S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 1 We have the tools How to attract the people? Creating a culture of Web-based participation.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

National training programmes EHES Training seminar, Rome, 12 February 2010 Päivikki Koponen.

Advertisements

1 Helsinki University of Technology Systems Analysis Laboratory Participatory Processes in Technology Programmes Tommi Gustafsson Systems Analysis Laboratory.

1 Research Topics Group: Professor Raimo P. Hämäläinen Graduate School Seminar University of Jyväskylä.

SEM II : Marketing Research

Screen 1 of 24 Reporting Food Security Information Understanding the User’s Information Needs At the end of this lesson you will be able to: define the.

NETT Recruitment-Admissions Interactive Review Congruence Survey for case study 1 Relationship between recruitment and admissions activity.

Mika Marttunen Finnish Environment Institute R., P. Hämäläinen Helsinki University of Technology Project web page: DECISION ANALYSIS.

Knowledge is Power Marketing Information System (MIS) determines what information managers need and then gathers, sorts, analyzes, stores, and distributes.

Facilitating Multi Stakeholder Processes and Social Learning Herman Brouwer/ Karèn Verhoosel Centre for Development Innovation Programme & Welcome!

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology A Preference Programming Approach to Make the Even Swaps Method Even Easier Jyri Mustajoki.

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Decision Support for the Even Swaps Process with Preference Programming Jyri Mustajoki Raimo.

Systems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology e-Learning Negotiation Analysis Harri Ehtamo Raimo P Hämäläinen Ville Koskinen Systems Analysis.

The importance of stakeholder dialogues in climate change adaptation Prof. Dr. Martin Welp University of Applied Sciences Eberswalde Photo: Hannah Förster.

Copyright Facilitate.com Beyond Web Conferencing: How To Create Value With Web Facilitation

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Using Intervals for Global Sensitivity and Worst Case Analyses in Multiattribute Value Trees.

Life Cycle Overview & Resources. Life Cycle Management What is it? Integrated concept for managing goods and services towards more sustainable production.

Quality Assurance in the University of Oulu Preparing for the Audit of QA system in November 2009 E-XCELLENCE Suvi Eriksson Coordinator University.

CSO engagement in policy process Hille Hinsberg State Chancellery Government Communication Officer

1 S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Decision and Negotiation Support in Multi-Stakeholder Development of Lake Regulation Policy.

ELearning / MCDA Systems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Introduction to Value Tree Analysis eLearning resources / MCDA team Director.

Helsinki University of Technology Systems Analysis Laboratory Ahti Salo and Antti Punkka Systems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology.

1 Helsinki University of Technology Systems Analysis Laboratory Rank-Based Sensitivity Analysis of Multiattribute Value Models Antti Punkka and Ahti Salo.

Demystifying the Business Analysis Body of Knowledge Central Iowa IIBA Chapter December 7, 2005.

Life Cycle of Products Source: Melanen et al Metals flows and recycling of scrap in Finland. The Finnish Environment 401. Finnish Environment Institute,

1 Helsinki University of Technology Systems Analysis Laboratory RPM-Explorer - A Web-based Tool for Interactive Portfolio Decision Analysis Erkka Jalonen.

E-participation Requires Systems Intelligence Paula Siitonen and Raimo P. Hämäläinen Helsinki University of Technology, Systems Analysis Laboratory Marcelo.

Web-Based GIS and the Future of Participatory GIS Applications within Local and Indigenous Communities By Dr. Peter A. Kyem, GISP. (Professor of Geography)

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology We have the tools How to attract the people? Creating a culture of Web-based participation.

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 1 Raimo P. Hämäläinen Systems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology

1 Systems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology How to Benefit from Decision Analysis in Environmental Life Cycle Assessment Pauli Miettinen.

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Can We Avoid Biases in Environmental Decision Analysis ? Raimo P. Hämäläinen Helsinki University.

1 S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Opinions-Online Platform for Global Participation, Voting, Surveys and Group Decisions.

Integrated Risk Management Charles Yoe, PhD Institute for Water Resources 2009.

Mika Marttunen Mikko Dufva Finnish Environment Institute Jyri Mustajoki Tampere University of Technology Timo P. Karjalainen Thule Institute, University.

Sebastian Slotte and Raimo P. Hämäläinen Systems Analysis Laboratory Aalto University School of Science Decision Structuring Dialogue.

1 Raimo P. Hämäläinen Systems Analysis Laboratory Aalto University, School of Science December, 2010 Aiding Decisions, Negotiating and.

A Dynamic Interval Goal Programming Approach to the Regulation of a Lake-River System Raimo P. Hämäläinen Juha Mäntysaari S ystems Analysis Laboratory.

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 1 Raimo P. Hämäläinen Jyri Mustajoki Systems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of.

Marketing Best Practices What to consider when launching a program.

Population Census Data Dissemination through Internet H. Furuta Lecturer/Statistician SIAP 1 Training Course on Analysis and Dissemination of Population.

