The World Bank Implementing Financial Management Information System Projects: Selected Lessons from IFMIS Community of Practice Bill Dorotinsky October.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

1 The PEFA Program – and the PFM Performance Measurement Framework Washington DC, May 1, 2008 Bill Dorotinsky IMF.

Advertisements

SUCCESS AND FAILURE FACTORS IN THE INTRODUCTION OF eGOVERNMENT SERVICES Nikolay Vassilev Minister of State Administration and Administrative Reform Republic.

IMPLEMENTING FINANCIAL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS FOR GOVERNMENT CHRISTIAN T. SOTTIE THE CONTROLLER AND ACCOUNTANT-GENERAL GHANA.

Water for a food-secure world Recommendations for implementing AWM in challenging contexts: 5 countries November 2012.

Water for a food-secure world Challenging contexts: commonalities across countries November 2012 Katherine Snyder.

Water for a food-secure world IFAD agricultural water management investments in “challenging contexts”: IFAD context, commonalities across countries, &

USE OF COUNTRY SYSTEMS TO MANAGE CLIMATE CHANGE PAUL STEELE, UNDP.

Elizabeth Lule Manager ACTafrica The World Bank’s Support to HIV/AIDS Programs in Africa.

PEFA as a Platform for Improving Public Financial Management

Budget Execution Course

GEF and Environmental & Conservation Funds Presentation for the Workshop on “Management of Environmental Funds for the Financial Sustainability of Biodiversity.

The World Bank Tracking Progress and Controlling Funds: Concepts Bill Dorotinsky, PRMPS Budget Management Course March 1-2, 2004.

The Rehabilitation in the Community of Persons with Mental Disabilities Law of Israel: Challenge and Opportunity in a Changing Mental Health Service System.

Multilateral Mechanisms for Managing International Development Assistance. The Challenge of Effectiveness and Reform Yuriy Zaytsev National Research University.

Public Sector Reform: What Works and Why? An IEG Evaluation of World Bank Support – September 2008.

Training Workshop (LOCATION) (DATE) and. Access Rationale governments sign the Rio Declaration. Rio’s Principle 10 mandates appropriate access.

From Effective Aid to Effective Institutions Synthesis of Joint International Evaluations Julia Betts and Helen Wedgwood Paris 5 th October 2011.

PARIS21 Partnership in Statistics for Development in the 21st Century Strategic planning for a better integration of sectors within NSS High Level Meeting.

TAI Background: Relevant International Commitments governments sign the Rio Declaration. Principle 10 mandated appropriate access to information,

The African Development Bank’s Contribution to Aid for Trade (AfT) Henri A. MINNAAR NEPAD, Regional Integration and Trade Department WIPO Conference on.

The Issues of Budgetary Reform Unit 3. PFM Reform – Change Management Module 3.2. Preparing and managing a reform programme.

ORGANISATION OF EASTERN CARIBBEAN STATES ELECTRONIC GOVERNMENT FOR REGIONAL INTEGRATION PROJECT KARLENE FRANCIS, PROJECT MANAGER.

Strengthening Public Financial Management Project Component 1: Implementation of Treasury Single Account : Issues & Challenges Dec 26,2013.

The International Center for Technical Cooperation on HIV/AIDS Gustav Liliequist - Consultant.

Implementation Methodology of the Integrated Public Financial Management Systems in Europe and Central Asia Cem Dener İstanbul, Türkiye February.

Disaster Risk Management and Examples of Early Warning Projects at the The Inter-American Development Bank.

Moving PFM reforms forward: A Strengthened Approach PEM reforms in PRSP countries from Europe and Central Asia Warsaw, February 6-9, 2005 David Biggs DFID.

EXPERIENCE SHARING ON LOCAL PFM & CURRENT REFORM INITIATIVES Babu Ram Shrestha, MOFALD.

Some reflections on the PEFA experience in Latin American “PEFA in Latin America, Seven Years of Implementation” EuropeAid's Workshop Brussels, 4-5 December.

Regional policy European Commission EN Update on IPA Component III - environment Brussels, 28 November 2008 Erich Unterwurzacher REGIO.I4 – IPA/ISPA.

Implementation Methodology of the Integrated Public Financial Management Systems in Europe and Central Asia Cem Dener Washington, DC May 2007 Implementation.

-0- June 2006 EU Infrastructure Trust Fund. The EU - Africa Partnership on Infrastructure and the Trust Fund Antonio Garcia Fragio Head of Division Transport,

Slide 1 GAC HOB Training Course - Essentials of Budget execution Addis Ababa, June

INTRODUCTION TO PUBLIC FINANCE MANAGEMENT (PFM) Module 1.1 Definitions, objectives of PFM and its context.

IFMIS RELATED ISSUES in AFRICAN COUNTRIES. List of Anglophone countries currently developing, implementing IFMIS, and/or those in pipeline. Uganda, Tanzania,

UNESCO INSTITUTE for STATISTICS UNESCO Institute for Statistics: Statistical Capacity Building.

The Strengthened Approach to Supporting PFM reforms Applying the PFM Performance Measurement Framework Washington, D.C., January 17-18, 2007 Bill Dorotinsky.

Developing a programme for the implementation of the 2008 SNA and supporting statistics Seminar on Developing a programme for the implementation of the.

Governance Indicators at AfDB Stephen Bahemuka May, 2012 African Development Bank.

CIS meeting Budapest 3-4 July 2013 Christophe Duhamel the Global Strategy to Improve Rural and Agricultural Statistics Reminder on GS objectives Specific.

The World Bank Implementing Financial Management Information System Projects: The World Bank Experience Preliminary Results Bill Dorotinsky PRMPS Budget.

