Relevance Feedback Content-Based Image Retrieval Using Query Distribution Estimation Based on Maximum Entropy Principle Irwin King and Zhong Jin The Chinese.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Applications of one-class classification
Advertisements

Yinyin Yuan and Chang-Tsun Li Computer Science Department
Pseudo-Relevance Feedback For Multimedia Retrieval By Rong Yan, Alexander G. and Rong Jin Mwangi S. Kariuki
Relevance Feedback and User Interaction for CBIR Hai Le Supervisor: Dr. Sid Ray.
Context-based object-class recognition and retrieval by generalized correlograms by J. Amores, N. Sebe and P. Radeva Discussion led by Qi An Duke University.
Introduction Distance-based Adaptable Similarity Search
Principal Component Analysis Based on L1-Norm Maximization Nojun Kwak IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 2008.
Fast Algorithms For Hierarchical Range Histogram Constructions
ECE 8443 – Pattern Recognition LECTURE 05: MAXIMUM LIKELIHOOD ESTIMATION Objectives: Discrete Features Maximum Likelihood Resources: D.H.S: Chapter 3 (Part.
Jun Zhu Dept. of Comp. Sci. & Tech., Tsinghua University This work was done when I was a visiting researcher at CMU. Joint.
Visual Recognition Tutorial
Relevance Feedback Content-Based Image Retrieval Using Query Distribution Estimation Based on Maximum Entropy Principle Irwin King and Zhong Jin Nov
Content Based Image Clustering and Image Retrieval Using Multiple Instance Learning Using Multiple Instance Learning Xin Chen Advisor: Chengcui Zhang Department.
EE 290A: Generalized Principal Component Analysis Lecture 6: Iterative Methods for Mixture-Model Segmentation Sastry & Yang © Spring, 2011EE 290A, University.
1 Content Based Image Retrieval Using MPEG-7 Dominant Color Descriptor Student: Mr. Ka-Man Wong Supervisor: Dr. Lai-Man Po MPhil Examination Department.
Prénom Nom Document Analysis: Parameter Estimation for Pattern Recognition Prof. Rolf Ingold, University of Fribourg Master course, spring semester 2008.
Learning Maximum Likelihood Bounded Semi-Naïve Bayesian Network Classifier Kaizhu Huang, Irwin King, Michael R. Lyu Multimedia Information Processing Laboratory.
Prénom Nom Document Analysis: Linear Discrimination Prof. Rolf Ingold, University of Fribourg Master course, spring semester 2008.
An efficient and effective region-based image retrieval framework Reporter: Francis 2005/5/12.
1 Statistical correlation analysis in image retrieval Reporter : Erica Li 2004/9/30.
Predictive Automatic Relevance Determination by Expectation Propagation Yuan (Alan) Qi Thomas P. Minka Rosalind W. Picard Zoubin Ghahramani.
ACM Multimedia th Annual Conference, October , 2004
Expectation Maximization Method Effective Image Retrieval Based on Hidden Concept Discovery in Image Database By Sanket Korgaonkar Masters Computer Science.
CONTENT BASED FACE RECOGNITION Ankur Jain 01D05007 Pranshu Sharma Prashant Baronia 01D05005 Swapnil Zarekar 01D05001 Under the guidance of Prof.
Relevance Feedback based on Parameter Estimation of Target Distribution K. C. Sia and Irwin King Department of Computer Science & Engineering The Chinese.
Prénom Nom Document Analysis: Data Analysis and Clustering Prof. Rolf Ingold, University of Fribourg Master course, spring semester 2008.
1 Integrating User Feedback Log into Relevance Feedback by Coupled SVM for Content-Based Image Retrieval 9-April, 2005 Steven C. H. Hoi *, Michael R. Lyu.
Evaluating Hypotheses
Presentation in IJCNN 2004 Biased Support Vector Machine for Relevance Feedback in Image Retrieval Hoi, Chu-Hong Steven Department of Computer Science.
