations in groundwater.

Results: Cancer Type:BladderKidneyLiverLungOverall df = 4 Sex & Quintile (all age intervals) Chi- square P value Chi- square P value Chi- squa re P value Chi- square P value Chi- square P value Male Quintile Male Quintile Male Quintile Male Quintile Male Quintile Female Quintile Female Quintile Female Quintile Female Quintile Female Quintile Table 1. Chi-square Values for Age & Sex-specific Incidence Rates: Differences between Observed & Expected Cancer Counts

Results: The Chi-square values among all the individual cancer types resulted in non-significant values suggesting arsenic concentration did not contribute to differences between the observed and expected cancer counts within the study area.

Results: CombinedBladderKidney Risk Ratio 95% CI P value Risk Ratio 95% CI P value Risk Ratio 95% CI P value Quintile 5 (≥50.1 ppb) Quintile 4 ( ppb) Quintile 3 ( ppb) Quintile 2 (1-10 ppb) Quintile 1 (0-0.9ppb) Reference Group 1.0N/AN/A1.0N/AN/A1.0N/AN/A LiverLung Risk Ratio 95% CI P value Risk Ratio 95% CI P value Quintile 5 (≥50.1 ppb) Quintile 4 ( ppb) Quintile 3 ( ppb) Quintile 2 (1-10 ppb) Quintile 1 (0-0.9ppb) Reference Group 1.0N/AN/A1.0N/AN/A Table 2. Risk Ratios and Confidence Intervals for Arsenic Concentration

Results: The individual regression analysis of each cancer type and the combined group resulted in non-significant results indicating that higher arsenic concentrations did not increase the incidence rate of the four cancers (bladder, kidney, liver and lung) after adjusting for age and sex.

Conclusions: The use of geographic information systems (GIS) provides the platform to analyze health effects in proximity to environmental hazards, which is important for public health intervention & prevention activities—great potential for EH studies. Spatial study of groundwater arsenic and associated health outcomes had not been previously done in Oregon—secondary data had definite limitations The results contradicted numerous epidemiologic studies that have found a positive association between arsenic ingestion and increased cancer incidence.

Conclusions: The statistical and spatial analytical problems inherent to substituting individual-level data with aggregate data may not have identified the actual risk to individuals. – –Surrogate exposure levels are not the optimal measurement for analysis but when used with a GIS, they may give a better understanding of associations between environmental contaminants and disease rates. Majority of census tracts fall into Quintiles 1 and 2, which are below MCL Missing cases in rural areas might contribute to underestimation of cancer incidence rates in these census tracts