Reality Check For Extension Programs Deborah J. Young Associate Director University of Arizona Cooperative Extension
UWEX Logic Model Ellen Taylor-Powell, Evaluation Specialist, Wisconsin Cooperative Extension Adopted by the Western Region Program Leaders, Cooperative Extension
What Is a Logic Model? Logical chain of connections showing what the program is to accomplish Core of program planning and reporting Use for assessment and evaluation
What Makes Up A Logic Model? Situation INPUTS OUTPUTS OUTCOMES Assumptions Environment
OUTCOMES What results for individuals, businesses, and communities Short term – Awareness, Knowledge, Attitudes, Skills, Opinion, Aspirations, Motivation (learning) Medium term – Behavior, Practice, Decisions, Policies, Social action (action) Long term – Behavior, Practice, Decisions, Policies, Social action (behavior)
CHAIN OF OUTCOMES Short term – producers increase knowledge of water contamination risks Medium term – unused wells are sealed Long term – improved water quality
OUTCOME STATEMENTS Economics Regulations Marketing and foreign trade Public policy and environment
OUTPUTS What we do: workshops, counseling, on-farm research, facilitation, product development, curriculum design, trainings, field days, conferences Who we reach: participants, clients, customers, users
INPUTS FACULTYSTAFFMONEYTIMEVOLUNTEERSPARTNERSEQUIPMENT
Outcome-based evaluations Evaluations should only be done if they have real use for real people.
What is a good evaluation? Utility Feasibility Propriety Accuracy
Utility The evaluation should answer questions that the end users need and want to know.
Feasibility Evaluations are both practical and cost- effective.
Propriety The evaluation is conducted with regard for the rights and interests of those involved.
Accuracy The data collected is valid and reliable.
So what? Gather credible evidence Use indicators, such as increase in number of producers, changes in the environment, and changes in participant behavior