1 An Empirical Study on Large-Scale Content-Based Image Retrieval Group Meeting Presented by Wyman
Dept. of Computer Science & Engineering, CUHK Pseudo Relevance Feedback with Biased Support Vector Machine in Multimedia Retrieval Steven C.H. Hoi 14-Oct,
Presented by Zeehasham Rasheed
Smart Traveller with Visual Translator for OCR and Face Recognition LYU0203 FYP.
Bing LiuCS Department, UIC1 Learning from Positive and Unlabeled Examples Bing Liu Department of Computer Science University of Illinois at Chicago Joint.
Face Processing System Presented by: Harvest Jang Group meeting Fall 2002.
Optimizing Learning with SVM Constraint for Content-based Image Retrieval* Steven C.H. Hoi 1th March, 2004 *Note: The copyright of the presentation material.
Extracting Places and Activities from GPS Traces Using Hierarchical Conditional Random Fields Yong-Joong Kim Dept. of Computer Science Yonsei.
1 Template-Based Classification Method for Chinese Character Recognition Presenter: Tienwei Tsai Department of Informaiton Management, Chihlee Institute.
Content-based Retrieval of 3D Medical Images Y. Qian, X. Gao, M. Loomes, R. Comley, B. Barn School of Engineering and Information Sciences Middlesex University,
Presented by Tienwei Tsai July, 2005
COLOR HISTOGRAM AND DISCRETE COSINE TRANSFORM FOR COLOR IMAGE RETRIEVAL Presented by 2006/8.
Partially Supervised Classification of Text Documents by Bing Liu, Philip Yu, and Xiaoli Li Presented by: Rick Knowles 7 April 2005.
Intelligent Bilddatabassökning Reiner Lenz, Thanh H. Bui, (Linh V. Tran) ITN, Linköpings Universitet David Rydén, Göran Lundberg Matton AB, Stockholm.
PSEUDO-RELEVANCE FEEDBACK FOR MULTIMEDIA RETRIEVAL Seo Seok Jun.
A Model for Learning the Semantics of Pictures V. Lavrenko, R. Manmatha, J. Jeon Center for Intelligent Information Retrieval Computer Science Department,
Computer Graphics and Image Processing (CIS-601).
2005/12/021 Content-Based Image Retrieval Using Grey Relational Analysis Dept. of Computer Engineering Tatung University Presenter: Tienwei Tsai ( 蔡殿偉.
Competence Centre on Information Extraction and Image Understanding for Earth Observation 29th March 2007 Category - based Semantic Search Engine 1 Mihai.
2005/12/021 Fast Image Retrieval Using Low Frequency DCT Coefficients Dept. of Computer Engineering Tatung University Presenter: Yo-Ping Huang ( 黃有評 )
1 A Compact Feature Representation and Image Indexing in Content- Based Image Retrieval A presentation by Gita Das PhD Candidate 29 Nov 2005 Supervisor:
Bing LiuCS Department, UIC1 Chapter 8: Semi-supervised learning.
Paper Reading Dalong Du Nov.27, Papers Leon Gu and Takeo Kanade. A Generative Shape Regularization Model for Robust Face Alignment. ECCV08. Yan.
Content-Based Image Retrieval Using Block Discrete Cosine Transform Presented by Te-Wei Chiang Department of Information Networking Technology Chihlee.
MindReader: Querying databases through multiple examples Yoshiharu Ishikawa (Nara Institute of Science and Technology, Japan) Ravishankar Subramanya (Pittsburgh.
Data Mining, ICDM '08. Eighth IEEE International Conference on Duy-Dinh Le National Institute of Informatics Hitotsubashi, Chiyoda-ku Tokyo,
1 An Efficient Classification Approach Based on Grid Code Transformation and Mask-Matching Method Presenter: Yo-Ping Huang.
Chapter 20 Classification and Estimation Classification – Feature selection Good feature have four characteristics: –Discrimination. Features.