Decentralization Thematic Group/Public Sector Group Funding “Assessment of the Impact of Decentralization: The Case of Colombia ( )”

Global Partnership for Enhanced Social Accountability (GPESA) December 19, 2011 World Bank.

African Centre for Statistics United Nations Economic Commission for Africa Proposed Regional Medium-term Civil Registration and Vital Statistics Plan.

Argentina – Fiduciary Action Plan Fiduciary Forum March 2008.

AFR Observatory on monitoring and evaluating procurement reform programs Working for a world free of poverty.

1 Lessons Learned from Bank’s Experience in Revenue Administration Reforms Tuan Minh Le PRMPS, World Bank.

IFMIS Implementations a history of success and failures World Bank study.

Exploring Capacity and Accountability Gaps Joan Kagwanja, Chief Land Policy Initiative World Bank Conference on Land and Poverty March 2016.

Implementing National Research and Education Networks (NRENs) in land locked African countries: critical success factors 1 D. Kunda, Director ICT B. Khunga,

© Grant Thornton. All rights reserved. What transparency initiative is or would be the most beneficial for your country? 1.Aid transparency 2.Budget execution.

TCOP GROUP 1 1. OUTLINE Countries present: Turkey, Bulgaria, Macedonia, Albania, Romania, Indonesia, France, (World Bank) Question 1: External conditions.

PFM reform – change management Module 3.2 Preparing and managing a PFM reform programme 1.

TREASURY OF GEORGIA – MISSION AND FUNCTIONS Nino Tchelishvili June, 2016 Chisinau, Moldova.

PUBLIC FINANCE IN THE REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA: REFORMS AND THE DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY PLENARY SESSION OF THE TREASURY COMMUNITY OF PRACTICE JUNE 1-3, 2015, KISHINEV,

Design and Implementation of Financial Management Information Systems (FMIS) Cem Dener June 14, 2011 Washington, DC Design and Implementation of Financial.

Building blocks for an effective WASH Sector Eddy Perez Professor of Practice in Global WASH, Emory Consultant, UNICEF.

Kishinev 2016 MINISTRY OF FINANCE OF THE REPUBLIC OF TAJIKISTAN.

Dr Ama Eyo Lecturer and Public Procurement Specialist Institute for Competition and Procurement Studies, Bangor University, North.

An Overview of Treasury/PFM Systems in ECA

Public Expenditure Management: Applications

Moving Forward in PFM for Sustainable Economic Growth and Development

Donor Coordination in Technical Assistance

Miraclefeet North Carolina, USA 12/5/2018

The Changing Face of PE Work – Financial Management Perspectives

The International Center for Technical Cooperation on HIV/AIDS

Budget Management and Financial Accountability: Overview

Implementing Budget Reforms

The Strengthened Approach to Supporting PFM reforms

Proposed Regional Medium-term Civil Registration and Vital Statistics Plan First Conference of African Ministers Responsible for Civil Registration August.

Presentation transcript:

The World Bank Implementing Financial Management Information System Projects: Selected Lessons from IFMIS Community of Practice Bill Dorotinsky October 15, 2008

The World Bank 2 Outline Origins and some basic findings Formalizing a FMIS maturity model A frequent question - Make vs. Buy

The World Bank 3 COP Origins: Bank FMIS Project Review The review covered 34 projects in 27 countries across 6 regions, involving $1 billion over 17 years Most Bank projects were not FMIS-only, but embedded in broader financial management or public sector reforms Many of the projects paid attention to training and ‘soft systems’ surrounding the technology, including FM training, change management training/advice An FMIS project, on average, –took 7 years to be complete Ranging from 9.1 years for Africa to 5.8 years for Latin America/Caribbean –average Bank-financed cost was $12.3 million* –component changes in 75 % of projects * Excluding $600 million for Russia

The World Bank 4 Risks, success & failure factors Projects risks –20 % cited technical complexity, too many components –24 % lack of institutional capacity –21 % weak government commitment Success factors –Full-time project coordinator (36%) –Champion at political level (14 %) –Training (14 %) (IT, FM, change management) Failure factors –Full-time project coordinator (23%) –Commitment (23%) –Project design (20%)

The World Bank 5 Preconditions for success? HR Capacity, ICT Readiness, & Project Success Burkina Faso L Malawi L Uganda L Bolivia L Indonesia L Brazil L Guatemala (1) S Nicaragua S Honduras S Ecuador (2) S Columbia S Chile S Hungary S Argentina S Human Development Index*E-gov Readiness* (Human Development Index: UNDP Human Development 2001 Index, E-government Readiness: UNPAN Global E-Government Index)

The World Bank 6 February 2008ECA Treasury / PFMS Projects6 Treasury/PFMS Maturity Framework Readiness  PFM reform strategy  Institutional capacity  Countrywide network infrastructure 1 Preparation  Legal and institutional frameworks  Budget coverage  Treasury Single Account (TSA) 2 PFMS Design  Definition of system functionality  Detailed technical requirements 3 Procurement  Large scale ICT systems  Technical Assistance and Training 4  System development & integration  Full scale testing and rollout  Training and change management Implementation 5 Maintenance and Support  Budget funds  Technical capacity  System administration  Maintenance 7 9 – 18 months 9 – 18 months 18 – 36 months Resources Effectiveness Time Monitoring & Evaluation  Monitoring mechanisms  Project mgmt capacity 6 Maturity Framework for Treasury/PFMS projects interactive monitoring and management of MF indicators

The World Bank 7 Make vs. Buy Question: Selected Parameters 1. Development Period 2. Functionality 3. Compliance with BPR 4. Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) 5. Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) 6. Maintenance and Upgrades 7. Flexibility 8. Integration with other systems and modules 9. Performance and Quality 10. Documentation and Training 11. Software Evaluation 12. Legal Redress Conclusion – no one right answer.