Large Scale Simulations of Reionization Garrelt Mellema Stockholm Observatory Collaborators: Ilian Iliev, Paul Shapiro, Marcelo Alvarez, Ue-Li Pen, Hugh.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Tom Theuns Institute for Computational Cosmology, Durham, UK Department of Physics, Antwerp, Belgium Munich 2005 Reionization And the thermal history of.
Advertisements

Metals at Highish Redshift And Large Scale Structures From DLAs to Underdense Regions Patrick Petitjean Institut d’Astrophysique de Paris B. Aracil R.
Probing the End of Reionization with High-redshift Quasars Xiaohui Fan University of Arizona Mar 18, 2005, Shanghai Collaborators: Becker, Gunn, Lupton,
Motivation 40 orbits of UDF observations with the ACS grism Spectra for every source in the field. Good S/N continuum detections to I(AB) ~ 27; about 30%
First Stars, Quasars, and the Epoch of Reionization Jordi Miralda Escudé Institut de Ciències de l’Espai (IEEC-CSIC, ICREA), Barcelona. Instituto de Astrofísica.
21cm Lines and Dark Ages Naoshi Sugiyama Department of Physics and Astrophysics Nagoya University Furlanetto & Briggs astro-ph/ , Zaldarriaga et.
End of Cosmic Dark Ages: Observational Probes of Reionization History Xiaohui Fan University of Arizona New Views Conference, Dec 12, 2005 Collaborators:
ESO Recent Results on Reionization Chris Carilli (NRAO) LANL Cosmology School, July 2011 Review: constraints on IGM during reionization  CMB large scale.
Cosmic Baryons: The IGM Ue-Li Pen 彭威禮. Overview History of Cosmic Baryons: a gas with phase transitions Missing baryons simulations SZ-Power spectrum:
Cosmological Reionization Nick Gnedin. Co-starring Gayler Harford Katharina Kohler Peter Shaver Mike Shull Massimo Ricotti.
Moriond, La Thuile 18. mar, cmFAST 21cmFAST A Fast, Semi-Numerical Simulation of the High-Redshift 21cm Signal Andrei Mesinger Princeton University.
Suman Majumdar Department of Astronomy and Oskar Klein Centre Stockholm University Redshift Space Anisotropies in the EoR 21-cm Signal: what do they tell.
Nick Gnedin. Epigraph Why is reionization interesting? I think the way to think about it is that it was the last time when most baryons got together and.
21cm Constraints on Reionization Benedetta Ciardi MPA T. Di Matteo (CMU), A. Ferrara (SISSA), I. Iliev (CITA), P. Madau (UCSC), A. Maselli (MPA), F. Miniati.
The Evidence for the Big Bang Student Resource Sheet 5 Science and Religion in Schools: Unit 4a.
A hot topic: the 21cm line II Benedetta Ciardi MPA.
The Dark Age… before the stars, beyond the galaxies…
Epoch of Reionization Tomography with the CSO Wide-field C+ spectral mapping and correlation with HI Matt Bradford CSO NSF visit: October 12, 2011 CSO.
1 ACT  Atacama Cosmology Telescope  Funded by NSF  Will measure CMB fluctuations on small angular scales  Probe the primordial power spectrum and the.
Cosmology with the 21 cm Transition Steve Furlanetto Yale University September 25, 2006 Steve Furlanetto Yale University September 25, 2006.
A Primer on SZ Surveys Gil Holder Institute for Advanced Study.
Simona Gallerani Constraining cosmic reionization models with QSOs, GRBs and LAEs observational data In collaboration with: A. Ferrara, X. Fan, T. Choudhury,
Ultraviolet Pumping of the 21-cm Line in the High Redshift Universe Leonid Chuzhoy University of Texas at Austin Collaborators: Marcelo Alvarez (Stanford),
Probing Dark Matter with the CMB and Large-Scale Structure 1 Cora Dvorkin IAS (Princeton) Harvard (Hubble fellow) COSMO 2014 August 2014, Chicago.
Inflation, Expansion, Acceleration Two observed properties of the Universe, homogeneity and isotropy, constitute the Cosmological Principle Manifest in.
Matched Filter Search for Ionized Bubbles in 21-cm Maps Kanan K. Datta Dept. of Astronomy Stockholm University Oskar Klein Centre.
Escape Fraction from Early Galaxies Elizabeth Fernandez University of Colorado, Boulder.
Moscow cm Cosmology Collaborators: Collaborators: Rennan Barkana, Stuart Wyithe, Matias Zaldarriaga Avi Loeb Harvard University.
130 cMpc ~ 1 o z~ = 7.3 Lidz et al ‘Inverse’ views of evolution of large scale structure during reionization Neutral intergalactic medium via HI.
Simona Gallerani Constraining reionization through quasar and gamma ray burst absorption spectra In collaboration with: T. Roy Choudhury, P. Dayal, X.
The Cosmic Microwave Background Lecture 2 Elena Pierpaoli.