GENDER AND AGE RECOGNITION FOR VIDEO ANALYTICS SOLUTION PRESENTED BY: SUBHASH REDDY JOLAPURAM.
Evaluation of gene-expression clustering via mutual information distance measure Ido Priness, Oded Maimon and Irad Ben-Gal BMC Bioinformatics, 2007.
Discriminative Training and Machine Learning Approaches Machine Learning Lab, Dept. of CSIE, NCKU Chih-Pin Liao.
2D-LDA: A statistical linear discriminant analysis for image matrix
Chance Constrained Robust Energy Efficiency in Cognitive Radio Networks with Channel Uncertainty Yongjun Xu and Xiaohui Zhao College of Communication Engineering,
Content-Based Image Retrieval Using Color Space Transformation and Wavelet Transform Presented by Tienwei Tsai Department of Information Management Chihlee.
ECE 8443 – Pattern Recognition ECE 8527 – Introduction to Machine Learning and Pattern Recognition Objectives: Mixture Densities Maximum Likelihood Estimates.
LECTURE 09: BAYESIAN ESTIMATION (Cont.)
Course Outline MODEL INFORMATION COMPLETE INCOMPLETE
PRAKASH CHOCKALINGAM, NALIN PRADEEP, AND STAN BIRCHFIELD
LECTURE 21: CLUSTERING Objectives: Mixture Densities Maximum Likelihood Estimates Application to Gaussian Mixture Models k-Means Clustering Fuzzy k-Means.
Random Neural Network Texture Model
Presentation transcript:

Relevance Feedback Content-Based Image Retrieval Using Query Distribution Estimation Based on Maximum Entropy Principle Irwin King and Zhong Jin The Chinese University of Hong Kong ICONIP2001, Shanghai, China November 16, 2001 This paper is supported in part by an Earmarked Grant from the Hong Kong Research Grants Council #CUHK4407/99E.

Introduction Images Internet Audio & Video Information = power! Management of information is important Information retrieval is crucial Search Engine Images Internet Text ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Content-Based Image Retrieval Retrieve images by color, shape, texture, sketch, spatial organization, etc. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Relevance Feedback Relevance feedback image retrieval Using user’s response to refine the retrieval result iteratively Why is relevance feedback significant? It is difficult for user to describe the desired outcome using features Only user’s similarity information is available Example Face identification ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Presentation User’s Feedback Generation Generation ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Key Issues Goal Two problems To utilize user’s feedback to estimate the outcome To construct an on-line and real time user classifier for the query to prune out unwanted data Two problems How to generate the images to be selected? How to utilize user’s feedback to update the image’s relevance? ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Related Work Relevance Feedback Cox et al. used a Bayesian approach to update each image’s relevance Rui et al. used a simple neural learning-like iterative updating equation to update each image’s relevance Problems Calculation is over ALL images=> time consuming Unnatural image selection procedure for presentation=> no logical basis which leads to poor performance ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Proposed Framework Estimation Stage Generation Stage Estimate the feedback mean and the feedback covariance matrix by using accumulative relevant and irrelevant retrieval information. This is a local estimate, not a global one! Generation Stage Generate a set of inquiries for relevance selection based on Maximum Entropy Principle. The MEP gives a natural and logical guideline to select presentation images. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

An Illustration ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Outline of Parameters Given a set of data points D={di}, i=1,…,n Image generation for presentation and selection G = {dj}, G is a subset of D Relevance feedback from the user RF = {dk}, RF is a subset of G Properties Sequential revelation of information from the user The relevance feedback information is relatively sparse Possible user’s misinformation ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Estimation Stage Assume parametric model based on normal distribution When the number T of relevant retrieval is less than the dimension M of the feature space, it is assumed that When T=1, an estimation can be given by an equal-probability constrain ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Generation Stage Using MEP, we want to maximize the information obtained from the user’s feedback. For K number of retrievals, K+1 points can be determined according to the following equal-probability conditions: all similar images in the database can be divided in the following K subsets: where ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Experiments Trademark image database 1,400 128 x 128 trademark images ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Shape Feature Extraction Shape content-based retrieval 7 dimensional invariant moments ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Test by Deformation We vary the trademark images using 10 deformation transformations. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Test Images 100 Test Images: ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Experimental Aim Experimental goal To evaluate the efficiency of the proposed generation stage, Generation MAXENT. The retrieval performance is measured using the following Average Retrieval Precision (ARP): Where K=10. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Experimental Procedure Compare three distances The three-step experiments are designed as follows: For a query image, return K retrievals by Euclidean distance. Perform the estimation stage and return retrievals by Euclidean distance, Mahalanobis distance, and Generation MAXENT respectively. Perform the estimation stage and return K retrievals by using the Mahalanobis distance. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Experimental Results http://www.cse.cuhk.edu.hk/~miplab/MAXENT ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Analysis of Results The proposed generation stage Generation MAXENT outperforms the commonly used Euclidean distance and Mahalanobis distance MAXENT begins with very large error, but it converges much quicker than the other two distance measures. The proposed Generation MAXENT aims to retrieve image samples which can reflect the user’s query distribution function better. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Discussions Theoretical convergence properties How to ensure convergence How to minimize the number of iterations Better heuristics for the generation stage How to select images for presentation efficiently Better error handling How to handle user’s mistake when selecting relevant images Better experimental procedure How to benchmark relevance feedback results ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Conclusion Proposed a novel two-stage relevance feedback framework for content-based image retrieval Query estimation through user’s feedback Maximum Entropy Principle for image generation in the presentation stage They are shown to be successful in improving accuracy and speed on a simple trademark image database. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Introduction Content-Based Image retrieval (CBIR) : The selection of images from a collection via primitive visual features representing color, shape, and texture extracted from images themselves. Successful CBIR systems require the integration of various techniques in the fields of : Pattern Recognition (PR) Digital Image Processing (DIP) Information Retrieval (IR) ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Introduction Relevance feedback (RF) : RF techniques include mainly: An iterative and interactive process for query reformulation based on user's feedback. RF techniques include mainly: Query moving technique Similarity function re-weighting technique ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Key Problem Problems Since the retrievals under the commonly used nearest-neighbor rule cannot reflect the query distribution function properly , most of relevance feedback techniques may fail under the following assumption: The number of relevant retrievals is small The number of iterations is required to be small ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Background RF technique in CBIR system can be regarded as a form of two-stage automatic learning for the unknown query distribution function: Estimate the query distribution function by using the Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm or by the classical statistics. Generate the inquiries to be returned to the user, where the nearest-neighbor rule is commonly used. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Background Limitation of estimation theories: EM has its limitations in CBIR Because of a small number of labeled data in RF. Only relevant information can be utilized by classical statistical theory. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Background Limitation of the nearest-neighbor rule: the retrievals generated cannot wholly reflect the Query Distribution Function (QDF) because the underlying QDF may not be isotropic in nature. QDF is the statistical distribution function deformed by all the images similar to the given query image in high dimensional feature space. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Background Review Shannon’s Entropy Maximum Entropy Principle (MEP): To obtain estimations by determining a probability distribution associated with a random variable over a discrete space which has the greatest entropy subject to constraints on the expectations of a given set of functions of the variable. The Maximum Entropy (MAXENT) solution with no bias (or constraints) is ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16

Background Review Some work on IR by MEP: In the early 80's, Cooper et al. made a strong case for applying the maximum entropy approach to the problems of information retrieval. Kantor extended the analysis of the MEP in the context of information retrieval. Recently, Greiff and Ponte took a fresh look at modeling approaches to information retrieval and analyzed classical probabilistic IR models in light of the MEP. ICONIP2001, Shanghai 2001/11/16