Patterns of Planner Involvement In ELULU Decisions Sanda Kaufman & Janet Smith Levin College of Urban Affairs Cleveland State University ACSP Conference,

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Product Stewardship and Local Government in Minnesota Lebanon Hills Regional Park Visitor Center 860 Cliff Road Eagan, MN October 1, 2009, 8:30-11:30 am.

Advertisements

A Framework to Guide and Monitor Disaster Reduction Online-Conference.

Building bridges: integrating the work of public health and urban planning Rajiv Bhatia, MD, MPH San Francisco Department of Public Health January 27 th,

Urban Information Modeling Reflections on the Urban Systems Collaborative Chicago Workshop April 19, 2012.

The Water Balance Model: A Tool for Designing with Nature Douglas College Rain Conference.

Land holders Policy developers Planners Who is who in the NRM business? Merv Lewis Presiding Member.

Shaping the Future of Local Government in Victoria The Changing Environment for Local Government MAV 2012.

Social Polis Social Platform on Cities and Social Cohesion

Promoting Social Inclusion of People with Disabilities at the Local Level Sean O’Riordain Faculty of Geography National University of Ireland, Maynooth.

LETS Governing transitions towards Low carbon Energy and Transport Systems for 2050.

Institutional Element and Policy in Destination Management Pertemuan Matakuliah: G1174/Tourism Management and Planning Tahun: 2007.

Building a Resilient Natural Environment Aberdeen City Council SUMMARY Aberdeen City Council is working with European partners on two green themed, innovative.

Session Creating Health Equity: Going Beyond the Health Gap, the Mental Health Gap, and the Climate Gap Advancing equity through health in all policies:

Blueprint Implementation. Ensuring effective implementation of the Blueprint “How do we link Blueprint products with organizational policies and activities?”

“LAND PLANNING AND TOURISM IN SPAIN” Bellvehí Legal Link 19th IFTTA Conference Portugal.

PLANNING CONTEXT & TYPES TOPIC 3. TOPICS 1.Planning types and planners Traditional Democratic Equity Incremental Strategic 2.Planning models Rational.

The Challenges of Negotiating Changes in ELULUs Sanda Kaufman Levin College of Urban Affairs Cleveland State University IACM Conference, Eugene, 1994 LULUs.

Expectations Of : African American Managers By Daphne Harley, MPA PPA 530.

Sanda Kaufman6/21/20151 P ARTICIPATORY S TRATEGIES FOR C OMMUNITY D EVELOPMENT C ONFLICTS UAA 27th Annual Meeting, April 16-19, Toronto S ANDA K AUFMAN.

Land-Use and Transportation

October, th SPIDR Conference Portland Intervention in Environmental Disputes: How can we tell if it works? Sanda Kaufman Levin College of Urban.

American Planning Association and American Institute of Certified Planners William Anderson, FAICP, APA Board of Directors Lance Schulte, AICP, AICP Commission.

Analysing News Articles. Questions for Analyzing Social Issues 1. What are the social issues associated with a particular IT development? 2. How did.

Zoning The legislative division of an area into separate districts with different regulations within each district for land use, building size, and the.

Chapter2: GIS in Decision Support Situations Dr. Ahmad BinTouq URL: GEOG440: GIS and Urban.

HOUSING. Studying housing Different approaches: Describing and analyzing government policy in reference to housing  legislative and institutional structure.

July 15, 2011 NEW YORK & CONNECTICUT SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES.

The Forum for Youth Investment, Washington, DC ©2005 The Forum for Youth Investment/Impact Strategies, Inc.. All rights reserved. Youth as Policy Makers:

Georgia Power Community & Economic Development. What is it? Most simply, it is the creation of wealth. Economic Development.

Oregon’s Statewide Land Use Planning Program A Framework for Community Decisions Richard Whitman – Director Oregon Department of Land Conservation and.

Quality Region Principles The New Visions Plan addresses the region’s quality of life in a number of important ways and provides a framework for improving.

Land Use Sustainable Development Environmental Justice.

1 A Framework for Comprehensive Planning City of Sunset Valley.

S.C. Food Policy Council Beth Crocker, SC Dept. of Agriculture & Susan Frost, SC Dept. of Health & Environmental Control August 24, 2010.

SESSION 6 – COMMUNITIES OF METHOD Copyright 2011 Phil Heywood.

Climate Change Council November 2011 draft ACT Planning Strategy.

COMPREHENSIVE PLAN FOR THE CREATION OF SUSTAINABLE HUMAN SETTLEMENTS 2004 “BREAKING NEW GROUND IN HOUSING DELIVERY”

The Urban Affairs Center Building Upon Existing Strengths & Identifying New Opportunities A Vision.

Coming home: Sustainable local solutions for public transport and energy supply. Workshop 2 Forum "The Single Market Act“ 30 November 2010 Committee of.

Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments Greater Washington 2050 A New Regional Initiative 5 th Mid-Atlantic Regional Planning Roundtable November.

Parliament’s Role in Peace-Building and Development.

Subregional Planning Initiative (SPI) Project Fact Sheet – East Port Area Plan – February 2010 What is the purpose of the SPI Initiative? The SPI Program.

