Race to the Top: Examining Predictors of Competition among First-Year Science Students Sylvia Hurtado Kevin Eagan Josephine Gasiewski Minh Tran Higher.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Success Stories: How Social Identities Affect Students Educational Trajectories in STEM AACU Annual Meeting October 22, 2010 Houston, Texas Felisha Herrera.
Advertisements

HERI Brown Bag Improving the Rate of Success for Underrepresented Racial Minorities in the Biological and Behavioral Sciences: Insights from a National.
Survey Responses Challenges and Opportunities Matt Richey St. Olaf College.
Sylvia Hurtado and Mitchell Chang NIH Interventions Meeting Burlingame, CA.
Graduate Students’ Multiple Identities: How can I be me and be a scientist? Minh Tran Felisha Herrera Josephine Gasiewski Higher Education Research Institute,
What Matters in College for Retaining Aspiring Scientists and Engineers? Mitchell Chang Jessica Sharkness Christopher Newman Sylvia Hurtado Higher Education.
Academic Achievement among STEM Aspirants: Why do Black and Latino Students Earn Lower Grades than their White and Asian Counterparts? Jessica Sharkness,
Expanding and Diversifying STEM Degree Recipients: What We Know From Students' Experiences NIH Interventions Meeting Sylvia Hurtado, UCLA Higher Education.
Beyond the Bachelor’s: What Influences STEM Post- Baccalaureate Pathways Juan C. Garibay, Bryce E. Hughes, M. Kevin Eagan, Sylvia Hurtado UCLA Association.
Gallaudet Institutional Research Report: Annual Campus Climate Survey: 2010 Pat Hulsebosch: Executive Director – Office of Academic Quality Faculty Senate.
THE AMERICAN ASSOCIATION FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF SCIENCE VISION AND CHANGE CONFERENCE AUGUST 29, 2013 Dr. Sylvia Hurtado: Higher Education Research Institute,
Access to Resources: Pre-college Characteristics and Experiences of Underrepresented Minority Students in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences Sylvia.
Stereotype Threat: Undermining the Persistence of Racial Minority Freshmen in the Sciences Mitchell J. Chang, Kevin Eagan, Monica Lin, Sylvia Hurtado UCLA.
Sylvia Hurtado, Professor and Director Higher Education Research Institute UCLA
o Data Source o 2004 Freshman Survey (TFS) o 2008 College Senior Survey (CSS) o HERI Faculty Survey o Sample o 2,311 student who.
The Science of Diversifying Science: Underrepresented Minority Student Experiences In Structured Research Programs Sylvia Hurtado, Nolan L. Cabrera, Monica.
Exploring the Intersectionality of Science and Racial Identity through Graduate Student Experiences Sylvia Hurtado Minh Tran Felisha Herrera Josephine.
{ Driving Up or Dialing Down Competition in Introductory STEM Courses: Individual and Classroom Level Factors Bryce E. Hughes, Sylvia Hurtado, and M. Kevin.
Multidisciplinary Preparation and Exposure to Multiple Career Pathways amongst STEM Graduate Students Gina A. Garcia Christopher B. Newman Josephine A.
Sylvia Hurtado Kevin Eagan Bryce Hughes Higher Education Research Institute, UCLA Priming the Pump or the Sieve: Institutional Contexts and URM STEM Degree.
+ Association for Institutional Research May 2013 Long Beach, California Making It!... Or Not: Institutional Contexts & Biomedical Degree Attainment Tanya.
Reversing Underrepresentation: The Impact of Undergraduate Research Programs on Enrollment in STEM Graduate Programs Sylvia Hurtado, M. Kevin Eagan, Tanya.
Promoting Diversity: Access and Engagement in Biomedical and Behavioral Research Careers Sylvia Hurtado, Professor & Director Mitchell Chang, Associate.
Barricades, Bridges, and Programmatic Adaptation: A Multi-campus Case Study of STEM Undergraduate Research Programs Josephine Gasiewski Gina Garcia Felisha.
Latinas/os in STEM: A Longitudinal Look at the Experiences that Lead to Persistence American Association of Hispanics in Higher Education Sixth Annual.
Investing in Human Capital Underrepresented Racial Minorities’ Intentions to Attend Graduate School in STEM Fields Kevin Eagan Christopher Newman University.
Mind the Gap: Overview of FSSE and BCSSE Jillian Kinzie NSSE.
The Transition to College for Underrepresented Students: Results for Biomedical Aspirants and Racial/Ethnic Minority Students Symposia on Diversity in.
Expanding and Diversifying STEM Degree Recipients: What We Know From Students' Experiences Sylvia Hurtado, UCLA Higher Education Research Institute.
Preparing for Graduate School in Psychology. Important Factors in Graduate Admissions (Keith-Spiegel) 158 faculty who had served on admissions committees.
Fostering “Habits of Mind” for Student Learning in the First Year of College: Results from a National Study Linda DeAngelo, CIRP Assistant Director for.
Medical errors cause 98,000 deaths in the US each year. The Institute of Medicine has recommended that researchers investigate strategies that build social.
Temple University Russell Conwell Learning Center Office of Senior Vice Provost for Undergraduate Studies GETTING INVOLVED IN RESEARCH AT TEMPLE UNIVERSITY.
Bryce E. Hughes, Juan C. Garibay, Sylvia Hurtado, & Kevin Eagan UCLA American Educational Research Association San Francisco, CA May 1,
+ Adjusting to the Graduate Environment: A Focus on URM Students in STEM Tanya Figueroa and Sylvia Hurtado UCLA Association for the Study of Higher Education.
KEVIN EAGAN, JUAN GARIBAY, MICHAEL SOH, SYLVIA HURTADO, MITCHELL CHANG GUNNING FOR THE WIN! HOW COMPETITIVE CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTS AND STUDENT EXPERIENCES.
When Science Lacks Diversity and Social Relevance, Can Students be Objective Scientists and Still be Themselves? Minh Tran Felisha Herrera Juan Garibay.
Progress Report Promoting Diversity: Access and Engagement in Biomedical and Behavioral Research Careers Sylvia Hurtado, Professor & Director Mitchell.
Assessing College Wide SLOs using a Student Perception Survey: A Tale of Two SLOs Jeanne Edman and Brad Brazil Cosumnes River College.
Learning within Teaching What professors can learn about their students and themselves as teachers when they innovate in their teaching ANABELLA MARTINEZ,
Supporting Future Scientists: Predicting Minority Student Participation in the STEM Opportunity Structure Tanya Figueroa, Bryce Hughes, and Dr. Sylvia.
Gallaudet Institutional Research Report: National Survey of Student Engagement Pat Hulsebosch: Executive Director – Office of Academic Quality Faculty.
ASHE Annual Conference November 17, 2011 Maintaining Career Aspirations in Science, Technology, Engineering, & Mathematics (STEM) among College Students.
Frances Lawrenz and The Noyce evaluation team University of Minnesota 1 Acknowledgement: This project was funded by National Science Foundation (Grant#REC )
Josephine Gasiewski, Sylvia Hurtado Tanya Figueroa, Gina Garcia UCLA, Higher Education Research Institute May 1 st, 2013 AERA San Francisco, CA “Having.
Transitions from High School to University Physics at BYU Steve Turley AAPT, Sacramento August 2, 2004.
Bryce E. Hughes and Sylvia Hurtado UCLA Association for the Study of Higher Education November 2013 St. Louis, MO.
Expanding and Diversifying STEM Degree Recipients: What We Know From Students' Experiences JAM 2010 Sylvia Hurtado, UCLA Higher Education Research Institute.
Training Future Scientists: Factors Predicting Underrepresented Minority Student Participation in Undergraduate Research Sylvia Hurtado, M. Kevin Eagan,
Kevin Eagan, Ph.D. Ellen Bara Stolzenberg, Ph.D. Higher Education Research Institute University of California, Los Angeles.
What Matters in STEM: Institutional Contexts That Influence STEM Bachelor’s Degree Completion Rates Kevin Eagan Sylvia Hurtado Mitchell Chang Higher Education.
California Educational Research Association Annual Meeting Rancho Mirage, CA – December 5, 2008 Hoky Min, Gregory K. W. K. Chung, Rebecca Buschang, Lianna.
Total Workforce vs. STEM Workforce Demographics Sources: National Science Foundation, 2009 & U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2009.
HIED 556: Students in Higher Education
Engaging Undergraduates in Science Research: Not Just about Faculty Willingness Kevin Eagan, Jessica Sharkness, Sylvia Hurtado, Mitchell Chang & Cynthia.
Sylvia Hurtado, Minh Tran, Kevin Eagan, Christopher Newman, & Paolo Velasco University of California, Los Angeles Association for Institutional Research.
The Academic Library Experiences & Information Seeking Behavior of Undergraduates Ethelene Whitmire Assistant Professor University of California – Los.
Thinking and Acting Like a Scientist: Investigating the Outcomes of Introductory Science and Math Courses Kevin Eagan Jessica Sharkness Sylvia Hurtado.
Predicting Transition and Adjustment to College: Minority Biomedical and Behavioral Science Students’ First Year of College Sylvia Hurtado, June C. Chang,
A Strong Start in the Sciences: Factors Influencing Minority Students’ Academic and Social Engagement Kevin Eagan & Jessica Sharkness Higher Education.
Progress Report Promoting Diversity: Access and Engagement in Biomedical and Behavioral Research Careers Sylvia Hurtado, Professor Mitchell Chang, Associate.
Making a Difference in Science Education for Underrepresented Students: The Impact of Undergraduate Research Programs Kevin Eagan Gina Garcia Felisha Herrera.
1 © 2010 Florida International University 1 Marty Tracey Professor of Biological Sciences pinch hitting for Ophelia Weeks Professor of Biological Sciences.
Damani White-Lewis, Tanya Figueroa, Sylvia Hurtado, Kevin Eagan
University of Michigan
Trends & Pathways for STEM Major Aspirants:
Derek Herrmann & Ryan Smith University Assessment Services
Kevin Eagan, Ph.D. Improving Undergraduate STEM Education Workshop
Predicting Transition and Adjustment to College: Minority Biomedical and Behavioral Science Students’ First Year of College Sylvia Hurtado, June C. Chang,
Presentation transcript:

Race to the Top: Examining Predictors of Competition among First-Year Science Students Sylvia Hurtado Kevin Eagan Josephine Gasiewski Minh Tran Higher Education Research Institute, UCLA 2010 International Conference on the First Year Experience Maui, HI June 10, 2010

Significance  Competitive culture of science  Focus on grades  “Survival of the fittest” mentality (Epstein, 2006)

Background  Effects of competition on: Academic achievement Retention Knowledge gains  Contexts of competition Selective institutions Introductory courses  Grading on a curve  Large classes  Lack of engaging pedagogy Out-of-class experiences

Research Questions  What individual experiences and institutional characteristics predict science students’ sense of competition for high grades among their peers?  What contexts and experiences contribute to students’ sense of competition?  What are students’ and faculty members’ perceptions about the culture of competition in science across institutions?

Theoretical Framework  Academic Tribes and Culture (Becher, 1989) Culture of Science as a source of “disruption”  Folklore, myths, and legends  Socialization  Normalization – “This is how science is done!”  Science Identification (Carlone and Johnson, 2007) Competence Performance Recognition

Qualitative Data Sources  5 campuses: 1 HBCU, 2 HSIs, and 2 PWIs Selective research programs Various funding sources  Faculty and staff interviews (n=16)  Student focus group interviews (n=71) 60% female/40% male 56% Latina/o, 18% Black, 13% Asian American, 8% multiracial, 2.5% American Indian, and 2.5% White 70% biology, biochemistry, or chemistry majors

Methods: Qualitative  Interpretive/descriptive qualitative study  Semi-structured interview protocol  Coded transcripts using NVivo® software to identify emergent themes  Reached inter-coder reliability of 85%

Methods: Quantitative  Data and sample 2004 CIRP Freshman Survey and 2005 Your First College Year Survey  3,112 biomedical and behavioral science aspirants  150 colleges and universities 2004 CIRP Freshman Survey and 2008 College Senior Survey  3,550 science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) aspirants  216 colleges and universities

Methods: Quantitative  Variables Dependent variable: Extent to which students sensed competition among their peers for high grades Independent variables  Background characteristics  Pre-college experiences  First-year college experiences (TFS-YFCY dataset)  Fourth-year college experiences (TFS-CSS dataset)  Institutional characteristics  Analyses Descriptive statistics Multilevel modeling

Findings: Predictors of Competition at the End of the First Year of College  Background characteristics and pre-college experiences Participated in pre-college research program (+) Chose college b/c had good academic rep (+) Social self-confidence (+) Sense of science identity (+) Academic self-confidence (-)  Disciplinary differences (all compared to psychology) Life science (+) Physical science (+) Health science (+)

