Diversity in the Workplace The Role of Communication in a Diverse Workplace
Statistics to Ponder The Hudson Institute, Workforce 2000: 5/6 of those entering the workforce in the year 2010 will be women and minorities In the federal workforce, white males 44%, white females 26%, 8% African American males,10% African American women, only 6% Hispanic men and women (2004 stats) Survey of top corporate jobs in Chicago finds only about 15% (boards and executive positions) are held by women (Boeing, Sears, Walgreen, Allstate, Kraft) (2004) Fortune 500 companies with the highest representation of women in top management show 35% higher ROE and 35 % higher total shareholder return The private sector will spend hundreds of millions of dollars on diversity training this year
Diversity Categories Protected or “suspect” classes: Gender Age Ethnicity/Race Physical Abilities Religious Affiliation Sexual Orientation
Some Hypothetical Examples A professional African American male comes to work with his hair newly done in corn rows. It is widely interpreted by his rural, white co-workers as representative of a prison or gangster culture. Some workers complain to managers about being afraid.
Hypothetical #2 A Latina manager complains that her mostly Asian subordinates don’t respect her because when she addresses them, they do not look her in the eye.
Metaphors for Diversity melting pot multicultural stew patchwork quilt tributaries leading to a mighty river assimilationist policies versus policies which truly celebrate differences (The Borg versus The Federation)
Flaws in Diversity Training Targeted at SWAMs Unitary in nature, one size fits all Dogmatic in philosophy, looking to change hearts and minds Often conducted by women/minority trainers Perpetuates victimage Often seen as “diversity penance”
Communication Training to Enhance Diversity The Wrong Way--U.S. DOT confrontation style program, suspended in 1993 The Right Way ethnocentrism awareness monitoring language ability to tolerate ambiguity conflict training
Successful Diversity Training Needs to be integrated into the overall business plan Needs to recognized as an organizational commitment, top to bottom Thomas (1992): diversity training is about enhancing a manager’s capability to tap the potential of a diverse group of employees. Use teams of trainers
The Nature of Resistance Resistance is unavoidable Resistance provides protection Resistance is a source of energy DT should work with resistance bring it to the surface “honor” the resistance (“I understand how this could be a problem for you”) explore methods for resolving it