Non Invasive Brain Computer Interfaces for Communication and Control Fabio Babiloni Department of Physiology and Pharmacology, University of Rome “La Sapienza” Fabio Babiloni Department of Physiology and Pharmacology, University of Rome “La Sapienza”
Technologies for the study of brain functions Epilepticus sic curabitur ('The way to cure an epileptic') Sloane Manuscript, collection of medical manuscripts, end of the 12th century - British Museum, London Epilepticus sic curabitur ('The way to cure an epileptic') The surgical treatment of epilepsy is not a recent innovation. As early as ancient Greek and Roman times, and in the Middle Ages, trepanation (the opening of the skull) was occasionally carried out on people with epilepsy. There were many different reasons for doing this, however. There was seldom a rational, medical reason for the operation, for instance to raise a piece of the skull cap which had entered the inner part of the skull as a result of an injury, perhaps in war, and which was thought to cause epileptic seizures in the patient. In such a case, the surgeon tried to raise the piece of bone and thus remove the cause of the epilepsy. Mostly, however, there were mystical, superstitious reasons for the trepanation operations which were performed. It was thought that opening the skull cap would cause the demons of the sickness, poisonous gases or disease-causing juices to escape. The practice of cauterisation was based on the same beliefs. In this picture, the person with epilepsy ('epilepticus') is undergoing both procedures - trepanation and cauterisation - at the same time.
Technologies for the study of brain functions Cauterisation (15th century) Image taken from the first medical textbook "Cerrahiyyet'ül Haniyye", written in Ottoman language by the Turkish surgeon Serafettin Sabuncuoglu. Cauterisation (15th century) Image taken from the first medical textbook "Cerrahiyyet'ül Haniyye", written in Ottoman languageby the Turkish surgeon Serafettin Sabuncuoglu. From the Ancient World to the Middle Ages, cauterisations were also used in the treatment of epilepsy.
Hyeronimus Bosch, The stone of madness, El Prado, Madrid
The scene painted by Jan Sanders van Hemessen shows a stone cutter at a fair. The surgeon, who is clearly happy that his operations have been successful, painstakingly moves his knife towards the stone, which is already visible. Behind him hang stones which have been successfully cut out of the head of other patients as a sign of his skill. Next to the quack stands a man who is wringing his hands in desperation - he is clearly going to be the next patient under the scalpel Jan Sanders Van Hemessen (1500-1566), The surgeon 1550, El Prado, Madrid
Variations of EEG waves are correlated with some mental states 8-12 Hertz, mu EEG waves Variation of oscillations and absolute level of amplitude can be modulated by the experimental subject 8-12 Hertz, alpha EEG waves
“To move things is all that mankind can do; … for such the sole executant is muscle, whether in whispering a syllabe or in felling a forest.” Sir Charles Sherrington, 1924
What a BCI is “Brain–computer interfaces (BCI’s) give their users communication and control channels that do not depend on the brain’s normal output channels of peripheral nerves and muscles.” “A BCI changes the electrophysiological signals from mere reflections of CNS activity into the intended product of the activity: messages and commands that act on the world” Wolpaw, 2002 8
Modification of Brain Signals BCI: logical scheme Increase of performance appropriate feature extraction Modification of Brain Signals Signal Features computer training user training Psychological Effort (Intention) Classification Of Intent Environment appropriate feedback strategy
Movement-related thoughts elicited specific cortical patterns Neuroscientific studies with fMRI have demonstrated that motor and parietal areas are involved in the imagination of the limb movements Several EEG studies have also demonstrated that imagined movements elicited desynchronization patterns different for right and left movement imaginations Imagined left movement Executed left movement
EEG features for BCIs Detection of mu rhythm modulation Detection of P300 Detection of Slow Cortical Potentials Detection of steady-state VEPs SINC 2007 11 11
Sensory motor rhythms SMR is a 8-12 Hz oscillatory rhythm of the brain’s electrical activity. It is detected on the central electrode sites (over the sensorimotor cortex) It is associated with inhibition of motor activity From Wolpaw et al. 2002, Clinph 12 12
EEG features for BCIs Detection of mu rhythm modulation Detection of P300 Detection of Slow Cortical Potentials Detection of steady-state VEPs SINC 2007 13 13
P300 Potential P300 potentials The P300 is an event-related potential, dominating at parietal electrode sites. P300 follows unexpected sensory stimuli or stimuli that provide task related information P300 speller From Selllers & Donchin 2006, clinph
Research Applications Speller “Symbolic” Communication Game Environment Control “Virtual” Mobility Mobility Neuroprosthesis
Ministero degli Affari Esteri Progetto “Brain Computer Interfaces Between China and Italy (BCI2)” Speller Credits: F. Aloise F. Babiloni U. Sapienza, Roma S. Gao Tsinghua Univ., RPC B. Hong
Fondazione Banca Nazionale della Comunicazione Progetto “Inclusione nella ICT di soggetti affetti da grave disabilità motoria tramite…” Game Credits: F. Aloise F. Babiloni U. Sapienza, Roma
Fondazione Telethon Progetto “ASPICE” “Virtual” Mobility Credits: F. Aloise G. Oriolo U. Sapienza, Roma A. Cherubini
European Commission – 6th Framework Programme Progetto “MAIA” FP6 Mobility Credits: J. Millàn IDIAP, CH M. Nuttin KU Leuven. B F. Cincotti FSL
P300-based control of a domestic environment
Neuroprosthesis Credits: F. Babiloni F.Aloise F. Cincotti FSL M.C. Carrozza SSSA, Pisa
Future trends “It’s always hard to make prediction, especially about the future” “640 KB RAM will be adequate for everybody in the future” Bill Gates, 1981 IBM “Computers are interesting, but the mondial market for them is limited in the future to not more of 5 pieces per year” Thomas Watson, IBM president, 1949 “People will not wear scalp electrodes during normal daylife” Chief of Research and Development of a mobile phone company