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Practical dominance and process support in the Even Swaps method Jyri Mustajoki Raimo P.

1 Conducting Consultation on Legislation in Vietnam By Mr. Tran Quoc Thuan Vice-Chairman (Standing) of the Office of the National Assembly

ICT TOOLS AND SOCIETY INVOLVEMENT AMONG THE EUPAN NETWORK HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE SURVEY RESULTS TANYA CHETCUTI AND MARCO FICHERA - WORKSHOP EUROPEAN COMMISSION.

Meeting the needs of diverse learners k-6. Carol Ann Tomilson  Its not a strategy but a total way of thinking about learners, teaching and learning.

Methodologies and Tools for Technology Needs Assessment: an Overview Zou Ji Dept. of environmental Economics and Management, Renmin University of China.

DEVELOPING PARENT INVOLVEMENT POLICIES Title I No Child Left Behind (NCLB) Section 1118.

1 Systems Analysis and Decision Support Prof. Raimo P. Hämäläinen Group: Dr. Kai Virtanen M.Sc. Sanna Hanhikoski, Juho Kokkala, Ville Mattila, Jirka Poropudas,

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Decision Conferencing in Nuclear Emergency Management by Raimo P. Hämäläinen Mats Lindstedt.

Helsinki University of Technology Systems Analysis Laboratory 1DAS workshop Ahti A. Salo and Raimo P. Hämäläinen Systems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki.

MCDA can be realized in many ways A. Decision makers and experts use MCDA on their own, no stakeholders involved B. Stakeholders opinions are.

1 The project is financed from the European Union funds within the framework of Erasmus+, Key Action 2: Cooperation for innovation and the exchange of.

DEVELOPING THE WORK PLAN

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 1 Decision Analysis Raimo P. Hämäläinen Systems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University.

Systems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology An e-Learning module on Negotiation Analysis Harri Ehtamo Raimo P.

1 S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Master’s Thesis Antti Punkka “ Uses of Ordinal Preference Information in Interactive Decision.

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 15th MCDM conference - Ankara Mats Lindstedt / 1 Using Intervals for Global.

Better regulation in the Commission Jonathon Stoodley Head of Unit C.1 Evaluation, Regulatory Fitness and Performance Secretariat General of the European.

M ARKET R ESEARCH Topic 3.1. W HAT IS MARKET RESEARCH ? The process of gaining information about customers, products, competitors etc through the collection.

RCUK International Funding Name Job title Research Councils UK.

©2013 Global Insights Consulting, LLC Neethling Brain Instrument™ NBI™ Thinking Preferences and Decision Making Neethling Brain Instrument™ NBI™ Thinking.

+ Session by Joy Behrens Maurya West Meiers Quick but not dirty - 6 Week Needs Assessment.

Mustajoki, Hämäläinen and Salo Decision support by interval SMART/SWING / 1 S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Decision support.

Aiding Decisions and Collecting Opinions on the Web

Aiding Decisions and Collecting Opinions on the Web

Raimo P. Hämäläinen Juha Mäntysaari

D E C I S I O N A R I U M g l o b a l s p a c e f o r d e c i s i o n s u p p o r t group decision making multicriteria decision analysis group.

Raimo P. Hämäläinen Systems Analysis Laboratory

Decision support by interval SMART/SWING Methods to incorporate uncertainty into multiattribute analysis Ahti Salo Jyri Mustajoki Raimo P. Hämäläinen.

Mika Marttunen Anne-Marie Hagman

Presentation transcript:

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 1 We have the tools How to attract the people? Creating a culture of Web-based participation in environmental decision making Raimo P. Hämäläinen Jyri Mustajoki Mika Marttunen

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 2 Web-tools New possibilities to support participatory decision making Decision analytical tools Tools for participation Experiences of web support in environmental management Multiple objectives Multiple stakeholders Often in georaphically different locations

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 3 Development of lake regulation policies Lake Päijänne 1995–1999 Lake Kallavesi 1999–2001 Pirkanmaa lakes 1999–2003 In collaboration with Finnish Environment Institute

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 4 The tools used Opinions-Online ( Platform for global participation, voting, surveys, and group decisions Web-HIPRE ( Value tree based decision analysis and support Joint Gains ( used only in a student role playing testwww.jointgains.hut.fi Multi-party negotiation support with the method of improving directions

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 5 Opinions-Online v.2.0 Online generation of web-survey forms Multiple / single choice questions Open ended Different ways of setting priorities Ranking, Approval voting, Multiattribute rating On-line analysis of the results Possibility to view and link to the results according to any field on the questionnaire Allows to see differences between stakeholder groups

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 6 Opinions-Online - Creating a new session

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 7 Opinions-Online - Analysis of results

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 8 Web-HIPRE

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 9 Who can use Web-HIPRE to create and evaluate preference models? Requires methodological support  Not easily applicable with general public Ok in steering groups with assistance Independent analysis of steering group members' models with Web-HIPRE? Possibly Ok – still risk of misunderstandings Web-based learning material can help understand the methods and software