Findings: Predictors of Competition at the End of the First Year of College  Classroom intimidation Felt intimidated by professors (+) Feel like most students are treated like numbers in a book (+)  Out-of-class experiences Studying with other students (+) Received tutoring (+) Feel that faculty are interested in students’ academic problems (+)  Contextual differences Institutional selectivity (+)

Findings: Predictors of Competition Four Years after College Entry  Background characteristics Asian American (+) Choosing a college based on prestigious reputation (+) Science identity (+)  Classroom intimidation Feeling intimidated by professors (+) Feeling overwhelmed by academic work (+)

Findings: Predictors of Competition Four Years after College Entry  Out-of-class experiences Joining major-related club (+) Discussing course content with students outside class (+) Studying with other students (+) Talking with faculty outside of class (+) Sensing a hostile racial climate (+) Sensing that faculty are interested in students’ academic problems (+)  Contextual differences Institutional size (+) Selectivity (+) Percentage of undergraduates majoring in STEM (+)

Classroom Intimidation o Fear of asking questions o Reveals lack of understanding o Reveals lack of intelligence o To both peers and professors o Hierarchy of questions o clarification vs. deep & profound o Fostered by professors “People in organic chemistry don’t sit there and ask, ‘How did that work?’ You wait until office hours, in the quiet, and make sure nobody thinks that you’re dumb.” (Female student, PWI) “I feel like there’s a lot of pressure to…it seems like there’s a lot of pressure or I put a lot of pressure on myself to…I feel bad if I ask a question that’s just for clarification and not something that’s deep and profound.” (Female student, PWI)

Out of Class Competition Students are hesitant to:  Share information and resources  Work together “It also depends if you can open up yourself to people and not just think like, ‘Oh, what if you join a group and you get the same grades?’ It’s all about competition, you know. A lot of the things that happen…are all about competition, getting the better A.” (Female student, PWI) “There are [people] that are really competitive and I remember there was…we had to get a journal article and it was in the microfilm area and even though you don’t get to take it away from there, someone threw it away, so you couldn’t get it and you had to order it and have it sent down from another university.” (Male student, PWI)

Contextual Differences Importance of getting noticed  Not just being a #  Personal attention Ethic of care  Students  Faculty “It seems like here, the people have a mentality…like the sharing mentality, so if you’re not…if you don’t share or if you’re not…if you’re thinking about number one, they kind of shun to the side. I mean, because everyone else is in the group and you’re…you think you can work better on your own, we’ll let you work on your own. That’s how it is here.” (Female student, HBCU)

Grades vs. Learning Pre-meds as intensely competitive Gate-keeper courses Rote memorization vs. learning Faculty emphasis on grades “It’s really hard when you’re studying with competitive people. It puts too much pressure on your when you’re not trying to understand the material because you like it, you’re trying just to ace the class, so it’s not that desire to learn, but the desire to get a better grade, and sometimes you kind of just have to step back from it and try to see why you’re doing what you’re doing, not just to get the grade, but to really understand the material so you can later apply it.” (Female student, PWI) “I know my mentor’s always like…I don’t know, like trying to motivate us and I think one way he seeks to motivate us is to kind of be like, ‘Don’t you want to be better than so-and-so,’ and you kind of do get that feeling. (Female student, HSI)

Mitigating Power of Undergraduate Research Programs  Provided: Smaller scale faculty interactions Peer networks Sense of community

Implications  Intimidation in class fosters a greater sense of competition  Academic competition extends out of class to students’ studying behaviors and strategies  Institutional context shapes how students perceive and experience competition  Future research needed to further examine grading practices, pedagogy and environment of introductory science

Group Activity  Given the themes and challenges we just presented… please discuss in small groups how these issues affect your individual campuses and develop a list of recommendations for your respective institutions. A spokesperson from each group will share you list with the rest of the participants.

Contact Information Acknowledgments: This study was made possible by the support of the National Institute of General Medical Sciences, NIH Grant Numbers 1 R01 GMO and R01 GMO as well as the National Science Foundation, NSF Grant Number This independent research and the views expressed here do not indicate endorsement by the sponsors. Papers and reports are available for download at: Project Faculty and Co-PIs: Sylvia Hurtado Mitchell Chang Monica Lin Gina Garcia Felisha Herrera Postdoctoral Scholars: Kevin Eagan Josephine Gasiewski Administrative Staff: Aaron Pearl Graduate Research Assistants: Christopher Newman Minh Tran Jessica Sharkness Cindy Mosqueda Juan Garibay