Benedetta Ciardi MPA Reionization Nucleosynthesis ‘Dark Ages’ Big Bang Fluctuations begin to condense into first stars and protogalaxies Decoupling matter-radiation.
The 21cm signature of the First Stars Xuelei Chen 陳學雷 National Astronomical Observatory of China Xuelei Chen 陳學雷 National Astronomical Observatory of China.
Sources of Reionization Jordi Miralda Escudé Institut de Ciències de l’Espai (IEEC-CSIC, ICREA), Barcelona. Beijing,
Nick Gnedin (Once More About Reionization)
CMB Polarization from Patchy Reionization Gil Holder.
Lecture 5: Matter Dominated Universe: CMB Anisotropies and Large Scale Structure Today, matter is assembled into structures: filaments, clusters, galaxies,
21 cm Reionization Forecast and Search at GMRT
Andrea Ferrara SISSA/International School for Advanced Studies, Trieste Cosmic Dawn and IGM Reionization.
Low Frequency Background and Cosmology Xuelei Chen National Astronomical Observatories Kashigar, September 10th 2005.
PHY306 1 Modern cosmology 3: The Growth of Structure Growth of structure in an expanding universe The Jeans length Dark matter Large scale structure simulations.
the National Radio Astronomy Observatory – Socorro, NM
Radiation backgrounds from the first sources and the redshifted 21 cm line Jonathan Pritchard (Caltech) Collaborators: Steve Furlanetto (Yale) Marc Kamionkowski.
Renaissance: Formation of the first light sources in the Universe after the Dark Ages Justin Vandenbroucke, UC Berkeley Physics 290H, February 12, 2008.
Mário Santos1 EoR / 21cm simulations 4 th SKADS Workshop, Lisbon, 2-3 October 2008 Epoch of Reionization / 21cm simulations Mário Santos CENTRA - IST.
The Distributions of Baryons in the Universe and the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium Baryonic budget at z=0 Overall thermal timeline of baryons from z=1000.
Reionisation and the cross-correlation between the CMB and the 21-cm line fluctuations Hiroyuki Tashiro IAS, ORSAY 43rd Rencontres de Moriond La Thuile,
From Avi Loeb reionization. Quest to the Highest Redshift.
Probing the Reionization Epoch in the GMT Era Xiaohui Fan (University of Arizona) Seoul/GMT Meeting Oct 5, 2010.
Probing the First Star Formation by 21cm line Kazuyuki Omukai (Kyoto U.)
A hot topic: the 21cm line III Benedetta Ciardi MPA.
The Twilight Zone of Reionization Steve Furlanetto Yale University March 13, 2006 Steve Furlanetto Yale University March 13, 2006 Collaborators: F. Briggs,
Lyman Alpha Spheres from the First Stars observed in 21 cm Xuelei Chen (Beijing) Jordi Miralda Escudé (IEEC, Barcelona).
Remote Quadrupole Measurements from Reionization Gil Holder Collaborators: Jon Dudley; Alex van Engelen (McGill) Ilian Iliev (CITA/Zurich); Olivier Dore.
Big Bang f(HI) ~ 0 f(HI) ~ 1 f(HI) ~ History of Baryons (mostly hydrogen) Redshift Recombination Reionization z = 1000 (0.4Myr) z = 0 (13.6Gyr) z.
Deep Surveys for High-z Galaxies with Hyper Suprime-Cam M. Ouchi (OCIW), K. Shimasaku (U. Tokyo), H. Furusawa (NAOJ), & HSC Consortium ≲ ≳≲ ≳
Radiative Transfer Simulations The Proximity Effect of LBGs: Antonella Maselli, OAArcetri, Firenze, Italy Collaborators: A.Ferrara, M. Bruscoli, S. Marri.
The Dark Age and Cosmology Xuelei Chen ( 陈学雷 ) National Astronomical Observarories of China The 2nd Sino-French Workshop on the Dark Universe, Aug 31st.
March 26, Large Scale Simulations: properties of the 21cm signal Garrelt Mellema Stockholm Observatory Collaborators: Martina.
Constraint on Cosmic Reionization from High-z QSO Spectra Hiroi Kumiko Umemura Masayuki Nakamoto Taishi (University of Tsukuba) Mini Workshop.
Study of Proto-clusters by Cosmological Simulation Tamon SUWA, Asao HABE (Hokkaido Univ.) Kohji YOSHIKAWA (Tokyo Univ.)
The cross-correlation between CMB and 21-cm fluctuations during the epoch of reionization Hiroyuki Tashiro N. Aghanim (IAS, Paris-sud Univ.) M. Langer.
Fingerprints in the CMB from Reionization Gil Holder.
AlbaNova, Stockholm 18. aug, cmFAST 21cmFAST A Fast, Semi-Numerical Simulation of the High-Redshift 21cm Signal Andrei Mesinger Princeton University.
High Redshift QUASAR Spectra as Probe of Reionization of IGM.
Reionization of the Universe MinGyu Kim
Probing Reionization with Lyman Alpha Emitters Pratika Dayal
Recovery of The Signal from the Epoch of Reionization
Semi-Numerical Simulations of
Constraint on Cosmic Reionization from High-z QSO Spectra
Presentation transcript:

Large Scale Simulations of Reionization Garrelt Mellema Stockholm Observatory Collaborators: Ilian Iliev, Paul Shapiro, Marcelo Alvarez, Ue-Li Pen, Hugh Merz, LOFAR EoR Key Project team

Contents Reionization Reionization Simulations Simulations Some results Some results WMAP1 versus WMAP3 WMAP1 versus WMAP3 Secondary CMB Anisotropies Secondary CMB Anisotropies Iliev et al. 2006, astro-ph/ Iliev et al. 2006, astro-ph/ GM et al. 2006, astro-ph/ GM et al. 2006, astro-ph/

Reionization A view of the epoch when the first galaxies formed. A view of the epoch when the first galaxies formed. Current observational data: WMAP Thomson optical depth, SDSS QSOs, T IGM from Lyα forest Current observational data: WMAP Thomson optical depth, SDSS QSOs, T IGM from Lyα forest Future observational data: redshifted 21cm radiation (21CMA, LOFAR, MWA, SKA); direct view of HII regions (nature of sources) and IGM density field. Future observational data: redshifted 21cm radiation (21CMA, LOFAR, MWA, SKA); direct view of HII regions (nature of sources) and IGM density field.

Simulations: Pro and Cons Limited ranges Limited ranges –mass resolution –spatial resolution –number of sources Expensive Expensive –Possible saves: No temperature No temperature No helium No helium Simple source prescription Simple source prescription Reionization process is complex: Reionization process is complex: –Source clustering –HII region overlap –Recombinations (n 2 ) –Temperature effects Analytical models cannot capture all of these effects, numerical models can. Analytical models cannot capture all of these effects, numerical models can.

Simulations: How? Our motivation: large scalesimulations. Our motivation: large scale simulations. –Observationally needed (~degree fields of view). –Theoretically needed (cosmic variance, size of HII regions, >>10 Mpc). Approach: Approach: –PMFAST (Merz, Pen, Trac 2005) simulations (4.3 billion particles): Evolving density field Evolving density field Collapsed halo list Collapsed halo list 100/h and 35/h Mpc volumes (minimum halo masses 2.5x10 9 and 10 8 M , respectively). 100/h and 35/h Mpc volumes (minimum halo masses 2.5x10 9 and 10 8 M , respectively). –C 2 -Ray (GM et al. 2006) postprocessing (203 3, ): Ionized hydrogen fraction Ionized hydrogen fraction ΛCDM (WMAP)

Simulations: Sources We have been working with stars as our sources of ionizing radiation. We have been working with stars as our sources of ionizing radiation. Assumptions: Assumptions: –M/L=const. –only atomically cooling halos contribute (M>10 8 M  ). –halos with M<10 9 M  can be suppressed. –fixed photons/atom escaping (Iliev, Scannapieco & Shapiro 2005): f = f SF x f esc x N photon. Choices used: f=2000 and 250. Choices used: f=2000 and 250. Other source models to be explored in the future. Other source models to be explored in the future.

Results: evolution Movie of density field and HII regions Movie of density field and HII regions Green: neutral Green: neutral Red: Ionized Red: Ionized Note: clustering & overlap. Note: clustering & overlap. From z=20 to 10 (WMAP3 parameters). Overlap expected at z~7. From z=20 to 10 (WMAP3 parameters). Overlap expected at z~7. 35/h Mpc

Importance of Large Scales From our (100/h Mpc) 3 volume we can analyze the reionization history of subvolumes. From our (100/h Mpc) 3 volume we can analyze the reionization history of subvolumes. Large variations found, need at least volume of (30/h Mpc) 3. Large variations found, need at least volume of (30/h Mpc) 3. Reionization is mostly inside-out. Reionization is mostly inside-out. Reionization histories for subvolumes

Statistics 3D powerspectra: 3D powerspectra: –Poisson noise at largest scales –Clear peak at some (time- dependent) characteristic scale. –Resemble analytical work (Furlanetto et al. 2004a,b) The signal is strongly non-gaussian: The signal is strongly non-gaussian: –Numerical results do not resemble analytical inside- out, nor outside-in results (Furlanetto et al. 2004a,b) Furlanetto et al. 2004a Full density HII density HI density

Statistics 3D powerspectra: 3D powerspectra: –Poisson noise at largest scales –Clear peak at some (time- dependent) characteristic scale. –Resemble analytical work (Furlanetto et al. 2004a,b) The signal is strongly non-gaussian: The signal is strongly non-gaussian: –Numerical results do not resemble analytical inside- out, nor outside-in results (Furlanetto et al. 2004a,b) 20/h Mpc 10/h Mpc 5/h Mpc z=11.9 z=10.8 Furlanetto et al. 2004b

LOS Reionization Histories From the simulations we can construct reionization histories along the line of sight. From the simulations we can construct reionization histories along the line of sight. Will be used to prepare for the analysis of the LOFAR observations (2009) Will be used to prepare for the analysis of the LOFAR observations (2009)

What Cosmology? 1 st year WMAP versus 3 year WMAP: 1 st year WMAP versus 3 year WMAP: –τ : 0.17: to 0.09 (if instantanious, z reion : 16 to 11) –n s : 1.0 to 0.95, σ 8 : 0.9 to Reionization happened later (good!), but structure formation also took longer. Reionization happened later (good!), but structure formation also took longer. Alvarez et al. (2006): approximate scaling for simulations with similar types of sources: (1+z 1 )/(1+z 3 )≈1.4. Confirmed by new simulations. Alvarez et al. (2006): approximate scaling for simulations with similar types of sources: (1+z 1 )/(1+z 3 )≈1.4. Confirmed by new simulations.

WMAP1 versus WMAP3 Identical simulations (100/h Mpc, f=250), differing only in cosmological parameters: Identical simulations (100/h Mpc, f=250), differing only in cosmological parameters: WMAP1 WMAP3 FM Band

Secondary CMB Anisotropies Patchy reionization is expected to imprint small scale anisotropies on the CMB signal through the kinetic Sunyaev-Zel’dovich effect. Patchy reionization is expected to imprint small scale anisotropies on the CMB signal through the kinetic Sunyaev-Zel’dovich effect. Several analytical estimates exist ( McQuinn et al. 2005, Santos et al. 2006, Zahn et al. 2006), with large variation in strength and scales. Now the first numerical ones. Several analytical estimates exist (Hu & Gruzinov 98, McQuinn et al. 2005, Santos et al. 2006, Zahn et al. 2006), with large variation in strength and scales. Now the first numerical ones. Temperature variations given by LOS integral: Temperature variations given by LOS integral:

Sample kSZ map from patchy reionization Sample kSZ map (100/h Mpc, f=250). Sample kSZ map (100/h Mpc, f=250). Range of pixel values is  T/T= to 10 -5, i.e.  T max/min are in the tens of  K at ~arcmin scales. Range of pixel values is  T/T= to 10 -5, i.e.  T max/min are in the tens of  K at ~arcmin scales. ~1°

kSZ Power Spectra Power spectra peak at l~ , with a peak value ~1 μK. Power spectra peak at l~ , with a peak value ~1 μK. Instant reionization has order of magnitude less power for l~ , but same large-l behaviour. Instant reionization has order of magnitude less power for l~ , but same large-l behaviour. Uniform reionization has much less power on all scales. Uniform reionization has much less power on all scales.

Conclusions Large scale simulations needed for useful results. Large scale simulations needed for useful results. Reionization produces a clear signature in the n HI power spectra. Reionization produces a clear signature in the n HI power spectra. WMAP3 results do not require different types of sources, but move reionization by a factor ~1.4 in (1+z). WMAP3 results do not require different types of sources, but move reionization by a factor ~1.4 in (1+z). kSZ due to patchy reionization produces a signal of ~μK at l~ kSZ due to patchy reionization produces a signal of ~μK at l~