1 Regional Parking Strategies for Focused Growth and Climate Protection Jeffrey Tumlin, Principal.

Plans and Planning Plan: A detailed scheme, program, or method worked out beforehand for the accomplishment of an objective.

Subregional Planning Initiative (SPI) Project Fact Sheet – East Port Area Plan What is the purpose of the SPI initiative? The SPI Program will provide.

Planning and Sustainability Paul Farmer American Planning Association M6: Protecting the Urban Environment and Historical and Cultural Heritage.

Improving Parks and Community Facilities. What do we mean by improving parks and other community facilities? A community facility is a physical feature.

Comprehensive Plan Update. General, far-reaching vision to benefit the whole community Takes a long term view of issues Focuses on physical development.

Is the Mid-Atlantic Region Water Rich? Presentation to 5 th Mid-Atlantic Regional Planning Roundtable November 7, 2008 Joseph Hoffman, Executive Director.

Texas Extension Program Councils Southeast Advisory Leaders Conference Kyle L. Smith and Mary Marshall May 3-5, 2001 Charlotte, North Carolina.

MARKETING RESEARCH George Brown College Janet Haist.

Policy Development and Advocacy Leaders in Health Namibia.

Mickey Slimp, Executive Director, Northeast Texas Consortium of Colleges & Universities Rich Gross, Executive Vice President, the Clements Group Ronda.

2060 Florida Transportation Plan Florida Model Task Force Meeting November 10, 2009.

Update: South Africa’s Preparatory Process for HABITAT III Presentation to Portfolio Committee on Human Settlements 15 March

Creating Sustainable Built Landscapes: Planning and Planner Perspectives Aslı Göçmen Assistant Professor Urban and Regional Planning, UW – Madison

Perceptions Of Executive Government Leadership In The Age Of Engagement and Community Based Decision Making Andrew Leader Flinders University.

ULI Symposium: Central City Commercial Development 1988.

CHINA – 4 – Challenges facing urban communities

Building Healthy Communities Conference

Settlement revision: Changing land use in urban areas.

The Political Economy of Policy Reform: A Framework about Process

Analysis Formulation Implementation The Policy-Making Process Problem

The Policy-Making Process

ADEA 2008 Biennale: Observations, Issues, Moving Forward Theme 1:

When do we make decisions?

Sustainability Plan Overview

Slide Deck 9: Objectives and Results

Mayors’ Commission on Climate Change

Mayors’ Commission on Climate Change

Presentation transcript:

Patterns of Planner Involvement In ELULU Decisions Sanda Kaufman & Janet Smith Levin College of Urban Affairs Cleveland State University ACSP Conference, Phoenix, 1994 What's in a name? Ten ELULU cases Where are the planners?

ELULU change What are ELULUs? ELULUs are Existing, Locally Unwanted Land Uses. S. Kaufman & J. Smith, ACSP, Phoenix, 1994 Consequences of change economic functional social environmental ELULU change n facility expansion n land use change

ELULU change Can planners help? Research Questions n What are the characteristics and needs of the ELULU change process? n What is the match between l current planner roles and l ELULU process needs? Approach n Case studies analysis with decision making focus S. Kaufman & J. Smith, ACSP, Phoenix, 1994

ELULU Change Examples S. Kaufman & J. Smith, ACSP, Phoenix, 1994 Land Use ChangePerceived ConsequencesType Douglas County, CO increase size of sand & gravel pit Chicago, IL relocate historic market to build univ. facilities Plymouth County, MA transform jail grounds into college campus Fairfax City, VA remove trailer park to build WalMart Millbrae, CA raze low-cost housing to build BART parking deck change & expansion change functional & environmental functional & economic functional & social functional, economic & social

ELULU change Facility expansion cases in Northeast Ohio S. Kaufman & J. Smith, ACSP, Phoenix, 1994

ELULU change Change in use cases in Northeast Ohio S. Kaufman & J. Smith, ACSP, Phoenix, 1994

ELULU change Drawbacks of current practices S. Kaufman & J. Smith, ACSP, Phoenix, 1994 n Some neglected issues/stakeholders/interests: l sustainability l long-range consequecnes l future generations l regional concerns n Effects of initial framing of issues & facts: n Decision makers mostly reactive, not goal-driven: n Unintended, far-reaching by-products: l adversarial conflict process l reduced outcomes space l politicians l community reps l regulators l developers l enacting legislation in response to 1 case l instituting adversarial traditions

ELULU Change PLANNER ROLES S. Kaufman & J. Smith, ACSP, Phoenix, 1994 Constituency TasksProcessRole Technician Equity Planner Intervenor Disadvantaged group Issues Solutions Persuasion Political pressure Stakeholder identification Process design Information flow Political Policy making As chosen Decision maker Data analysis & recommendations Information processing Advisory Advocacy As interpreted limits: mandate, tradition, political climate, resources, personality, organizational position, experience Within

ELULU change Planner tasks S. Kaufman & J. Smith, ACSP, Phoenix, 1994 Represent Technician EquityIntervenor Educate Monitor Process Drawbacks Needs No Yes Maybe

ELULU change Team approach S. Kaufman & J. Smith, ACSP, Phoenix, 1994 ELULU change needs planning help ELULU concerns are: diverse at odds TEAM represent interests inform educate (intervenor) (equity) (technician)