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 10 Public Web- HIPRE Opinions- Online Web Site Decision on recommendations Steering Group Results to Web Preference elicitation Analysis of results Preference elicitation Information FeedbackAnalysis of the feedback Analysis of the feedback Information Analysis of results Web Independent use Assisted use Framework for the use of Web Results to Web

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 11 Stages in a traditional participatory environmental policy process 1. Initial screening of stakeholder concerns 2. Evaluation and modeling of the problem 3. Informing the public, e.g. about decision recommendations 4. Collecting and analysing feedback from the public 5. Decision on policy recommendations 6. Public evaluates the decision

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Initial screening of stakeholder concerns Web does not yet provide natural ways to inform about possibilities to participate  Traditional ways of informing the public still needed Newspapers, radio, TV, … Mail questionnaires Expensive to send and analyze Once public has been informed, Web can be used for e-participation

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Evaluation and modeling of the problem Decision analysis provides a transparent way to model preferences Stakeholder weights and rankings can be published on the Web Decision analysis interviews Analyst assures the proper use of the methods Decision conferences/workshops Individual preference models as a basis of discussion and group models

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 14 Lake Päijänne Steering group, 20 people Decision analysis interviews with HIPRE and Web-HIPRE Typical models publicly available on the Web Initial screening by mail questionnaires 10 public meetings, including interactive DA Closing seminar 51 participants Results of the value tree analyses Opinions-Online feedback

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 15 Lake Päijänne Web site

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Web Site for Informing the Public Impacts of policy alternatives Pictures, text, graphs, diagrams Description of Web-HIPRE models of the steering group members Clear separation of facts and values Aim to explain the values and objectives of different stakeholder groups Can be analyzed by stakeholders in local meetings

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 17 Pirkanmaa lakes Web site Information about the recommendations on the Web

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology Collecting and analysing public feedback Direct links to opinions-online surveys and results opinions from different geographical areas and stakeholder groups people learn each others’ perspectives – feeling that they have a voice Everyone does not have access to Internet Alternative ways to participate, e.g. by mail, should be provided Web tools can still be used by entering the opinions from the mail questionnaires into the web

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 19 Pirkanmaa lakes Opinions-Online was the primary way to collect public feedback about the regulation recommendations Web questionnaire and material broadly advertised on: lists, Web pages Local newspapers Local radio and TV Possibility to alternatively reply by regular mail 333 replied on the Web and 6 by mail

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 20 Visits to the Web questionnaire Open from February 19 to March 7 Weekend

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 21 Pirkanmaa lakes Web site Results available for the public

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 22 Is Web participation too easy? How to assure that stakeholders examine the different options thoroughly? E.g. in the Pirkanmaa Web questionnaire very few people visited the information material provided on the recommendations  Learning of the regulation and understanding of the other stakeholders' views may not happen Public anchored onto just expressing a voice or a vote but were not ready for active participation?

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 23 Discussion The Web-based framework meets several objectives of public participation Openness Fairness Clarification of facts and values Opportunity for every person to present an opinion - not only stakeholder representatives Provides a possibility for an active role for the public

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 24 Culture grows from positive experiences Collaboration of DA researchers and policy planners Small steps Simple Web-based tools first Web pages for information Surveys Steering group use of DA tools Interactive evaluation of decision models by stakeholdes Can the public use DA tools independently? This will take years

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 25 How to attract the people? It is not enough to have tools – technology push does not work ! New innovations take 30 years to be accepted eTools for participation are available but they are not enough: Participation process has to be designed with a systems intelligent perspective -Communication so that trust will not be lost -Collaboration and learning as a working mode

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 26 References M. Marttunen and R.P. Hämäläinen (1995): Decision analysis interviews in environmental impact assessment, European Journal of Operational Research, 87(3), 1995, M. Marttunen, E.A. Järvinen, J. Saukkonen and R.P. Hämäläinen (1999): Regulation of Lake Päijänne - a learning process preceding decision-making, Finnish Journal of Water Economy, 6, (in Finnish) J. Mustajoki and R.P.Hämäläinen (2000): Web-HIPRE: Global decision support by value tree and AHP analysis, INFOR, 38(3), R.P. Hämäläinen, E. Kettunen, M. Marttunen and H. Ehtamo (2001): Evaluating a Framework for Multi-Stakeholder Decision Support in Water Resources Management, Group Decision and Negotiation, 10(4), R.P. Hämäläinen (2003): Decisionarium - Aiding Decisions, Negotiating and Collecting Opinions on the Web, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 12(2-3), J. Mustajoki, R.P. Hämäläinen and M. Marttunen (2004): Participatory multicriteria decision support with Web-HIPRE: A case of lake regulation policy, Environmental Modelling & Software, 19(6),

S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 27 Web sites Findings of 20 years of research in environmental decision analysis and participation: Lake Päijänne project: Lake Kallavesi project: Pirkanmaa lakes project: Decisionarium: Finnish Environment Institute: Water Resources in Finland: